New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Biden-Hur Transcripts

I’m not defending Stalin or “his version of communism.” I’m pointing out that Stalin’s regime rested on the betrayal of communism, the murder and repression of its defenders, and the abandonment of its principles and methods, and would have been impossible if not for the support it got from the international capitalists against the communists.
What communist nation would you choose to live in? Which ones match your hypothetical perfect communist society and economy?
 
Again..that version exists only on paper. It never existed. Existing versions grounded in reality relied largely on the consolidation of power and economy through violence and death
He offers a version of communism that does not agree with Stalin, Mao, Kim....or practically any other leader of a communist nation. Why is his interpretation any more valuable than the interpretations of those who ruled millions of people and slaughtered them in the hundreds of thousands or even went to war to expand their power?
 
Again..that version exists only on paper. It never existed. Existing versions grounded in reality relied largely on the consolidation of power and economy through violence and death
The Soviet Union, like every state in history, maintained a system of class rule through violence, with war/killing as the ultimate guarantee of state authority.

But there is a vast difference between the faithful practical implementation of Marxist praxis under Lenin and the pseudo-Marxist rationalizations of Stalin and his successors, reflecting a fundamental reversal of the nature of government. Lenin’s government, put in power on the basis of a social revolution by workers against the rule of the bourgeoisie, was a government of, by, and for the proletariat, a democratic dictatorship of the working majority over anyone who would presume to dictate to them as rulers. Stalin’s government, put into power by a political counterrevolution of a (privileged) petit-bourgeois caste (which, again, could never have succeeded without the assistance of international capitalism), was still an instrument of proletarian social rule (hit on as a compromise between a proletariat too weak to rule without the aid of that privileged layer, and a bourgeoisie too weak to restore capitalism), but the government was fundamentally hostile to the revolution that had put the proletariat in power, and in seeking first and foremost to secure their special privileges aimed to reproduce the hierarchies of class privilege typical of capitalism and to systematically undermine the Leninist revolution, even when sometimes obliged to make leftist feints to outflank the forces seeking to restore communist rule.

This class difference in the political program of the government was reflected in the stark reversals of the fundamentals of the Marx-Lenin program on the essentials of Marxism, demonstrating that it was not the “attempt to implement Marxist principle” but the abandonment of Marxist principle for capitalist-inspired pragmatism that explained the Stalinist regime.
 
The reasons why people fled from the colonies after the revolution had a lot more to do with loyalty to the crown and to Britain...and not with fear of the coming repression from the powers in control.

North Korea doesn't allow travel for the average citizen. That they do that by denying passports is obvious...

Talk to Navalny about life expectancy in Siberia.
Most of those who fled Cuba in the immediate aftermath of the revolution were latifundists, mafiosi, and torturers for the Batista regime.

Yes, Navalny was killed by the capitalist regime in Russia, almost as if repression under the Soviet Union had more to do with Russian backwardness than with socialism. The same goes for N. Korea, etc.
 
He offers a version of communism that does not agree with Stalin, Mao, Kim....or practically any other leader of a communist nation. Why is his interpretation any more valuable than the interpretations of those who ruled millions of people and slaughtered them in the hundreds of thousands or even went to war to expand their power?
My version of communism is genuine (proletarian) communism as practiced by Lenin, as opposed to the counterrevolutionary (petit-bourgeois) counterfeit of communism that was able to temporarily move genuine communism out of leadership due to the weakness of international communism in its earliest decades.
 
What communist nation would you choose to live in? Which ones match your hypothetical perfect communist society and economy?
The aim of the international communist revolution is to abolish all forms of state repression. The establishment of the workers’ state is merely an initial stage in this struggle, in which the state fundamental to class society is put to the task of putting an end to class society. You call the struggle worthless (and therefore, in practice, counsel resignation to the depression, war, fascism, and environmental devastation that are capitalism’s long-term alternative to communist revolution) if some utopian paradise hasn’t been created on day 1 of a revolution, no matter in how backward a country, although it took centuries of war, genocide, slavery, and dictatorship to lay the foundations of capitalist success, such as they are.
 
