New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ben Carson: The Devil Made Him Do It!!

What does the word sentient mean?

sen·tient
ˈsen(t)SH(ē)ənt/
adjective
  1. able to perceive or feel things.
able to perceive or feel things.
"she had been instructed from birth in the equality of all sentient life forms"
synonyms: (capable of) feeling, living, live; More

1.
having the power of perception by the senses;conscious.
2.
characterized by sensation and consciousness.
noun
3.
a person or thing that is sentient.


examples from the Web for sentientExpand
Contemporary Examples

That isn't a universally accepted concept. Lets look at what it means to be "conscious."

Consciousness:
noun
1.the state of being conscious; awareness of one's own existence, sensations, thoughts, surroundings, etc.
2.the thoughts and feelings, collectively, of an individual or of an aggregate of people:
the moral consciousness of a nation.
3.full activity of the mind and senses, as in waking life:
to regain consciousness after fainting.
4.awareness of something for what it is; internal knowledge:
consciousness of wrongdoing.
5.concern, interest, or acute awareness:
class consciousness.
6.the mental activity of which a person is aware as contrasted with unconscious mental processes.
7.Philosophy. the mind or the mental faculties as characterized by thought, feelings, and volition.

Where does the dog fall in that set of descriptions? It would seem your definition of "sentience" is in contradiction with itself. One must be "conscious" to be "sentient" or, if not, just be a "thing" that is "sentient?" WTF is up with that?
 
As the word means "able to feel", "having the power of perception"...it means they are sentient...That they have senses.

Again...you try to use a ridiculous comparison. No...it is not the same as understanding quantum physics. No one, other than you, argues that it is.

You're again confusing and conflating human intelligence with sentience.


...Based on the overwhelming and universal acceptance of the Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness I offer here what I call a Universal Declaration on Animal Sentience. For the purpose of this essay I am defining "sentience" as "the ability to feel, perceive, or be conscious, or to experience subjectivity(link is external)" (for wide-ranging discussion please click here(link is external).)

Evidence of animal sentience is everywhere": It's a matter of why sentience evolved, not if it evolved

A strong and rapidly growing database on animal sentience supports the acceptance of the fact that other animals are sentient beings. We know that individuals of a wide variety of species experience emotions ranging from joy and happiness to deep sadness, grief, and PTSD, along with empathy, jealousy and resentment. There is no reason to embellish them because science is showing how fascinating they are (for example, mice, rats, and chickens display empathy) and countless other "surprises" are rapidly emerging...

...For example, we share with other mammals and vertebrates the same areas of the brain that are important for consciousness and processing emotions.

We surely are not exceptional or alone in the arena of sentience and indeed, membership in the sentience club is rapidly growing. There are sound biological reasons for recognizing animals as sentient beings. We need to abandon the anthropocentric view that only big-brained animals such as ourselves, nonhuman great apes, elephants, and cetaceans (dolphins and whales) have sufficient mental capacities for complex forms of sentience and consciousness. So, the interesting and challenging question is why has sentience evolved in diverse species, not if it has evolved...



https://www.psychologytoday.com/blo...al-declaration-animal-sentience-no-pretending

Yes I understand there is a movement to include animals in the category of "sentient" beings. That is key to the athiest effort to deny the existence of God and the concept of a human soul.

Consciousness:

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/consciousness

It just doesn't look to me like any of that applies to animals.
 
That isn't a universally accepted concept. Lets look at what it means to be "conscious."

Consciousness:
noun
1.the state of being conscious; awareness of one's own existence, sensations, thoughts, surroundings, etc.
2.the thoughts and feelings, collectively, of an individual or of an aggregate of people:
the moral consciousness of a nation.
3.full activity of the mind and senses, as in waking life:
to regain consciousness after fainting.
4.awareness of something for what it is; internal knowledge:
consciousness of wrongdoing.
5.concern, interest, or acute awareness:
class consciousness.
6.the mental activity of which a person is aware as contrasted with unconscious mental processes.
7.Philosophy. the mind or the mental faculties as characterized by thought, feelings, and volition.

Where does the dog fall in that set of descriptions? It would seem your definition of "sentience" is in contradiction with itself. One must be "conscious" to be "sentient" or, if not, just be a "thing" that is "sentient?" WTF is up with that?

