New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

About them doggone drones.

So let's go on killing innocent people just like we have the past 200 years. That's the spirit.

The use of drones actually minimizes civilian casualties. This is precision warfare. We cannot help it if Al Qaeda chooses to use innocent women and children as human shields. But the situation is VASTLY better than the carpet bombing of entire cities that characterized World War II, no? The firebombing of Dresden was almost as devastating as the nuclear bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
 
LeRoy said this in responding Arkady:

So in USA = murder. Outside USA != murder.

I agree in the USA it would be murder. But tell me why? Why is it murder?

If we had been able to apprehend Awlaki, and brought him to the United States, and put him on trial, and had found him guilty, then he might have received the death penalty, in due accordance with our laws, and then we might have executed him, just as we did, for example, to Timothy McVeigh. Do you think we 'murdered' Timothy McVeigh?
 
LeRoy said this in responding Arkady:



So in USA = murder. Outside USA != murder.

I agree in the USA it would be murder. But tell me why? Why is it murder?


Because having the enemy combatant in custody proves that you were able to feasibly apprehend the enemy combatant. If he was tried and convicted and sentenced to death in a court of law, would that be murder?
 
The use of drones actually minimizes civilian casualties. This is precision warfare. We cannot help it if Al Qaeda chooses to use innocent women and children as human shields. But the situation is VASTLY better than the carpet bombing of entire cities that characterized World War II, no? The firebombing of Dresden was almost as devastating as the nuclear bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

So if we know there is a good chance that women and children might by murdered in these attacks we should go ahead anyway? Doesn't sound much like any American principle I know of. Doesn't our judicial system bend over backwards to protect the innocent?

I'll ask again. Do these attacks help in the long run? Are we gaining anything or are we just spinning our wheels killing as many terrorists as we are creating?
 
There is tension between the notions of the right to self-defense and the recognized human right to life that is not extrajudicially or arbitrarily terminated. Both are recognized rights under international law.

As you suggest, "International Law", such as it is, is necessarily a mish-mash of often contradictory ideas and provisos. For just about any "International Law' we might cite, there's a countervailing "International Law".

For instance and WAY oversimplifying:

Let's take a presumptive international law that says one nation shouldn't assassinate the leader of another nation. Sounds pretty cut 'n dried, hunh? BUT...there may be a whole 'nother international law that says all nations may defend themselves. So, which prevails? I would suggest that it's the latter. To the extent that "International Law" - as a practical matter - is actually applied, no person or nation could be "convicted" (so to speak) of the "crime" of assassination, no matter the evidence at hand, IF an even remotely plausibe case could be made that they did so in their own defense.

The only reason for me babbling all this, is to make the case that "droning" must be considered seperately from our perceptions of international law. If we decide that droning is bad in and of itself, we can then apply the principle of international law. BUT...if we decide that it's "good", then international law is essentially irrelevant. "International Law" will not - as a practical matter - forestall any nation from defending itself. It can't....because after all, the intirety of "International Law", whether we like it or not, is voluntary.
 
So if we know there is a good chance that women and children might by murdered in these attacks we should go ahead anyway? Doesn't sound much like any American principle I know of. Doesn't our judicial system bend over backwards to protect the innocent?

Really? You really just said that?!? How many women and children do you think died in our firebombing of Dresden during the waning days of World War II? Are you saying we were going completely against our 'principles' when we fought Adolf Hitler and his mad Nazis?

Look: war is a messy business. General George Sherman said "War is hell". Stanley Baldwin said "War would end if the dead could return." [That's a creepy thought!] Civilian casualties happen in war. SOME sides in a war actually strive to create as many civilian casualties as they can. We usually regard that as evil. In our more recent conflicts, America is striving very hard to MINIMIZE civilian casualties. We understand that we need to win the hearts and minds of the people in these countries. That is why something like Abu Ghraib HURT the United States VERY badly. It besmirched our image in the entire world. Undoubtedly, Abu Ghraib created more terrorists. Had we invaded Yemen to try to apprehend Awlaki, we might well have created 10 thousand new terrorists, just to get one. That would have been STUPID. If we can kill terrorists with our precision warfare, while minimizing civilian casualties, then certainly the hope is that, over time, the terrorist threat will wane. People will simply come to see terrorism as the route to a very short life expectancy. Perhaps, at some point in the future, we will develop techniques of warfare that are even MORE precise: weapons tailored to kill one and only one person, for example, possibly by zeroing in on their DNA. The stuff of science fiction, maybe, but we live in a science fiction world. You can BET that the Pentagon and DARPA are working on such technologies.
 
