New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Balanced Budget Amendment

The issue is whether it does a better job than the alternative. We can all get together and say we hate the government, if you like. We can have a nice Orwellian two minute hate about it, if it makes you feel better. But then the issue comes down to whether we're better off with a given program or not. The answer won't always go either way. Some programs will be worse than nothing. Some, despite their flaws, will be an improvement. But, again, that whole way of thinking about is a practical one, based on real-world costs and benefits. Right-wingers too often instead think of it in quasi-religious terms, and imagine that less government is always better.



I'm happy to discuss policy failures all you want. There have been many. Heck, you just have to open up the Pentagon budget to find page after page of billion-dollar boondoggles, and anyone who lived through the radically counter-productive and hyper-expensive Iraq invasion is only too aware of government policy failures. All those things are legitimate targets of criticism, and there are many more. But it would be irrational to conclude that because government has screwed some stuff up we're better off without it, or even that we're always better off shrinking it. It would be as irrational as thinking that because it's done some things right it should take over everything.

The more salient debate is over whether our society is too large and complex to manage through bureaucratic fiat. It's pretty clear that as our government became larger and took on a more comprehensive regulatory oversight and social welfare program stance, that its effectiveness at even the most basic of its charges disintegrated into bureaucratic incompetence. I don't see how one can (intelligently) argue that by making it even bigger, with an even larger role in directing (virtually) every aspect of our lives, as the progressives want, it will suddenly somehow become a paragon of efficiency and quality service. That stands 2000 years of societal history on its head. I suppose one could suggest that technology is the means to this (utopian) end but, again, that stands at least the past 50 years of government technological deployment history on its head. You guys act like you have all the answers, but that's only because you refuse to answer (honestly) these kinds of simple questions. Which, of course, is why history is replete with examples of major dominant societies adopting these kinds of (bloated) governmental "services" only to suddenly find themselves joining the (historical) trash heap of "former" empires.
 
Given the possibility of a Constitutional Convention to pass a balanced budget amendment, would you favor it?

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_..._teaming_up_to_call_a_new_constitutional.html

For me, it comes down to the details. I think it's a popular idea among conservatives because they see it stacking the deck in favor of their own vision of a small, weak government. Basically, pass popular tax cuts and then, when the columns don't add up, automatic spending cuts kick in, even if the cuts are unpopular enough that they'd never have passed democratically.

However, it would be theoretically possible to set the idea up to stack the deck in the opposite direction. Instead of automatic spending cuts kicking in to bring spending down to revenues, automatic tax hikes could kick in to bring revenues up to spending. Understandably, the conservatives wouldn't like this, because liberals could use it to bring about larger, stronger government: pass popular spending programs, then when the columns don't add up, automatic tax increases kick in, even if these increases are unpopular enough that they'd never have passed democratically.

In theory, you could middle-ground it. In the event of a mismatch between revenues and spending, automatic spending cuts and automatic tax hikes both kick in, designed to meet half-way. That way the amendment could not be used to stack the deck either way -- there'd be a genuinely democratic fight about the proper size and role of government.

Another issue is how you deal with situations where a deficit really is needed. For example, what about wartime? Should we really discipline ourselves with "pay as you go" during a war? We'd never have won independence or survived the war of 1812 or preserved the union with that rule. If we're unable to borrow and adversaries are, we're at a distinct disadvantage. Yet, you wouldn't want wars that aren't existential threats to create a blank checkbook. We blew trillions of dollars on a dumb whim in Iraq, and a little fiscal discipline to steer us away from that mistake would have been nice.

Standard economic theory also argues you should run a deficit during recessions and the first part of recoveries, and then offset that by running surpluses in other times. And demographic bulges can create situations where you might want to borrow in some periods and run surpluses in others. Special buying opportunities also would justify borrowing (e.g., to finance the Louisiana Purchase or the purchase of Alaska), and so could other investments that would create long-term returns.

One idea to deal with all this would be some sort of super-majority voting rules allowing for deficits and surpluses. But, that keeps it a highly politicized matter. You might instead create a mechanism for some nonpartisan group, insulated from day-to-day politics, to set the yearly deficit or surplus based on various factors, similar to how the Fed sets money supply. However, given the way right-wing heads explode when Fed control of money supply is mentioned, I doubt that will be a popular idea.

What do others here think?
I never thought an amendment to require a balanced budget was going to work.

