New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

About them doggone drones.

<sighing> USA needs to put more money in space exploration... we got plenty of nuts to send out there. When one reads some of this "far-out crap," makes a person stay close to home.
 
<sighing> USA needs to put more money in space exploration... we got plenty of nuts to send out there. When one reads some of this "far-out crap," makes a person stay close to home.


Outward bound again ? Running away from problems never solves them, they always follow one.

All of us should be putting our own houses in order and treating each other with at the very least, respect.
 
Why not ? Exactly LeRoy ......that is exactly what 'you' are doing.


And exactly what 'you' were doing then too

I can't decipher this post. Are you claiming it was Americans who exterminated the Tasmanians?? Are you saying that Americans are committing genocide today?? [If so, against whom??] Our policies toward the Amerindians throughout much of the 19th century could arguably be called genocidal ["The only good Indian is a dead Indian"], but we didn't completely exterminate them, did we? Like you Brits did to the Tasmanians....

The Australian rock group Midnight Oil had a wonderful protest song about the extermination of the Tasmanians. It is called 'Truganini'. That was the name of the last full-blooded Tasmanian, a woman who died in the early 20th century. In her later years, she greatly feared that when she died, the British would dissect her and put her bones on display. They did.
 
I can't decipher this post. Are you claiming it was Americans who exterminated the Tasmanians?? Are you saying that Americans are committing genocide today?? [If so, against whom??] Our policies toward the Amerindians throughout much of the 19th century could arguably be called genocidal ["The only good Indian is a dead Indian"], but we didn't completely exterminate them, did we? Like you Brits did to the Tasmanians....

The Australian rock group Midnight Oil had a wonderful protest song about the extermination of the Tasmanians. It is called 'Truganini'. That was the name of the last full-blooded Tasmanian, a woman who died in the early 20th century. In her later years, she greatly feared that when she died, the British would dissect her and put her bones on display. They did.


One of the tragedies of life, I have found is that it is only by our own 'misdeeds' ( you may transpose that with any appropriate word from you treasury ) that we begin to understand the price of 'folly', how that folly came about and it's consequences. Then comes a sad wisdom and another sort of love. Thus I always call my advice asked for or otherwise 'Advice from an Idiot' in life and also as I look back on the History of my Island Race as well as others.

Why do I so despair of Britains modern Governments, all had good educations all know the truth, but the Monster did not die ...........I promise you I have shed many tears for the horrors done in the King/Queens name as I am warning you so will you.

Yes I am saying the USA is commiting genocide NOW on indigenous peoples. And only the American people can stop it.


It is true, if we are on a Ship to the future, we all have an arm on the tiller
 
The government of the USA is not engaged in genocide. If it was, the people of the USA could only stop it by means of a violent, bloody revolution.


Not if 'they' are told it is not happening ................... half way through January there had been 40 Drone deaths of innocents in Pakistan alone ............finding out about remote areas in The Yemen and so on is extremely difficult especially since journalist have become legit Military targets. But I saw the figures for the acknowledged attacks, they are many ...............and they are escalating.

The UN is obviously trying to do something to stop the madness but, what can any one do ? It is expected to be even more dreadful this year. It is up to you to find out for yourselves.
 
Not if 'they' are told it is not happening ................... half way through January there had been 40 Drone deaths of innocents in Pakistan alone ............finding out about remote areas in The Yemen and so on is extremely difficult especially since journalist have become legit Military targets. But I saw the figures for the acknowledged attacks, they are many ...............and they are escalating.

The UN is obviously trying to do something to stop the madness but, what can any one do ? It is expected to be even more dreadful this year. It is up to you to find out for yourselves.

The population of Pakistan is more than 176 million. 40 deaths out of a population of 176 million is (approximately) 0.000023% of the populaton of Pakistan. You have a uniquely bizarre definition of the term 'genocide'.
 
Believe me, I certainly share your concerns about the seemingly endless nature of the 'War on Terror'. I don't know when it will end. I don't think anyone should pretend to know. But it IS a real war, nonetheless. We know that Al Qaeda has made repeated efforts to acquire weapons of mass destruction, such as nuclear warheads, chemical weapons, and biological weapons. Do you really doubt, for even a moment, that they would be gleeful to unleash such weapons on America?

I rather doubt that ANY of our Founding Fathers could have envisioned large airplanes being flown into skyscrapers. They had neither airplanes nor skyscrapers at the time. I rather doubt that any of our Founding Fathers could have envisioned genetically-engineered biological weapons. Perhaps you see them as being prophets, rather than merely unusally wise men.

