New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Bush's Third Term

well, I can't disagre with any of that, other than perhaps the success issues raised on the cause front. http://www.google.com/search?q=clinton+success&sitesearch=cepr.net

I also won't quibble with the other distinctions of the style kind.

The only point I was trying to make was the similarities they share of the big biz/etc v little guy kind. The origin of the DLC/Third Way crap had to do with cutting the dem dependency on labor unions and other traditional dem sources of campaign dough, and to tap the money wells of say, those bankers that have largely gotten off scott free.

BC and BHO are two different men that operated on two different political landscapes and occupants of that to some degree. The issues of their personal governing styles, etc, take a back seat to their shared goals as the "good cops" imo, which are certainly more beneficial to the masses than the alternative, but less so than the dems our fathers voted for.

ANd one must consider as well, that BC's admin was the maiden voyage to the land of riches for the newly minted "New Dems", and given the many and varied failures of the Bush admin, "No drama" Obama was typecasted perfectly to further their shared agenda. We could of course brainstorm and come up with other examples of this besides SS now being on the chopping block, which will only support the only point I was making -- the good cops try to do for their monied masters as much as the political realities (like reelection possibilities) and legacy considerations will allow, as opposed to the rightingnuts (bad cops) who shamelessly let us know who is buttering their bread.

Citing the stock bubble to explain away the Clinton-era success never made sense to me. We've had an astounding bull-market stock run under Obama. Do you see similar across-the-board improvements? I don't. We had an epic real estate bubble under Bush, but even while it was inflating it didn't yield the kind of dramatic improvement of the Clinton years. The Republicans used to credit Clinton's success to Greenspan or the Republican Congress, but those excuses sound lame once you know that things fell apart starting in 2001, even as Greenspan and the Republican Congress stayed in place. So now they credit the stock bubble. They couldn't accept that maybe Clinton's liberal policies did it.
 
To the best of my knowledge, being "the best" does not equal being perfect. Unless we elect a God as our President, I doubt that we'll ever have one who achieves perfection.

No President starts with a clean slate. Instead, they inherit the situation that exists at the time when they are elected. They all make mistakes, since they are often put in the position of making decisions with inadequate information to predict with absolute certainty the final results of those decisions.

I would suggest that the only valid means of ranking past Presidents is to compare the results of their tenure, rather than comparing them to an ideal standard. Barack Obama is not a perfect President. That said, to compare his tenure thus far with that of his predecessor is patently absurd. Barack Obama is no George W. Bush -- and I thank God for that.

I agree with this one! For those who are blaming Obama for not cleaning up the Bush mess fast enough, I can only say,"Pffft!" The President is not alone in making decisions. congess controls the money! they refused funding when Obama wanted to close Guantanamo!

[B Kind of makes me sick when a poster complains about Obama,so the Hallelujah chorus on the right can come in and say,"Amen,amen!"

FDR was not perfect and neither is Obama,but you can bet your bottom dollar when History is written both will be at the top,right along with BillyJeff:) I really like that name for the most admired man in the world!
 
judge my character based upon your knowledge of your own, personal character flaws.

Hey! A good time to point out my signature line.
 
Well, that's your opinion and you're entitled to it. Those on the wrong side of the chicken-wire might see it differently.

Zam, just a little note here! I know the Japanese woman who got a settlement for those who were interred.She married one of the men in the Paratroopers Convention we went on. He was a close buddy of my best friend. I could tell you all about it. She was not welcomed warmly by those guys who watched their buddies smashed on the rocks, jumping too low to avoid radar of the Japanese.If you had been there,you would understand their feelings!
 
We "Obama worshipers" have to stick together and never criticize him for anything.

Long live the new Messiah!

Oddly, most of the usual suspects are avoiding commenting on a thread critical of Obama. (They have to pretend they don't see it. Good job!)
 
Zam, just a little note here! I know the Japanese woman who got a settlement for those who were interred.She married one of the men in the Paratroopers Convention we went on. He was a close buddy of my best friend. I could tell you all about it. She was not welcomed warmly by those guys who watched their buddies smashed on the rocks, jumping too low to avoid radar of the Japanese.If you had been there,you would understand their feelings!



Having been in a war, I understand a bit about "hard feelings". It doesn't excuse, however, rounding up law-abiding citizens based on their ethnicity and locking them up. Any attempt to justify that is going to come up short.
 
Well, that's your opinion and you're entitled to it. Those on the wrong side of the chicken-wire might see it differently.