Your idea about the alternative forcing direction of such an amendment that would require raising taxes to pay for expenditures is interesting. Still I don't think it will work unless everybody pays federal income tax fairly (i.e. the same percentage of income).
 
I think 120% was able to be grown out of because of technology and manufacturing. I am not sure unless we were to dominate the global economy if we could ever grow out of 120% again. I think it would have to be much less.
We weren't unique in growing out of debt of that level. Many countries have done so, including many that didn't "dominate the global economy." The UK has grown out of a lot more debt than that at least twice:

350px-UK_GDP.png


Closer to home, Canada had over 70% in the mid-90s and grew out of it.

In fact, see figure 2 here:

https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/spn/2010/spn1013.pdf

And figure 3.2 here:

https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2012/02/pdf/c3.pdf

The AVERAGE advanced nation had well over 100% of GDP in debt following WWII, not just the US, and as a group we simply grew out of it. This wasn't just a one-time post-WWII thing, since countries spiked into that same territory multiple times before WWII and occasionally after WWII, and came back down (e.g., Israel in 1977, or Ireland in 1986). A while back a couple economists disgraced themselves by trying to argue that 90% debt/GDP was some sort of magic number which spelled economic disaster, but peer review exposed their work as riddled with basic errors, including bad references in their spreadsheets. Once you fixed those errors, it turns out their idea fell apart. Debt, obviously, can be a drag on the economy, but even at the 90% level it hasn't tended to be particularly problematic, historically. Most major countries have experienced debt at that level at least once, following WWII, and several have experienced it multiple times, or even much higher levels, as with the UK. Countries can and do grow their way out of it.

That doesn't mean, of course, that we should be complacent about debt. We took some specific tax steps to grow out of our debt problem after WWII. And when we were growing out of it again in the mid-to-late Clinton years, that followed a tax hike. You can't just indulge your upper class with tax cuts and expect the laissez-fairies to wave their magic wands to make your debt disappear. You need sound tax policy, or GDP growth will be matched or exceeded by debt growth. Growing your way out of debt is a broadly tested formula for success, historically, but it doesn't work if you've got some fiscal incompetent like Reagan or Bush at the helm.
 
The more salient debate is over whether our society is too large and complex to manage through bureaucratic fiat.

I think that's a debate that's only happening in your imagination, since I've never heard anyone suggest managing our whole society by way of bureaucratic fiat.

I don't see how one can (intelligently) argue that by making it even bigger, with an even larger role in directing (virtually) every aspect of our lives, as the progressives want, it will suddenly somehow become a paragon of efficiency and quality service.

Here's two ways to think about the problem of whether a larger and more interventionist government than we currently have is likely to be an improvement -- or, conversely, whether a smaller and less interventionist one is likely to be an improvement.

(1) In the big picture, government has been growing and getting more interventionist in the US over the course of the last century. There have been periods that pushed in the opposite direction, obviously, like the Obama era, when real government spending per capita actually fell and the number of government workers was reduced considerably. But, overall, it's been an upwards trend over a century-long time scale. So, did this coincide with improvement or worsening from a social perspective? Compared to 100, 50, or even 25 years ago, are real household incomes higher or lower, are life expediencies higher or lower, is poverty higher or lower, do people have more material goods or less, do they have more or less non-material goods like education and leisure time? If the trend line, as we've increased the size of government, has been for things to get worse for most people, then that would be sending up warning signals that we should turn back. If, however, things seem to be improving, overall, it suggests we may be well served by moving farther in that direction.

(2) If you look at the 30 or 40 richest economies and most prosperous societies in the world, they all are built upon the same overall design: democratic government, with a hybrid economy that combines a majority part of free-market capitalism with a minority part of government socialistic intervention. That's the winning formula. But, among those 30 or 40 countries, there's a range of mixes of capitalist and socialist ingredients in those hybrids. The details matter, but for purposes of a big-picture analysis, you can understand it as a range of government spending as a share of GDP. How you calculate that produces different results, but by any calculation I know of, the US is very close to the bottom of that range, close to such marginal nations as Chile and Mexico, instead of the majority of the rich nations. This suggests that there's more risk in moving downward, into territory that has not yet been proven to be compatible with generalized prosperity, rather than upward, into territory where we have lots of real-world examples of generally prosperous nations functioning at that level.
 
Last edited:
I never thought an amendment to require a balanced budget was going to work.

