New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Balanced Budget Amendment

It seems as though the national debt grew under Obama more than any other president whether it was his fault or not and any deficit decreases were because of the sequester that he didn't want and spoke adamantly against.
The deficit decreases were not primarily due to the sequester. The deficit reductions had happened in FY 2010, 2011, and 2012. The sequestration hit in March 2013, about half-way through FY 2013. Rather, the deficit reductions were due primarily to the economic recovery, which started half-way through Obama's first year.

The deficit peaked in FY 2009, at $1.4 trillion, when federal spending was $3.5 trillion. For FY 2015, federal spending was actually a bit more than that -- about $3.8 trillion. Yet the deficit has fallen by well over half in that time. Although a slowing of the growth rate of federal spending was a factor, revenue growth was the driving factor, just as during our last period of rapid deficit decline, under Clinton. Between FY 2009 and FY 2015, revenues grew at an annualized rate of 7.1%, which is exactly the same pace as between FY 1993 and FY 2001, the Clinton era.
 
The deficit decreases were not primarily due to the sequester. The deficit reductions had happened in FY 2010, 2011, and 2012. The sequestration hit in March 2013, about half-way through FY 2013. Rather, the deficit reductions were due primarily to the economic recovery, which started half-way through Obama's first year.

The deficit peaked in FY 2009, at $1.4 trillion, when federal spending was $3.5 trillion. For FY 2015, federal spending was actually a bit more than that -- about $3.8 trillion. Yet the deficit has fallen by well over half in that time. Although a slowing of the growth rate of federal spending was a factor, revenue growth was the driving factor, just as during our last period of rapid deficit decline, under Clinton. Between FY 2009 and FY 2015, revenues grew at an annualized rate of 7.1%, which is exactly the same pace as between FY 1993 and FY 2001, the Clinton era.

So what is the bottom line. Will we spend more in 2015 then we bring in? Will we spend more in 2016 then we bring in? If so, without being involved in any real wars, how is this possible? I am guessing besides just growing the economy that the only solution is entitlement reform.
 
You completely missed the point. I'm not arguing whether or not the Obama era represents a retreat from big governmentalism. I'm saying that the overall trend of the last century has been of growing government, notwithstanding the minor trend in the opposite direction since Obama took office. That's basically the same as your point. It's just that I then go on to point out that this trend of growing government coincided with a very distinct trend of improving life for most people. If the opposite had been true, it would have sent up a cautionary flag about further government growth. But that's not what happened.

There has been no minor trend toward smaller government under Obama. You are using a strict measure that is grotesquely deformed due to his (and Bush's) "stimulus" spending during his first year in office. If you back that (temporary) spending out you will see a rising level (more or less) throughout his time in office. And I simply reject the notion that spending is the only measure of the size (and reach) of government, ESPECIALLY on a real PER CAPITA basis.

Screen Shot 2016-01-27 at 10.34.40 AM.png
 
Simply because its fair.

There are people today living off of other people. Yes/No? That is not fair. A flat tax is fair, no one can argue different. You can argue it won't work but you can't argue it isn't fair.
I believe a flat tax is unfair. I believe that it unfairly burdens the working class, while wrongly imagining that layering a flat tax on top of a system that is set up to give wildly unfair advantages to the wealthy is somehow equitable. You may believe that a flat tax is fair, for some reason, but that's very different from saying that nobody can argue the opposite.

What is it, exactly, that makes you think a flat tax is fair? It's just one of an infinite number of mathematical possibilities. A person could argue it's unfair in the other direction, too -- that it's unfair because the rich pay much more in dollar terms, rather than everyone paying the same flat amount (as opposed to the same flat rate). There's nothing holy or magical about using a single rate, as opposed to some simpler or more complicated formula.
 
I believe a flat tax is unfair. I believe that it unfairly burdens the working class, while wrongly imagining that layering a flat tax on top of a system that is set up to give wildly unfair advantages to the wealthy is somehow equitable. You may believe that a flat tax is fair, for some reason, but that's very different from saying that nobody can argue the opposite.

What is it, exactly, that makes you think a flat tax is fair? It's just one of an infinite number of mathematical possibilities. A person could argue it's unfair in the other direction, too -- that it's unfair because the rich pay much more in dollar terms, rather than everyone paying the same flat amount (as opposed to the same flat rate). There's nothing holy or magical about using a single rate, as opposed to some simpler or more complicated formula.

No, you are arguing that the compensation system is unfair, which has nothing to do with the tax system.
 
