New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Background Checks

The post I offered had a mechanism where you could report the stolen gun and the thief couldn't buy ammo for it....You now have a trail to link the thief to any other crimes committed with your gun.

So the thief uses a stolen gun and stolen ammo, but the crime still takes place -- the difference being that no matter how secure the storage facility the original owner has, you will now prosecute him because, after he was first a crime victim, his firearm was used to victimize someone else (perhaps you yourself aren't calling for this, but I've seen it called for here, and I'm assuming a worst-case scenario).

By the way, where in the second amendment is your right to lend a gun to anyone you please? I haven't seen that. You do realize that there are a number of limitations specified to your excercise of the right to "bear arms".

Anyone I would loan it to has a right to bear arms, too -- they're not restricted to just owning them.
 
And so she wouldn't have bought the guns for them, but someone else would have --- someone over 21 with fewer scruples than her. Beer is restricted to sales of people over 21, but I never had any trouble getting it when I was Harris and Klebold's age.




I'm all for "better" background checks, but I see no means to enforce a background check on private sales that doesn't amount to registration. Yes, this includes this "ammo purchase license" idea. You think that everyone on your side of the gun control debate, calling for more restrictions, is trustworthy. I have reasons for doubt on that score, as I've seen the actual violations of federal law used to create a registry of gun owners. That registry, done with the knowledge and support of the sitting president, was in direct violation of specific language written into federal law -- yet it was still created.



I think it would be safe to say that I don't see it as being as large a problem as you do. Even if you expand the category to "all gun deaths" the number of such deaths compared to the number of firearms could be measured in parts per million. If you restrict it to murders, its a small problem still, and if you eliminate the fact that most murders are "criminal on criminal" murders, the "problem" is still smaller.

So yes, I'm in favor of the slightly higher-risk environment entailed in by the additional freedom we enjoy.

Christ on a cracker....I've already explained how an APL could be implemented that it would not be registration, but either you are just flat out unwilling to engage the logic portion of your brain or you think you win the debate by pretending not to understand. The gun store takes your picture, embeds it in your APL. The picture exists no place else, but on your APL. Now when you buy ammo you present your card, the guy looks at you, looks at your picture...yup....it's you. Wand the card on a veriphone reader and it verifies that it is a valid card, optionally you could wand the barcode on the ammo box to make sure you are buying ammo for the gun listed on the APL.

You keep bringing up the so called "registration system". Do you have a link to support your assumption that it's use constituted registration? Your calling it as much is just not all that persuasive. My understanding was that the data was kept a few days longer than it was supposed to have and the ATF folks involved had interpreted the legislation as allowing it since it wasn't being used for the purposes of identifying the individual buying weapons. I only vaguely remember the event and can't find reference to it on the web, so I'd appreciate any link to the facts.

Talking about the odds of being murdered should be great comfort to the folks who have lost family members.

So yes, I'm in favor of the slightly higher-risk environment entailed in by the additional freedom we enjoy

Your guns have nothing at all to do with the additional freedoms I enjoy, but thanks for playing.....
 
Christ on a cracker....I've already explained how an APL could be implemented that it would not be registration, but either you are just flat out unwilling to engage the logic portion of your brain or you think you win the debate by pretending not to understand. The gun store takes your picture, embeds it in your APL.

Maximum regligious epithet -- WHO HAS ACCESS to the point where the ID and the weapon come together? If ANYONE has access to that, you can call it whatever you like but it is still registration. Your methodology is predicated on the firearms owner trusting people he has no reason to trust.

The picture exists no place else, but on your APL. Now when you buy ammo you present your card, the guy looks at you, looks at your picture...yup....it's you. Wand the card on a veriphone reader and it verifies that it is a valid card, optionally you could wand the barcode on the ammo box to make sure you are buying ammo for the gun listed on the APL.

The other trouble I see here is that it's a means of limiting ammo sales. If I need 5,000 rounds of 12 gauge ammo because I shoot skeet four times a month, I need no "nope, you've exceeded the limit on your ammo card" to keep me from having it. And as I said, no way would have any of my personal firearms data on a cell phone, or even accessible to one. It would mean a lost cell phone would target my arms collection for theft.

You keep bringing up the so called "registration system". Do you have a link to support your assumption that it's use constituted registration? Your calling it as much is just not all that persuasive. My understanding was that the data was kept a few days longer than it was supposed to have and the ATF folks involved had interpreted the legislation as allowing it since it wasn't being used for the purposes of identifying the individual buying weapons. I only vaguely remember the event and can't find reference to it on the web, so I'd appreciate any link to the facts.

