New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ben Carson: The Devil Made Him Do It!!

Rationally? Carson's ideology is the ideology of mainstream patriotic Christian Americans and has been for generations. "Progressives" are the reactionary freaks, not Dr. Carson.

Really? Mr. Friscus says (post #87) that his beliefs are NOT mainstream Christian beliefs. Are you saying he is not a mainstream patriotic Christian American, and too progressive to even be in touch with what they believe?
 
I know the feeling. I often feel like I'm teaching lefties junior high civics and American history on political forums. Our education system is messed up.

Maybe you should unlearn some of the oversimplified, propagandistic civics you were taught in junior high. Try taking a high school class on the subjects sometime.
 
Of course it's about ideology. How else would you have someone like Al Sharpton, who's barely literate, in the position of a White House advisor to the president, or Van Jones, an admitted communist and wacko 9/11 "truther" in a high-level position in Obama's adminstration?

Check your premises.
1. Al Sharpton, a college-educated minister and TV personality known for his poetic diction, is not "barely literate."
2. Al Sharpton was never a White House advisor to the president.
3. Van Jones was never in a high-level administration position.
4. Van Jones was not a "wacko 9/11 truther."
5. Your own opposition to Van Jones is clearly ideological.
 
Check your premises.
1. Al Sharpton, a college-educated minister and TV personality known for his poetic diction, is not "barely literate."
2. Al Sharpton was never a White House advisor to the president.
3. Van Jones was never in a high-level administration position.
4. Van Jones was not a "wacko 9/11 truther."
5. Your own opposition to Van Jones is clearly ideological.

Gotta give him credit for telling the most lies with the fewest words. A very efficient liar. A much-admired trait in GOP circles.

;-)
 
Other animals do have their own societies. If they don't have cities, the simple explanation is that they lack the cognitive capacity of the average or above-average human.

Precisely. And that simply calls the question, why? Why has no other "animal" species developed more complex mental capacity over time?
 
Many animals are sentient. If you are asking why they have not become as intelligent as humans, remember that natural selection is not a teleological process, but one that .proceeds in response to any changes in the environment and involves certain trade-offs (for example, any adaptive advantages given humans by our large brains are also paid for with greater risk of death in childbirth, and long periods when the young are immature, vulnerable, and in need of care that comes at the expense of optimal adult survival and reproduction). Humans developed complex brains because it was an adaptive advantage for our Paleolithic ancestors. Many other primates did too, but to a lesser extent. Our brains have given us an advantage, allowing us to spread into many environments and grow in numbers. But besides the costs mentioned above, they have also created other costs (war, climate change, pollution, diseases related to urbanization and domestication, etc.) and to that extent served as maladaptations. It is not inconceivable that high intelligence is an evolutionary dead-end and that the survivors among our species or even our phylum will be those of lower intelligence.

http://ar.vegnews.org/brain_size.html

Again, this calls the question, why? If it were merely evolution and natural selection, at some point we'd see most animal species beginning to develop the same complex mental capacities that humans have "developed." It's simple logic...
 
Sure we do: descent with modification and evolutionary pressure due to natural selection.

Which also applies almost equally across all species, yet man is the only one that responded with advanced mental capabilities? That's not logical.
 
Check your premises.
1. Al Sharpton, a college-educated minister and TV personality known for his poetic diction, is not "barely literate."
2. Al Sharpton was never a White House advisor to the president.
3. Van Jones was never in a high-level administration position.
4. Van Jones was not a "wacko 9/11 truther."
5. Your own opposition to Van Jones is clearly ideological.
Check your premises.
1. Al Sharpton, a college-educated minister and TV personality known for his poetic diction, is not "barely literate."
2. Al Sharpton was never a White House advisor to the president.
3. Van Jones was never in a high-level administration position.
4. Van Jones was not a "wacko 9/11 truther."
5. Your own opposition to Van Jones is clearly ideological.
 
Not really - that the climate is changing is "observable." But the observability doesn't lead to the anthropogenic conclusion. That part is sheer theory.

Not really. The theory of anthropogenic global warming makes specific predictions (stratospheric cooling, ocean acidification, etc.) that aren't accounted for by alternative hypotheses about the cause of the warming.
 
Precisely. And that simply calls the question, why? Why has no other "animal" species developed more complex mental capacity over time?

Because, as I explained above, evolution isn't a goal-directed process leading inexorably toward greater and greater intelligence. The development of greater intelligence in human ancestors was the result of a unique conjuncture of environmental pressures.
 
http://ar.vegnews.org/brain_size.html

Again, this calls the question, why? If it were merely evolution and natural selection, at some point we'd see most animal species beginning to develop the same complex mental capacities that humans have "developed." It's simple logic...

1. Many other animals have BEGUN to develop the same capacities.
2. The argument works only if those complex mental capacities provide a selective advantage. As I pointed out earlier, there are also selective costs for the modifications involved in making them possible (e.g., longer immaturity periods with all the risks involved for children and adults). Bacteria, which have no intelligence, are the most successful creatures in the world in terms of reproduction. Insects, which have little to no intelligence, are the most prolific animals. Whence the assumption that evolution always selects for greater intelligence?
 
Which also applies almost equally across all species, yet man is the only one that responded with advanced mental capabilities? That's not logical.

No, the environmental pressures do not apply "almost equally across all species." The whole point is that populations separated by environmental chance (e.g., the ancestors of humans and of chimpanzees) diverge due to differing environmental circumstances.
 
Back
Top