If you know people on the wrong side of the chicken wire, I'd be interested to hear their thoughts. Yes, many of them were locked up unjustly, and that was a great travesty. But the government wised up and the exclusion order was rescinded in 1945 (while the war was still ongoing), and much later apologized and provided compensation. That may have been inadequate, but I wonder how many of those interned feel that they would have been better off if FDR had never been president. That blot on his legacy was just one portion of the impact he had on their lives. He helped to pull them out of the Great Depression, he helped to win WWII, and he set up the regulatory framework and infrastructure investment that made the post-war period one of the most dramatic increases in prosperity in world history. Most of those interned lived through all that, too. If their 1940 selves could have seen how their 1950, 1960, or 1970 selves were living, they probably couldn't have believed how well things had gone, even if they knew about the few years of their lives that had been stolen between those two periods. So, the question is whether even that tiny minority of Americans would have felt that, overall, FDR's leadership was bad for them. Maybe. Maybe not.
 
Michael Lind, a supposed former neocon, fails to mention Bush's illegal invasion of Iraq and the torture regimen. yet suggests Obama did the same? I don't think so. and what's this, "Both involved the country in a foreign war with a Muslim nation.?" I don't get that. does he mean Libya?

the article wasn't as fascinating as you seem to think it was. heck, you write more in depth than this Lind guy (who wrote a book calling Vietnam the necessary war).

Those comments, without quotation marks, were from me, not Lind. Yes, I was referring to Libya. Whether or not you think getting involved in Libya was a good idea, the fact is it was a foreign war with a Muslim nation. It was also done without Congressional approval, so you could argue it was worse, legally, than what Bush did in Iraq.
 
you could argue it was worse, legally, than what Bush did in Iraq.

But strategically and diplomatically, a masterpiece in comparison. I'll go with the lawbreaker on this one. I think lying us into the Iraq war was a more egregious crime than Obama's more overt one, regardless of how the proper protocol machinations worked.
 
well, that's why I noted differing landscapes.

I'm no economist, but it seems to me that your confusion may lie in making such comparisons without regard or consideration of/in isolation from other factors. For example:

The other way that the bubble drove the economy is through the wealth effect on consumption. The run-up in stock prices generated roughly $10 trillion in bubble wealth. The wealth effect from stock is usually estimated to be 3-4 cents on the dollar. This would mean that the bubble generated between $300 billion to $400 billion annually in additional consumption. This would have been 3-4 percent of GDP at the time ($480 billion to $560 billion annually in today's economy). This is born out in the Commerce Department's data which show that the saving rate fell from close to 7 percent at the start of the 1990s to around 2.0 percent at the peak of the bubble in 2000. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dean-baker/there-is-no-santa-claus-a_b_2362845.html

Like I said, I don't care about those things, just the political persuasions and goals of both men, which he captures quite well here.

The big difference is that, unlike the Republicans, the Rubin-Clinton crew believes that the rich should have to pay their taxes. That's something, but until there is someone in this debate who isn't pushing policies that redistribute before-tax income upward, the vast majority in this country can only lose.

that's why I call the the "good cops".
 
well, that's why I noted differing landscapes.

I'm no economist, but it seems to me that your confusion may lie in making such comparisons without regard or consideration of/in isolation from other factors. For example:

The other way that the bubble drove the economy is through the wealth effect on consumption. The run-up in stock prices generated roughly $10 trillion in bubble wealth. The wealth effect from stock is usually estimated to be 3-4 cents on the dollar. This would mean that the bubble generated between $300 billion to $400 billion annually in additional consumption. This would have been 3-4 percent of GDP at the time ($480 billion to $560 billion annually in today's economy). This is born out in the Commerce Department's data which show that the saving rate fell from close to 7 percent at the start of the 1990s to around 2.0 percent at the peak of the bubble in 2000. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dean-baker/there-is-no-santa-claus-a_b_2362845.html

Like I said, I don't care about those things, just the political persuasions and goals of both men, which he captures quite well here.

The big difference is that, unlike the Republicans, the Rubin-Clinton crew believes that the rich should have to pay their taxes. That's something, but until there is someone in this debate who isn't pushing policies that redistribute before-tax income upward, the vast majority in this country can only lose.

that's why I call the the "good cops".

