New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Divisiveness

It's actually the republicans that are trying to pit white against black, with statements such as this:


One observation I feel I must make is that if the dead "child" Trayvon had been white, and the incident received all of this attention, President Obama, Fredericka Wilson, Maxine Waters, Spike Lee, the hooded Congressman, and others............would have been standing up for Zimmerman. Zimmerman is being called "white" to make this about blacks being bullied and killed by white people. He wouldn't be classified as "white" in most cases

I'm not a Democrat, I'm an Independent and the way I see it, the commotion is about an apparent lack of further investigation into the death of a human being. Because that human being happened to be black and we know how at least some people feel about who is to blame for much of the crime in a particular part of the nation, the lack of further investigation sent up red flags, in large part based on Zimmerman's conversation with an police operator and his suggestion and speculation that Martin was up to no good based on what appears to be in Zimmerman's mind, Martin's dress and perhaps the color of his skin. One could speculate in certain parts of the nation, if the deceased were white, there would be no hesitation to investigate further. Was there over reaction based on race, perhaps so, but what fueled that other than what some people in certain parts of the nation feel about some people of another race. It's no secret. The problem appears to be that the good ole network made a decision to try to protect its SYG law and what would have been a can of worms even if they had investigated it further, by trying to sweep it under the rug and say "case closed". That only helped fuel the flames of speculation when someone spoke out about what was under the rug, why it was swept under the rug, how Zimmerman defied policy and rules, was the only one armed and the only one alive to tell his side of the story and why the state's attorney seemed to ignore the lead investigator who wasn't convinced Zimmerman's story lined up.

As far as I can see the political divide is "Neos" trying to defend Zimmerman's action, perhaps not for racial reasons or perhaps for the subconscious idea that blacks are responsible for a lot of crime and that Martin, because of his race was the attacker and up to no good, not Zimmerman, even though Zimmerman was armed with a firearm (against the training and policy of Neighborhood Watches) and Martin was not. Zimmerman was told not to pursue, as is also Neighborhood watch policy and instead of getting back in his vehicle and meeting police at the agreed to location, he chose to go against policies and the direction of law enforcement, things that raised the suspicion of the lead investigator, but didn't seem to phase the state's attorney at the time who seemed to think there was no reason to look any further into it.

If people are honest with themselves I believe they might say that no one knows for sure except Zimmerman and Martin what occurred. Martin is dead and can't speak for his side of the events of that night and THAT is just the point of this whole issue, that there was no further investigation. Many can speculate why or who was guilty of what, but the only thing anyone can be somewhat certain of is that there are missing pieces to the puzzle of what happened that night and people who didn't seem to think those obvious missing pieces needed to be check out further in the name of justice and with respect for the person killed who could not and cannot speak for their side of the events of the evening.

One used to hear the advice that if one shot, seriously injured or killed someone on their property to make sure to drag the body onto the front stoop or porch in an effort to try to ensure some proof of justifiable self defense. Stand Your Ground laws, perhaps based on emotion and the believe that a gun will solve all problems, more than a great deal of thought (of the potential problems with proving who was standing their ground), have muddled what has always tried to be a narrow definition of defense, for the very reasons that if expanded, people could find ways to lure or force others into situations where they actually were the ones trying to defend themselves, but because of the planning and staging were set up to look as though they were the attackers. it would be like me inviting someone I had a beef with into my home, placing a firearm in a convenient location, getting that person angry and threatening them so that they moved to defend themselves, but because they were in my home and I had set up the scenario, I could fairly easily fill them full of holes and claim they were the one attacking me in my home, not their trying to defend themselves from my attack on them in my home.

Without in depth investigation and that person dead on the floor, who could claim otherwise? The idea is to not make such scenarios possible or to make them a lot more difficult. If Martin tried to hide from what he might have thought was some dude following him and Zimmerman pursued where he thought Martin had gone with his gun drawn or not and Martin jumped him, hoping suprise would be his advantage over a guy pursuing him with a gun, who really was standing their ground. Pursuing trouble is NOT standing one's ground. Stopping and confronting a pursuer would be standing one's ground.