So what is the bottom line. Will we spend more in 2015 then we bring in? Will we spend more in 2016 then we bring in?

Yes, of course. Although deficits are declining rapidly, they were left at such a very high level by the failed Bush administration that even reducing deficits by a staggering $830 billion in just six years isn't enough to eliminate them entirely. Keep in mind that the mistakes of the Bush years impose costs for years to come. For example, those veterans maimed in Bush's obscene war on Iraq didn't magically recover the day Obama took office. We taxpayers will be paying for what we did to them for the rest of their lives. But, we're at least moving swiftly in the right direction. At this point, the question is whether we'll stay the course to full recovery, or relapse into the kind of catastrophic errors the nation made in 1980 and 2000. Time will tell.
 
There has been no minor trend toward smaller government under Obama. You are using a strict measure that is grotesquely deformed due to his (and Bush's) "stimulus" spending during his first year in office. If you back that (temporary) spending out you will see a rising level (more or less) throughout his time in office. And I simply reject the notion that spending is the only measure of the size (and reach) of government, ESPECIALLY on a real PER CAPITA basis.

View attachment 29533
As you know, there was a rare, multi-year period of total government spending decreasing in real per capita terms since Obama came to office. If you opt to insist that isn't a trend towards smaller government on Obama's watch, that's fine. Semantics don't interest me. Besides, you're essentially bolstering my point. I'm arguing that the overall trend has been of a growing government, and that the slight reduction of the Obama years doesn't change that. You seem to be saying the same thing.

I agree, by the way, that spending isn't the only measure of the size and reach of government. For example, if government were to outlaw abortion, it would basically be reaching right into women's wombs, but that wouldn't really show up in the spending numbers, other than whatever it cost to prosecute and jail those who exercised reproductive choice. If you have some other way to quantify it in a reasonable way, I'm happy to consider it.
 
As you know, there was a rare, multi-year period of total government spending decreasing in real per capita terms since Obama came to office. If you opt to insist that isn't a trend towards smaller government on Obama's watch, that's fine. Semantics don't interest me. Besides, you're essentially bolstering my point. I'm arguing that the overall trend has been of a growing government, and that the slight reduction of the Obama years doesn't change that. You seem to be saying the same thing.

I agree, by the way, that spending isn't the only measure of the size and reach of government. For example, if government were to outlaw abortion, it would basically be reaching right into women's wombs, but that wouldn't really show up in the spending numbers, other than whatever it cost to prosecute and jail those who exercised reproductive choice. If you have some other way to quantify it in a reasonable way, I'm happy to consider it.

You are the one abusing semantics here. If you are measuring the size of the federal government by spending, then measure it - don't use some self serving twist of the data by dividing it by population. Either it is spending more one year to the next or it isn't.

And even after you abuse the data in your favor by dividing it by a growing population (as if no economies of scale should ever apply to any government program), you then further distort it by claiming the (temporary) "stimulus" spending as "growth of government" (which it most definitely BY DEFINITION IS NOT) so as to be able to claim it's removal as a "reduction" in the size of government. Sheesh!

This level of dishonesty on your part really calls into question your willingness to be taken seriously around here. I hope you see this as the gross breach of data etiquette that it most assuredly is.
 
I like the 1990's example but I don't like going back to world war 2. But it is encouraging that countries have done it. Makes you wonder why we have 19 trillion in debt now when there was no world war?

Well, recall that as recently as the Clinton years debt was falling pretty rapidly as a share of GDP. So, the question is: what changed? Obviously the financial meltdown factored in, but debt was rising long before that. The two key differences were Bush's fiscally reckless upper-class tax cuts (the vast majority of which were made permanent by Obama), and putting America on a military footing that's essentially what you'd expect if there were a world war. The Iraq and Afghan wars cost us trillions of dollars and will cost us trillions more by the time their full cost has been experienced. And even now, without those wars, we spend four and a half times more than any other nation on our military. The "defense" budget eats up 3.3% of our economy, compared to 2.9% at the end of the Clinton era, and just 1.7% before WWII.

Capable people need to get a job it is that simple.

It's a demand problem, not a supply one. If the problem was that people couldn't find employees willing to take jobs, we'd see that as a rapid increase in wages, as employers competed for workers. Maybe a little of that is happening now, as the labor market is finally getting a little tight, but for the vast majority of the post-crisis era, it's simply been a matter of too few job openings. When there are enough job openings, we know that unemployment can drop very low -- as low as 3.9% in the Clinton years, and even lower in the Johnson and Truman years (all, not coincidentally, periods of long Democratic runs at president). It's not like we have too many people who just aren't willing to work. We're a culture of worker bees, when there are jobs to be had.
 