If it was a wealth effect on consumption, the question is why there hasn't been a similar wealth effect on consumption today, as the stock run has been fairly spectacular since early 2009. Or why there wasn't such a huge wealth effect in the Bush years (when equity growth in real estate had a MUCH bigger impact on the average person's bottom line that whatever pittance he had in stocks).

I think a wealth effect has multiple components, some of which are psychological. When people think things are going well and will continue to go well, they see rising wealth levels as permission to spend more and save less. But when they figure the other shoe is going to fall sooner or later, they sit on those gains, as has been happening in the Obama years.
 
you could argue it was worse, legally, than what Bush did in Iraq.

But strategically and diplomatically, a masterpiece in comparison. I'll go with the lawbreaker on this one. I think lying us into the Iraq war was a more egregious crime than Obama's more overt one, regardless of how the proper protocol machinations worked.

Agreed, strategically and diplomatically. Politically and economically, too. But in strict legal terms, Bush had a vote that could reasonably be interpreted as Congressional approval for what he did, whereas Obama was acting without approval, and eventually in violation of the War Powers Resolution. As for Bush's lies, I agree with you. It's a great tragedy that Obama allowed a precedent to be set that basically says the president can get away with anything, from ordering people to be tortured (to death, in a couple cases), to spying on Americans without a warrant, to willfully deceiving the public into a disastrous war, and there will be no legal repercussions.
 
The "War Powers Act" angle, is tiresome. There are very legitimate arguments against this Act's constitutionality. Therefore, this one remains an unanswered question until someone either challenges the Act in court, or challenges some action that presumably violates it.

People have every right to suggest that per their personal interpretation of the War Powers Act, or per how THEY would interpret if they were to sit in its judgement, this or that is a violation. But, the idea that what Obama, or any other president has done vis a vis the War Powers Act, is some sort of obvious-to-all violation of the act, is silly.
 
If you know people on the wrong side of the chicken wire, I'd be interested to hear their thoughts. Yes, many of them were locked up unjustly, and that was a great travesty. But the government wised up and the exclusion order was rescinded in 1945 (while the war was still ongoing), and much later apologized and provided compensation. That may have been inadequate, but I wonder how many of those interned feel that they would have been better off if FDR had never been president. That blot on his legacy was just one portion of the impact he had on their lives. He helped to pull them out of the Great Depression, he helped to win WWII, and he set up the regulatory framework and infrastructure investment that made the post-war period one of the most dramatic increases in prosperity in world history. Most of those interned lived through all that, too. If their 1940 selves could have seen how their 1950, 1960, or 1970 selves were living, they probably couldn't have believed how well things had gone, even if they knew about the few years of their lives that had been stolen between those two periods. So, the question is whether even that tiny minority of Americans would have felt that, overall, FDR's leadership was bad for them. Maybe. Maybe not.

If the internment of Japanese during WW Two is all they can complain about, I can only say,"You just had to be there and know just how vicious the Japanese were."

A friend of mine from the Philippines died a few years ago. She often told me of being in her little village,on her knees,waiting to be shot when the Americans showed up and saved them.She hated the Japanese until the day she died of a rare kidney infection. She was a Teacher, a lovely woman,and a dear friend and neighbor.
 
If it was a wealth effect on consumption, the question is why there hasn't been a similar wealth effect on consumption today, as the stock run has been fairly spectacular since early 2009. Or why there wasn't such a huge wealth effect in the Bush years (when equity growth in real estate had a MUCH bigger impact on the average person's bottom line that whatever pittance he had in stocks).

I think a wealth effect has multiple components, some of which are psychological. When people think things are going well and will continue to go well, they see rising wealth levels as permission to spend more and save less. But when they figure the other shoe is going to fall sooner or later, they sit on those gains, as has been happening in the Obama years.

Today's "wealth effect" comes from the FRB's printing press, which immediately goes to Wall Street (Goldman Sachs/JPMorgan), unlike before when wealth was created the old fashion way (production of goods/services + savings)
 
As to the Japanese-American internment regime, it's probably only useful for us to consider how we followed it up, and not obsess too overly much over the fact of our indulging it in the first place. That sort of thing was world norm, at that time. It would've been nice if we'd been able to outperform the norm. But, we didn't

As above, the more useful testimony to our righteousness is that we acknowledged the error of our ways, ended the regime BEFORE our war with Japan was even over, and subsequently committed to never doing anything like that again. In fact, were it not for our experience with Japanese-Americans back in the 40's, I imagine way more people would've been calling for some sort of internment of Muslim-Americans, post 9/11.
 
Back
Top