So if we know there is a good chance that women and children might by murdered in these attacks we should go ahead anyway? Doesn't sound much like any American principle I know of. Doesn't our judicial system bend over backwards to protect the innocent?

I'll ask again. Do these attacks help in the long run? Are we gaining anything or are we just spinning our wheels killing as many terrorists as we are creating?

I would suggest that what you're missing, is historical context. As compared with the way war has been conducted in ALL eras prior, "droning" CLEARLY results in the least mayhem, destruction, and death. It's all well and good that you want the world to transition from millions of deaths, to hundreds of thousands of deaths, to ZERO deaths in a historical blink of an eye. But, your wishes simply might not be practical.
 
I would suggest that what you're missing, is historical context. As compared with the way war has been conducted in ALL eras prior, "droning" CLEARLY results in the least mayhem, destruction, and death. It's all well and good that you want the world to transition from millions of deaths, to hundreds of thousands of deaths, to ZERO deaths in a historical blink of an eye. But, your wishes simply might not be practical.

Well put. That is what I was trying to say, but you did it much more succinctly.
 
The use of drones actually minimizes civilian casualties. This is precision warfare. We cannot help it if Al Qaeda chooses to use innocent women and children as human shields. But the situation is VASTLY better than the carpet bombing of entire cities that characterized World War II, no? The firebombing of Dresden was almost as devastating as the nuclear bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

I have no problem with drones, and I think the liberals who do have a problem with them are often engaged in some fuzzy thinking on the topic. Drones are merely a technology for delivering death -- a technology that has the advantage of having the precision of smart-bombs, without requiring that our troops be put in harm's way.

My issue isn't with the technology but rather with how it's being used. I'd be equally outraged by extrajudicial killings of people far from any battlefield if some commando was sneaking into their apartment complexes and planting bombs. What I want is a legal framework. I want a system of checks and balances, and some clear guidance that has the force of law, so that we don't have a president who essentially has the unilateral power to have anyone killed. If the president is going to have people killed away from a battlefield, I want an INDEPENDENT judicial-style review, according to legislatively dictated standards. And I want those standards to contain rules about when an assassination is permitted, versus requiring arrest, and also rules about the probable cause and the nature of the crimes permitting the killings.

For example, what if we found out Obama had killed an American based solely on the American's pro-Al Qaeda propaganda? Let's say there was no evidence the American had ever had any operational role in any terrorist activity or terrorist group -- he'd merely penned a series of essays arguing that Al Qaeda's acts were justifiable retaliation for various American attacks on Muslims. But let's say those essays were so persuasive and fiery that interrogations of captured terrorist suspects kept finding out that the essays had been an important factor in their becoming radicalized. So, the government thought we'd all be safer if the guy wasn't alive to write essays any more. Would that be OK?

I don't think so. I think that arguing that al Qaeda is justified is textbook First Amendment expression. But since Obama essentially considers himself as having complete freedom within a legal void, when he's purporting to be using force to secure us against terrorists, couldn't he disagree? And since there are no standards that have the force of law, governing that kill decision (since he invented whatever standards he deigns to recognize, in secret, without the legislative process), nor any independent forces with the power to overrule him, what's to prevent that abuse?!

I think for most liberals it comes down to "I trust Obama not to abuse that discretion." But we're supposed to be a nation of laws, not of men. The proper way for a liberal to be thinking about it is to ask himself if he trusts President Cheney not to abuse that discretion, because once the precedent is there, there's no telling who might use it and how. What's to prevent some future neo-con president from having Palestinian activists killed, on the specious grounds that they're providing aid and comfort to terrorists who are loosely affiliated with those who attacked us on 9/11? Once you concede that the president can kill whoever he wants if he thinks it makes us safer, you've allowed for all of that.
 