Yes, of course. Although deficits are declining rapidly, they were left at such a very high level by the failed Bush administration that even reducing deficits by a staggering $830 billion in just six years isn't enough to eliminate them entirely. Keep in mind that the mistakes of the Bush years impose costs for years to come. For example, those veterans maimed in Bush's obscene war on Iraq didn't magically recover the day Obama took office. We taxpayers will be paying for what we did to them for the rest of their lives. But, we're at least moving swiftly in the right direction. At this point, the question is whether we'll stay the course to full recovery, or relapse into the kind of catastrophic errors the nation made in 1980 and 2000. Time will tell.

The question had nothing to do with Bush. I think we all understand there will be deficits in years where there is a war.
 
You are the one abusing semantics here. If you are measuring the size of the federal government by spending, then measure it - don't use some self serving twist of the data by dividing it by population.

Quite obviously, any sane analysis will require factoring in population. A government that is minuscule for America might be crushingly large for Luxembourg. And, in the same sense, a government that was big for an era when the US was smaller might be small today. As population grows, so do the costs of providing a given level of services to the population.
by claiming the (temporary) "stimulus" spending as "growth of government" (which it most definitely BY DEFINITION IS NOT)

Why not? Is this just a semantic distinction you're making, that temporary growth can't be called growth? If so, like I said, semantics don't interest me. I'm more interested in the underlying questions, and my argument was based on the underlying century-long trend of the government growing.
 
Well, recall that as recently as the Clinton years debt was falling pretty rapidly as a share of GDP. So, the question is: what changed? Obviously the financial meltdown factored in, but debt was rising long before that. The two key differences were Bush's fiscally reckless upper-class tax cuts (the vast majority of which were made permanent by Obama), and putting America on a military footing that's essentially what you'd expect if there were a world war. The Iraq and Afghan wars cost us trillions of dollars and will cost us trillions more by the time their full cost has been experienced. And even now, without those wars, we spend four and a half times more than any other nation on our military. The "defense" budget eats up 3.3% of our economy, compared to 2.9% at the end of the Clinton era, and just 1.7% before WWII.



It's a demand problem, not a supply one. If the problem was that people couldn't find employees willing to take jobs, we'd see that as a rapid increase in wages, as employers competed for workers. Maybe a little of that is happening now, as the labor market is finally getting a little tight, but for the vast majority of the post-crisis era, it's simply been a matter of too few job openings. When there are enough job openings, we know that unemployment can drop very low -- as low as 3.9% in the Clinton years, and even lower in the Johnson and Truman years (all, not coincidentally, periods of long Democratic runs at president). It's not like we have too many people who just aren't willing to work. We're a culture of worker bees, when there are jobs to be had.

Clinton this and Bush that. That was many years ago. While I understand we today have to pay interest on the debts from those administrations I don't understand why we are running up debt now when there is no war. It must be because entitlements have ballooned under Obama. That can be the only explanation. The economy is supply and demand, presidents don't have much to do with that. But the political will to balance the budget just isn't there with Obama or Bush so the economy and its people will suffer at some point. I am tired of the excuses, I want to see the debt going down, period.
 
The question had nothing to do with Bush. I think we all understand there will be deficits in years where there is a war.
You asked "Will we spend more in 2015 then we bring in? Will we spend more in 2016 then we bring in? If so, without being involved in any real wars, how is this possible?"

The answer is Bush. Your discomfort with that answer is noted, but when you ask an open-ended question, it doesn't make sense to then insist the question wasn't about the subject that one has to address in order to answer it.
 
You asked "Will we spend more in 2015 then we bring in? Will we spend more in 2016 then we bring in? If so, without being involved in any real wars, how is this possible?"

The answer is Bush. Your discomfort with that answer is noted, but when you ask an open-ended question, it doesn't make sense to then insist the question wasn't about the subject that one has to address in order to answer it.

So the answer is that 8 years after the failed Bush presidency we will spend more than we take in. Very sad and a trend that needs to end. Entitlements is the problem. Bush's tax cut and his war were wrong but not the cause of 19 trillion in debt.
 
