Because you point out that somehow a "hispanic with no markers" somehow isn't confronting any challenges. Which means that if someone "whitifies" themselves, they have no need for Affirmative Action. which essentially is the same as saying that "if you whitify" then you eliminate the need for Affirmative Action.
I guess we may be talking past each other here, because it seems I have absolutely no idea what "whitify" means. As far as I know, he's made no attempt to emulate any ethnic norms of any sort. He looks like what he looks like because of genetics, and talks the way he talks because that's how people in his peer group talked (at his elite boarding schools). I very much doubt he had to work on his accent any more than I did (I used to have a Texas twang when I was little, which faded effortlessly when I moved away from Texas). Your comments suggest he must have worked to "whitify." I see absolutely no reason to think that's true, if by "whitify" you mean to work to fit in with social cues expected of non-Hispanic whites.
You assume he faced a lot of discrimination. I assume he didn't. Neither of us know for sure. I do know that he was the youngest person in my department to reach a certain rank, and that he did so despite being CONSPICUOUSLY lazy (working shorter hours than any other person in a large department), and despite giving no appearance of being particularly bright. I also know that his mother was personal friends with the CEO, thanks to them serving together on a charity board. And I know that he went to the same private school as another senior executive, who served as his mentor. He basically followed a path similar to George Bush or Mitt Romney, with the whole path greased by family money and connections (admittedly on a smaller scale than those two). The only difference is that his father came from a dynasty in Latin America, rather than one in North America.
"And Affirmative Action for her would not put her in competition with Trap but in competition with me."
It puts her in competition with all of us. I have coworkers who came from money. And I've got ones who came from nothing. I came from the middle class. That gave me a few advantages that some of those working-class people I'm competing with didn't have (e.g., I only worked over the summers during high school, even though I had to work during college; and I lack any verbal signifiers of lower-class upbringing). But it gave me disadvantages relative to those who came from the upper class, like my Hispanic colleague. My mom doesn't go to social events with the CEO. My high school didn't give me an "in" with a senior VP (it was a public school in a small town in Maine). I didn't have an upbringing that lets me chat with the industry movers and shakers about skiing in Vail or our summer home in Hilton Head. I can't name-drop VIPs. And so a lot of doors were swung open for people like him that people like me have to fight like mad to open for ourselves. I'm very much in competition with people like that, and their economic and social advantages make the playing field of that competition decidedly uneven. Giving the advantage of affirmative action to some of them just makes that playing field even less fair.
"He's not competing with you since he's coming in with a higher starting off point."
I don't have a clue what you mean. I compete with him directly. Our reviews are done on a curve. I'm competing with him for raises, bonuses, and promotions. When there are layoffs, I'm competing with him for an opportunity to keep my job. In that competition, he'd have an advantage already, thanks to his connections and background. Affirmative action gives him another advantage on top of that. And it's not just the intended affirmative action, but also the subconscious affirmative action of those who know he's in a position to sue and I'm not. If they have to fire one of us, he's a member of a protected class, so he can at least get past the opening hurdle with a lawsuit, forcing expensive production of documents to establish that he wasn't fired for being Hispanic. If I try to sue when I'm fired, it's going to be very cheap and quick, because as a non-Hispanic white male who has not yet reached his elder years, I simply don't have standing for a wrongful termination claim. They won't have to show they had any cause to terminate me, because there's no reason that would have been off limits. So, which are they going to fire? Unless they can make a very clear-cut case that I was a lot better than him, I'm the much safer termination. And that also spares them the embarrassment of the CEO having to explain to mommy why her little boy suffered that loss.
Now, I'll fully admit again that he's an unusual case, and you can support affirmative action on the basis of the idea that ON AVERAGE it will do more good than harm, and thus that he's an unintended beneficiary and the poor whites he out-competes on that basis are the unintended victims. I have no problem with supporting policies that have some negative side effects when the alternative would be worse. I just won't agree to pretend those side effects don't happen or that they're inconsequential. Affirmative action does, without a doubt in my mind, worsen inequities in some cases, by enhancing the privilege of some already-privileged people. Some princes of the aristocracy get yet another unearned advantage against their competitors because of a meaningless accident of birth.