New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Debate critique

1. The moderator seemed to think she was part of the debate at times. And she certainly interrupted Ryan a lot. I hope to see the statistics regarding who spoke most.......and who she interrupted and how many times each.

2. Biden's smirk was disgusting and creepy and way overdone. And the "my friend" thing.... really creepy.

3. Biden lied when he said "we were not told that they requested more security in Libya". I think that that will be found out to be an outright boldface lie.

4. I liked how Biden stood by his words. That means we may use his words and nobody can say 'boo' about it.

5. Biden even smirked when Ryan thanked him. Sheeez.

I thought Ryan did well. And of course I know that my thoughts are one-sided and I do not apologize for that.

At least Biden didn't come out like his boss as "ho hum.... it's in the bag for me". I appreciate that he put out some effort for the debate unlike Obama who obviously put forth no energy whatsoever.

#1 Really, maybe it was because he never answered his question but went on a tirade about his talking points.
#2 If that is your biggest problem, great to hear it.
#3 You say he lied, then you say when the information comes out we will see, so you know nothing more than what fox news says
#4 What that means Jen is he may mistate something but it's basically what he means, just like Ryan and Romney on their 30%/47% remarks about people not trying.
#5 That is the best you got, OMG, did you watch Ryan? Truth is debate is about how you react as much as what you say.
 
I found the debate very interesting. Biden by his own admission contradicts his own State Dept concerning Libya if what he said is true then the president should be impeached, secondly his statements concerning the 716 billion transferred from Medi - Care to Obama - Care were completely false. Biden's arrogance and rudeness took away from what ever ground he tried to gain in his talking points. Ryan failed to attack Biden on his energy policy, Biden voted against the Alaska pipeline, and has prevented this nation from being energy independent by not allowing us to develop our own resources. Ryan also failed to call Biden on many of his misrepresentations of the truth. I would call the debate a draw maybe a slight edge to Biden but that was in part due to the moderator who did her best but handled the debate poorly. Ryan did in the last 15 minutes of the debate bring up some excellent points concerning the choice we face and I thought overall Ryan presented himself well, he was polite but assertive, he was respectful but firm, Biden was condescending and rude, demonstrating very inappropriate behavior.
 
Someday republicans will learn that you must base your talk on the truth, not made up talking points from Fox news, and the RNC backed Ryan Romney lying team.
 
1. Alaska Pipeline? WTF?
2. The moderator interrupted Ryan because he talked past the limit on his time.
3. We are producing far more domestic energy today than we were in 2008 and you think Ryan had a leg to stand on to
criticize the kind of policies that move us closer to independence that any of the republican administrations from 1981 to now have done?
4. Ryan failed....that is the bottom line. He did not appear presidential. He didn't even seem competent in a debate.
 
of course you would agree. The truth is that Ryan looked like a little kid who just farted, not like an adult or less an individual who could be president. Ryan lied or came off as uninformed about his own presidential candidate's platform. He wouldn't talk about the math of their tax proposal. He was wrong about Romney's defense spending proposal (it is on Romney's website).

CBS poll of uncommitted voters 52% for Biden vs 38% for Ryan....
 
Jen, a long time ago I lost any respect for NC that I could muster, your getting close with your constant BS.
 
I agree NCM and Bidens sneers and disrespect are going to resonate with voters and not in a good way.

You just aren't very sharp about people are you... See Biden's sneers and disrespect he was able to backup with a fact based critique.. Ryan was not

and that showed
 
I will hold Ryan to his words. He has never denied his words or been known to say stupid stuff, so Ryan had no need to "stand by" the what he's said like Biden did the crap he said. But hey.............. Biden stands by his words. There should be some excellent GOP ads forthcoming using Biden's own words which he stands by.

And I'm pretty sure that the undecided people will see those constant smirks of Biden as slimy and rude.


For a teacher one might believe you would be more observant and knowledgable. Please look up the word incredulous and see how it is related to an incredulous smile. Then, please read the following and tell me with all honesty that Ryan was not FULL of "stupid stuff" tonight when he constantly blamed Obama, once running down his Obama is to blame for the economy, the high unemployment and failure of the recovery, completely ignoring the state of the economy Obama inherited and from whom and what Party in the White House that preceded him.


The economy was what when Bush entered office? It was what when he left office?

