New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

About that 2nd amendment.

yep, the most stupid part imo is the way many of them are for arming the tyrannical gov they must one day lock horns with that make their peashooters worthless.

My understanding is that the Heller decision determining an individual right was a departure from the jurisprudence before it that gave weight to the militia thing

You demonstrate very well the fundamental failure to understand the definition of a militia that is common to the anti-Bill of Rights crowd you represent.
 
Your standard diversions are less effective the more you use them. And I responded 4 hours ago to your "ignored" post with all of the gravitas it commanded. Looks like everyone else was satisfied.
 
Like I said, never let the facts get in the way of good propaganda.

The fact is that you're the one who used that phrase in direct reference to those murdered children in Newtown. I'll be happy to bump that for you as often as you like. Better go edit now.
 
The court has determined that the operative clause in the amendment is the independent clause. I have always interpreted the Second as an individual right and was glad to see the court issue their opinion. I would point out to you that members of the militia had to bring their own guns, so it was assumed that citizens owned them by right: these were not weapons purchased by individuals for the sole purpose of participation in the militia.

None of this mean that we can't regulate gun ownership. It is pretty clear that gun manufacturers dominate the NRA and other organizational agendas. We should begin be taking them on, not individual gun owners.

Let us assume for the moment that it were illegal to privately own guns. Mass murderers would use other deadly force such as explosives or toxic gases to kill just as indiscriminately. They could drive down the street in a big pickup and run people over. The problem is not the instrument being used but the violcnce itself.

God Speed,
David
 
Let us assume for the moment that it were illegal to privately own guns. Mass murderers would use other deadly force such as explosives or toxic gases to kill just as indiscriminately. They could drive down the street in a big pickup and run people over. The problem is not the instrument being used but the violcnce itself.

God Speed,
David

No, actually, they would still use guns, just illegal ones, which is why all this anti-Bill of Rights crap coming from the left has nothing to do with crime or violence. It has to do with controlling people.
 
Like I said, never let the facts get in the way of good propaganda.

The fact is that you're the one who used that phrase in direct reference to those murdered children in Newtown. I'll be happy to bump that for you as often as you like. Better go edit now.

You go right ahead and do that, because you dishonor them more by politicizing their deaths, and using their deaths to make political gains, than I do in standing up for my constitutional rights. You're propagandizing the deaths of innocents in the name of depriving me of freedom, and I will continue to name it as propaganda while you continue to do it.
 
Did you denounce your statement that victims of gun violence are the "price we pay for freedom"? No. You doubled down and tried to smear me rather than owning your words. Good luck with that.

Your tag team partner said it straight out directly in reference to the kids at Newtown.

But I'm the nasty one. Uh huh.....

When someone holds another rally outside a soldier's funeral with signs saying they're glad he's dead, be sure to tell anyone who stands up for the deceased that they're "nasty" for "standing on their graves". Or do murdered little kids deserve less consideration for some reason?

Has anyone checked yet to see if you're Trap's sock puppet? I think it would be a worthwhile pursuit. Hard to believe two people are so consistently obtuse, have the same disconnect from reason on the same pet issue, use the exact same tactics and always show up together. The longer "you two" hang around together on gun thrteads, the more you merge into one personality. Odd, that.

Others can do what they like. I'll be picturing the same character for both until I see evidence to the contrary. It all seems to be piling up in one direction so far.

When I see two people in one day willing to say that murdered children are the price of freedom, I am given a choice whether to believe that a coincidence or have a little more faith in the human race. I'm going with door #2, Trap.
 
When someone holds another rally outside a soldier's funeral with signs saying they're glad he's dead, be sure to tell anyone who stands up for the deceased that they're "nasty" for "standing on their graves". Or do murdered little kids deserve less consideration for some reason?

That would be the Democrats from the Westboro Baptist "Church".
 
Did you denounce your statement that victims of gun violence are the "price we pay for freedom"? No. You doubled down and tried to smear me rather than owning your words. Good luck with that.

Your tag team partner said it straight out directly in reference to the kids at Newtown.

But I'm the nasty one. Uh huh.....

When someone holds another rally outside a soldier's funeral with signs saying they're glad he's dead, be sure to tell anyone who stands up for the deceased that they're "nasty" for "standing on their graves". Or do murdered little kids deserve less consideration for some reason?

