Sorry, MV, not that I don't think you bring up good points... but I agree with most of what Trapdoor says, based on the things I have observed or experienced. YMMV
.Sorry. He has so inflated any real event in our history that it can only be written off as paranoia. People were much the same when machineguns were sold from the Sears catalog and guns could be mail ordered to your home....when the laws changed there were people running around claiming there would be troops going door to door to take their guns
Mid, that's an unfair characterization. Where have I done this? If anyone on this thread has inflated an event beyond its boundaries, it is those who have done so with the Sandy Hook shooting, using it as a means of tarring anyone who owns a semiautomatic weapon with the same brush.
I defy you to document widespread public opposition to the National Firearms Act. There was none. Any opposition was solely on the floor of the House and Senate.
I spelled out a plan (that I have also communicated to my congressman and senators). I told Trap what would be in the record on the computer. Somehow he either fails to comprehend or just ignores repeated posts with the details that state he is wrong....but he thinks that the records can magically point to him.
The flaw with your "plan" has been well explained. Our bureaucracies don't work that way in the real world. If I'm required a card, they will expect card-accountability, and those who want to regulate guns would make the cards themselves more difficult to get, and incorporate additional restrictions as to what applies on each card. You dismiss this with an armwave in the name of your plan, and call me "paranoid" for expecting both bureaucracies and anti-gun legislators to act in the way I can prove they've acted in the past.
Something like 90% of the population want universal background checks...
At one point, 90 percent of the population favored segregation, too. That which is popular isn't always right, which is why our system is built with protections against such tyrannies of the majority -- albeit that they work imperfectly.
On a sidenote, I get a kick out of folks who're loud and proud about their association with the NRA BUT...they oppose gun registration because they're afraid the guvmint would use it to take away their guns.
Shit..why would the guvmint go to all THAT trouble? The first thing the guvmint would do, is hack into the NRA's membership list!
Sorry Frey, but based on my 60 years....I disagree. 90% of us want universal background checks. The best thing that the other 10% can do is participate in a conversation that allows us a system that works, but does not "infringe" on your rights as you perceive them.
Trap seems to think the 2nd amendment somehow applies to antique weapons. It doesn't. He also things that it allows the sale of any weapon to any buyer. The courts disagree.
He says buying guns today is harder than at any time in our history. Really? You can go to a gun show and buy guns in the parking lot without a background check (which is where three of the guns used to massacre kids in a high school were bought). Something like 60% of gun sales are without a background check. Does that make sense to you? Is it at all desirable? It isn't to 90% of voters.
I've been in touch with both of my senators and my congressman. About this idea. Congressman Perlmutter has, in fact, talked about such an idea on a sunday morning talk show. In any case, you are correct, there is not legislation being considered at the moment.
I've read no proposals related to registration to enforce secondary sales. Got a link?
When they are talking about "universal" background checks, as the president did this week, they're discussing a background check on secondary sales. That's where you buy a gun over the counter, and then at some point later in time you sell it to me -- I'm a secondary purchaser.
You are opposed to universal background checks, but 90% of the country is in favor. It would be in your own best interests to start talking about ways to have background checks without registration....and my idea of an APL is one way.
I'm not opposed to universal background checks. I'm opposed to registration. That means I don't want to have to have a card, or special ID or any other rigamarole involved in my purchasing a new gun (or an antique one, for that matter). The stumbling block with universal background checks lies there, because even you acknowledge some sort of system is required if such checks are to be enforceable. Otherwise, those who don't want to obey the law, criminals in other words, will ignore it.
I have designed and help build computer systems for the government where the legislature had specified what was allowed to be in the system. I've done work for the Franchise Tax board and the DMV in California, 911 systems,a telephone company, Nasdaq and some banks, prescription drug applications and credit card processors. These are systems that have regulations limiting how they are used, what data is allowed to be maintained and for how long.
And I'm saying the information that you want to exclude from the system will be included in it by any enabling legislation.
You keep throwing out how bureaucracies actually work but you are wrong. Some manager in some department doesn't make decisions like you think...and people like me, who research legal ramifications, don't do the work if it is not in compliance....and even if the work is done, somebody comes along and blows the whistle....(as in the case of data being kept on a prescription drug database where I did some work)....