I'll try to give you a detailed answer tomorrow. I'm strapped for time today. What I recall was not extra days, but months, and resistance on the part of the adminsitration to surrendering the data once there was a court order. No matter, really, as the law called for it the data to be destroyed immediately, not at some time later at the convenience of the executive.
Talking about the odds of being murdered should be great comfort to the folks who have lost family members.


For good or ill, that's how we tally up the risks we face in society is via statistics. It is a tragedy when one person dies in a car wreck, but we talk about seat belt laws in relation not to one death, but to the overall numbers of deaths. The same is true for firearms. It is a tragedy when anyone is killed with a firearm, even by accident, but that shouldn't prevent us from using the statistics as a measure of their actual risk.

So yes, I'm in favor of the slightly higher-risk environment entailed in by the additional freedom we enjoy

Your guns have nothing at all to do with the additional freedoms I enjoy, but thanks for playing.....

You, personally, choose not to enjoy the freedom of the right to firearms. For me, it is one of my central passtimes. Most people never use the freedom of the press, either, but for me it was once my livlihood, and I believe no one should be deprived of it.
 
Care to tell me how it could be anything else? It's a photo ID. Who takes the photo? It carries your address, your address must be on file somewhere -- that's how photo ID works on any other ID I've ever seen.




Some firearms made before 1968 DID have serial numbers -- but they weren't required. Many firearms (possibly most) didn't have them. You're saying its a small issue, but if I get caught with one, you'd call it a "serious crime."

By the way, unless you change the law, you're friends 1878 Colt wouldn't be captured by this scheme, either. Guns made before 1898 are considered "curios and relics" and aren't bound by the same laws as modern firearms.

1. Having a picture on a card doesn't mean your home address, phone number, blood type, mom's name, favorite food or any other information about you is recorded anywhere. What is recorded is the serial number of the card and the serial number and caliber of the gun. How many times do I need to explain that?
2. I would include any and all working firearms that you might want to buy ammo for. I don't care if it is a collector's item. That would be small comfort if used to blow someone's brains out.
3. Your understanding of how photo id relates to computerized records of your address and name are probably not a match for mine. I've written software for 911 systems, credit card systems, the Franchise tax board (California's IRS)...and know in intimite detail how computers work.
4. Your gun without a serial number....where do you get that I'd call it a serious crime? If you've modified the gun to eliminate the serial number, yes, I would...otherwise, no.
 
So the thief uses a stolen gun and stolen ammo, but the crime still takes place -- the difference being that no matter how secure the storage facility the original owner has, you will now prosecute him because, after he was first a crime victim, his firearm was used to victimize someone else (perhaps you yourself aren't calling for this, but I've seen it called for here, and I'm assuming a worst-case scenario).

Anyone I would loan it to has a right to bear arms, too -- they're not restricted to just owning them.
1. No, "ANYONE" does not have the right to bear arms. It is already accepted that convicted felons have lost that right. In 17 states is is accepted that if you've been committed by court order to psychiatric care you do not have that right....in many states if you have a restraining order you may not buy a gun.

2. No, you report the stolen gun and it is used in a crime, you are not subject to prosecution unless you may have been careless in the storage and security of your weapons....in which case you may be prosecuted for "careless indifference", which is something that could happen even now.
 
You are not being deprived of your right to own a firearm...that is your last refuge, that somehow that is the goal of all those damned liberals, even if it isn't. I've owned guns and do not wish to take yours away.

You mind the additional risk entailed to allow you to own guns, but that doesn't have to extend to ex-felons or the possibly criminal insane.

As far as your first point..."WHO HAS ACCESS to the point where the ID and the weapon come together? If ANYONE has access to that, you can call it whatever you like but it is still registration. Your methodology is predicated on the firearms owner trusting people he has no reason to trust."

I have no idea what you are talking about....Where do the id and the weapon "come together"? At your house? When you walk into the gun store to both buy ammo and get your gun serviced? The idea I've offered, in fact, prevents someone from being able to access any central information source that would identify you as a gun owner.

I've said nothing about limiting how much ammo you buy. That is you, off in search of something to whine about again.

You do realize that such an attempt would require congressional legislation to allow it? Quit inventing bogeymen....
 