Has anyone checked yet to see if you're Trap's sock puppet? I think it would be a worthwhile pursuit. Hard to believe two people are so consistently obtuse, have the same disconnect from reason on the same pet issue, use the exact same tactics and always show up together. The longer "you two" hang around together, the more you merge into one personality. Odd, that.

Others can do what they like. I'll be picturing the same character until I see evidence to the contrary. It all seems to be piling up in one direction so far.

When I see two people willing to say that murdered children are the price of freedom, I am given a choice whether to believe that a coincidence or have a little more faith in the human race. I'm going with door #2, Trap.

I am sick and tired of people pointing their fingers at me and screaming that I bear some responsibilty for those kids; I am no more responsible for their deaths than you are, so [Unwelcome language removed] you. You don't have a logical or defensible position on the matter, so you resort to emotional tirades and bullshit accusations, and when you get called on it, you make even more accusations. You are full of shit.... and you damn well know it.
 
I like how the anti-gun crowd on this thread ignored my citation of the actual law regarding the militia. Never let facts get in the way of good propaganda, I guess.

there is no anti-gun crowd here on PJ. I don't even know an anti-gun crowd out there in the real world.
 
You don't have to bear arms in the interest of your nation. You have an individual right to keep and bear arms that has nothing to do with participation in any militia.

If, however, you wish to participate in a militia, but don't wish to be in the National Guard, that is provided for under U.S. law, too.

Under 10 USC Chapter 13: "STATUTE-
(a) The militia of the United States consists of all able-bodied
males at least 17 years of age and, except as provided in section
313 of title 32, under 45 years of age who are, or who have made a
declaration of intention to become, citizens of the United States
and of female citizens of the United States who are members of the
National Guard.
(b) The classes of the militia are -
(1) the organized militia, which consists of the National Guard
and the Naval Militia; and
(2) the unorganized militia, which consists of the members of
the militia who are not members of the National Guard or the
Naval Militia.
" (Emphasis in bold added).

And, the 2nd Amendment says what? "Militia" or "well regulated Miliita"???????

http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/agency/army/militia.htm

In addition, the statute cited excludes all women who are NOT members of the National Guard.
 
Ok; NinaS, Bugsy, Bo, yourself, and a whole host of others on here have spoken of restricting common firearms. To me, that comes across as anti-gun; how would you define the term?

How does restricting the types of some arms, guns specifically, but not eliminating them, translate as "anti-gun" to you?

How does specifying a right to keep and bear arms (a personal defense term?) to "the people" of "a well regulated miliitia" in service and duty to "the common defense" come across as "anti-gun"?
 
Ok; NinaS, Bugsy, Bo, yourself, and a whole host of others on here have spoken of restricting common firearms. To me, that comes across as anti-gun; how would you define the term?

wanting to restrict SOME firearms is not being anti-gun.

wanting to restrict ALL firearms is being anti-gun.
 
Did you denounce your statement that victims of gun violence are the "price we pay for freedom"? No. You doubled down and tried to smear me rather than owning your words. Good luck with that
.

No. I think that higher risks, including a higher risk of gun violence, is among the prices we pay for having additional freedom. I merely don't have to stand on the graves of 20 elementary school kids to make my point. I didn't politicize their deaths, nor did the NRA. That was done by people like you.


When someone holds another rally outside a soldier's funeral with signs saying they're glad he's dead, be sure to tell anyone who stands up for the deceased that they're "nasty" for "standing on their graves". Or do murdered little kids deserve less consideration for some reason?

You're not standing up for the deceased -- you're using their death to score political points. There is a size-large difference. No one from the NRA was outside protesting at the funerals of the children. Only propagandists like yourself are attempting to leverage their deaths.

Has anyone checked yet to see if you're Trap's sock puppet? I think it would be a worthwhile pursuit. Hard to believe two people are so consistently obtuse, have the same disconnect from reason on the same pet issue, use the exact same tactics and always show up together. The longer "you two" hang around together on gun thrteads, the more you merge into one personality. Odd, that.

I have no "sock puppets" nor do I need any to make my viewpoints and state them clearly. If anything is a "disconnect from reason" it is in the idea that banning the sort of weapon used in the least number of murders will somehow have an impact on violent crime as a whole. As for "odd" there is nothing odd about the idea of people having similar views having similar views. If I worried about sock puppets I'd have to wonder if you and Zoar are such.
 
Back
Top