New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Affirmative Action

Right... so ignoring a head start and continual boosts that come as a result of being white and male... that's NOT racism..

recognizing that, and taking that into consideration is...


IOW According to you, the very act of recognizing racism is itself.. racism..


WELLL DONE.

degsie has just solved the problem of poverty and joblessness in America.

well at least for white males
 
and that is the whole basis of lefty philosophy...that certain folks dont have a chance.
Want some oats with that straw?

No its based in the verifiable fact that whites and white males in particular, received uneared priviledged treatment and thus are actually achieving LESS.
 
Want some oats with that straw?

No its based in the verifiable fact that whites and white males in particular, received uneared priviledged treatment and thus are actually achieving LESS.

so I, as a white male, could have skipped college, sat on my ass watching the price is right and been a millionaire.

degsie, I feel like you don't care about me by relating this information to me decades too late
 
Want some oats with that straw?

No its based in the verifiable fact that whites and white males in particular, received uneared priviledged treatment and thus are actually achieving LESS.

Way to promote your racist views...not since lefty attacked the bus that the freedom riders were on near Birmingham Ala have we seen anything so dispicable...isnt the first time I hve called you out and wont be the last.
 
So essentially you are saying that minorities should "whitify" themselves rather than be taken at face value.

What makes you think that's what I'm saying?

I'm saying that in this particular case, this particular minority would not be subject to any race/ethnicity-based discrimination, based on his Hispanic ancestry, unless he went out of his way to identify himself as Hispanic, since there are otherwise no clues. I can know people for years without them finding out I have Norwegian ancestry, because it's just not the kind of thing that comes up in most non-genealogical discussions, and I don't wear that ancestry in my appearance, my name, or my accent. The same is true for his Hispanic origin. The only reason I even know of it is that he brings it up frequently (my company is very big on "diversity," so being able to claim minority status is a big career advantage.)

As for the idea that he is somehow "more qualified," that's utter nonsense in his case. Given the vanishingly small role ethnic discrimination played in his life (only whatever role he was comfortable letting it play, since his ethnic identity is only known to those he chooses to reveal it to), the ECONOMIC advantages he had were VASTLY more important in where he ended up. He could be dumber and lazier than your typical person here, because his super-rich and well-connected parents could see to it that he had all the advantages money and social status could buy in getting him ahead. I'll fully admit that he is an unusual case. But he's a case all the same. If race-based affirmative action is to be supported, it has to be supported despite its unintended role in increasing his advantage, not based on the false assumption that it somehow recognizes a disadvantage in his case.

My own niece is likely to be another example. She is half Native American, half Irish. Her mother had her by a Native American man, who died before she was born, and then she was raised by my brother. She doesn't look Native American (mixing that heritage with her mother's pale Irish complexion, she comes out the same tone as me). She doesn't have any other clues of Native American ancestry (she's got my brother's last name and a non-ethnic first name). She has no memory whatsoever of her Native American biological father, and as far as anyone in the outside world is concerned, she's just a white kid in a white family, like her siblings. Yet, unlike her siblings, she'll get preferential access to hiring, promotion, college admissions, etc., in addition to various other benefits that flow to those with Native American claims (free hunting and fishing licenses, access to special race-based scholarships, and potentially tribal revenue sharing if the tribe had any money). That doesn't counter any discrimination. And it certainly doesn't make it more likely that an employer or college will get the "best candidate." There's no meaningful sense in which she'll have to "accomplish more" to be on equal footing with others due to her hidden ethnic heritage. It's just a stray side effect of an extremely blunt policy tool. It makes it so she'll get something over a more deserving person because of a meaningless bit of genealogy.
 
Right... so ignoring a head start and continual boosts that come as a result of being white and male... that's NOT racism..

recognizing that, and taking that into consideration is...


IOW According to you, the very act of recognizing racism is itself.. racism..


WELLL DONE.

Yes, ignoring any head starts, etcetera, is what has to happen. You can't end racism by setting up a system of racial preferences.

You can't penalize underprivileged white males for being white and male, simply because they receive a perceived privilege in some environments. That's no way to heal the wounds of racism, it is simply a way to make people who already have racist proclivities say, "see, they (whomever the they is) can't make it without help." It promotes racism, it doesn't reduce it.

And as the affirmative action doesn't disambiguate for class, your arguments regarding class simply don't make any sense. The poor white kid does compete with the rich black kid -- but the rich black kid also gets affirmative action.
 
Yes, ignoring any head starts, etcetera, is what has to happen. You can't end racism by setting up a system of racial preferences.

You can't penalize underprivileged white males for being white and male, simply because they receive a perceived privilege in some environments. That's no way to heal the wounds of racism, it is simply a way to make people who already have racist proclivities say, "see, they (whomever the they is) can't make it without help." It promotes racism, it doesn't reduce it.

And as the affirmative action doesn't disambiguate for class, your arguments regarding class simply don't make any sense. The poor white kid does compete with the rich black kid -- but the rich black kid also gets affirmative action.

bingo. we have a black man as president. case closed.

all I need to invalidate degsie and the other race arsonist's claims is one person who did what they said can't be done. or they justify by saying that 'its hard'. apparently it's written somewhere that life shouldn't be hard
 
Way to promote your racist views...not since lefty attacked the bus that the freedom riders were on near Birmingham Ala have we seen anything so dispicable

"lefties" attacked the Freedom Rider's busses????? LOL!!!! your dishonesty is so hilarious.