I found a reference to the "Firearms Tracing System" in some NRA documents that basically allege that the BATF is using that system as a backdoor registration. The allegation is based on keeping records related to a trace on a gun. So if the gun is suspected of having been used in a crime then there is a trace to figure out where it originated and who all the owners were. Those records are kept forever. The NRA alleges that this is a way to make addresses of gun owners available, since even when it is determined that the gun wasn't used in a crime, the record isn't expunged. I find it difficult to believe that this is the genesis of a mechanism to confiscate guns.....you will probably disagree.

In any case, there are other references to data from FFL dealers who go out of business. That data may be paper documents or they may be digitized records. That data is then sent to the BATF. The NRA doesn't like that either.
 
1. Having a picture on a card doesn't mean your home address, phone number, blood type, mom's name, favorite food or any other information about you is recorded anywhere. What is recorded is the serial number of the card and the serial number and caliber of the gun. How many times do I need to explain that?

So my name's not on the card and it can be created in the gun store using simple equipment. Fine, I'll just make my own at home and buy whatever ammo I want. I apologize for the sarcasm, but the system you propose is simply pie in the sky.

2. I would include any and all working firearms that you might want to buy ammo for. I don't care if it is a collector's item. That would be small comfort if used to blow someone's brains out
.

Can you show that antiques are a high-crime creator that need to be controlled in the new way you're describing. You know, I have a Swiss military rifle made in 1867. You can't buy "factory ready" ammo for it. You have to by the brass for a current rifle, modify that brass to fit the Swiss rifle, and then make your own projectiles (projects like this are fun). How would I do that if I have to own a rifle in the same caliber as my ammo card?

3. Your understanding of how photo id relates to computerized records of your address and name are probably not a match for mine. I've written software for 911 systems, credit card systems, the Franchise tax board (California's IRS)...and know in intimite detail how computers work.

I don't have to know how these systems are created to know how they're abused, hacked and otherwise not suitable for my private information.

4. Your gun without a serial number....where do you get that I'd call it a serious crime? If you've modified the gun to eliminate the serial number, yes, I would...otherwise, no.

Well, either you or Arkady said having a gun where the serial number didn't match the ammo card would be a "serious crime." I'm sorry if I got the two of you confused. On this forum I am as outnumbered as you would be on a pro-gun forum and attempting to respond to all is akin to juggling chain saws while balancing on one foot.
 
1. No, "ANYONE" does not have the right to bear arms. It is already accepted that convicted felons have lost that right. In 17 states is is accepted that if you've been committed by court order to psychiatric care you do not have that right....in many states if you have a restraining order you may not buy a gun.

I didn't say anyone has a right to keep and bear arms. I said anyone I would loan a gun to has the right to keep and bear arms. Would you loan or sell a gun go a criminal? Neither would I.

2. No, you report the stolen gun and it is used in a crime, you are not subject to prosecution unless you may have been careless in the storage and security of your weapons....in which case you may be prosecuted for "careless indifference", which is something that could happen even now.

Who gets to decide what level of storage is "careless," and how will that determination be made? Will police need a warrant to come to your home to determine the safe level of storage?
 
I found a reference to the "Firearms Tracing System" in some NRA documents that basically allege that the BATF is using that system as a backdoor registration. The allegation is based on keeping records related to a trace on a gun. So if the gun is suspected of having been used in a crime then there is a trace to figure out where it originated and who all the owners were. Those records are kept forever. The NRA alleges that this is a way to make addresses of gun owners available, since even when it is determined that the gun wasn't used in a crime, the record isn't expunged. I find it difficult to believe that this is the genesis of a mechanism to confiscate guns.....you will probably disagree.

That's not what I was referencing, although it is yet another means of backdoor registration. I don't want any registration, no matter how seemingly noble the cause. Once they've done the trace, why would they need the records or keep them?

In any case, there are other references to data from FFL dealers who go out of business. That data may be paper documents or they may be digitized records. That data is then sent to the BATF. The NRA doesn't like that either.

I'm not wild about that, either. It's a provision of the 1968 Gun Control Act, and I'm not certain how it contributes to the benefit of society .
 
So again, why did Wayne LaPierre wholeheartedly endorse universal background checks in 1999....

but opposes them today???
 
You are not being deprived of your right to own a firearm...that is your last refuge, that somehow that is the goal of all those damned liberals, even if it isn't. I've owned guns and do not wish to take yours away
.