Where you are an expert on computer systems, I maintain an active congressional liaison. So does the BATF, and that bureaucracy will be certain to say, "We need this, this, and this or this legislation won't work," and the cards will include name, address, etc., of the cardholder via the legislation. Feinstein's proposal already calls for this as it basically brings most semiautos under the NFA '34. You're talking computer systems -- fine. I'm talking about the politics that will take place to enact the computer system.
You don't have any info on the ATF keeping background check data longer than they were supposed to, but I'd bet that if you looked at the law and at what the ATF was doing, some lawyer looked at the law and said "the proposed use isn't in violation of the letter of the law"....and that the data was never used as a backdoor registration (meaning it was never used to track down an owner)
Actually, that didn't happen, and it took court action to get the administration to quit keeping the data -- this was also about the time of "Travelgate" when the FBI was illegally keeping people's travel records. Basically, I'm saying if they have an oppportunity to misbehave, misbehavior is apt to occur.
Trap seems to think the 2nd amendment somehow applies to antique weapons. It doesn't. He also things that it allows the sale of any weapon to any buyer. The courts disagree.
Where do you derive that the 2nd Amendment doesn't apply to antique weapons. The Heller decision says I have an individual right to firearms for "traditionally legal purposes including self defense in the home." Among those "traditionally legal" purposes is the collection of antiques.
I have not referenced, ever, the sale of weapons to "any buyer."
.He says buying guns today is harder than at any time in our history. Really? You can go to a gun show and buy guns in the parking lot without a background check (which is where three of the guns used to massacre kids in a high school were bought). Something like 60% of gun sales are without a background check. Does that make sense to you? Is it at all desirable? It isn't to 90% of voters
It is still more difficult than when you could order an AR-15 through the mail without leaving your house -- and yet none sold that way were ever used in a school massacre of any kind.
And when they come to my home, I can say I own no guns. That I simply belonged to the NRA because I liked to read the magazine. Any past purchases of firearms I've made that they can document were purchased as gifts for friends and family members -- and oh, by the way, do you have a warrant?
You could say similar if your guns were registered. You could say, "I don't have them anymore. I lost 'em. And, where's your warrant?"
And when they come to my home, I can say I own no guns. That I simply belonged to the NRA because I liked to read the magazine. Any past purchases of firearms I've made that they can document were purchased as gifts for friends and family members -- and oh, by the way, do you have a warrant?
fairsheet has a pretty good point, trap.
Not very likely at all that somebody would be a member of the NRA and not own a gun...or probably dozens.
They wouldn't need registration....the NRA already has that for them, their own membership list (which will be VERY updated, given how the NRA wants to know where you are so they can hit you up for more money).
BTW, probable cause is good enough for a warrent. If you subscribed to "Al Qaeda Weekly", I'm pretty sure the FBI or locals could get a judge to issue one.![]()
I know some gun owners who won't join the NRA for just that reason. I'm not that paranoid. Being an NRA member isn't a criminal activity, and non-criminal behaviors don't amount to probable cause for a search.
The only people who are pro regulation are gun-control psychos who have been deluded into believing Liberal bullshit that making guns illegal will stop crime.
Not very likely at all that somebody would be a member of the NRA and not own a gun...or probably dozens.
I like this idea....it would mean that a stolen gun wouldn't be as easy to buy ammo for....since even the APL would become invalid once the theft is reported. The gun couldn't be reregistered.
1. All purchases of a new gun would be accompanied by an Ammunition Purchase License. The APL would be recorded in an FBI database which would consist of the APL serial number, the date, the serial number and caliber of the gun. No identification of the owner. On the card itself would be your picture and the serial number and caliber of the gun.
2. Don't have an APL, no problem, come on down to the nearest gun store, with your gun and ID. If you pass the BC you get an APL for a couple of bucks. Don't pass the BC, the gun store will either sell your gun on consignment or send it to the gun dealer of your choice.
3. Sell your gun, bring it on down to the gun store with your buyer. He passes the BC and he gets an APL....yours is now invalid.
Cost of the system is minimal. Equipment to swipe the APL to verify that you can buy that ammo is simple veriphone or even the kind of reader that works on an iphone....
Why not chips in the gun?
You're wrong about that. Since the mid 1970s, the NRA hasn't really been a gun owners club, but a partisan political organization. Many current NRA members would have no idea what to do with a gun if they did own one.