Clinton this and Bush that. That was many years ago

Yes, and only by studying history can we make informed policy choices now. We can draw some pretty strong conclusions about what works and what doesn't based on what seems to have worked and seems to have failed in the past. This makes people uncomfortable if, for emotional reasons, they're tied to certain solutions that run at odds with history.

While I understand we today have to pay interest on the debts from those administrations I don't understand why we are running up debt now when there is no war.

First, as I mentioned, the costs of Bush's war are ongoing. That includes the obvious costs like all the disability payments. But it also includes less obvious ones. In the Bush years, military pay scales had to be hiked considerably to get decent people, because potential recruits and retainees knew what they were signing up for included long deployments in war zones, stop-loss orders, and so on. The amount we spent on military personnel doubled between FY 2001 and FY 2009, even as total active duty military personnel actually declined slightly, and median incomes elsewhere in the economy didn't even keep up with inflation. Thanks to Obama's superior leadership, that military personnel cost has started to come down in the last four years, since we're at least not paying through the nose for combat zone bonuses, etc. But it would be tough to take away the pay increases that were associated with more rapid war-era promotions, and just the general up-creep in military pay, and all the enhanced retirement pay people got thanks to their inflated incomes during the Bush years, and so on. Bad policy choices echo for decades.

But the political will to balance the budget just isn't there with Obama or Bush

We've seen over $800 billion of deficit decline on Obama's watch. Can you name any other president about whom that can be said? My criticism of Obama is actually the opposite of yours. I think he foolishly overemphasized moving towards a balanced budget at a time when we should have kept deficits higher. I think he deserves some credit for not going as whole-hog for that counter-productive austerity as leaders in other countries, which spared us from under-performing as badly as most of them, but he still gave too much play to ill-timed deficit hawkery.
 
Quite obviously, any sane analysis will require factoring in population. A government that is minuscule for America might be crushingly large for Luxembourg. And, in the same sense, a government that was big for an era when the US was smaller might be small today. As population grows, so do the costs of providing a given level of services to the population.


Why not? Is this just a semantic distinction you're making, that temporary growth can't be called growth? If so, like I said, semantics don't interest me. I'm more interested in the underlying questions, and my argument was based on the underlying century-long trend of the government growing.

Got it! You don't think any economies of scale should apply in government - an entity that you want to get even bigger and do even more. And you surely can't be expected to be taken seriously in the preposterous suggestion that (temporary) "stimulus" spending must be counted as permanent in any time series government spending analysis.

Just keep showing us your absurd notions and we'll keep considering you ever further out there on the fringe.
 
Got it! You don't think any economies of scale should apply in government

No. What did I say that gave you that impression? I do, in fact, expect economies of scale to apply. Other things being equal, I'd expect government to have to expand less than the population in order to provide the same services. But it would have to expand. So, you'd need to factor in the expansion of population. If you'd like to propose some more sophisticated way to do so, that assumes some economy of scale savings, I'm open to it.

However, I didn't do so, myself, for two reasons. One is simply that I don't know how to even begin coming up with that kind of factor. If population grows 50%, would government need to grow 48%, 30%, 25%, or what, to keep the same level of services with the benefit of economies of scale? I'm reluctant to simply pull a number out of the air, and I have no framework for deciding on one.

The second reason is that it isn't just population that grows and increases the burden on the government. Economic activity itself does so. Take as a simple example the maintenance of a bridge, leading from some bedroom community to a work site. Obviously, the growth of that bedroom community will tend to put more wear and tear on that bridge, requiring more government spending to maintain it to the same degree. But even if the bedroom community stays the same size but becomes more economically active, that could do it, too. If you have fewer stay-at-home spouses and more workers, that increases the bridge traffic. If people are buying more stuff, meaning more trips across that bridge to markets, and more trucks heading over that bridge to bring things to local stores, that does, too. There are lots of ways in which the more active the economy gets, the more government spending would be expected to cover the same services.... for example, if you're inspecting shipments coming into our ports, the more shipments, the more inspections needed to check a given percentage of them. Pollution mitigation is another example. The pollution burden represented by a given population depends in large part on their level of economic activity -- a population with higher GDP/capita will tend to produce more garbage per capita, and thus burden waste disposal services more.

So, over the long term, you could argue that comparing the size of government to the GDP is a more sensible way to look at it than comparing to population. And given the tendency of real GDP to grow more quickly than population, doing the comparison on the basis of GDP would show less relative government growth than doing it by population. So, it seemed like a decent compromise to think of it in terms of real per-capita figures, without applying an economy-of-scale factor, which is probably in the ballpark, anyway, of doing it on a per-GDP basis while applying a reasonable economy-of-scale factor.