That's not true. You support a ban on assault weapons, that would take some of them away.


As far as your first point..."WHO HAS ACCESS to the point where the ID and the weapon come together? If ANYONE has access to that, you can call it whatever you like but it is still registration. Your methodology is predicated on the firearms owner trusting people he has no reason to trust."

I have no idea what you are talking about....Where do the id and the weapon "come together"? At your house? When you walk into the gun store to both buy ammo and get your gun serviced? The idea I've offered, in fact, prevents someone from being able to access any central information source that would identify you as a gun owner.

At some point, that card is going to have to have my name on it, and some unique number that identifies me, and the "legitimate" ownership of the gun for which I'm buying ammo. If it doesn't do that, it is functionally useless for the purpose you say you desire. If it does do that -- it's registration.

I've said nothing about limiting how much ammo you buy. That is you, off in search of something to whine about again.

YOU haven't said anything about that -- other people on this board most certainly have. If such a system ever went through the sausage making of becoming actual law, I'd expect an ammo limit would be the least of my worries, but it would be among them.
 
I haven't found it from a source you'll accept, but the violation of the law done during the Clinton era that effectively created a firearms registry was not done by the BATF as I recalled, it was done by the FBI. The FBI violated the McClure-Volkmer Act by retaining the individual data from NICS checks, keeping them for an alleged 18 months (we really don't know how long they were keeping them -- they weren't supposed to keep them at all).
 
Guns made before 1968 weren't required to have serial numbers. Who would have access to the third-party web service? I'd suspect the government would be able to subpoena that information, or just take it via warrantless searches the way it data mines overseas phone calls.

Yes. And it can also, in theory, already data mine the records of stores that sell firearms. If you ever use a credit card or check to buy a gun or ammunition, or to pay for a gun range, or even to subscribe to the NRA, your information is out there for the taking. The key to keeping that behavior in line is punishing those who commit those breeches of law.

What if its a Remington semiautomatic shotgun my uncle bought in 1966? It's not "very old with inherent value" as an antique. Neither is it an "old untraceable flintlock (flintlocks aren't considered firearms under federal law). Its sole current value is as a "shooter" and its sentimental connection to my relative, but having a serial number engraved on it would destroy its originality and ruin any future collector's value.

If they all have the etching (at least all those that can legally be purchased), then there's no competing purchase option, and it won't drive down the value as a collectible. It's akin to the way the color of old oil paintings always fades a bit. If it happens to all of them, it doesn't drive down the value of those it happens to.

Would or would not a police officer have the abiliity to find out if I had a weapon legallly during a police stop? If he would, then he would have the same ability at my home. That's registration, no matter what you choose to call it.

If a law permitted it, yes. You can call that registration, or flocconucuhihalipilification, if you want, but that doesn't make it so.
What if I don't own a smart phone. Morel likely, what if I'm in a remote part of a rural area (you know, where people go hunting) and have no cell phone or computer service? Then my brother is liable for a "serious crime" (your words) even though neither he nor myself are engaged in an illegal activity.

Stop by the local library and use their computer. It's not hard. Before you go hunting, you have to get your brother a hunting license, too.... when you do that, just set him up with a temporary license to use your gun.

Well, I don't believe in having a slap on the wrist fine because I've loaned my brother (or anyone else I know) a rifle or shotgun or pistol to hunt with.

Then simply get the temporary license. If you choose, instead, to defy the law, then pay the fine, the same as if you'd chosen to hunt without getting your hunting license, or out of season, etc.
Criminals wouldn't bother with them, they'd simply steal guns and ammo.

Some would. Some wouldn't. Some, like criminals in countries where it's much harder to get your hands on guns and ammo, would do without, and that would push our violent crime rates down to something closer to what they have in those other countries. The goal isn't to make it impossible for criminals or the insane to get guns. That's impossible. The goal is to make it difficult enough for them that some meaningful percentage doesn't do it, who otherwise would if it were easier.

Think of it in the context of whether we should prevent alcohol and tobacco from being sold to minors. When we make the effort, it doesn't make it impossible for them to get their hands on those things. It just makes it harder, and thus cuts down a bit on use by them. Background-check loopholes for private sales and gun shows are analogous to cigarette vending machines they used to have available all over the place.... they're a convenient way for those who couldn't buy through normal channels to nevertheless get their hands on the product. Closing those loopholes and getting rid of cigarette vending machines doesn't keep the target audience from getting their hands on the product in all cases, but it cuts down on how many do.
 
