New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Biden-Hur Transcripts

Yup. Very similar to the methods used in previous centuries by capitalist reformers such as Cromwell and Peel for primitive capitalist accumulation, and a vicious repudiation (made possible by the defeat of communist forces by the forces of capitalist counterrevolution) of the Marxist program of voluntary collectivization on the basis of a worker-peasant alliance.

Engels of course warned in 1882 that if Russia were to have a working-class revolution, but that revolution did not quickly spread to a more advanced country (Germany or the UK), the result would be an "orgy of barbarism" due to the mismatch between the objective requirements for socialist construction and Russia's material and political backwardness.
The truth is that there are no successful communist economies. The slaughter of the citizens of communist countries in the name of communism is ubiquitous.
 
The truth is that there are no successful communist economies. The slaughter of the citizens of communist countries in the name of communism is ubiquitous.
If you hold “communist economies” to a separate and distinctly higher standard of success you can conclude that. If you compare them to capitalist countries on the same basis, they come out looking rather well. For example, every country that has begun socialist construction has seen its life expectancy rise compared with its capitalist past, and this in the face of the massed might of the capitalist world making destroying those countries their top priority.
 
Yup. Very similar to the methods used in previous centuries by capitalist reformers such as Cromwell and Peel for primitive capitalist accumulation, and a vicious repudiation (made possible by the defeat of communist forces by the forces of capitalist counterrevolution) of the Marxist program of voluntary collectivization on the basis of a worker-peasant alliance.

Engels of course warned in 1882 that if Russia were to have a working-class revolution, but that revolution did not quickly spread to a more advanced country (Germany or the UK), the result would be an "orgy of barbarism" due to the mismatch between the objective requirements for socialist construction and Russia's material and political backwardness.
There was nothing voluntary about collectivization
 
If you hold “communist economies” to a separate and distinctly higher standard of success you can conclude that. If you compare them to capitalist countries on the same basis, they come out looking rather well. For example, every country that has begun socialist construction has seen its life expectancy rise compared with its capitalist past, and this in the face of the massed might of the capitalist world making destroying those countries their top priority.

Are you kidding? The slaughter of millions is hardly a success. The mass emigration of their citizens indicates failure. How many thousands of Cubans fled to the US after Castro took over? Why did East Germany need a wall to keep their citizens in? Why is it illegal for North Koreans to travel?

Yeah, life expectancy improved if you weren't imprisoned in Siberia.
 
Are you kidding? The slaughter of millions is hardly a success. The mass emigration of their citizens indicates failure. How many thousands of Cubans fled to the US after Castro took over? Why did East Germany need a wall to keep their citizens in? Why is it illegal for North Koreans to travel?

Yeah, life expectancy improved if you weren't imprisoned in Siberia.
The biggest mass slaughters were in the capitalist world though … again you are holding socialism to a distinctly higher standard.

600,000 Cubans maybe?

How many fled the U.S. following the American revolution? Does that prove the American revolution was a failure?

Was E. Germany a repressive dictatorship? Certainly. Do you honestly aver that it was better off under the prior (Nazi) regime?

N. Korea is another repressive regime that, like so many others, restricts travel without a passport. Was it better off as a colony of imperial Japan? Go ahead and look up “Unit 731” on Wikipedia.

Soviet citizens in Siberia lived longer on average than imperial Russian subjects in general.
 
Who in hell would give up their property in the name of communism. Collectivization was always by force.
Peasants under Lenin, Castro, and Ortega could often be induced to give up their private property to join collectives in exchange for material assistance from the state (tractors, fertilizer, etc.) and the increased productivity that came along with economy of scale.
 
Glad you agree.
Oh, I was addressing the inspired by capitalism part. It wasn't inspired by capitalism, it was inspired by the desire to exterminate the peasant class and ukrainians in particular. It was inspired by the communist centralized authority and approach perspective
 
Peasants under Lenin, Castro, and Ortega could often be induced to give up their private property to join collectives in exchange for material assistance from the state (tractors, fertilizer, etc.) and the increased productivity that came along with economy of scale.
Or more often be persuaded by force.
 