The aim of the international communist revolution is to abolish all forms of state repression. The establishment of the workers’ state is merely an initial stage in this struggle, in which the state fundamental to class society is put to the task of putting an end to class society. You call the struggle worthless (and therefore, in practice, counsel resignation to the depression, war, fascism, and environmental devastation that are capitalism’s long-term alternative to communist revolution) if some utopian paradise hasn’t been created on day 1 of a revolution, no matter in how backward a country, although it took centuries of war, genocide, slavery, and dictatorship to lay the foundations of capitalist success, such as they are.
I would not choose to live in the "utopia" you describe. I started with nothing and did pretty well by making good choices and working hard. Better me making those choices than some government official
 
He offers a version of communism that does not agree with Stalin, Mao, Kim....or practically any other leader of a communist nation. Why is his interpretation any more valuable than the interpretations of those who ruled millions of people and slaughtered them in the hundreds of thousands or even went to war to expand their power?

It's a game. He's playing an idealized game. Or stylized game whatever you want to call it.
It's actually an insult the people who suffered through communism... Making light of it, and the history, as though the words of Marx and Engels are the only real versions. Even though they weren't real versions ever
 
The Soviet Union, like every state in history, maintained a system of class rule through violence, with war/killing as the ultimate guarantee of state authority.

But there is a vast difference between the faithful practical implementation of Marxist praxis under Lenin and the pseudo-Marxist rationalizations of Stalin and his successors, reflecting a fundamental reversal of the nature of government. Lenin’s government, put in power on the basis of a social revolution by workers against the rule of the bourgeoisie, was a government of, by, and for the proletariat, a democratic dictatorship of the working majority over anyone who would presume to dictate to them as rulers. Stalin’s government, put into power by a political counterrevolution of a (privileged) petit-bourgeois caste (which, again, could never have succeeded without the assistance of international capitalism), was still an instrument of proletarian social rule (hit on as a compromise between a proletariat too weak to rule without the aid of that privileged layer, and a bourgeoisie too weak to restore capitalism), but the government was fundamentally hostile to the revolution that had put the proletariat in power, and in seeking first and foremost to secure their special privileges aimed to reproduce the hierarchies of class privilege typical of capitalism and to systematically undermine the Leninist revolution, even when sometimes obliged to make leftist feints to outflank the forces seeking to restore communist rule.

This class difference in the political program of the government was reflected in the stark reversals of the fundamentals of the Marx-Lenin program on the essentials of Marxism, demonstrating that it was not the “attempt to implement Marxist principle” but the abandonment of Marxist principle for capitalist-inspired pragmatism that explained the Stalinist regime.
Again. There wasn't any faithful practical application ever. Lenin's time was a power grab, by brute force and violence, and the slaughter of all who opposed.
 
I would not choose to live in the "utopia" you describe. I started with nothing and did pretty well by making good choices and working hard. Better me making those choices than some government official
Again, the aim is the abolition of the state and other restrictions on individual freedom.
 
Again. There wasn't any faithful practical application ever. Lenin's time was a power grab, by brute force and violence, and the slaughter of all who opposed.
Regardless, I would not want to live in Lenin’s USSR due to the war conditions and backwardness and the poverty attendant on them, nor in the USSR of Khrushchev or later E. Germany or Czechoslovakia, where material conditions were better but freedom was stifled by a harsh dictatorship.

The fact remains that Lenin’s program was the program of the proletarian masses setting themselves free. It is not that Lenin (or Marx) made no mistakes … we all do … but that their views and aims aligned with the objective requirements of the liberation of oppressed humanity from bourgeois rule. It is a demonstrable fact that the Stalinist counterrevolution meant the sharp reversal of Leninist policy on core issue after core issue; this is because it reflected the loss of political control by the communists who held power (through the strength given their movement by the ruling masses, and with an eye always to expanding democracy) in Lenin’s time. The violence employed by Lenin’s government against anti-Semites, bandits, proto-fascists, labor skates, White Guards, and assorted other enemies of the people was justifiable since the alternative would have been the endless slaughter of imperialist war and the condemnation of countless generations to more poverty. The abolition of the systems of hoboism, company towns, scrip for piecework, child labor, and sweatshop mining in the U.S. is largely attributable to Lenin’s victories over international capitalism.