Yes. And it can also, in theory, already data mine the records of stores that sell firearms. If you ever use a credit card or check to buy a gun or ammunition, or to pay for a gun range, or even to subscribe to the NRA, your information is out there for the taking. The key to keeping that behavior in line is punishing those who commit those breeches of law.

Not all, but most, gun stores maintain their 4473s via paper records. I did dozens of the useless things while working for a sporting goods chain several years ago. The only way to "data mine" such a record is to break and enter. Somehow, I doubt that's going on. As far as the government is concerned, I've purchased guns and ammo as gifts for other people, and my membership in the NRA is indicative of my politics, not of my gun ownership.

If they all have the etching (at least all those that can legally be purchased), then there's no competing purchase option, and it won't drive down the value as a collectible. It's akin to the way the color of old oil paintings always fades a bit. If it happens to all of them, it doesn't drive down the value of those it happens to.

But what would be the purpose of destroying the historicity of such a firearm? For collectors such as myself, firearms contain history and art -- they're representative of the cultures that produced them. There's a huge difference between a German revolver from the 1870s and a Colt revolver from the same period. Old paintings fade, but that's not what you're requiring. You're saying their value isn't harmed if new paint is put on them, and that simply isn't true.



If a law permitted it, yes. You can call that registration, or flocconucuhihalipilification, if you want, but that doesn't make it so
.

Well, then, given the choice I'll call it as I see it -- it's registration, and I oppose registration for reasons already stated.


Stop by the local library and use their computer. It's not hard. Before you go hunting, you have to get your brother a hunting license, too.... when you do that, just set him up with a temporary license to use your gun.

Under U.S. law I'm not even required to be able to read, much less use a computer. So you're saying I'd be denied a civil right for being uneducated, or in a remote place (not every rural town has a library, and if it does, not all of them have the Internet). So then the person I loan a gun to, for a simple trip out to the fields, is committing a "serious crime." I'd laugh, but it makes me feel more like crying.

Some would. Some wouldn't. Some, like criminals in countries where it's much harder to get your hands on guns and ammo, would do without, and that would push our violent crime rates down to something closer to what they have in those other countries. The goal isn't to make it impossible for criminals or the insane to get guns. That's impossible. The goal is to make it difficult enough for them that some meaningful percentage doesn't do it, who otherwise would if it were easier.

Well, what I see is that it would make things very difficult for the honest gun owner and have little or no impact on crime in general. It would just be a new layer of law that criminals (people who disobey the law) would ignore. I'm not certian the comparison with foreign countries that lack a tradition of firearms ownership is valid. If it is, let's compare with Brazil, which has no such tradition, very strict firearms control, and a violent crime rate with firearmes that is through the roof.

Think of it in the context of whether we should prevent alcohol and tobacco from being sold to minors. When we make the effort, it doesn't make it impossible for them to get their hands on those things. It just makes it harder, and thus cuts down a bit on use by them.

I don't think it cuts it down very much. It didn't when I was a teen. What I have seen, caused by what a pre-21 DUI can do to a teens license, is young people of legal age who drink too much because they're getting a first-time exposure (I'm opposed to having a drinking age -- I think education on alcohol is a parental responsibility and deciding when and how to use it is part of the adolescent experience).

Background-check loopholes for private sales and gun shows are analogous to cigarette vending machines they used to have available all over the place.... they're a convenient way for those who couldn't buy through normal channels to nevertheless get their hands on the product.

And I have no real problem with requiring a background check for secondary sales, so long as there is no registration and there is no additional cost attached to such sales. What I don't favor is allowing Mrs. "Send them all in" Feinstein to create a back-door registration system.

But if that happens, my AR-15 won't be illegal -- it will just be "undocumented."
 
So my name's not on the card and it can be created in the gun store using simple equipment. Fine, I'll just make my own at home and buy whatever ammo I want. I apologize for the sarcasm, but the system you propose is simply pie in the sky.

No, your name and picture are on the card. The card also has an embedded machine readable serial number, which, when wanded at the gun store, verifies at the FBI that it is a valid card and that the caliber of ammo you are buying is correct. Why is it that you think that your picture and name on the card means it has to be recorded somewhere? It isn't. The guy who made your card got your name from your DL when you passed your background check...and your picture was taken at the same time....