Your idea about the alternative forcing direction of such an amendment that would require raising taxes to pay for expenditures is interesting. Still I don't think it will work unless everybody pays federal income tax fairly (i.e. the same percentage of income).
As I've explained, I don't think the flat tax concept is workable in the US. In order to bring in anywhere close to current revenue levels, you'd need a rate of 18% or so. That would be a substantial tax hike on at least 80% of the population, and a really crushing one for the poor. The lower-middle class, for example, would have their effective tax rates more than double. How can you suck that much more money out of those already struggling to get by without precipitating a social catastrophe? The only way I can think to do so would be to offset the net impact by bolstering social spending so that, as in Western Europe, poorer people can get by with little take-home pay because so much of their life is paid for by government or at least heavily subsidized. But, that means you'd need even more taxes to pay for it, with rates of 20%. I just don't see the American people agreeing to what amounts to a gigantic tax hike for most of us, along with a big transformation of our social system.
 
As I've explained, I don't think the flat tax concept is workable in the US. In order to bring in anywhere close to current revenue levels, you'd need a rate of 18% or so. That would be a substantial tax hike on at least 80% of the population, and a really crushing one for the poor. The lower-middle class, for example, would have their effective tax rates more than double. How can you suck that much more money out of those already struggling to get by without precipitating a social catastrophe? The only way I can think to do so would be to offset the net impact by bolstering social spending so that, as in Western Europe, poorer people can get by with little take-home pay because so much of their life is paid for by government or at least heavily subsidized. But, that means you'd need even more taxes to pay for it, with rates of 20%. I just don't see the American people agreeing to what amounts to a gigantic tax hike for most of us, along with a big transformation of our social system.

As I explained to you already states should tax more to support the level of social services their residents demand. That competition for productive residents would make for greater efficiency and effectiveness which is something the federal government as a monopoly isn't subject to. Why are you against competition when it is how you get better goods and services?

Increasing taxes on those who pay no taxes would result in higher pay for them in order to afford those taxes. We could take the minimum wage add $3/hr to it and on top of that add another 15% for minimum wage employees to be able to pay a federal 15% flat tax.
 
We weren't unique in growing out of debt of that level. Many countries have done so, including many that didn't "dominate the global economy." The UK has grown out of a lot more debt than that at least twice:

350px-UK_GDP.png


Closer to home, Canada had over 70% in the mid-90s and grew out of it.

In fact, see figure 2 here:

https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/spn/2010/spn1013.pdf

And figure 3.2 here:

https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2012/02/pdf/c3.pdf

The AVERAGE advanced nation had well over 100% of GDP in debt following WWII, not just the US, and as a group we simply grew out of it. This wasn't just a one-time post-WWII thing, since countries spiked into that same territory multiple times before WWII and occasionally after WWII, and came back down (e.g., Israel in 1977, or Ireland in 1986). A while back a couple economists disgraced themselves by trying to argue that 90% debt/GDP was some sort of magic number which spelled economic disaster, but peer review exposed their work as riddled with basic errors, including bad references in their spreadsheets. Once you fixed those errors, it turns out their idea fell apart. Debt, obviously, can be a drag on the economy, but even at the 90% level it hasn't tended to be particularly problematic, historically. Most major countries have experienced debt at that level at least once, following WWII, and several have experienced it multiple times, or even much higher levels, as with the UK. Countries can and do grow their way out of it.

That doesn't mean, of course, that we should be complacent about debt. We took some specific tax steps to grow out of our debt problem after WWII. And when we were growing out of it again in the mid-to-late Clinton years, that followed a tax hike. You can't just indulge your upper class with tax cuts and expect the laissez-fairies to wave their magic wands to make your debt disappear. You need sound tax policy, or GDP growth will be matched or exceeded by debt growth. Growing your way out of debt is a broadly tested formula for success, historically, but it doesn't work if you've got some fiscal incompetent like Reagan or Bush at the helm.


I like the 1990's example but I don't like going back to world war 2. But it is encouraging that countries have done it. Makes you wonder why we have 19 trillion in debt now when there was no world war? Yes the Bush war added 2 trillion but it is entitlements that added the rest. Capable people need to get a job it is that simple.
 
I think that's a debate that's only happening in your imagination, since I've never heard anyone suggest managing our whole society by way of bureaucratic fiat.



Here's two ways to think about the problem of whether a larger and more interventionist government than we currently have is likely to be an improvement -- or, conversely, whether a smaller and less interventionist one is likely to be an improvement.