The economy was what When Obama took office, it is what now?

http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/Documents/20120229_EssentialEcon.PDF
http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/US-Economy/Pages/default.aspx#crisis

'The bursting of the dot-com bubble may have played an important role in the slow growth of 2001 and 2002, but to be fair, the technology sector’s crash wasn’t the fault of Bush 43. The one-year lag gives the recession to Clinton. On the other hand, Clinton bequeathed to Bush 43 a huge fiscal gift: The debt as a percentage of GDP steadily fell from 1996 through the recession year of 2001, to 56.4 percent from 67.1 percent. That’s an improvement of 10.7 percentage points.'

"Comparisons have been made between the economy Reagan inherited and the one Obama inherited, with some claiming Reagan was dealt the worse hand. True, Reagan had to cope with high inflation and high interest rates and Obama didn’t, but other than those two indicators, the economy Obama took on was significantly worse."

"For example, Reagan inherited a national debt at the end of Carter’s last budget (1981) of only 32.5 percent of GDP. Obama inherited a national debt of 85.2 percent of GDP in 2009, including debt owed by the U.S. Treasury to the Social Security trust fund and other intergovernmental obligations. With the economy still spiraling down, debt was rapidly climbing. Obama had far less maneuvering room than Reagan did to jump-start the economy. In addition, Bush 43 left Obama with 9.3 percent unemployment, while Carter left Reagan a 7.6 percent jobless rate. Bush handed Obama an economy in steep decline, with GDP decreasing 3.5 percent. Reagan came to office with GDP growing 2.5 percent, a 6 percentage point difference in growth rates."

"Looking at Obama’s performance in the context of his inheritance, his record is respectable. Obama’s score is 79 points higher than that of Bush 43, greater than the difference in scores between second and sixth place in the presidential rankings, and comparable to the margin between Reagan and Carter."

"Under Obama, the federal budget as a share of GDP shrank by 1.1 percentage points, compared with Bush 43’s increase of 7 percentage points. Obama so far has the lowest tax revenue as a share of GDP, at 15.3 percent, and the largest reduction in real interest rates of 3.5 percentage points. He also has better stock-market growth -- 5.5 percent against 1.9 percent for Bush -- and a reduction in the unemployment rate of 1.2 percentage points versus the second largest increase under Bush of 4.5 percentage points."
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-...conomic-legacy-is-his-successor-s-burden.html



Written in 2003:
"Over the course of the 1980's, under the influence of this revolution, what grew most was federal debt, from 26 to 42 percent of G.D.P. During the next decade, Republican leaders became less conditional in their advocacy. Since 2001, the fiscal strategizing of the party has ascended to a new level of fiscal irresponsibility. For the first time ever, a Republican leadership in complete control of our national government is advocating a huge and virtually endless policy of debt creation."

"The numbers are simply breathtaking. When President George W. Bush entered office, the 10-year budget balance was officially projected to be a surplus of $5.6 trillion -- a vast boon to future generations that Republican leaders ''firmly promised'' would be committed to their benefit by, for example, prefinancing the future cost of Social Security. Those promises were quickly forgotten. A large tax cut and continued spending growth, combined with a recession, the shock of 9/11 and the bursting of the stock-market bubble, pulled that surplus down to a mere $1 trillion by the end of 2002. Unfazed by this turnaround, the Bush administration proposed a second tax-cut package in 2003 in the face of huge new fiscal demands, including a war in Iraq and an urgent ''homeland security'' agenda. By midyear, prudent forecasters pegged the 10-year fiscal projection at a deficit of well over $4 trillion."
http://www.nytimes.com/2003/06/08/magazine/08WWLN.html?pagewanted=all




Written in 2006:
"The federal government and the U.S. economy face a looming debt crisis. The budget procedures and commitment to fiscal discipline that helped bring down the federal budget deficit and boost national saving in the 1990s have been abandoned. Deficits and debt are rising once again, as they were in the 1980s, and national saving has declined sharply.