Or more often be persuaded by force.


He's playing in manicured and stylized history

Stalin: grow grain, surrender it, or die. History tells us peasants who dared even hide a morsel of grain were beaten to death or shot. Millions starved. His 'economies of scale's are the old smiling communist films shared with the west.
 
Oh, I was addressing the inspired by capitalism part. It wasn't inspired by capitalism, it was inspired by the desire to exterminate the peasant class and ukrainians in particular. It was inspired by the communist centralized authority and approach perspective
The methods were inspired by capitalism. The British government for example used similar methods to dispossess peasants and exterminate the Irish in Black ‘47, in order to affirm the central authority of the money power.
 
He's playing in manicured and stylized history

Stalin: grow grain, surrender it, or die. History tells us peasants who dared even hide a morsel of grain were beaten to death or shot. Millions starved. His 'economies of scale's are the old smiling communist films shared with the west.
That Stalin’s approach was a 180-degree reversal of the approach of Marx, Engels, and Lenin, and a revival of capitalist methods and values that were common in the czarist period and would have atrocious results, was noted as such at the time by the defenders of Lenin’s course, whose persecution by the Stalinist counterrevolution (which could not have succeeded without global capitalism’s support) made possible the betrayal of the Ukrainian peasants.
 
That Stalin’s approach was a 180-degree reversal of the approach of Marx, Engels, and Lenin, and a revival of capitalist methods and values that were common in the czarist period and would have atrocious results, was noted as such at the time by the defenders of Lenin’s course, whose persecution by the Stalinist counterrevolution (which could not have succeeded without global capitalism’s support) made possible the betrayal of the Ukrainian peasants.
Your defense of Stalin and his version of communism is amusing.
 
Your defense of Stalin and his version of communism is amusing.
I’m not defending Stalin or “his version of communism.” I’m pointing out that Stalin’s regime rested on the betrayal of communism, the murder and repression of its defenders, and the abandonment of its principles and methods, and would have been impossible if not for the support it got from the international capitalists against the communists.
 
That Stalin’s approach was a 180-degree reversal of the approach of Marx, Engels, and Lenin, and a revival of capitalist methods and values that were common in the czarist period and would have atrocious results, was noted as such at the time by the defenders of Lenin’s course, whose persecution by the Stalinist counterrevolution (which could not have succeeded without global capitalism’s support) made possible the betrayal of the Ukrainian peasants.
Huh? Marx and Engels approach exists only on paper. They lived rather well, and Engels to my recollection was a lascivious pig banging women left and right, including the wives of his friends. Lenin's approach on the other hand was consolidation of power through Mass slaughter and incarceration..

Lol. Stylized indeed
 
I’m not defending Stalin or “his version of communism.” I’m pointing out that Stalin’s regime rested on the betrayal of communism, the murder and repression of its defenders, and the abandonment of its principles and methods, and would have been impossible if not for the support it got from the international capitalists against the communists.
Again..that version exists only on paper. It never existed. Existing versions grounded in reality relied largely on the consolidation of power and economy through violence and death
 
The biggest mass slaughters were in the capitalist world though … again you are holding socialism to a distinctly higher standard.

600,000 Cubans maybe?

How many fled the U.S. following the American revolution? Does that prove the American revolution was a failure?

Was E. Germany a repressive dictatorship? Certainly. Do you honestly aver that it was better off under the prior (Nazi) regime?

N. Korea is another repressive regime that, like so many others, restricts travel without a passport. Was it better off as a colony of imperial Japan? Go ahead and look up “Unit 731” on Wikipedia.

Soviet citizens in Siberia lived longer on average than imperial Russian subjects in general.
The reasons why people fled from the colonies after the revolution had a lot more to do with loyalty to the crown and to Britain...and not with fear of the coming repression from the powers in control.

North Korea doesn't allow travel for the average citizen. That they do that by denying passports is obvious...

Talk to Navalny about life expectancy in Siberia.
 
Back
Top