For three decades leading up to the mid-1960s, we had tax rates on the top bracket that ranged from 70% to 92%. This funded a rapid expansion of the federal government, including the creation of Social Security, the building of the Interstate Highway System, and the GI Bill. This was also an era of extraordinary intervention of the federal government into the economy -- massive government jobs programs like the WPA, and the creation of most of the major regulatory regimes in this country. The results were nothing short of spectacular for the nation.
And those tax rates were put in for a simple short-term goal -- to finance WWII both in the run-up before we were in the war, and to pay off the debts incurred during the war. They were part and parcel of a wartime necessity, neither designed to be permanent nor believed to be salutory (most economists predicted a huge economic collapse once the war ended).
And the taxes didn't go away for two reasons: 1) it was an era of strong economic growth (this was not caused by the taxation) so most people didn't care; and 2) The growth of entitlement programs through the 1960s meant it was difficult to end the higher tax rates. Despite this, even voices from the left realized they couldn't stay high forever, and one of John F. Kennedy's first acts as president was to push for lower taxation.
Unfortunately, around that time, we reversed course. From 1969 to 1992 the White House was controlled by a Republican for 20 years, and the remaining four years it was in the hands of a conservative Southern Democrat who presided over capital gains tax cuts (from a high of 98% all the way down to 28%). The results were predictably horrible. The poverty rate, which had hit an all-time low in the early 1970s, surged back upwards, and income growth was nearly non-existent for anyone who wasn't in the top 10%.
The blame game is a futile one, but if it must be played, let's point the fingers in the correct direction. You cite the period of 1969 to 1992 as 20 years of Republican control. That isn't true, if only because Jimmy Carter was president from 1976 to 1980, and despite what you say he was by no means a conservative Southern democrat. But much more importantly the period that you cite is also part of a larger political era -- the Democratic control of the House and Senate during the 48 years that preceded the Gingrich "revolution" in 1992. Presidents merely propose bugdets -- appropriations and expenditures happen in Congress.
Then the nation got an eight-year reprieve with some good leadership, under Clinton: poverty rates fell back nearly to their all-time lows, unemployment rates dipped far below what Republicans had assured us was "full employment" in the Reagan years, and incomes grew robustly at all levels of the income ladder.
Clinton benefitted from an economic boom time that he did little or nothing to create. The tech sector was taking off and continued to boom throughout the time he was in office -- but by the time he left office, economists were already hoping for a soft landing at the end of the boom.
Sadly, the good times couldn't last, and the nation again experimented with the catastrophically dangerous drug of Republican leadership. By 2008, the country was in a nightmare unlike anything we'd seen since before that long period of improvement first began, way back in 1933. We're still working to dig our way out of that mess.
I'm by no means a huge supporter of everything George Bush did, but his economy over his first four years in office is heaven compared to Obama's first four years. And you really don't want to get into a discussion of unemployment, especially as that is apt to be a rising indicator for at least the rest of this year.