The obvious and inherent problems with such laws put in place by people whose thinking about the pitfalls of such laws fall short.

One could speculate that the state's attorney was all for the SYG laws and didn't want to see anything that could put be added to any evidence that could put them in jeopardy, so he decided to try to sweep a can of worms (for the law) case under the rug and got caught doing so. Now Zimmerman may pay even more dearly for what looks like an attempt to sweep what might have really happened that night under the rug. He may have even shot Martin by accident or realized after that Martin did no pose a deadly threat or simply that Zimmerman knew he broke the rules about pursing and carrying a firearm and needed desperately to try to justify doing so by making Martin out to be the attacker. I guess the question might be, will anyone learn anything from this and from other incidents where STG laws have muddled the "defense" justification by confusing who indeed is feeling threatened and who is standing their ground as a result, when two people might be claiming the same thing.
 
It's not about trying to pit blacks against whites. It's about trying to make sure there isn't a miscarriage of justice because of victim was black. One doesn't need much knowledge of history to realize there is a long and dark history of crimes against blacks (and against white civil rights workers who try to help blacks) going unpunished in the south. Against that kind of historical backdrop, when an unarmed black kid is killed by an armed non-black, and local officials don't even arrest the shooter, don't you think it makes sense that black civil rights figures would become concerned that this is yet another example of that kind of miscarriage of justice? Don't you think it makes sense that they'd want to bring a national spotlight to the case, so that if there are grounds for charges, charges actually get brought? I mean, even if you think the south has almost entirely outgrown its evil history of unpunished vigilante killings of blacks who step out of line, the "almost" in that sentiment matters. It doesn't seem like a terrible stretch to imagine there are still pockets of anti-black prejudice strong enough to result in someone not being charged who should be, and so of course national black civil rights leaders would want to make sure extra scrutiny is brought to those kinds of suspicious circumstances.

Picture the shoe being on the other foot. Since I assume you're white, it may be hard to picture yourself subject to the kinds of prejudice minorities face. So, try to picture yourself in the situation of being a minority. For example, picture you're living in some other country where Americans aren't very popular. Let's say you're working in some Middle Eastern country, for example. And picture your kid goes out to the store and never makes it home, because (despite being unarmed) a local shoots and kills him. And picture that, weeks later, no charges have been brought, and you suspect that because your kid's an American, the local authorities aren't terribly enthused about the idea of holding his killer accountable. Wouldn't you want the State Department or some other group that looks out for Americans to bring extra attention to the case, so that if there was enough evidence to justify the bringing of charges, it would actually happen? Wouldn't you want a big spotlight on the case, so people would be shamed into doing the right thing?


This is a good post, Arkady, for real. You left out one thing though......Since the shooting, there's been alot of rhetoric about the right and their affection for the right to carry and how that is partly responsible for Trayvon's death. And anytime someone on the right even questions the events or feels they know what events took place and opines that Zimmerman was acting in self defense, right away the talk about racism starts. This all goes on against the ever present backdrop of rhetoric about how conservatives have contempt for poor people and minorities.
That's why this issue has become laden down with divisiveness. It is intentional.

People have boldly, publicly put a price on Zimmerman's head and any discussion about how wrong and illegal that is has also been met with discussion about how blacks have suffered in this country. The mafia style "wanted" calls are almost excused away because of that, with the further assumption that anyone who's unforgiving of this behavior can't or won't understand the plight that drives it. Blacks have a history of being abused and mistreated in America, no doubt. Still doesn't anyone the right to put a bounty on someone's head. The jails are full of people who were convicted for conspiring to order or buy the death of others. Why the people who are attempting to do the same aren't being arrested is a mystery.