Without a serious commitment to the budget principles and procedures that worked to restore fiscal discipline in the1990s, the U.S. economy faces consequences likely to include growth stunting increases in interest rates and possibly an international financial crisis. Symbolic gestures such as a line-item veto or unrealistic budget targets will almost surely fail again as they failed in the 1980s."
http://www.jec.senate.gov/archive/Documents/Reports/debtandtaxes2006.pdf


Written just recently:
"Thirty years of Republican apostasy — a once grand party’s embrace of the welfare state, the warfare state and the Wall Street-coddling bailout state — have crippled the engines of capitalism and buried us in debt. Mr. Ryan’s sonorous campaign rhetoric about shrinking Big Government and giving tax cuts to “job creators” (read: the top 2 percent) will do nothing to reverse the nation’s economic decline and arrest its fiscal collapse. "

"Mr. Ryan professes to be a defense hawk, though the true conservatives of modern times — Calvin Coolidge, Herbert C. Hoover, Robert A. Taft, Dwight D. Eisenhower, even Gerald R. Ford — would have had no use for the neoconconservative imperialism that the G.O.P. cobbled from policy salons run by Irving Kristol’s ex-Trotskyites three decades ago. These doctrines now saddle our bankrupt nation with a roughly $775 billion “defense” budget in a world where we have no advanced industrial state enemies and have been fired (appropriately) as the global policeman."
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/14/opinion/paul-ryans-fairy-tale-budget-plan.html




Now think about what an "incredulous smile" means.
 
Biden stands by his words. There should be some excellent GOP ads forthcoming using Biden's own words which he stands by.
Such as? Remember Biden owned up to mis-speaking. And frankly making fun of the malaprops of a stutterer is rather childish don't you think?

As for Biden's incredulousness at Ryan's bold faced lying? You would have been right if that's all that Biden did.

But then Biden took the gloves off and went after Ryan. So hard that Ryan sheepishly had to explain to Radditz that Biden had just called him a liar. And Ryan took body-blow after body-blow on that. True he didn't crumble completely, but he backed himself into a corner and started just parroting talking points.

And Negative ones at that. which made his closing statement all that more ludicrous since it essentially was a criticism of anyone doing little else than spouting negative talkng points.


That Ryan THRICE got caught out not answering the question Really hurt him
 
I found the debate very interesting. Biden by his own admission contradicts his own State Dept concerning Libya

Um where? when? Sorry that's just not true.
secondly his statements concerning the 716 billion transferred from Medi - Care to Obama - Care were completely false.

Nope. Biden spun some things but overall he was no worse than the Half True claims from Ryan http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-m...hecking-vice-presidential-debate-between-joe/

Biden wasn't rude. He was dismissive of someone doing a lot of lying. And while that takes away for him for a KoolAde drinker like you, it made Ryan look dishonest and weak to the independent voters by a 16 point margin.
 
Good to see Joe Biden call Bull$hit on Ryan's Right Wing Talking points....Which were mostly distorted babble and lies
 
You just aren't very sharp about people are you... See Biden's sneers and disrespect he was able to backup with a fact based critique.. Ryan was not

and that showed


That is funny, this morning the media has the debate as an actual toss up. Biden was non factual about Libya and he threw his own Intelligence Agency under the bus, about the 718 Billion transferred to Obama-Care, Social Security, also and most importantly about the Obama record. I had to agree with Ryan concerning Obama's failed foreign policy, and in my opinion Iran and the nuclear treat it poses is anything but a laughing matter.
 
That is funny, this morning the media has the debate as an actual toss up. Biden was non factual about Libya and he threw his own Intelligence Agency under the bus
again... how? As Romney reminded us all inthe 1st debate, simply repeating your claim does not make it so... what is your FACTUAL evidence?

As for the Medicare transfers to Obamacare.. again what is it that Biden said that is factually wrong? Remember that the fact checkers say that the very claim about 716 Bill is AT BEST Half Truth.

I had to agree with Ryan concerning Obama's failed foreign policy, and in my opinion Iran and the nuclear treat it poses is anything but a laughing matter.
Of course you agreed with Ryan... you drink the KoolAde... but except to other KoolAde drinkers you have not offered anything to support your claims and quoting other KoolAde drinkers proves nothing except that you live in an echo chamber
 
Um where? when? Sorry that's just not true.


Nope. Biden spun some things but overall he was no worse than the Half True claims from Ryan http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-m...hecking-vice-presidential-debate-between-joe/

Biden wasn't rude. He was dismissive of someone doing a lot of lying. And while that takes away for him for a KoolAde drinker like you, it made Ryan look dishonest and weak to the independent voters by a 16 point margin.