Tell us again what your definition of racism is again? Oh yeah.. its the one that makes those Freedom Riders "racist" according to you.

LOL!!!

Your hatred of minorities and Obama is palpable.
 
quote_icon.png
Originally Posted by degsme
So essentially you are saying that minorities should "whitify" themselves rather than be taken at face value.
What makes you think that's what I'm saying?

Because you point out that somehow a "hispanic with no markers" somehow isn't confronting any challenges. Which means that if someone "whitifies" themselves, they have no need for Affirmative Action. which essentially is the same as saying that "if you whitify" then you eliminate the need for Affirmative Action.

As for the idea that he is somehow "more qualified," that's utter nonsense in his case. Given the vanishingly small role ethnic discrimination played in his life
See this is where you and Trap go off the rails. You ASSUME that there is a small role in ethnic discrimination in his life

  • AFTER he has already done the work of "whitifying"... which is an effort that he has had to make that YOU did not have to make.
  • without actually knowing what discrimination he has and has not faced or is and is not facing. For example, one of my sisters was the youngest VP ever at Wells Fargo. This would seem that she was NOT subject to gender discrimination. But the moment she got married, here boss started asking her when she was planning to have kids (she wasn't) and suddenly took her off of some plum assignments because they were multi-year assignments.

    As a co-worker, you would not have made that association, because you would still see her as the youngest VP on a supposed fast track

So its a big mistake to make such an assertion about his lack of discrimination.


Rememer I addressed the issue of ECONOMIC advantages in my example of Vanessa Williams. She and I both had economic advantages over Trapdoor. What she ALSO had, was a gender and race disadvantage in COMPETING WITH ME. And Affirmative Action for her would not put her in competition with Trap but in competition with me. Same applies to YOUR example. He's not competing with you since he's coming in with a higher starting off point.



And yes, there will ALWAYS be singleton edge cases in any public policy application. PUBLIC POLICY is not made by these edge cases.
 
Yes, ignoring any head starts, etcetera, is what has to happen.
IOW you want to ossify the remaining unearned priviledges you still have. That itself is a desire to CONTINUE racism

You can't end racism by setting up a system of racial preferences.
Its not happening. So that's a meaningless statement.

You can't penalize underprivileged white males for being white and male,
You aren't. You aren't being penalized WRT YOUR SOCIOECONOMIC PEERs.. that's the part you don't seem to get. What's really going on is that you don't want to give up what unearned priviledges you have.

Your notion of "healing the wounds of racism" is noble and completely meaningless if what you advocate is simply permitting existing racism - which while attenuated and more sublte STILL IS PERVASIVE.

People with racist proclvities are going to be racist anyway. not challenging them is like letting some as$hole like Drumcollie run around unchallenged simply to not "make waves".


simply because they receive a perceived privilege in some environments. That's no way to heal the wounds of racism, it is simply a way to make people who already have racist proclivities say, "see, they (whomever the they is) can't make it without help." It promotes racism, it doesn't reduce it.

And as the affirmative action doesn't disambiguate for class, your arguments regarding class simply don't make any sense.
Sure they do. Because the socioeconomic class self-disambiguates. Vanessa was never applying to the same schools you were. Nor was I. YOUR line of reasoning would suggest that it WOULD HAVE BEEN fair, if she was reduced to competing directly with you, while I didn't have to face an equal footing challenge from either of you.
 
So Here is one for y'all, will accept advice

Our youngest is 60-70% hispanic and has physical features as to where he could be a chameleon and change colors to suit his surroundings.

I always indicate he is hispanic when filling out all school forms and his mom ( a naturalized citizen from Central America) gets mad and says we should call him white because she thinks white kids have a leg up on the others. We have about a 65K household income and college is a big sacrifice for us and I try to explain to her that more grants and scholarship money as well as points towards acceptance at the better colleges are geared to give him an advantage as a hispanic.

So is it Warrenesque to take advantages of his minority status?

Or would he be better off raising the bar for him thus forcing him to overachieve as a white kid to get the same possibilities of acceptance
 
Our youngest is 60-70% hispanic and has physical features as to where he could be a chameleon and change colors to suit his surroundings.

I always indicate he is hispanic when filling out all school forms and his mom ( a naturalized citizen from Central America) gets mad and says we should call him white because she thinks white kids have a leg up on the others. We have about a 65K household income and college is a big sacrifice for us and I try to explain to her that more grants and scholarship money as well as points towards acceptance at the better colleges are geared to give him an advantage as a hispanic.

So is it Warrenesque to take advantages of his minority status?

Or would he be better off raising the bar for him thus forcing him to overachieve as a white kid to get the same possibilities of acceptance

milk the system for all it's worth, lup.

don't buy into the lib nonsense that you hear regarding, for example, taxes.

the wealthy manipulate the tax code in an effort to minimize their tax burden. because that's the way the system is set up. that's how the game's played.

so congress passes a law to penalize a particular activity. then the tax lawyers/cpa'S figure out a way around it and lobbyists make their case to the legislators and so it goes.

someone who knowingly pays more in taxes than they have to isn't philanthropic, they're stupid.

ditto affirmative action. the game is rigged. if your kid has a leg up because he can check a box and get him in the door, go for it. what he does once on the other side of the door is all on him so he'll have his chance to stand on his own merits.

maybe someday he'll be successful, run for congress and then do away with affirmative action; knowing that he didn't NEED it but simply took advantage of it because it existed
 
Back
Top