New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Annulment - ???

It isn't making the marriage as if it never happened. The marriage existed. But in Catholic law, a marriage must be both in official - i.e. you actually did get married under whatever rules governed your marriage, and must be sacramental. Sacramental is due to the fact that marriage is one of Catholic's Sacrament. In laymens terms think of it as blessed or approved by the church. So, an anullment says - yes you were married but the sacrament wasn't valid. Doesn't say there never was a marriage.
 
There are many poeple /churches who don't require you to go to marriage counseling. You can get married by a justice of the peace and not have any marriage counseling.

I know many people who went into marriage thinking - well if it doesn't work there is always divorce. That just simply isn't a marriage under the rules of the Catholic church. Doesn't mean they didn't have a marriage - but it didn't meet Catholic rules. And, that is all a delcaration of nullity is - for Catholics.
 
what I don't understand is if the church can say yes to an annulment and basically it didn't happen, then why haven't they been able to say the kids have no standing in a marriage that is considered as not have happened.

The truth is money rules the world and it has bought the catholic church. There is no rhyme or reason as to why a person can get a divorce because they cheated on the previous wife and couldn't reconcile the difference.

The real part is it's just like religion, it's able to change to meet whatever it needs too. It is only true for the moment. If it needs to be something different than has been, all you have to do is change it. Other words, marriage in a religious sense is pure garbage. It's a thing for law and that is it.

They are not saying that the marriage never happened. That is the misconception. The church doesn't actually use the term anullment - because that is NOT really what it is. Annulment has been used in secular terms for a marriage that is disolved as if it didn't happen. The Church actually uses the term - Declaration of Nullity - because it is about stating that part of the consents required to meet Catholic requirements wasn't there at the time the marriage was made. Doesn't mean there wasn't a marriage. Going forward that marriage would be continued to be listed in the Catholic records as a marriage.
 
I never had any of that when my marriage was annulled by the Catholic Church. A Bishop came round to my house, had a chat with me for about an hour. Next I got a letter saying that my marriage was annulled, and I was free to marry in a Catholic church. No forms to fill out, nothing to sign, no tribunal to attend, no witnesses to call, and nothing to pay. And, no reason given for the annulment. I still have no idea on what the grounds were for the annulment. Perhaps having a uncle-in-law who was a New York DeMarco might have helped!!
 
Well, it depens. Are you Catholic and was your first marriage performed in a Catholic church or via dispenseation? If not it was not to cannonical form, and those themselves are the grounds. Same true if your Ex was Catholic and you didn't get married in a Catholic Church.

CAtholics are required to be married in a Catholic Church by a Catholic priest. There are some rare occasions where a dispensation to this may be granted by your bishop. If you do not marry in a Catholic church, your marriage is invalid according to Catholic law even if you are married till death do you part, unless you get a re-affirmation of your vows in the church which I am forgetting the actual term for right now.
 
my good friend, an Episcopalean, married her first husband, a Catholic, in the Episcopal church. after the divorce, she wanted to marry her new Catholic beau. permission was granted (an annulment of sorts?) from the Catholic Church with the conclusion that her first husband erred in marrying in the Episcopal church. it cost 20 bucks. I'm not kidding. (or maybe that was the tip they left)
 
Right. Because her first husband was required by the Church to marry in the Catholic church. He did not so according to the CAtholic church the marriage was not valid. That is a very simple annulment. The process I outlined before was for people who had no requirement to marry in a specific way, i.e other religions or no religion.

connie
 
I know many people who went into marriage thinking - well if it doesn't work there is always divorce. That just simply isn't a marriage under the rules of the Catholic church.

That isn't a legitimate marriage under the rules of any Christian church. Hell, it's not even a legitimate marriage under secular law. That's why we have divorce. Divorce is a legal process to address a breach of contract. Catholics are not allowed to divorce, so they nullify instead. Same result.

BTW: You don't understand the Catholic definition of "sacrament". A sacrament is a ritual theoretically instituted by Christ and entrusted exclusively to the Church, by which divine life is dispensed to the Church members that have been properly prepared to receive the sacraments. A sacrament is not a code of conduct -- it is a magical spell that can only be legitimately performed by the Priesthood of the Church.
 
That isn't a legitimate marriage under the rules of any Christian church. Hell, it's not even a legitimate marriage under secular law. That's why we have divorce. Divorce is a legal process to address a breach of contract. Catholics are not allowed to divorce, so they nullify instead. Same result.

BTW: You don't understand the Catholic definition of "sacrament". A sacrament is a ritual theoretically instituted by Christ and entrusted exclusively to the Church, by which divine life is dispensed to the Church members that have been properly prepared to receive the sacraments. A sacrament is not a code of conduct -- it is a magical spell that can only be legitimately performed by the Priesthood of the Church.