The Founders could easily have pictured terrorist attacks as deadly as 9/11 -- much deadlier, in fact, in proportion to the population at the time. 9/11 killed about 0.001% of the nation's population. That's proportionally equivalent to a 1790 terrorist attack killing about 40 people.... far, far less than we'd expect from a successful Guy Fawkes-style gunpowder plot.

Nor would it have been inconceivable to picture an attack, using only technology available at the time, that would have a death toll in excess of 9/11, even on a non-per-capita basis. Early American cities were tinder-boxes, with closely-built wooden structures and no serious firefighting technologies. Some historical fires have killed many thousands of people, including at least a couple fires in the US. And as recently as 1776 the Founders would have seen the great fire of New York, which burned down about a tenth of the city and was blamed, by the British occupiers, on rebel arsonists. Or how about the 1788 fire of New Orleans -- the year before the Constitution was drafted, in which about 80% of the city was burned to the ground. Whether or not those fires were actually acts of terrorism, it's at least clear that the Founders wouldn't have been hard pressed to imagine an act of terrorism much more destructive and deadly than 9/11, especially relative to their much smaller world.

So, I'm reluctant to take the view that somehow 9/11 should be seen a rewriting all the rules.
 
To sum up the Obamabot position with regards to drones:


Killing people with drones is okay. Killing people with guns is bad. Killing should only be done by the government because we can trust them.

Killing suspected terrorists with drones is good. Waterboarding them is bad.

Warrant-less wiretapping is a violation of civil rights. Killing Americans with drones without the benefit of due process is not a violation of civil rights.

Of course, if a Republican becomes President, all bets are off.
 
The use of drones as weapons is not illegal per se, and what I meant was that the extrajudicial killings by US drones is likely illegal under international law.
 
The use of drones as weapons is not illegal per se, and what I meant was that the extrajudicial killings by US drones is likely illegal under international law.

I would be in favor of more Congressional oversight of our drone program, particularly by the Intelligence Committees of both the House and the Senate, but requiring judicial review every time we kill an enemy soldier is the quickest and surest way to lose a war. If the Union had done that during the Civil War, the Confederacy would have won, and we might still have a slavery-based economy even today. If America had done that during World War II, the Nazis would have won, and we'd probably all be speaking Deutsch today. International law certainly does not require or demand that we have judicial review of every killing of an enemy during wartime. I have no idea where you got that notion.
 
LeRoy, sometimes I regret starting threads. This is one of those occasions. Thanks for the math assist. Figures as found in arithmetic texts were never my bag. Figures in other walks of life have tantalzed me. If ever a theme has been transformed into apples and oranges this one qualifies. All I wanted to do was try to put into prospective what my views are regarding using modern methods at our disposal to dispatch enemies who otherwise are not easily located. And my view was it's okay by me. I think I am qualified to make such calls since I was once in a position where making such harsh decisons would've detrmined whether I was to live or die (the introduction of atomic weapons to hasten the end of WWII). I figure (however lacking my skills with math are) that my being on Okinawa making ready for the assault on Japan proper put me in more of a lose/lose situation than a win/win predicament. Correct me if you think I'm wrong. Math is your field. I do not necessarily believe we'd have lost that war with conventional methods BUT ???????? who is to say for sure. We actually had the Nips on the ropes and were pounding hell out of them, not only because we'd developed a superior force but because we also improved the methods and gear for such a fight (the M-1 rifle being a simple explanation which gave almost every Yank the advantage in fire power to the eventual creation of atomic weapons). And I know one hellova a lot more about the facts surrounding Japan's loss than the average guy on the street BECAUSE (and I have never told anyone on these boards before) I was in the Counter-Intelligence bureau, often in the field, and equally as often where I was privy to top secret documents, the contents of which would scare hell out of lots of folks today.

I figure I owe a lot to those mathematical geniouses who perfect the atomic bomb as we as to the gutty guys who delivered them and to HST for have the courage to make such a horrendous decision. So, you see, LeRoy, What kind of individual would I been at this late date to insist we deny our people in the field whatever tools they need to succeed if I enjoyed the same privilege when I was in their shoes,

Now, why did I take this opportunity to respond to a host of responses to this thread by opting to reply to yours? Well, I knew you would read my message and digest my message without lot of cockamamie hokey-pokey nonsense and while you were taking time to assess it a few others posters might do the same.

Have a nice day, LeRoy.

Gramps




The population of Pakistan is more than 176 million. 40 deaths out of a population of 176 million is (approximately) 0.000023% of the populaton of Pakistan. You have a uniquely bizarre definition of the term 'genocide'.
 