Conscious...



con·scious
ˈkän(t)SHəs/
adjective
  1. aware of and responding to one's surroundings; awake.
    synonyms: aware, awake, alert, responsive, sentient, compos mentis
    "the patient was conscious"
    • having knowledge of something; aware.
      "we are conscious of the extent of the problem"
      synonyms: aware, mindful, sensible; More
    • painfully aware of; sensitive to.
      "he was very conscious of his appearance"

We see this in animals on a constant basis. They are aware of their surroundings. Not just dogs, but all sorts of animals. Elephants, certainly. They know things. No...not quantum physics.

It sounds like part of a plotline conceived by Charles Dickens: Two days before Christmas, an ex-orphan named Emily returns as an adult to the orphanage that had treated her so kindly in order to give birth to her own baby in safety...

http://thewildlife.wbur.org/2015/01/12/elephant-orphan-returns-to-caretakers-to-give-birth/

Scientists from the Elephant Listening Project (ELP) are beginning to crack the code of elephant language and learn how elephants communicate with each other over long distances through the use of sounds too deep for the human ear to perceive.

A report on NPR’s Morning Edition discussed the work of the animal linguists who study elephant communication, particularly biologist Katy Payne, who was the first person to detect song patterns in whale communication in the 1960s...

http://www.rawstory.com/2015/08/lis...cate-long-distance-using-subsonic-infrasound/

We will never understand what elephants can...until we break their language. They are social, protect, and communicate. They remember.
 
Yes I understand there is a movement to include animals in the category of "sentient" beings. That is key to the athiest effort to deny the existence of God and the concept of a human soul.

Consciousness:

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/consciousness

It just doesn't look to me like any of that applies to animals.


Yeah...but the word conscious does...


con·scious
ˈkän(t)SHəs/
adjective
  1. aware of and responding to one's surroundings; awake.
    synonyms: aware, awake, alert, responsive, sentient, compos mentis
    "the patient was conscious"
    • having knowledge of something; aware.
      "we are conscious of the extent of the problem"
      synonyms: aware, mindful, sensible; More

    • painfully aware of; sensitive to.
      "he was very conscious of his appearance"




God made the animals too.
 
Yeah...but the word conscious does...


con·scious
ˈkän(t)SHəs/
adjective
  1. aware of and responding to one's surroundings; awake.
    synonyms: aware, awake, alert, responsive, sentient, compos mentis
    "the patient was conscious"
    • having knowledge of something; aware.
      "we are conscious of the extent of the problem"
      synonyms: aware, mindful, sensible; More

    • painfully aware of; sensitive to.
      "he was very conscious of his appearance"




God made the animals too.

So animals are "mindful?" "Aware" of the extent of a problem? "Sensitive" to their appearance? WTF???

Can a machine be "sentient?"

http://fortune.com/2015/11/01/artificial-intelligence-robots-work/
 
So animals are "mindful?" "Aware" of the extent of a problem? "Sensitive" to their appearance? WTF???

Can a machine be "sentient?"

http://fortune.com/2015/11/01/artificial-intelligence-robots-work/

No...animals are AWARE. Of their surroundings.

Sentience is the ability to perceive one's environment, and experience sensations such as pain and suffering, or pleasure and comfort.1 An animal that is sentient will have the ability to receive internal sensation and information from its environment, and then interpret this as an emotion.

http://agriculture.vic.gov.au/pets/care-and-welfare/animals-and-people/what-is-sentience


I have always stated that there are degrees to understanding. You continue to want this argument to be one of sameness...that I'm arguing that animals can do quantum physics and hang around solving the problems of the world. I am not, so please halt this conflationary tactic you insist upon.


http://www.amazon.com/The-Emotional...35&sr=8-2-fkmr0&keywords=bekoff+smile+dolphon


https://www.psychologytoday.com/blo...onclude-nonhuman-animals-are-conscious-beings

http://www.stuff.co.nz/nelson-mail/...legally-recognises-animals-as-sentient-beings


http://www.lcanimal.org/index.php/b...lly-admits-that-animals-are-sentient-beings-2

http://kwelos.tripod.com/sentientbeings.htm
 
Yes, but like I keep telling Craig, the fact that a dog "understands" a command/reward situation isn't the same as a human "understanding" of quantum physics. I just don't buy the concept that animals are sentient because they can "feel" pleasure or pain. Studies have proven that plants exhibit an awareness of comfort/discomfort as well - does that mean plants are "sentient?" It's more than that - it's the ability to learn a language, perform arithmetic, and more importantly to teach what one "understands" to another.

The eminent physicist Richard Feynmann: NO ONE understands quantum mechanics.

By the definition proffered in your last sentence, the great apes are CLEARLY sentient, as they can learn sign language, can TEACH that sign language to other apes, and can indeed perform very simple arithmetic operations.....
 