(1) In the big picture, government has been growing and getting more interventionist in the US over the course of the last century. There have been periods that pushed in the opposite direction, obviously, like the Obama era, when real government spending per capita actually fell and the number of government workers was reduced considerably. But, overall, it's been an upwards trend over a century-long time scale. So, did this coincide with improvement or worsening from a social perspective? Compared to 100, 50, or even 25 years ago, are real household incomes higher or lower, are life expediencies higher or lower, is poverty higher or lower, do people have more material goods or less, do they have more or less non-material goods like education and leisure time? If the trend line, as we've increased the size of government, has been for things to get worse for most people, then that would be sending up warning signals that we should turn back. If, however, things seem to be improving, overall, it suggests we may be well served by moving farther in that direction.

(2) If you look at the 30 or 40 richest economies and most prosperous societies in the world, they all are built upon the same overall design: democratic government, with a hybrid economy that combines a majority part of free-market capitalism with a minority part of government socialistic intervention. That's the winning formula. But, among those 30 or 40 countries, there's a range of mixes of capitalist and socialist ingredients in those hybrids. The details matter, but for purposes of a big-picture analysis, you can understand it as a range of government spending as a share of GDP. How you calculate that produces different results, but by any calculation I know of, the US is very close to the bottom of that range, close to such marginal nations as Chile and Mexico, instead of the majority of the rich nations. This suggests that there's more risk in moving downward, into territory that has not yet been proven to be compatible with generalized prosperity, rather than upward, into territory where we have lots of real-world examples of generally prosperous nations functioning at that level.

The idea that the Obama era represents some sort of retreat from big governmentism, based solely on the GROWTH RATE of real per capita spending (without acknowledging that his administration has maintained an average real per capita spending that is the highest since WWII, as well as the fact that government's reach has ballooned on his watch), simply renders you an un-serious participant in this conversation.
 
As I've explained, I don't think the flat tax concept is workable in the US. In order to bring in anywhere close to current revenue levels, you'd need a rate of 18% or so. That would be a substantial tax hike on at least 80% of the population, and a really crushing one for the poor. The lower-middle class, for example, would have their effective tax rates more than double. How can you suck that much more money out of those already struggling to get by without precipitating a social catastrophe? The only way I can think to do so would be to offset the net impact by bolstering social spending so that, as in Western Europe, poorer people can get by with little take-home pay because so much of their life is paid for by government or at least heavily subsidized. But, that means you'd need even more taxes to pay for it, with rates of 20%. I just don't see the American people agreeing to what amounts to a gigantic tax hike for most of us, along with a big transformation of our social system.

If you close the corporate tax loopholes a flat tax would probably work. The "poor" use government roads, facilities, and national defense just as much as the middle class yet don't pay any taxes...

Raise the minimum wage to $12 or $15, close all tax loopholes and get that 10% or 12% flat tax going.
 
The idea that the Obama era represents some sort of retreat from big governmentism, based solely on the GROWTH RATE of real per capita spending (without acknowledging that his administration has maintained an average real per capita spending that is the highest since WWII, as well as the fact that government's reach has ballooned on his watch), simply renders you an un-serious participant in this conversation.

It seems as though the national debt grew under Obama more than any other president whether it was his fault or not and any deficit decreases were because of the sequester that he didn't want and spoke adamantly against.
 
As I explained to you already states should tax more to support the level of social services their residents demand.

There are two problems with that.

First, in a system with free movement of labor, goods, and capital, this will tend to cause a mutually destructive "race to the bottom." It's a bit like the prisoner's dilemma. Two prisoners are offered a deal. If one rats out the other and doesn't get ratted out in turn, he gets off without punishment, while the other gets twenty years in jail. If they both rate each other out, they both get five years in jail. If neither rats out the other, they each get one year in jail. Viewed as a pair, their rational decision is for both keep quiet, which will result in only two years in jail total. But, each is better off, regardless of what the other does, if he rats out the other. So, unless there's some way for them to coordinate their actions, they'll rat each other out and get ten total years in jail, which is a much worse result for each of them than the optimal solution.