I doubt that. I doubt it very much. I think that Obama went through a genuine evolution of his views on gay marriage, exactly as many, many millions of other Americans have. Including myself. If you had asked me back in the 1980s if gay marriage should be allowed, I would have not only said no, I would have said "HELL no!" If you had asked me in the early 1990s, I would have said the idea made me very uncomfortable. If you had asked me in the late 1990s, I would have said "I don't think I have any real problem with it, personally, but the American people are clearly not ready for it." Only at some point in the last twelve years or so, have I become a strong supporter of the idea of allowing gays to marry.

You know, Hillary Clinton, the former Secretary of State, whom you seem to admire very much for her 'honesty', was one of the people who HAD to sign off on the targeting of Anwar Al-Awlaki. The Secretary of State is one of the members of the National Security Council. Perhaps you weren't aware of that.

Did Clinton sign off on the killing of Al-Awlaki? Or was she merely one of those on the Council that did? Who was in the room at the time? Who voted which way? I'd love to know.
 
The use of drones as weapons is not illegal per se, and what I meant was that the extrajudicial killings by US drones is likely illegal under international law.

Nope. The geneva convention specifically addresses the issue of non-uniformed combatants. There is no requirement to provide "DUE PROCESS" to participants to hostilities unless they surrender.
 
I'm reasonably sure that the President doesn't just arbitrarily decide to order a drone attack. But to cover all legal ninceties we could have a (kangaroo) court and try these traitors in absentia and sentence them to death by drone.

If we're going to have targeted killings outside of war zones, that's exactly the kind of thing we should have. They should first have to get an arrest warrant. If they decide it's not feasible to carry out the arrest because of diplomatic and military issues (as certified in writing by the State Department or Pentagon), they can then petition a court for an execution order, and announce a trial. The person would be welcome to present himself for defense, or send an attorney to offer a defense. If the person were then proven guilty of a capital crime beyond a reasonable doubt, by a jury, he'd then be thrown in jail (if he had presented himself), or would be subject to a death warrant. That would preserve the Constituionally-guaranteed protections of due process and a jury trial.
 
LeRoy, sometimes I regret starting threads. This is one of those occasions. Thanks for the math assist. Figures as found in arithmetic texts were never my bag. Figures in other walks of life have tantalzed me. If ever a theme has been transformed into apples and oranges this one qualifies. All I wanted to do was try to put into prospective what my views are regarding using modern methods at our disposal to dispatch enemies who otherwise are not easily located. And my view was it's okay by me. I think I am qualified to make such calls since I was once in a position where making such harsh decisons would've detrmined whether I was to live or die (the introduction of atomic weapons to hasten the end of WWII). I figure (however lacking my skills with math are) that my being on Okinawa making ready for the assault on Japan proper put me in more of a lose/lose situation than a win/win predicament. Correct me if you think I'm wrong. Math is your field. I do not necessarily believe we'd have lost that war with conventional methods BUT ???????? who is to say for sure. We actually had the Nips on the ropes and were pounding hell out of them, not only because we'd developed a superior force but because we also improved the methods and gear for such a fight (the M-1 rifle being a simple explanation which gave almost every Yank the advantage in fire power to the eventual creation of atomic weapons). And I know one hellova a lot more about the facts surrounding Japan's loss than the average guy on the street BECAUSE (and I have never told anyone on these boards before) I was in the Counter-Intelligence bureau, often in the field, and equally as often where I was privy to top secret documents, the contents of which would scare hell out of lots of folks today.

I figure I owe a lot to those mathematical geniouses who perfect the atomic bomb as we as to the gutty guys who delivered them and to HST for have the courage to make such a horrendous decision. So, you see, LeRoy, What kind of individual would I been at this late date to insist we deny our people in the field whatever tools they need to succeed if I enjoyed the same privilege when I was in their shoes,

Now, why did I take this opportunity to respond to a host of responses to this thread by opting to reply to yours? Well, I knew you would read my message and digest my message without lot of cockamamie hokey-pokey nonsense and while you were taking time to assess it a few others posters might do the same.

Have a nice day, LeRoy.

Gramps

Hi, Gramps. I had an uncle who was one of the guys who loaded 'Little Boy' on the Enola Gay, to be dropped on Hiroshima. I have to tell you, I didn't like my uncle. He was one of the worst bigots I have ever met in my life. He always used racist terms in referring to blacks (calling them 'porch monkeys' was his favorite epithet), never got over his hatred for the Japanese (as late as the 1980s, he was saying that any American who bought a Japanese automobile was a traitor who should be shot), and once told me that Jimmy Carter was a traitor for giving the Panama Canal back to Panama. I always thought we could have exploded a nuclear bomb in Tokyo Harbor, minimizing civilian casaulties, and would have gotten the Japanese to surrender, but I also admit that I might be wrong about that. I am not going to criticize Harry S. Truman for making the decisions that he made in the waning days of that terrible war.