But, regardless of where you come down on these nuances, the overall trend is going to show up the way I said: you're going to find that over the last century, the general tendency has been for government to grow, whether in proportion to population, or GDP, notwithstanding what happened since Obama took office. And that brings us back to my argument. That growth of government (both here and throughout wealthy nations), has coincided in a big-picture increase in prosperity, too. If it had been the opposite, we'd be wise to put on the brakes and wonder if maybe the growth of government were one of the reasons prosperity was declining. But that's just not the way it went.

And you surely can't be expected to be taken seriously in the preposterous suggestion that (temporary) "stimulus" spending must be counted as permanent in any time series government spending analysis.

I didn't say anything at all about temporary stimulus being counted as permanent. I just pointed out, correctly, that real per capita government spending grew over the last 100 years, notwithstanding its shrinkage since Obama took office. Those are simply facts. I see that the facts make you really uncomfortable, so perhaps you should think about why that is.
 
There are two problems with that.

First, in a system with free movement of labor, goods, and capital, this will tend to cause a mutually destructive "race to the bottom." It's a bit like the prisoner's dilemma. Two prisoners are offered a deal. If one rats out the other and doesn't get ratted out in turn, he gets off without punishment, while the other gets twenty years in jail. If they both rate each other out, they both get five years in jail. If neither rats out the other, they each get one year in jail. Viewed as a pair, their rational decision is for both keep quiet, which will result in only two years in jail total. But, each is better off, regardless of what the other does, if he rats out the other. So, unless there's some way for them to coordinate their actions, they'll rat each other out and get ten total years in jail, which is a much worse result for each of them than the optimal solution.

Similarly, what if the optimal solution to a policy question involves both the states doing something -- but each is better, individually, if he doesn't do so? This can play out in the real world. For example, maybe hiking taxes in order to improve primary education is better, and if both of two neighboring states do so, they both wind up more prosperous. But, one can also choose to free-ride on the actions of the other -- keep taxes low and neglect education, knowing that when those kids grow up, with their excellent educations paid for by the other state, they're free to move across the border to enjoy the lower-tax state, bringing their educations with them. The possibility of a free-rider like that will cause both to race to the bottom, to their mutual disadvantage.

Those same dynamics pop up repeatedly in public policy issues. For example, a state that provides better health care may get excellent bang for its buck, in terms of creating a more productive workforce, less weighed down by long-term ailments. But what if this results in sick people moving to the state, while healthy people move away to take advantage of lower taxes elsewhere? Similarly, consider any kind of pollution that can cross borders, like air pollution. In those cases, a state is positioned to internalize the benefit of a pro-pollution policy (attracting manufacturing to the state, due to lower costs), while externalizing much of its cost (e.g., the industrial mid-west acidfying the lakes and destroying the forests of the Northeast, which has the disadvantage of being downwind).

Setting states up for mutually-destructive races to the bottom is bad policy.

The second issue is simply economies of scale. As anyone with much business acumen knows, you get big efficiencies when operating on larger scales. That's why companies are a lot more likely to merge than to divest.... even when they do divest, it's usually because of a premium some other company is willing to pay to merge with the same unit, or because the proceeds will finance a later merger that will create more efficiencies. When big, national companies operate in a lot of states, they don't set those units up to compete with each other with the idea that somehow they'll be more efficient that way. They instead try to consolidate as many functions as practicable at the national level. For example, Walmart doesn't have each state reinvent the wheel when it comes to employee training, advertising, design, product ordering, and so on -- most of that stuff comes out of HQ, where they get economies of scale, bulk buying power, etc.

If you divest more power to the states, the reasonable expectation is you'll have to pay more taxes to get the same services, because you'll create inefficient redundancies and undercut bulk buying power.



Probably. But just as probably, the increase in pay would be much smaller than the increase in taxes. This is the same reason why the upper class isn't complacent about their tax levels. Tell them you're going to hike their rates back to the 70% or 92% paid in our economic golden age, and they'll freak the hell out, even though they understand that they might get some increase in pay to make those taxes more affordable for them. They'd know that whatever pay increase there was wouldn't come close to covering the increased expense.



Enough of a minimum wage increase would make it affordable for the poor, and might put some upward pressure on wages for the middle class. But considering we're talking about a tax hike for around 80% of Americans, the mitigated impact of a minimum wage hike is unlikely to make up for the added tax for most of those hit by it. For the middle class, you'd be hiking their taxes pretty drastically.

