New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Bush's Third Term

No MaryAnne. Arkady and I got off on a tangent about FDR. That's what we were discussing. If you go back and review the thread you'll see that.

Yes,I saw that,but feel I needed to step in,as I am much closer to that period than either you or Arkady are. I was alive then and had a chance to meet and talk with the woman who pushed the settlement through Congress.

I disagree with Obama on some things,too,but do not agree with Arkady on this one. Obama had too much on his plate to try and bring the economy back to become embroiled in all that Bush created! Obama is not Superman!
 
If the internment of Japanese during WW Two is all they can complain about, I can only say,"You just had to be there and know just how vicious the Japanese were."

A friend of mine from the Philippines died a few years ago. She often told me of being in her little village,on her knees,waiting to be shot when the Americans showed up and saved them.She hated the Japanese until the day she died of a rare kidney infection. She was a Teacher, a lovely woman,and a dear friend and neighbor.

There's certainly no comparison, but that's still no excuse. Bad behavior by the Empire of Japan does not excuse bad behavior against Japanese Americans any more than the unthinkable brutality of genocidal Hutus excuses bad behavior against African Americans.

I accept that FDR did a terrible thing with those internments. I just think that it was overwhelmed by all the good he did. If the internments were even more terrible (larger in scale, longer in duration, or more similar to the work camps and death camps used in other places), I'd be less willing to overlook that misdeed. As it is, I'll condemn him for it, but say that, on balance, he still rates as our best president.
 
Having been in a war, I understand a bit about "hard feelings". It doesn't excuse, however, rounding up law-abiding citizens based on their ethnicity and locking them up. Any attempt to justify that is going to come up short.

I did not justify anything.I simply told you of the anger and fear that a Japanese here would try another attack.
 
(Bush with privatization, Obama with a COLA adjustment that would erode Social Security benefits progressively over time, primarily to the detriment of the young)


First I would agree that Obama is Bush 2.0 ..he has doubled down on everything Bush has done...debt....you name it...But Privatization of social security would be a far better option than Obama...because wiith Privatization you have the opportunity for growth..with Democrats you take and tax...the Paul Krugman theory...spend first.

The problem either Obama faces and as well Bush was Harry Reid...the triumvirat of the Democrat inept Obama Biden and Reid. Anyone wjho agrees with Reid is an idiot.
 
The Clinton Era "wealth effect" was profoundly different from the Li'l George Era "wealth effect", for one simple reason - taxation. When our economy is hot, we should raise taxes in order to capitilize and assure our benefit. What? do private entities cut prices when their sales are soaring? Presumably capitalist GOPs tell us that a hot economy will redound to the benefit of us all. But, in the midst of Li'l George's hot economy, he insisted on keeping taxes low.
 
well, my guess would be the difference between the dot.com, stock bubble, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dot-com_bubble and what underlies the growth in the markets today arky, which has less to do with such growths like in the tech job markets back then, as well as the increased consumer spending already noted.

I think that's why Baker put it all under the bubble, because there was more of a commingling of things that led to the robust economy that were directly related to that tech sector. On the other hand

As the stock market has been advancing into all-time high territory this week, many Americans are wondering how the economy can be so great while they’re struggling so hard to make ends meet. Let’s correct that perception immediately: the stock market is not the economy, and should not be conflated with it. The stock market is only one of many indicators that measure the financial health of the country. Wall Street, our metonym for the financial markets, rarely resembles Main Street, U.S.A., and this market run provides a perfect illustration of that fact. http://beforeitsnews.com/obama-birt...lie-underlying-economic-weakness-2457986.html

whereas today there is not any single economy-wide thing that provides the level of interconnectedness to encapsulate the explanation as was the case with the dot.com growth. Today as I understand it, it is simply a reflection of the state of the financial markets in isolation from us less than confident consumers, and thriving on the basis of other things, as argued for here in the same article

There are primarily three reasons the markets have ascended to these lofty levels. The first is that after the market correction of 2008, earnings projections were dramatically lowered in the wake of the reduced economic growth prospects. The bar of expectations was lowered so far that they had no place to go but up, and for the next eight quarters of earnings reports, over 90% of publicly traded companies exceeded their reduced earnings forecasts. Positive earnings represent profits, which is the fuel for appreciating equity (stock) values.

The second reason is based on the cozy crony-capitalistic relationship between Washington and Wall Street. With tax-advantaged treatment, bailouts, grants, and interest-free loans, Washington has, for self-aggrandizing purposes, infused massive amounts of capital into select industries, sectors, and companies, that has significantly augmented their financial condition.

The third, but arguably most significant reason, is Fed monetary policy. Historically, the Federal Reserve, through their Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) has had two conventional tools at their disposal to stimulate the economy, the Fed Funds Rate and the Discount Rate. The target Fed Funds Rate is the rate at which banks and other depository institutions actively trade balances held at the Federal Reserve, on an uncollateralized basis. And the Discount Rate, or window, is the rate the Federal Reserve charges member banks when borrowing money from the Feds for themselves, and not for lending to other banks.


like I said, I'm not an economist, and think it would be unproductive to make what would imo, be apples to oranges comparisons between such things. On the totality of the evidence I see BC as the first pope of the third way, and BHO his successor, which imo is evidenced by his first appointment of Rahm Emanuel and many that followed that were part of the Clinton or Bush admin, as well as the policy choices outlined above that explain the current condition of the markets, e.g. crony capitalism, etc.

I'm guessing that the third way BS also underlies most of your objections to his policy choices on the domestic front as well. I never worry about comparing presidents on foreign policy matters, because that's always been largely a bipartisan affair. The two are also connected -- our economy and foreign policy-- at least by my understanding of it al, by the petrodollar, which the Carter Doctrine cemented firmly on the world economic landscape insomuch as it satisfied the condition upon which it's adoption was secured. It's all about empire and keeping the our economy and those of other western-worlders well lubed, and which as disparity in wealth, etc indicate, to the benefit of the few far more so than we peons. That's what conservatism has been about from the bginning, cheap labor and preservation of the aristocracy and their continued enrichment. In the final analysis, your post raises the question "Is BHO more a con than a lib/lefty"? I suspect you know my answer.

This issue you raised could really take us to many places arky, which is why I sought to confine myself to identifying the cause for the similarities between BHO and Bush on many fronts -- the leaning rightward of dem DC leaders in many ways on the domestic front that has occured since Clinton deviated from the traditional largely leftward path. We dogs will contine to get smaller and smaller bones until we start literally biting some ankles...lol

Methinks that the SS issue is resulting in one of the first and certainly one of the more significant examples of the teeth being bared by the little guys.

have a good one dude -- gotta scoot.
 
On another tack, Clinton (and we) enjoyed a bubble and Li'l George (and we) enjoyed a bubble. The bubbles were different. One was a cyber bubble and the other was a real estate bubble. When the Clinton bubble finally ran out of steam, we were in a way better position than we were at its start, in a couple of significant ways. One was that we advantaged ourselves of that bubble, by taking ourselves from "deficits as far as the eye can see", to "surpluses as far as the eye can see". And, the second is that the-tech bubble established a whole new foundation for us and our economy, from which we will benefit in perpetuity. We enjoyed a "railroad bubble" a century or so ago. It eventually burst. In then end tough, were we bettor or worse off, for having laid all that track?

On the flipside, we have Li'l George's real estate bubble. I'll need to leave it to an advocate for Li'l George, to tell us what longterm benefit we'll realize from THAT one.
 
Back
Top