Really? You really just said that?!? How many women and children do you think died in our firebombing of Dresden during the waning days of World War II? Are you saying we were going completely against our 'principles' when we fought Adolf Hitler and his mad Nazis?

Look: war is a messy business. General George Sherman said "War is hell". Stanley Baldwin said "War would end if the dead could return." [That's a creepy thought!] Civilian casualties happen in war. SOME sides in a war actually strive to create as many civilian casualties as they can. We usually regard that as evil. In our more recent conflicts, America is striving very hard to MINIMIZE civilian casualties. We understand that we need to win the hearts and minds of the people in these countries. That is why something like Abu Ghraib HURT the United States VERY badly. It besmirched our image in the entire world. Undoubtedly, Abu Ghraib created more terrorists. Had we invaded Yemen to try to apprehend Awlaki, we might well have created 10 thousand new terrorists, just to get one. That would have been STUPID. If we can kill terrorists with our precision warfare, while minimizing civilian casualties, then certainly the hope is that, over time, the terrorist threat will wane. People will simply come to see terrorism as the route to a very short life expectancy. Perhaps, at some point in the future, we will develop techniques of warfare that are even MORE precise: weapons tailored to kill one and only one person, for example, possibly by zeroing in on their DNA. The stuff of science fiction, maybe, but we live in a science fiction world. You can BET that the Pentagon and DARPA are working on such technologies.

Fine. All wars are the same. War is hell. War is messy. No other options are ever available. Innocent people die. Repeat. Repeat. Repeat forever.

One last question for you. In your opinion are we making progess in this war on terror?
 
I have no problem with drones, and I think the liberals who do have a problem with them are often engaged in some fuzzy thinking on the topic. Drones are merely a technology for delivering death -- a technology that has the advantage of having the precision of smart-bombs, without requiring that our troops be put in harm's way.

My issue isn't with the technology but rather with how it's being used. I'd be equally outraged by extrajudicial killings of people far from any battlefield if some commando was sneaking into their apartment complexes and planting bombs. What I want is a legal framework. I want a system of checks and balances, and some clear guidance that has the force of law, so that we don't have a president who essentially has the unilateral power to have anyone killed. If the president is going to have people killed away from a battlefield, I want an INDEPENDENT judicial-style review, according to legislatively dictated standards. And I want those standards to contain rules about when an assassination is permitted, versus requiring arrest, and also rules about the probable cause and the nature of the crimes permitting the killings.

For example, what if we found out Obama had killed an American based solely on the American's pro-Al Qaeda propaganda? Let's say there was no evidence the American had ever had any operational role in any terrorist activity or terrorist group -- he'd merely penned a series of essays arguing that Al Qaeda's acts were justifiable retaliation for various American attacks on Muslims. But let's say those essays were so persuasive and fiery that interrogations of captured terrorist suspects kept finding out that the essays had been an important factor in their becoming radicalized. So, the government thought we'd all be safer if the guy wasn't alive to write essays any more. Would that be OK?

I don't think so. I think that arguing that al Qaeda is justified is textbook First Amendment expression. But since Obama essentially considers himself as having complete freedom within a legal void, when he's purporting to be using force to secure us against terrorists, couldn't he disagree? And since there are no standards that have the force of law, governing that kill decision (since he invented whatever standards he deigns to recognize, in secret, without the legislative process), nor any independent forces with the power to overrule him, what's to prevent that abuse?!

I think for most liberals it comes down to "I trust Obama not to abuse that discretion." But we're supposed to be a nation of laws, not of men. The proper way for a liberal to be thinking about it is to ask himself if he trusts President Cheney not to abuse that discretion, because once the precedent is there, there's no telling who might use it and how. What's to prevent some future neo-con president from having Palestinian activists killed, on the specious grounds that they're providing aid and comfort to terrorists who are loosely affiliated with those who attacked us on 9/11? Once you concede that the president can kill whoever he wants if he thinks it makes us safer, you've allowed for all of that.

