NightSwimmer
Senator
I know of no way that a doctor can order someone committed without either a court order or the patient agrees.
Perhaps you should entertain the possibility that you do not know everything?
I know of no way that a doctor can order someone committed without either a court order or the patient agrees.
I'm pretty sure that background checks have been legally imposed (or there anyway even if not imposed) for a long long time.
I have no problem with background checks, however, if someone wants a gun and cannot pass that sort of check, I am quite certain that there are ways of getting a gun anyway. And that is one of the reasons we have problems in this country. The guns are out there. No way to haul them all in. What we need is hefty and mandatory sentencing for anyone committing any sort of crime with a gun or a gun in their possession.
That wouldn't have stopped crazy people like the fellow that killed the kids in Sandy Hook. As far as I can tell, everything there was on the up and up and his mom would have passed a background check to get her guns.
Background checks are only mandatory when you buy a gun from a dealer. Not when you answer an ad in the paper or hang out in the parking lot at a gun show....
Perhaps you should entertain the possibility that you do not know everything?
And most such transactions are from a person who would be a legal seller to a person who would be a legal buyer. Why would they be any of the government's business?
Really? The sale of a car is the government's business, but the sale of a gun is not.....
Look up how Harris and Klebold got their guns. A straw buyer and an illegal sale to a minor. No background checks at all.....
I came up with a method of enforcing background checks in private sales without requiring registration. It's not as good as a full registration system, which I advocate, but it would be better than nothing.
He
And there would be a registry of the cards, no matter how carefully you policed the system. How do I know this? Based on what the BATF did with the Insta Check system during the Clinton administration. The Insta Check law specifically forbids the retention of Insta-Check-collected data in order to keep a registry, yet the BATF did exactly that as a means of "studying patterns of gun sales." It's just back-door registration.
Further, I own about 30 firearms. Under your proposed regimen, I'd hvae to carry a deck of cards just to purchase ammo or ammo components, let alone firearms. Other problems include "entering the serial number of the firearm." A lot of weapons made before 1968 didn't have serial numbers -- does that mean we can't own antiques anymore?
So you're saying there would be a computer-based way to determine that this person had legal ownership of this gun -- in other words, registration. You're saying it isn't but it is. Let's pick a different scenario. I own two shotguns, and I and my brother go quail hunting. He borrows one of my shotguns and we're at opposite ends of a 300-acre field. He gets stopped by a game warden. He doesn't have the authentication code -- now he's guilty of a serious crime?
It's just a different form of registration.
The typical complaint with any record keeping that folks like you call registration, is that it could be used to confiscate guns. If the records kept at the ATF do not contain your name, address, SS number, driver's license info....and cannot be used to trace the gun to you....then it doesn't rise to the definition of registration that could be used for confiscation.
Your "problem" of owning 30 guns can easily be resolved by combining those cards into a single card. No problem. If you sold one then you'd have to get a new card with the remaining 29 guns on it. Big deal. We can record a lot of info on that card and the info we are talking about only needing a serial number of the card itself, the serial numbers of the guns, the caliber of the guns....and maybe the date issued. Your picture and your name would be on the front, but your ID would not be recorded at the ATF.
The real issue here is that people on your end of the conversation aren't interested in a solution. The only answer we get from you guys is "good guys with guns" to kill "bad guys with guns" or we make the punishment for using the gun in a crime more severe....nothing at all about prevention.
The use of a car on the public roads is a privilege, not a right, and you only have to register the sale if you wish to enjoy the privilege -- you don't have to license or register a car you're junking, just for example. The straw purchaser who bought the Columbine weapons would have passed the background checks, so the background check, per se, is irrelevant. Klebold and Harris were in violation of 19 federal and state firearms laws -- another layer of laws wouldn't have prevented their activities, as they'd have simply ignored them as they did the National Firearms Act, the Gun Control Act of 1968, and the Firearms Owners Protection Act of 1986.
What I see in all of the current legislation is a panic, a need to do something, something, and right now "for the sake of the children," even if that something either shows no respect for the millions of legal gun owners, and is apt to be ineffective from the standpoint of reducing cri
me. The guns used in Connecticut, after all, had been purchased legally in a state that had background checks and registration. And my reasoned assumption is that if similar measures become federal law, and are then shown to be ineffective, more severe impositions on my rights will be the next step.
The typical complaint with any record keeping that folks like you call registration, is that it could be used to confiscate guns. If the records kept at the ATF do not contain your name, address, SS number, driver's license info....and cannot be used to trace the gun to you....then it doesn't rise to the definition of registration that could be used for confiscation.
As described there is a specific way to match a specific gun to a specific owner. That's registration. Registration may not be an intentional step toward confiscation, but it would certainly make it easier (it's what happened to Canadians who registered their Garand rifles with the guarantee they would never be confiscated -- and then they were confiscated).