The eminent physicist Richard Feynmann: NO ONE understands quantum mechanics.

By the definition proffered in your last sentence, the great apes are CLEARLY sentient, as they can learn sign language, can TEACH that sign language to other apes, and can indeed perform very simple arithmetic operations.....

And they have been observed using tools. Not sure that's enough to "prove" they are sentient or not as we have no idea their level of UNDERSTANDING what they are in fact doing.
 
And they have been observed using tools. Not sure that's enough to "prove" they are sentient or not as we have no idea their level of UNDERSTANDING what they are in fact doing.

I took YOUR definition of sentience: "It's more than that - it's the ability to learn a language, perform arithmetic, and more importantly to teach what one "understands" to another."

I then demonstrated that the great apes satisfy this definition that YOU gave.

Not surprisingly, you are now changing the goalposts, and in such a way that the sentience of apes could NEVER be demonstrated. Even if a chimpanzee were to walk up to you and start discussing relativity and quantum mechanics, you could just (predictably) claim that the chimp had been TRAINED to do this, but had no real understanding of what he (or she) was doing.
 
I took YOUR definition of sentience: "It's more than that - it's the ability to learn a language, perform arithmetic, and more importantly to teach what one "understands" to another."

I then demonstrated that the great apes satisfy this definition that YOU gave.

Not surprisingly, you are now changing the goalposts, and in such a way that the sentience of apes could NEVER be demonstrated. Even if a chimpanzee were to walk up to you and start discussing relativity and quantum mechanics, you could just (predictably) claim that the chimp had been TRAINED to do this, but had no real understanding of what he (or she) was doing.

Sounds like an Arkady argument to me. Small technical point accepted means my entire argument disintegrates. Whatever - apes may or may not actually UNDERSTAND language by making simple hand gestures or math by whatever you call the arithmetic they are "performing." Is it different than teaching a horse to "count" or a dog to respond to its owner calling "treat?" I don't know - do you?
 
Sounds like an Arkady argument to me. Small technical point accepted means my entire argument disintegrates. Whatever - apes may or may not actually UNDERSTAND language by making simple hand gestures or math by whatever you call the arithmetic they are "performing." Is it different than teaching a horse to "count" or a dog to respond to its owner calling "treat?" I don't know - do you?

One of the apes that was taught sign language----the gorilla Koko----was presented one day with a watermelon, an object she had not been taught any sign language word for. What Koko did was to INVENT a word to describe the watermelon. She called it 'candy fruit', using two words she HAD been taught.

I would say that demonstrates an excellent level of understanding.
 
One of the apes that was taught sign language----the gorilla Koko----was presented one day with a watermelon, an object she had not been taught any sign language word for. What Koko did was to INVENT a word to describe the watermelon. She called it 'candy fruit', using two words she HAD been taught.

I would say that demonstrates an excellent level of understanding.

So she didn't know if it was candy or fruit and that demonstrates an "excellent level of understanding" to you? That explains a lot about why you think all the bad (Keynesian) economic policies "work."
 
So she didn't know if it was candy or fruit and that demonstrates an "excellent level of understanding" to you? That explains a lot about why you think all the bad (Keynesian) economic policies "work."

She PUT TOGETHER two seemingly unrelated words to give what I would call a rather accurate DESCRIPTION of a watermelon.

Maybe Koko is smarter than you, Lukey. What would YOU call a watermelon if you had never encountered one before?? I am guessing Lukey would just go, "Uh, duh. I have NO idea what to call this....."

For the UMPTEENTH time, I am NOT a Keynesian. Why do you keep calling me one, despite that? Is it just native stupidity on your part?
 
She PUT TOGETHER two seemingly unrelated words to give what I would call a rather accurate DESCRIPTION of a watermelon.

Maybe Koko is smarter than you, Lukey. What would YOU call a watermelon if you had never encountered one before?? I am guessing Lukey would just go, "Uh, duh. I have NO idea what to call this....."

For the UMPTEENTH time, I am NOT a Keynesian. Why do you keep calling me one, despite that? Is it just native stupidity on your part?

You support and defend a lot of Keynesian policies. Does that make you a Keynesian? Or just a big government loving liberal? It doesn't really matter...
 
You support and defend a lot of Keynesian policies. Does that make you a Keynesian? Or just a big government loving liberal? It doesn't really matter...

In all fairness, Keynes WAS one of the most brilliant men of the 20th century. There is a reason, many reasons actually, why his ideas have been so influential. But I am a Schumpeterian economist, not a Keynesian. I support government funding of research in science and technology, which you undoubtedly (but incorrectly) view as a Keynesian idea. And perhaps that is the source of your confusion.