I WANT more Congressional oversight of our drone program, in particular by the members of the Intelligence committees of both the House and the Senate. I don't know how many times I need to say that. But judicial review? NO. I know of NO nation, at any point in recorded history, that has applied the concept of judicial review to the killing of enemy soldiers during wartime, excepting only cases where we have CAPTURED enemy soldiers. I think demanding judicial review for each and every act of killing an enemy soldier would be the quickest and surest way to lose a war.

I agree with you that someone simply defending Al Qaeda in speech or writing is protected First Amendment speech.

No, I would not trust a President Cheney to have such powers. And since I am saying that more Congressional oversight is needed, I am NOT conceding "that the President can kill whoever he wants if he thinks it makes us safer".
 
Fine. All wars are the same. War is hell. War is messy. No other options are ever available. Innocent people die. Repeat. Repeat. Repeat forever.

One last question for you. In your opinion are we making progess in this war on terror?

It reminds me a bit of the novel 1984, where every few years, to keep the perpetual state of war going (which was necessary to keep the authoritarian government in place), they just swapped opponents -- if Eastasia was having trouble in its war against Eurasia and Oceana, the three would re-align, so that there was no risk of the war ever ending... and everyone would dutifully pretend they'd always been aligned in that configuration.

It's now been twelve years since we declared this particular war. In that time we've killed Bin Laden and killed or captured just about every other senior Al Qaeda member anyone had heard of back in 2001. We've blasted their cave bases to rubble. On a lark, we also started a war with Iraq and killed Hussein and his family, then helped kill Khadaffi in Libya, too. Every time the latest enemy we've identified is killed or captured, we just broaden or relocate the war, so there's no risk of accidentally finding ourselves at peace. As long as we leave enough grieving loved ones in places like Yemen, we can rest assured that the next generation will come along to pick up the Al Qaeda brand name, as an act of defiance, and then we can keep on fighting.
 
Fine. All wars are the same. War is hell. War is messy. No other options are ever available. Innocent people die. Repeat. Repeat. Repeat forever.

One last question for you. In your opinion are we making progess in this war on terror?

I am NOT arguing that "all wars are the same". We are trying, we are trying very HARD, to minimize civilian casualties. That is VERY different from earlier wars. The ancient Assyrians used to gouge out the eyes of captured enemies. I like to think that we are a little more civilized.

In answer to your question, I do not KNOW that we are making progress in the war on terror. I would LIKE to think that we are. Maybe you should ask me again in five years. I MIGHT have a better idea then.

Will you answer my earlier question? Did the U.S. government MURDER Timothy McVeigh?
 
It reminds me a bit of the novel 1984, where every few years, to keep the perpetual state of war going (which was necessary to keep the authoritarian government in place), they just swapped opponents -- if Eastasia was having trouble in its war against Eurasia and Oceana, the three would re-align, so that there was no risk of the war ever ending... and everyone would dutifully pretend they'd always been aligned in that configuration.

It's now been twelve years since we declared this particular war. In that time we've killed Bin Laden and killed or captured just about every other senior Al Qaeda member anyone had heard of back in 2001. We've blasted their cave bases to rubble. On a lark, we also started a war with Iraq and killed Hussein and his family, then helped kill Khadaffi in Libya, too. Every time the latest enemy we've identified is killed or captured, we just broaden or relocate the war, so there's no risk of accidentally finding ourselves at peace. As long as we leave enough grieving loved ones in places like Yemen, we can rest assured that the next generation will come along to pick up the Al Qaeda brand name, as an act of defiance, and then we can keep on fighting.

I think it is fairly obvious that Al Qaeda declared war on us, before we declared war on them. But maybe you have a different opinion.

The invasion of Iraq was a tragic mistake. In fact, it may well have been the most serious, world-class, geopolitical blunder the United States has ever made. I think we know who to blame for that.
 
So an American overseas is what... an enemy soldier or enemy leader?

That's the difference you chose to ignore.
 
Back
Top