Your "problem" of owning 30 guns can easily be resolved by combining those cards into a single card. No problem. If you sold one then you'd have to get a new card with the remaining 29 guns on it. Big deal. We can record a lot of info on that card and the info we are talking about only needing a serial number of the card itself, the serial numbers of the guns, the caliber of the guns....and maybe the date issued. Your picture and your name would be on the front, but your ID would not be recorded at the ATF.
You're talking about a photographic firearms license. The idea that this could be done without a registry of who is eligible for such a license is almost laughable. And again, what about the millions of guns out there that were made before there was any legal requirement for a serial number?
The real issue here is that people on your end of the conversation aren't interested in a solution. The only answer we get from you guys is "good guys with guns" to kill "bad guys with guns" or we make the punishment for using the gun in a crime more severe....nothing at all about prevention.
To be interested in a solution, I'd have to see a problem that involves more than 1/2 of one percent of all firearms. As I think the real goal isn't to reduce crime, but merely to take an increment toward still more restrictions, I feel compelled to fight each increment.
2. The straw purchaser bought the guns at the Tanner Gun show from an unlicensed seller. She stated in court that she wouldn't have bought the guns if a background check had been required. She then "gave" the guns to Klebold. Since they were a "gift" she was not guilty of a crime. The other gun was sold by a private seller. He went to jail for 3 years for selling to a minor. 3 years for arming a murderer.....not enough.
And so she wouldn't have bought the guns for them, but someone else would have --- someone over 21 with fewer scruples than her. Beer is restricted to sales of people over 21, but I never had any trouble getting it when I was Harris and Klebold's age.
While suggestions offered so far would not have stopped the shooting in Ct. does any solution have to solve all possible misuses of firearms? Better background checks could have stopped Aurora, Virginia, Arizona....
I'm all for "better" background checks, but I see no means to enforce a background check on private sales that doesn't amount to registration. Yes, this includes this "ammo purchase license" idea. You think that everyone on your side of the gun control debate, calling for more restrictions, is trustworthy. I have reasons for doubt on that score, as I've seen the actual violations of federal law used to create a registry of gun owners. That registry, done with the knowledge and support of the sitting president, was in direct violation of specific language written into federal law -- yet it was still created.
So far I'd say we need to worry about the most severe imposition of our rights....being killed by someone who shouldn't have been able to buy a gun. I guess you don't see that as a problem.
I think it would be safe to say that I don't see it as being as large a problem as you do. Even if you expand the category to "all gun deaths" the number of such deaths compared to the number of firearms could be measured in parts per million. If you restrict it to murders, its a small problem still, and if you eliminate the fact that most murders are "criminal on criminal" murders, the "problem" is still smaller.
So yes, I'm in favor of the slightly higher-risk environment entailed in by the additional freedom we enjoy.
Well, Big Government is a danger isn't it ?
another equally intelligent response that compares with its long winded responses...neither is very usefull
And there would be a registry of the cards, no matter how carefully you policed the system. How do I know this? Based on what the BATF did with the Insta Check system during the Clinton administration. The Insta Check law specifically forbids the retention of Insta-Check-collected data in order to keep a registry, yet the BATF did exactly that as a means of "studying patterns of gun sales." It's just back-door registration.
Further, I own about 30 firearms. Under your proposed regimen, I'd hvae to carry a deck of cards just to purchase ammo or ammo components, let alone firearms.
Other problems include "entering the serial number of the firearm." A lot of weapons made before 1968 didn't have serial numbers -- does that mean we can't own antiques anymore?
So you're saying there would be a computer-based way to determine that this person had legal ownership of this gun -- in other words, registration.
You're saying it isn't but it is. Let's pick a different scenario. I own two shotguns, and I and my brother go quail hunting. He borrows one of my shotguns and we're at opposite ends of a 300-acre field. He gets stopped by a game warden. He doesn't have the authentication code -- now he's guilty of a serious crime?
Everything is a potential danger -- Big Government and the absence of big government, too.
I'm not aware of that. But, regardless, you can solve it easily enough simply by never sharing the information with the government. All the government would ever have is the gun serial number and the associated authorization code. The personal information could be handled by the app or a third party web service, such that it only went to the government once encrypted. At no point would the government ever have the associated person's name.
Guns made before 1968 weren't required to have serial numbers. Who would have access to the third-party web service? I'd suspect the government would be able to subpoena that information, or just take it via warrantless searches the way it data mines overseas phone calls.
That doesn't sound like a hassle. If your hobby is important enough to you to find space for 30 firearms and boxes and boxes of ammunition for all those kinds of weapons, then a stack of cards half the width of a deck of playing cards would be no great hassle to manage. And, as a practical matter, you'd only need to carry a couple for any given shopping trip, unless you buy for all 30 at once (at which point, your little deck of cards will be the least of your hassles). There could also be a simple smart phone app which has all the information, so all you need to do is carry your phone.
I live on the Iowa/Illinois border, and your proposal sounds a lot like the Firearms Owners ID card required in Illinois. There, in any case, it is simply a registration scheme. I want my privacy far too much to ever put a list of my firearms on a telephone ap.