Similarly, what if the optimal solution to a policy question involves both the states doing something -- but each is better, individually, if he doesn't do so? This can play out in the real world. For example, maybe hiking taxes in order to improve primary education is better, and if both of two neighboring states do so, they both wind up more prosperous. But, one can also choose to free-ride on the actions of the other -- keep taxes low and neglect education, knowing that when those kids grow up, with their excellent educations paid for by the other state, they're free to move across the border to enjoy the lower-tax state, bringing their educations with them. The possibility of a free-rider like that will cause both to race to the bottom, to their mutual disadvantage.

Those same dynamics pop up repeatedly in public policy issues. For example, a state that provides better health care may get excellent bang for its buck, in terms of creating a more productive workforce, less weighed down by long-term ailments. But what if this results in sick people moving to the state, while healthy people move away to take advantage of lower taxes elsewhere? Similarly, consider any kind of pollution that can cross borders, like air pollution. In those cases, a state is positioned to internalize the benefit of a pro-pollution policy (attracting manufacturing to the state, due to lower costs), while externalizing much of its cost (e.g., the industrial mid-west acidfying the lakes and destroying the forests of the Northeast, which has the disadvantage of being downwind).

Setting states up for mutually-destructive races to the bottom is bad policy.

The second issue is simply economies of scale. As anyone with much business acumen knows, you get big efficiencies when operating on larger scales. That's why companies are a lot more likely to merge than to divest.... even when they do divest, it's usually because of a premium some other company is willing to pay to merge with the same unit, or because the proceeds will finance a later merger that will create more efficiencies. When big, national companies operate in a lot of states, they don't set those units up to compete with each other with the idea that somehow they'll be more efficient that way. They instead try to consolidate as many functions as practicable at the national level. For example, Walmart doesn't have each state reinvent the wheel when it comes to employee training, advertising, design, product ordering, and so on -- most of that stuff comes out of HQ, where they get economies of scale, bulk buying power, etc.

If you divest more power to the states, the reasonable expectation is you'll have to pay more taxes to get the same services, because you'll create inefficient redundancies and undercut bulk buying power.

Increasing taxes on those who pay no taxes would result in higher pay for them in order to afford those taxes.

Probably. But just as probably, the increase in pay would be much smaller than the increase in taxes. This is the same reason why the upper class isn't complacent about their tax levels. Tell them you're going to hike their rates back to the 70% or 92% paid in our economic golden age, and they'll freak the hell out, even though they understand that they might get some increase in pay to make those taxes more affordable for them. They'd know that whatever pay increase there was wouldn't come close to covering the increased expense.

We could take the minimum wage add $3/hr to it and on top of that add another 15% for minimum wage employees to be able to pay a federal 15% flat tax.

Enough of a minimum wage increase would make it affordable for the poor, and might put some upward pressure on wages for the middle class. But considering we're talking about a tax hike for around 80% of Americans, the mitigated impact of a minimum wage hike is unlikely to make up for the added tax for most of those hit by it. For the middle class, you'd be hiking their taxes pretty drastically.

The math is unforgiving. Every flat tax I've seen proposed amounts to a gigantic tax cut for the very rich. You don't get something for nothing. Every dollar of reduction in what they pay either has to be a dollar of increase for someone else, or a dollar cut from spending, or a dollar of added debt, or some combination of the three. Tinker with the exemptions and other details all you want, but it still comes down to the fact the rich are getting a massive windfall (which is why they like it), and that money has to come from somewhere.
 
If you close the corporate tax loopholes a flat tax would probably work. The "poor" use government roads, facilities, and national defense just as much as the middle class yet don't pay any taxes...

Raise the minimum wage to $12 or $15, close all tax loopholes and get that 10% or 12% flat tax going.
Try the math out some time. Here's a simplified way to think of it. As of 2011, the top 1% of earners paid an average effective federal tax rate of 29.0%. Any flat tax set below 29%, therefore, will create a corresponding revenue shortfall, which will need to be made up by a hike elsewhere, or less spending, or more debt. Assuming you don't want to just drive debt up, and you're not willing to cut military spending to a small fraction of what it is today, that means you either greatly increase the tax burden on the middle and lower class, or you greatly decrease the social spending they rely on (e.g., gutting Social Security or Medicare).

What, in particular, would you do to balance the books? Closing corporate tax loopholes is a decent idea, but keep in mind that although US corporations pay a slightly lower effective tax rate than the trade-weighted OECD average, it's pretty close. Close many loopholes without also lowering nominal rates and you drive away corporations. There's only a little room to raise their effective rates before they're just not competitive with what's going on in other wealthy nations. I don't think you can make the math work to balance a flat tax with higher effective corporate tax rates without causing a great deal of harm.
 