The math is unforgiving. Every flat tax I've seen proposed amounts to a gigantic tax cut for the very rich. You don't get something for nothing. Every dollar of reduction in what they pay either has to be a dollar of increase for someone else, or a dollar cut from spending, or a dollar of added debt, or some combination of the three. Tinker with the exemptions and other details all you want, but it still comes down to the fact the rich are getting a massive windfall (which is why they like it), and that money has to come from somewhere.

No, competition is good and monopoly is bad.
 
No. What did I say that gave you that impression? I do, in fact, expect economies of scale to apply. Other things being equal, I'd expect government to have to expand less than the population in order to provide the same services. But it would have to expand. So, you'd need to factor in the expansion of population. If you'd like to propose some more sophisticated way to do so, that assumes some economy of scale savings, I'm open to it.

However, I didn't do so, myself, for two reasons. One is simply that I don't know how to even begin coming up with that kind of factor. If population grows 50%, would government need to grow 48%, 30%, 25%, or what, to keep the same level of services with the benefit of economies of scale? I'm reluctant to simply pull a number out of the air, and I have no framework for deciding on one.

The second reason is that it isn't just population that grows and increases the burden on the government. Economic activity itself does so. Take as a simple example the maintenance of a bridge, leading from some bedroom community to a work site. Obviously, the growth of that bedroom community will tend to put more wear and tear on that bridge, requiring more government spending to maintain it to the same degree. But even if the bedroom community stays the same size but becomes more economically active, that could do it, too. If you have fewer stay-at-home spouses and more workers, that increases the bridge traffic. If people are buying more stuff, meaning more trips across that bridge to markets, and more trucks heading over that bridge to bring things to local stores, that does, too. There are lots of ways in which the more active the economy gets, the more government spending would be expected to cover the same services.... for example, if you're inspecting shipments coming into our ports, the more shipments, the more inspections needed to check a given percentage of them. Pollution mitigation is another example. The pollution burden represented by a given population depends in large part on their level of economic activity -- a population with higher GDP/capita will tend to produce more garbage per capita, and thus burden waste disposal services more.

So, over the long term, you could argue that comparing the size of government to the GDP is a more sensible way to look at it than comparing to population. And given the tendency of real GDP to grow more quickly than population, doing the comparison on the basis of GDP would show less relative government growth than doing it by population. So, it seemed like a decent compromise to think of it in terms of real per-capita figures, without applying an economy-of-scale factor, which is probably in the ballpark, anyway, of doing it on a per-GDP basis while applying a reasonable economy-of-scale factor.

But, regardless of where you come down on these nuances, the overall trend is going to show up the way I said: you're going to find that over the last century, the general tendency has been for government to grow, whether in proportion to population, or GDP, notwithstanding what happened since Obama took office. And that brings us back to my argument. That growth of government (both here and throughout wealthy nations), has coincided in a big-picture increase in prosperity, too. If it had been the opposite, we'd be wise to put on the brakes and wonder if maybe the growth of government were one of the reasons prosperity was declining. But that's just not the way it went.



I didn't say anything at all about temporary stimulus being counted as permanent. I just pointed out, correctly, that real per capita government spending grew over the last 100 years, notwithstanding its shrinkage since Obama took office. Those are simply facts. I see that the facts make you really uncomfortable, so perhaps you should think about why that is.

Thank you for this (frankly rather wordy) admission to the group that you were using completely worthless measurements of government in your (false) argument that government has gotten "smaller."

As for your last point, government has been growing faster than GDP since 2000:

Screen Shot 2016-01-27 at 1.09.41 PM.png
And as government has grown, year over year GDP growth has declined:

Screen Shot 2016-01-27 at 1.11.04 PM.png
So I'm not sure what point it is you are trying to make but we'll just label that one FAIL!
 
No, competition is good and monopoly is bad.
As you're probably aware, I'm always pushing for us to compete better with our international peers. It's just that we're hamstrung in our efforts to do so by our antiquated state-by-state system. If I worked for McDonalds and pushed for consolidation of certain functions at the corporate level (e.g., more training materials coming out of the home office, rather than having every store reinvent the wheel), people would understand that it was so we could be more competitive in the market, against the likes of Burger King, etc. But when I push the same thinking when it comes to consolidating functions from the state to the federal level, people imagine it's because I have a problem with competition. I don't. I just have a problem with competing poorly.
 
Back
Top