Nope. What connie said about the sacrament is true. Receiving the grace of a sacrament, especially marriage, is contingent upon the person receiving to be receiving with complete belief in what he's taking and what he's engaging in, and with complete consent to what the sacrament now requires of him. The priest (in that ritual) administers the sacraments on the physical behalf of Christ. But he does not have Christ's view into the heart of the recipient. So the Church creates requirements to be met before each sacrament that are constructed to ensure that the recipient understands what he's receiving and what he should do during and afterward. If the priests were God, they could simply just know, the way God does, who is ready and who is not, who's mature enough, sincere, and who isn't. And there would be no formal requirements to meet.
So it's not unreasonable, but rather dead on, to say that someone who wouldn't live the tenets of a Catholic marriage didn't receive the sacrament.The priest on the altar at the wedding ceremony may not have known that this someone wouldn't uphold his promises, but when these facts come to light during a request for an annullment, it's understood that God always knew and God did not impart the sacrament onto that couple, leaving them both still able to receive it. There are four sacraments that can only be received once, two received as often as possible, and one when needed. Marriage is one that can only be received once.

We had an inlaw family member that didn't get his annullment approved. It seemed horrible at the time, given what he told us about how his exwife was throughout the marriage. But later, the decision proved wise since four years into the marriage, he was looking to marry someone else.
 
True, perhaps... Yet incomplete. What I said is also true. Then again, nothing in your post denies that.

I think my post does refute what you said about sacraments.

And Catholics are not penalized for divorcing anymore. The Church began to recognize that people do get left. Sometimes people have to get out of an abusive situation. The problem arises when the divorced person engages in a new relationship. Until and unless an annullment is completed, the Church thinks the marriage is valid. And if the marriage is valid, then whatever new relationships someone gets involved in are adulterous. Even some requests for annullment are denied. Not everything is grounds for an annullment.
 
I do understand what a sacrament is - which is why marriages which are entered into as if they are not permanent are not sacramental. And, actually - I think you are incorrect because marriages in the Catholic church are actually the two parties marrying themselves in the witness of others.
 
Yep married in a Catholic church, by a Catholic priest, ex-wife Catholic, me; brought up Catholic, first communion, confirmation, ex altar boy, the lot, and as religious as the average house brick.
 
If I recall correctly, that's the one that TK used...I don't think it's a matter of how many sentences one can write, but how many 0s one is willing to put on the check...

Friday, if old Martin Luther hadn't rocked the boat, Gnewt could have just bought an "indulgence" or two (maybe even got a discount for volume).
 
If you two don't understand the mystical aspect of the sacraments, then you don't know very much about the Roman Catholic Church.
 
Gigi - actually I think that when people decide to get married - and they're both adults and the marriage is not arranged by others - they are responsible for that marriage. It is just strange that the Catholic church can come along and declare that the marriage is null and void. It seems to make all marriages suspect because one party can decide, after the fact of the divorce, to have the church declare that the marriage never took place at all. Since the reasons the church allows people to use to declare the marriage null (e.g., "I didn't know what I was doing" or "he/she wanted me to use birth control") are so easy to state or to lie about, why is the church getting involved in this? Rather than having people jump through hoops to get their prior marriage(s) annulled, it seems the church would be simply happy to marry them in the church and levy whatever requirements (e.g., raise the children as Catholic) that they believe are important.

Exactly how I feel. It's something between you and your God.

I see no sense to annulment at all.
 
If you two don't understand the mystical aspect of the sacraments, then you don't know very much about the Roman Catholic Church.

NS, all of our sacraments come from Christ. Period. It doesn't matter what they resemble. At least not to Catholics.
 
NS, all of our sacraments come from Christ. Period. It doesn't matter what they resemble. At least not to Catholics.

You're correct. It doesn't matter what they resemble. It matters what they are. I'm not Gordon (bless his heart), and I'm not just trying to pick on you. I made no reference to similarities between Catholic rituals and any prior Pagan rituals from which they might have been adopted -- that is a different conversation altogether.

I'm only referring to the fact that the sacraments are, at least, purported to be mystical events imparting divine power to the recipient of the sacrament. If it's only a set of rules and ritual behaviors for you, then you're not doing it right.
 
You're correct. It doesn't matter what they resemble. It matters what they are. I'm not Gordon (bless his heart), and I'm not just trying to pick on you. I made no reference to similarities between Catholic rituals and any prior Pagan rituals from which they might have been adopted -- that is a different conversation altogether.

I'm only referring to the fact that the sacraments are, at least, purported to be mystical events imparting divine power to the recipient of the sacrament. If it's only a set of rules and ritual behaviors for you, then you're not doing it right.

It's divine grace that's imparted, not power.
And no, it's not only a set of behaviors to be followed. The behaviors are the outgrowth of the belief.
 
Belief in what? According to you, there's nothing Supernatural in which you believe. Are you a member of a Church, or a social club?
 
Back
Top