The idea that the Obama era represents some sort of retreat from big governmentism, based solely on the GROWTH RATE of real per capita spending (without acknowledging that his administration has maintained an average real per capita spending that is the highest since WWII, as well as the fact that government's reach has ballooned on his watch), simply renders you an un-serious participant in this conversation.
You completely missed the point. I'm not arguing whether or not the Obama era represents a retreat from big governmentalism. I'm saying that the overall trend of the last century has been of growing government, notwithstanding the minor trend in the opposite direction since Obama took office. That's basically the same as your point. It's just that I then go on to point out that this trend of growing government coincided with a very distinct trend of improving life for most people. If the opposite had been true, it would have sent up a cautionary flag about further government growth. But that's not what happened.
 
I like the 1990's example but I don't like going back to world war 2. But it is encouraging that countries have done it. Makes you wonder why we have 19 trillion in debt now when there was no world war? Yes the Bush war added 2 trillion but it is entitlements that added the rest. Capable people need to get a job it is that simple.
Whoever Controls Language Controls Thought

Paid job training is the only natural motivation for that. We're stuck in this mess because no Establishment educationist reformer suggests that. Free tuition still requires working without pay. Our illogical phrase, "working his way through college," implies that schoolwork is not work. It is also absurd to call refusal to work without pay "laziness."
 
If you close the corporate tax loopholes a flat tax would probably work. The "poor" use government roads, facilities, and national defense just as much as the middle class yet don't pay any taxes...

Raise the minimum wage to $12 or $15, close all tax loopholes and get that 10% or 12% flat tax going.
The Nobility With No Ability

Why should we believe that taxing away the idle portion of wealth and activating it by creating government jobs and projects is robbing Peter to pay Paul?

A flat tax treats all wealth as equally job-productive. Stevie Forbes, its main advocate, is a spoiled derp who, like 99% of them, would be a nobody without his Daddy's money. Trust funds create jobs only for people who would never get them on their own and whose incompetence in their bought positions causes job loss.
 
Try the math out some time. Here's a simplified way to think of it. As of 2011, the top 1% of earners paid an average effective federal tax rate of 29.0%. Any flat tax set below 29%, therefore, will create a corresponding revenue shortfall, which will need to be made up by a hike elsewhere, or less spending, or more debt. Assuming you don't want to just drive debt up, and you're not willing to cut military spending to a small fraction of what it is today, that means you either greatly increase the tax burden on the middle and lower class, or you greatly decrease the social spending they rely on (e.g., gutting Social Security or Medicare).

What, in particular, would you do to balance the books? Closing corporate tax loopholes is a decent idea, but keep in mind that although US corporations pay a slightly lower effective tax rate than the trade-weighted OECD average, it's pretty close. Close many loopholes without also lowering nominal rates and you drive away corporations. There's only a little room to raise their effective rates before they're just not competitive with what's going on in other wealthy nations. I don't think you can make the math work to balance a flat tax with higher effective corporate tax rates without causing a great deal of harm.

People here and on tv constantly claim the largest corporations and the richest people pay no tax, they would all now pay a flat tax which would make up for the shortfalls. That and the loopholes being closed. Yes/No or is that all just bs about the top companies not paying any taxes? Hard to know what to believe when reading PJ and watching todays news.
 
The Nobility With No Ability

Why should we believe that taxing away the idle portion of wealth and activating it by creating government jobs and projects is robbing Peter to pay Paul?

A flat tax treats all wealth as equally job-productive. Stevie Forbes, its main advocate, is a spoiled derp who, like 99% of them, would be a nobody without his Daddy's money. Trust funds create jobs only for people who would never get them on their own and whose incompetence in their bought positions causes job loss.

Simply because its fair.

There are people today living off of other people. Yes/No? That is not fair. A flat tax is fair, no one can argue different. You can argue it won't work but you can't argue it isn't fair.
 
It seems as though the national debt grew under Obama more than any other president whether it was his fault or not and any deficit decreases were because of the sequester that he didn't want and spoke adamantly against.

Yes, federal debt as a percent of GDP didn't double on Obama's watch because he was shrinking government. The entire premise (Obama as effecting smaller government) is a parody of a joke (unless one is a pie eyed progressive seeking to obscure his true legacy of failed big governmentism).
 
Back
Top