Shouldn't be too hard to deal with. Very old weapons, with inherent value as antiques, could be exempted. I'm not too worried about a rash of violent crimes occurring with some old untraceable flintlocks. Newer pre-'68 firearms could get serial numbers after the fact. Take your gun old in, and have it engraved with a serial number for free.
What if its a Remington semiautomatic shotgun my uncle bought in 1966? It's not "very old with inherent value" as an antique. Neither is it an "old untraceable flintlock (flintlocks aren't considered firearms under federal law). Its sole current value is as a "shooter" and its sentimental connection to my relative, but having a serial number engraved on it would destroy its originality and ruin any future collector's value.
No, that's what YOU'RE saying. I'm saying there'd be a computer-based way to determine that which didn't involve registration.
Would or would not a police officer have the abiliity to find out if I had a weapon legallly during a police stop? If he would, then he would have the same ability at my home. That's registration, no matter what you choose to call it.
That would be easy enough to deal with. Simply have auto-expiring temporary codes for such circumstances. Pull up your smartphone or a web page, enter the permanent certification number, the registration number, and your name or other personal identifying information, and it spits out a temporary pass, ten seconds later, which gives you the right to use it for a couple days, at the end of which time it expires.
What if I don't own a smart phone. Morel likely, what if I'm in a remote part of a rural area (you know, where people go hunting) and have no cell phone or computer service? Then my brother is liable for a "serious crime" (your words) even though neither he nor myself are engaged in an illegal activity.
It would be functionally equivalent to you selling the gun to your brother for a few days, then him selling it back to you. Very little hassle. There could also be flexibility in enforcement, for just such a circumstance. If the proper owner is nearby, and confirms he was just lending you the gun, and can produce the proper authorization code, it could be a slap-on-the-wrist fine.
Well, I don't believe in having a slap on the wrist fine because I've loaned my brother (or anyone else I know) a rifle or shotgun or pistol to hunt with. Like Ghandi, I don't believe I should pay two rupees. I've yet to see how these complications to me exercising my right would have any positive impact. Criminals wouldn't bother with them, they'd simply steal guns and ammo. The fact that you would have a registry of their legal ownership wouldn't affect where they went once that ownership was lost.
You're talking about a photographic firearms license. The idea that this could be done without a registry of who is eligible for such a license is almost laughable. And again, what about the millions of guns out there that were made before there was any legal requirement for a serial number?
Care to tell me how having a photo on a card makes it part of a registration system?
The issue of guns without serial numbers is less of an issue. You could simply have a generic id for non-serialized guns....if you weren't so busy finding something to whine about, perhaps you could contribute to solutions.
PS....guy sitting behind me has an antique Colt from the 1870s....it has a serial number on it. I think the issue of guns without serial numbers is probably pretty minor....
Guns made before 1968 weren't required to have serial numbers. Who would have access to the third-party web service? I'd suspect the government would be able to subpoena that information, or just take it via warrantless searches the way it data mines overseas phone calls.
I live on the Iowa/Illinois border, and your proposal sounds a lot like the Firearms Owners ID card required in Illinois. There, in any case, it is simply a registration scheme. I want my privacy far too much to ever put a list of my firearms on a telephone ap.
What if its a Remington semiautomatic shotgun my uncle bought in 1966? It's not "very old with inherent value" as an antique. Neither is it an "old untraceable flintlock (flintlocks aren't considered firearms under federal law). Its sole current value is as a "shooter" and its sentimental connection to my relative, but having a serial number engraved on it would destroy its originality and ruin any future collector's value.
Would or would not a police officer have the abiliity to find out if I had a weapon legallly during a police stop? If he would, then he would have the same ability at my home. That's registration, no matter what you choose to call it.
What if I don't own a smart phone. Morel likely, what if I'm in a remote part of a rural area (you know, where people go hunting) and have no cell phone or computer service? Then my brother is liable for a "serious crime" (your words) even though neither he nor myself are engaged in an illegal activity.
Well, I don't believe in having a slap on the wrist fine because I've loaned my brother (or anyone else I know) a rifle or shotgun or pistol to hunt with. Like Ghandi, I don't believe I should pay two rupees. I've yet to see how these complications to me exercising my right would have any positive impact. Criminals wouldn't bother with them, they'd simply steal guns and ammo. The fact that you would have a registry of their legal ownership wouldn't affect where they went once that ownership was lost.
The post I offered had a mechanism where you could report the stolen gun and the thief couldn't buy ammo for it....You now have a trail to link the thief to any other crimes committed with your gun.
By the way, where in the second amendment is your right to lend a gun to anyone you please? I haven't seen that. You do realize that there are a number of limitations specified to your excercise of the right to "bear arms". You cannot own a nuclear weapon. You've already accepted that limitation, haven't you? There are many others. The right of the government to insure convicted felons cannot buy a gun isn't in question, right? So why would we limit that function to guns bought at a store and not to guns bought from your neighbor or some stranger in a parking lot?