And I DO agree with the Keynesian dictum that "The boom, and not the slump, is the time for austerity." But that strikes me as nothing more than good, old-fashioned, common sense.

Shrug.
 
In all fairness, Keynes WAS one of the most brilliant men of the 20th century. There is a reason, many reasons actually, why his ideas have been so influential. But I am a Schumpeterian economist, not a Keynesian. I support government funding of research in science and technology, which you undoubtedly (but incorrectly) view as a Keynesian idea. And perhaps that is the source of your confusion.

And I DO agree with the Keynesian dictum that "The boom, and not the slump, is the time for austerity." But that strikes me as nothing more than good, old-fashioned, common sense.

Shrug.

I bet you are especially fond of the "demise of capitalism" part of Schumpterian economic theory.

And so you are (also) Keynesian in the sense that you perceive that the government should actively seek to control the business cycle.

I have never seen you argue against any expansion of government, or in favor of any reduction. You are a "good, old fashioned" big government liberal.
 
I bet you are especially fond of the "demise of capitalism" part of Schumpterian economic theory.

And so you are (also) Keynesian in the sense that you perceive that the government should actively seek to control the business cycle.

I have never seen you argue against any expansion of government, or in favor of any reduction. You are a "good, old fashioned" big government liberal.

Wow. You are wrong, on all three counts.

(1) No, I am NOT fond of Schumpeter's 'demise of capitalism' idea. Not at all. Schumpeter DID say he thought capitalism had a few more rounds of expansion left in it before what he saw as socialist tendencies taking over. I, on the other hand, have the fervent hope that capitalism will carry humanity to the stars.........

(2) We talked about this one several weeks ago. No, I am NOT in favor of stabilization policy. I do NOT think the government should be using fiscal policy and/or monetary policy to try to prevent or ameliorate your garden-variety recessions. Like any good classical economist, I regard the business cycle as being a normal, natural, and inherent part of capitalism. Keynesians regard the business cycle as being somehow AB-normal, UN-natural, and want to stamp it out. I insist they are wrong.

(3) I was against George W. Bush's expansion of Medicare to include prescription drug benefits. I was (mostly) in favor of the recommendations that the Simpson/Bowles Commission made to tackle the national debt. If you recall, they recommended a combination of spending cuts and tax increases. I would like to see the social safety net reduced, though certainly not eliminated. I would favor some pretty sharp cutbacks in military spending, but also favor major reforms to our entitlement programs.

Really, Lukey, you MUST do better. At the very least, you should STOP deliberately misrepresenting the views of those who disagree with you. At this point, I am going to start assuming you are doing that deliberately.
 
Wow. You are wrong, on all three counts.

(1) No, I am NOT fond of Schumpeter's 'demise of capitalism' idea. Not at all. Schumpeter DID say he thought capitalism had a few more rounds of expansion left in it before what he saw as socialist tendencies taking over. I, on the other hand, have the fervent hope that capitalism will carry humanity to the stars.........

(2) We talked about this one several weeks ago. No, I am NOT in favor of stabilization policy. I do NOT think the government should be using fiscal policy and/or monetary policy to try to prevent or ameliorate your garden-variety recessions. Like any good classical economist, I regard the business cycle as being a normal, natural, and inherent part of capitalism. Keynesians regard the business cycle as being somehow AB-normal, UN-natural, and want to stamp it out. I insist they are wrong.

(3) I was against George W. Bush's expansion of Medicare to include prescription drug benefits. I was (mostly) in favor of the recommendations that the Simpson/Bowles Commission made to tackle the national debt. If you recall, they recommended a combination of spending cuts and tax increases. I would like to see the social safety net reduced, though certainly not eliminated. I would favor some pretty sharp cutbacks in military spending, but also favor major reforms to our entitlement programs.

Really, Lukey, you MUST do better. At the very least, you should STOP deliberately misrepresenting the views of those who disagree with you. At this point, I am going to start assuming you are doing that deliberately.

I don't get it then. In light of that it would seem there's not much difference between our viewpoints. So why do you keep arguing with me?
 
Presumably because you frequently say wrong things.....:rolleyes:

I'm in favor of cutting government spending back to the size it was under Clinton (including the military). I would also like to see tax rates restored to the level they were under Clinton. Then focus on getting the Fed out of the business of managing the economy and have it focus instead on keeping the dollar stable. And move the regulatory environment back to roughly the same cost and scope as it was under Clinton. What is "wrong" with any of that?
 
Back
Top