As I explained to you already states should tax more to support the level of social services their residents demand.
There are two problems with that.
First, in a system with free movement of labor, goods, and capital, this will tend to cause a mutually destructive "race to the bottom." It's a bit like the prisoner's dilemma. Two prisoners are offered a deal. If one rats out the other and doesn't get ratted out in turn, he gets off without punishment, while the other gets twenty years in jail. If they both rate each other out, they both get five years in jail. If neither rats out the other, they each get one year in jail. Viewed as a pair, their rational decision is for both keep quiet, which will result in only two years in jail total. But, each is better off, regardless of what the other does, if he rats out the other. So, unless there's some way for them to coordinate their actions, they'll rat each other out and get ten total years in jail, which is a much worse result for each of them than the optimal solution.
Similarly, what if the optimal solution to a policy question involves both the states doing something -- but each is better, individually, if he doesn't do so? This can play out in the real world. For example, maybe hiking taxes in order to improve primary education is better, and if both of two neighboring states do so, they both wind up more prosperous. But, one can also choose to free-ride on the actions of the other -- keep taxes low and neglect education, knowing that when those kids grow up, with their excellent educations paid for by the other state, they're free to move across the border to enjoy the lower-tax state, bringing their educations with them. The possibility of a free-rider like that will cause both to race to the bottom, to their mutual disadvantage.
Those same dynamics pop up repeatedly in public policy issues. For example, a state that provides better health care may get excellent bang for its buck, in terms of creating a more productive workforce, less weighed down by long-term ailments. But what if this results in sick people moving to the state, while healthy people move away to take advantage of lower taxes elsewhere? Similarly, consider any kind of pollution that can cross borders, like air pollution. In those cases, a state is positioned to internalize the benefit of a pro-pollution policy (attracting manufacturing to the state, due to lower costs), while externalizing much of its cost (e.g., the industrial mid-west acidfying the lakes and destroying the forests of the Northeast, which has the disadvantage of being downwind).
Setting states up for mutually-destructive races to the bottom is bad policy.
The second issue is simply economies of scale. As anyone with much business acumen knows, you get big efficiencies when operating on larger scales. That's why companies are a lot more likely to merge than to divest.... even when they do divest, it's usually because of a premium some other company is willing to pay to merge with the same unit, or because the proceeds will finance a later merger that will create more efficiencies. When big, national companies operate in a lot of states, they don't set those units up to compete with each other with the idea that somehow they'll be more efficient that way. They instead try to consolidate as many functions as practicable at the national level. For example, Walmart doesn't have each state reinvent the wheel when it comes to employee training, advertising, design, product ordering, and so on -- most of that stuff comes out of HQ, where they get economies of scale, bulk buying power, etc.
If you divest more power to the states, the reasonable expectation is you'll have to pay more taxes to get the same services, because you'll create inefficient redundancies and undercut bulk buying power.
Increasing taxes on those who pay no taxes would result in higher pay for them in order to afford those taxes.
Probably. But just as probably, the increase in pay would be much smaller than the increase in taxes. This is the same reason why the upper class isn't complacent about their tax levels. Tell them you're going to hike their rates back to the 70% or 92% paid in our economic golden age, and they'll freak the hell out, even though they understand that they might get some increase in pay to make those taxes more affordable for them. They'd know that whatever pay increase there was wouldn't come close to covering the increased expense.
We could take the minimum wage add $3/hr to it and on top of that add another 15% for minimum wage employees to be able to pay a federal 15% flat tax.
Enough of a minimum wage increase would make it affordable for the poor, and might put some upward pressure on wages for the middle class. But considering we're talking about a tax hike for around 80% of Americans, the mitigated impact of a minimum wage hike is unlikely to make up for the added tax for most of those hit by it. For the middle class, you'd be hiking their taxes pretty drastically.
The math is unforgiving. Every flat tax I've seen proposed amounts to a gigantic tax cut for the very rich. You don't get something for nothing. Every dollar of reduction in what they pay either has to be a dollar of increase for someone else, or a dollar cut from spending, or a dollar of added debt, or some combination of the three. Tinker with the exemptions and other details all you want, but it still comes down to the fact the rich are getting a massive windfall (which is why they like it), and that money has to come from somewhere.