Fidel Castro, though his movement was far more infected by Stalinist ideology and practice due to the necessity of adaptation to Soviet/Chinese power, also led his government in a revolutionary (communist) direction on occasion, and is the most admirable of the post-Lenin state leaders in my opinion. Again, “utopia” is your straw man. The question is whether his government made concrete interventions on the side of oppressed humanity that outweighed the harms they did to the cause of the same.
 
Regardless, I would not want to live in Lenin’s USSR due to the war conditions and backwardness and the poverty attendant on them, nor in the USSR of Khrushchev or later E. Germany or Czechoslovakia, where material conditions were better but freedom was stifled by a harsh dictatorship.

The fact remains that Lenin’s program was the program of the proletarian masses setting themselves free. It is not that Lenin (or Marx) made no mistakes … we all do … but that their views and aims aligned with the objective requirements of the liberation of oppressed humanity from bourgeois rule. It is a demonstrable fact that the Stalinist counterrevolution meant the sharp reversal of Leninist policy on core issue after core issue; this is because it reflected the loss of political control by the communists who held power (through the strength given their movement by the ruling masses, and with an eye always to expanding democracy) in Lenin’s time. The violence employed by Lenin’s government against anti-Semites, bandits, proto-fascists, labor skates, White Guards, and assorted other enemies of the people was justifiable since the alternative would have been the endless slaughter of imperialist war and the condemnation of countless generations to more poverty. The abolition of the systems of hoboism, company towns, scrip for piecework, child labor, and sweatshop mining in the U.S. is largely attributable to Lenin’s victories over international capitalism.

Fidel Castro, though his movement was far more infected by Stalinist ideology and practice due to the necessity of adaptation to Soviet/Chinese power, also led his government in a revolutionary (communist) direction on occasion, and is the most admirable of the post-Lenin state leaders in my opinion. Again, “utopia” is your straw man. The question is whether his government made concrete interventions on the side of oppressed humanity that outweighed the harms they did to the cause of the same.
His interventions did not. They brought death.
 
Again, the aim is the abolition of the state and other restrictions on individual freedom.
Which has historically resulted in the destruction of individual incentive to create and accomplish things like building a business. The aim, as you think it is, has never been accomplished.
 
Which has historically resulted in the destruction of individual incentive to create and accomplish things like building a business. The aim, as you think it is, has never been accomplished.
The material results speak for themselves. The USSR, cut off from world trade by every other country in the world aiming to destroy it, went in a generation from gaslight, mass illiteracy, and being unable to hold its own in a war with Poland to defeating the Nazi war machine, bringing electricity and literacy to the whole country, and pioneering the space race. China went from being much poorer than India to being much wealthier. Cuba went from one of the poorest countries in Latin America to one of the richest.
 
Sigh. We were discussing your faux socialist Nirvana. Put the (now obliterated) goal posts back where they were
You were discussing a “faux socialist nirvana” because you can’t discredit socialism without holding it to a distinctly higher standard … when you compare socialist societies with the capitalist societies they emerged from, or the first hundred years of socialist construction with the first hundred years of capitalist construction, you get a different answer.
 
You were discussing a “faux socialist nirvana” because you can’t discredit socialism without holding it to a distinctly higher standard … when you compare socialist societies with the capitalist societies they emerged from, or the first hundred years of socialist construction with the first hundred years of capitalist construction, you get a different answer.
No. I dismissed them entirely. See it? Faux...
 
You were discussing a “faux socialist nirvana” because you can’t discredit socialism without holding it to a distinctly higher standard … when you compare socialist societies with the capitalist societies they emerged from, or the first hundred years of socialist construction with the first hundred years of capitalist construction, you get a different answer.
So now you want to switch to defending Socialism instead of Communism....practically every single first world nation has some degree of socialist policies...that has little to do with the extreme of communism which requires complete control of the economy, production, employment, housing and education. Would you let a government official tell you where you'd go to school, work, live...Your career is decided for you...your home is their choice...not yours.
 
So now you want to switch to defending Socialism instead of Communism....practically every single first world nation has some degree of socialist policies...that has little to do with the extreme of communism which requires complete control of the economy, production, employment, housing and education. Would you let a government official tell you where you'd go to school, work, live...Your career is decided for you...your home is their choice...not yours.
Yup
 
Back
Top