But I agree with you that we MUST leverage our technological superiority in fighting the terrorists. Some folks here seem to have the notion that we should just send in Sylvester Stallone and Arnold Schwarzenegger to fight them hand-to-hand. ["They'll know what to do!!"] I do indeed find that point of view to border on the ludicrous.
 
If we're going to have targeted killings outside of war zones, that's exactly the kind of thing we should have. They should first have to get an arrest warrant. If they decide it's not feasible to carry out the arrest because of diplomatic and military issues (as certified in writing by the State Department or Pentagon), they can then petition a court for an execution order, and announce a trial. The person would be welcome to present himself for defense, or send an attorney to offer a defense. If the person were then proven guilty of a capital crime beyond a reasonable doubt, by a jury, he'd then be thrown in jail (if he had presented himself), or would be subject to a death warrant. That would preserve the Constituionally-guaranteed protections of due process and a jury trial.

It must be pointed out that Anwar Al-Awlaki DID have a chance "to present himself [in court] for defense", and CHOSE not to do so. Having judicial review for every occasion in which we kill an enemy soldier is a particularly ludicrous idea, and would be the quickest and surest way of losing a war. We have NEVER done that. For very good reasons.
 
So were air attacks on German positions "Summary executions"?

If we are talking about someone who is making war on the US from France....would we use a predator? No. We'd rely on the local law enforcement officers to apprehend them. There would be court proceedings to extradite them and then they'd get the benefit of due process.

Do you actually think that the conditions you brought up were not considered by Obama and his security advisors? In what case was there a question about anyone who has been killed? Got a name? When could we have apprehended any of these people? Not in a war zone? Sorry, you must not know what is happening in Yemen. It is a war zone and large parts of that country are not under the control of the government. Certainly the areas in Pakistan being attacked are not under control of the government in Islamabad.

The rules are completely different when the targeted individual is in the United States. Even if the people involved were to say they are at war with the government.....

If we were at war with Yemen, I'd be fine with bombing there. We aren't.

The rules are completely different when the targeted individual is in the United States

Which rules, exactly? I'm a big fan of written rules, but if we've decided the US Constitution no longer matters, and that people can be deprived of life without due process of law and that a jury trial and a right to counsel and to confront one's accusers are all just quaint relics of the past that can now be ignored, I'm curious which rules remain that say things are different when the government is exercising its powers inside the US instead of elsewhere. Because I have a strong suspicion that if we found out that Obama ordered a suspected terrorists to be executed right here in the US, without trial, the mere fact that it was Obama who ordered it would have all the usual suspects telling me it was perfectly OK for such and such a reason. On the flip side, if it were some Republican successor, I'm sure those usual suspects would be up in arms about it, just as they were up in arms about Obama-style excesses back when they were Bush actions.
 
If we were at war with Yemen, I'd be fine with bombing there. We aren't.

Which rules, exactly? I'm a big fan of written rules, but if we've decided the US Constitution no longer matters, and that people can be deprived of life without due process of law and that a jury trial and a right to counsel and to confront one's accusers are all just quaint relics of the past that can now be ignored, I'm curious which rules remain that say things are different when the government is exercising its powers inside the US instead of elsewhere. Because I have a strong suspicion that if we found out that Obama ordered a suspected terrorists to be executed right here in the US, without trial, the mere fact that it was Obama who ordered it would have all the usual suspects telling me it was perfectly OK for such and such a reason. On the flip side, if it were some Republican successor, I'm sure those usual suspects would be up in arms about it, just as they were up in arms about Obama-style excesses back when they were Bush actions.

You are certainly engaging in a lot of very silly argumentation on this question, which is not like you, Arkady.

(1) We are not at war with Yemen. We are, however, at war with Al Qaeda, and Al Qaeda has a large presence in Yemen, which is a classic example of a 'failed state'. This is WHAT Al Qaeda does. They like to locate their operations and training camps in failed states. They have done so repeatedly. They have done so in Afghanistan, in parts of Pakistan, in Somalia, in Yemen, and most recently in portions of Mali, Libya, and Algeria, that are not under the control of the central governments of those countries. Why are you oblivious to this blindingly obvious pattern??

(2) It has been repeatedly pointed out to you that we have NEVER insisted on due process, jury trials, the right to counsel, and the right to confront one's accusers, when an American citizen joins a foreign force that is engaging in hostilities with the duly elected government of the United States. We did not do so during the Civil War. We did not do so during World War II (when some American citizens joined and fought for the Nazis).

(3) Your 'suspicion' is idiotic. If Obama were to order the execution of a suspected terrorist in our custody, here in the United States, without a trial, then he would indeed be guilty of murder, and should not only be impeached and removed from office, but actually prosecuted for murder. But he hasn't done that, has he?
 
Back
Top