Can you show that antiques are a high-crime creator that need to be controlled in the new way you're describing. You know, I have a Swiss military rifle made in 1867. You can't buy "factory ready" ammo for it. You have to by the brass for a current rifle, modify that brass to fit the Swiss rifle, and then make your own projectiles (projects like this are fun). How would I do that if I have to own a rifle in the same caliber as my ammo card?

No, and I don't need to. The idea is to make a system that doesn't have loopholes that someone will figure out a way through. As far as your Swiss rifle... You can simply list the appropriate caliber when you go in for your background check. I'm sure that the person handling your APL will understand what you are saying and work with you on it....this isn't hard stuff. You just want to make it seem so.

I don't have to know how these systems are created to know how they're abused, hacked and otherwise not suitable for my private information.

You are wrong. You don't know that they were abused, unless you found that credible account of a system that was actually hacked or abused. Your paranoia gets in the way of a rational conversation about solutions....




Well, either you or Arkady said having a gun where the serial number didn't match the ammo card would be a "serious crime." I'm sorry if I got the two of you confused. On this forum I am as outnumbered as you would be on a pro-gun forum and attempting to respond to all is akin to juggling chain saws while balancing on one foot.[/QUOTE]
 
The only way to "data mine" such a record is to break and enter.

A tax audit would do the trick.

my membership in the NRA is indicative of my politics, not of my gun ownership.

It would be a good place to start a search for guns if we were doing seizures, don't you think?

But what would be the purpose of destroying the historicity of such a firearm?

To allow for enforcing background checks on sales, obviously. That's what we were discussing.

Under U.S. law I'm not even required to be able to read, much less use a computer. So you're saying I'd be denied a civil right for being uneducated, or in a remote place (not every rural town has a library, and if it does, not all of them have the Internet).

No. That's what YOU'RE saying. I'm saying you are quite welcome to exercise your civil right, but if you want to sell or transfer your firearm, you'll need to have a certificate. If you're too uneducated or remote to handle that, get a buddy to do it for you. Maybe the NRA will help.

So then the person I loan a gun to, for a simple trip out to the fields, is committing a "serious crime." I'd laugh, but it makes me feel more like crying.

Not at all. You're only committing a crime if you willfully choose to commit one by refusing to take the extremely simple steps provided for in the law. IF you choose to commit that crime, I will laugh.

Well, what I see is that it would make things very difficult for the honest gun owner

Not me. I see no significant difficulty.
and have little or no impact on crime in general.

All real-world experience would cause us to anticipate a significant impact.

I don't think it cuts it down very much. It didn't when I was a teen.

I don't know when you were a teen, but teen smoking is, in fact, down sharply in recent decades.

And I have no real problem with requiring a background check for secondary sales, so long as there is no registration and there is no additional cost attached to such sales.

Do you have any ideas for having a no-cost system that would not include "registration" (using your own counter-factual, ultra-broad definition of that term) that would have any enforceability? If not, I'll interpret your statement as "I have no problem with doing this as long as we do it in a way that would be utterly pointless, since then I know we won't bother."

What I don't favor is allowing Mrs. "Send them all in" Feinstein to create a back-door registration system.

Has Feinstein called for confiscation of all guns? If not, what are you referring to?
 
I didn't say anyone has a right to keep and bear arms. I said anyone I would loan a gun to has the right to keep and bear arms. Would you loan or sell a gun go a criminal? Neither would I.

Cool. So you'd do a background check, prior to loaning or selling a gun. Great!


Who gets to decide what level of storage is "careless," and how will that determination be made? Will police need a warrant to come to your home to determine the safe level of storage?

Hmm, I'm thinking a prosecutor may make a decision based on what he learns about the source of a gun or guns used in a crime. If he thinks that a reasonable person would have locked up his guns....he may just press charges if your guns were used and they were left laying on the back seat of your car, windows down, doors unlocked....
In any case, it would be up to a jury to decide.
 
I haven't found it from a source you'll accept, but the violation of the law done during the Clinton era that effectively created a firearms registry was not done by the BATF as I recalled, it was done by the FBI. The FBI violated the McClure-Volkmer Act by retaining the individual data from NICS checks, keeping them for an alleged 18 months (we really don't know how long they were keeping them -- they weren't supposed to keep them at all).

So you do not have a source for your allegation. Ok. What you know is that some blog, somewhere, says the BATF maintained data for the purpose akin to a registration....got it. So how many guns were confiscated as a result?
 
Back
Top