Wow, first I am a racist and now a Kool-Aid drinker. Let's see, I heard Biden say the Intelligence Agency provided him with the information concerning what occurred in Libya when on this same day Heads of that agency testified in an investigative hearing the exact opposite. Biden claimed he knew nothing of a request for increased security when Lt. Col Wood has testified that numerous requests had been made and that these requests were ignored by the White House. Of course they were, Obama could ill afford another terrorist incident this close to an election and on top of that the cover up stems from the fact that the Obama administration clearly misled the American people for nearly 17 days. I completely disagree with you concerning the 718 billion taken out of Medi-Care to fund Obama-Care you cannot spend this money twice, Medi-Care as well as Social Security will go bankrupt under the Obama fiscal policies that is the fact. So the only Kool-Aid drinker in the room appears to be you, Sir.

16 point margin, where do you continue to get all this false data, do you just make it up as you go along or do you think everyone buys the BS you are trying to sell. By all accounts Biden was extremely rude as well as condescending, he continued to interrupt when his administration's policies were truthfully challenged and the smirking and uncontrolled laughing did not help his cause. Quite frankly he was an embarrassment as the Vice-President of the United States of America. Ryan made his case and the Obama record is there for all to see. The choice is clear we cannot afford four more years of failed economic policy, uncontrolled spending, record national debt, no budget, high unemployment, a failed energy policy as well as failed foreign policy in this nation.
 
again... how? As Romney reminded us all inthe 1st debate, simply repeating your claim does not make it so... what is your FACTUAL evidence?

As for the Medicare transfers to Obamacare.. again what is it that Biden said that is factually wrong? Remember that the fact checkers say that the very claim about 716 Bill is AT BEST Half Truth.


Of course you agreed with Ryan... you drink the KoolAde... but except to other KoolAde drinkers you have not offered anything to support your claims and quoting other KoolAde drinkers proves nothing except that you live in an echo chamber


Echo chambers and Kool-Aid drinkers, is that the best you have. Did you not see and hear what these two men said? Are you so ignorant as to believe the American people do not see what Obama is doing to this country? The wasted Trillions of dollars, the mis guided and failed policies. The lies, the cover ups, the false and down right dirty politics practiced daily by the Obama Spin machine. Like I said the only one that seems to be drunk on the Kool-Aid is you my friend.
 
Wow, first I am a racist and now a Kool-Aid drinker.
the two are not mutually exclusive

Let's see, I heard Biden say the Intelligence Agency provided him with the information concerning what occurred in Libya when on this same day Heads of that agency testified in an investigative hearing the exact opposite
.
Um really? that's not the testimony I heard in Issa's witch hunt... Nor is it an accurate representation of what Biden said. So again... SPECIFICS.. I asked for Specific examples of it being false.... not your impressions but VERIFIABLE EXAMPLES...

Still nothing

Biden claimed he knew nothing of a request for increased security when Lt. Col Wood has testified that numerous requests had been made and that these requests were ignored by the White House.
No Lt. Col Wood testified to numerous requests being made UP THE CHAIN OF COMMAND IN LIBYA.

Stevens' own cables reveal:
Despite that warning, Mr Stevens did not ask for more U.S. troops, and commented that Benghazi officials believed the city was becoming safer.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...a-consulate-asked-security.html#ixzz294wgBols
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
Sorry your claim is not demonstrated

Of course they were, Obama could ill afford another terrorist incident this close to an election
that's not a fact, that's an opinion on your part... and so far you have offered no evidence beuyond the KoolAde drinking of any coverup.

I completely disagree with you concerning the 718 billion taken out of Medi-Care to fund Obama-Care
Your PERSONAL disagreement carries no weight. I gave you a link to an indpendent fact checking site that puts the very question as only half true. And you have offered NO FACTUAL EVIDENCE contraditing what Biden said..

That's KoolAde drinking.

yes Biden was rude and condescending. he had every reason to be. Ryan was lying through his teeth... The best Ryan managed was two "half true"s... and One False and two Mostly False... That's plenty of reason for Biden to be condescending. And lying itself is rude.... Being rude to someone who is rude is not an embarassement to any office. http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-m...hecking-vice-presidential-debate-between-joe/
 
In the greater strategy of the debate process Biden will cost Obama more than he gained tonight. The voting populous, unlike those of us who are politically active in both mind and body remember not the words or the ideas....but mostly the appearances. In a few weeks what people will remember is a calm, respectful Ryan standing next to a Punk-ass smirking idiot.

JO
 
Back
Top