Yes. And it can also, in theory, already data mine the records of stores that sell firearms. If you ever use a credit card or check to buy a gun or ammunition, or to pay for a gun range, or even to subscribe to the NRA, your information is out there for the taking. The key to keeping that behavior in line is punishing those who commit those breeches of law.
Not all, but most, gun stores maintain their 4473s via paper records. I did dozens of the useless things while working for a sporting goods chain several years ago. The only way to "data mine" such a record is to break and enter. Somehow, I doubt that's going on. As far as the government is concerned, I've purchased guns and ammo as gifts for other people, and my membership in the NRA is indicative of my politics, not of my gun ownership.
If they all have the etching (at least all those that can legally be purchased), then there's no competing purchase option, and it won't drive down the value as a collectible. It's akin to the way the color of old oil paintings always fades a bit. If it happens to all of them, it doesn't drive down the value of those it happens to.
But what would be the purpose of destroying the historicity of such a firearm? For collectors such as myself, firearms contain history and art -- they're representative of the cultures that produced them. There's a huge difference between a German revolver from the 1870s and a Colt revolver from the same period. Old paintings fade, but that's not what you're requiring. You're saying their value isn't harmed if new paint is put on them, and that simply isn't true.
If a law permitted it, yes. You can call that registration, or flocconucuhihalipilification, if you want, but that doesn't make it so
.
Well, then, given the choice I'll call it as I see it -- it's registration, and I oppose registration for reasons already stated.
Stop by the local library and use their computer. It's not hard. Before you go hunting, you have to get your brother a hunting license, too.... when you do that, just set him up with a temporary license to use your gun.
Under U.S. law I'm not even required to be able to read, much less use a computer. So you're saying I'd be denied a civil right for being uneducated, or in a remote place (not every rural town has a library, and if it does, not all of them have the Internet). So then the person I loan a gun to, for a simple trip out to the fields, is committing a "serious crime." I'd laugh, but it makes me feel more like crying.
Some would. Some wouldn't. Some, like criminals in countries where it's much harder to get your hands on guns and ammo, would do without, and that would push our violent crime rates down to something closer to what they have in those other countries. The goal isn't to make it impossible for criminals or the insane to get guns. That's impossible. The goal is to make it difficult enough for them that some meaningful percentage doesn't do it, who otherwise would if it were easier.
Well, what I see is that it would make things very difficult for the honest gun owner and have little or no impact on crime in general. It would just be a new layer of law that criminals (people who disobey the law) would ignore. I'm not certian the comparison with foreign countries that lack a tradition of firearms ownership is valid. If it is, let's compare with Brazil, which has no such tradition, very strict firearms control, and a violent crime rate with firearmes that is through the roof.
Think of it in the context of whether we should prevent alcohol and tobacco from being sold to minors. When we make the effort, it doesn't make it impossible for them to get their hands on those things. It just makes it harder, and thus cuts down a bit on use by them.
I don't think it cuts it down very much. It didn't when I was a teen. What I have seen, caused by what a pre-21 DUI can do to a teens license, is young people of legal age who drink too much because they're getting a first-time exposure (I'm opposed to having a drinking age -- I think education on alcohol is a parental responsibility and deciding when and how to use it is part of the adolescent experience).
Background-check loopholes for private sales and gun shows are analogous to cigarette vending machines they used to have available all over the place.... they're a convenient way for those who couldn't buy through normal channels to nevertheless get their hands on the product.
And I have no real problem with requiring a background check for secondary sales, so long as there is no registration and there is no additional cost attached to such sales. What I don't favor is allowing Mrs. "Send them all in" Feinstein to create a back-door registration system.
But if that happens, my AR-15 won't be illegal -- it will just be "undocumented."