Yes, I'm white. A member of my family was shot nearly a dozen times and killed just for being a white cop years ago. Some of the same people speaking out in different ways against Zimmerman for being a racist also came to the assistance of the men who shot and killed my uncle. Only they claimed it was a case of mistaken identity, a lynching of innocents, (nine black jurors and a black judge) despite the fact that witnesses and my uncle's partner, who'd also been shot but thank God lived, identified the murderers, despite the fact that these men bragged about killing a white cop. To this day, some of those people work to gin up support for the one murderer who still survives. There is an entire movement based on the idea that he's the victim. Some members of my family have faced threats from these support systems. The woman who inspired this violent behavior lives in another country because she's wanted for several murders in the U.S. and is empathized with for her status as a political prisoner. So yes, I do know a little bit about losing a family member in an instant just for being the wrong color. Racism is real and it's a horrible and ugly thing. People ought not just throw that accusation around the way they do.
 
Gigi,

For the record, I am a job creator who has built (and sold) two businesses. I am a capitalist. Nevertheless, I support President Obama and the Democratic Party generally. I think that there vision of the economy is healthier and more sustainable over the long term than Romney, Ryan, and the Republican Party. Despite my background, since President Obama was elected, I have been called a communist and/or a socialist on multiple occassions (including here on PJ) by "conservatives." I have also noted that the Republican leadership (and particularly the associated SuperPacs) have played on that to "divide the country." They have also accused "pro-choice" folks of being "baby-killers" and "murderers."

Now, I am not going to say that Democrats or Democratic leaders are never "divisive" but I think that it cuts both ways. Republicans and conservatives have nothing to be proud of. They are equally divisive.

HI IRP. I've been called a communist and a socialist in my time, too. But usually when I"m arguing about an economic issue or an issue I felt the feds should get more involved in. Not when discussing a shooting/murder or a single case that's gained national attention. I think that context matters.
And from my view from the middle of the road, I see the accusations coming alot more from the left.

I'm sorry if someone called prochoicers babykillers and murderers. But at least you're not being accused of thinking every sexually active woman is a s l u t who should be punished and pick for her punishment between a rusty curette wielded by a med-school flunk out or raising her baby in abject and humilating poverty.
 
I see the accusations coming alot more from the left.

I don't.

But at least you're not being accused of thinking every sexually active woman is a s l u t who should be punished and pick for her punishment between a rusty curette wielded by a med-school flunk out or raising her baby in abject and humilating poverty.

Two wrongs don't make a right.

I know I am not a Christian. But SERIOUSLY, does Jesus care who threw the first or the most insults?
 
I don't.



Two wrongs don't make a right.

I know I am not a Christian. But SERIOUSLY, does Jesus care who threw the first or the most insults?

Eventually we run out of cheeks to turn though. I tend to think God would have built us with alot more of them if He intended for us to quietly turn one against every arrow that got slung at us.
 
God does not worry about the arrows slung at you. He worries about the arrows that you sling at others. That is what my faith teaches me.

Eventually we run out of cheeks to turn though. I tend to think God would have built us with alot more of them if He intended for us to quietly turn one against every arrow that got slung at us.
 
God does not worry about the arrows slung at you. He worries about the arrows that you sling at others. That is what my faith teaches me.

Well, my faith teaches me that too and it also teaches me that God doesn't like to see any of His children maligned or falsely accused. There was a whole story about that exact thing in the New Testament. Real happy ending, the Victim was delivered and exalted, but it was real touch and go there for awhile.
 
That includes LEFTIES and RIGHTIES. Both are children of God. Mysterious, isn't it.

I don't think it's so mysterious at all.

Can you bring me up to speed on a story about a crime committed by someone of one race against someone of another that the righties used in the way the left is using Trayvon's shooting to call people racist? Maybe I'm just missing something.
 
I don't think it's so mysterious at all.

Can you bring me up to speed on a story about a crime committed by someone of one race against someone of another that the righties used in the way the left is using Trayvon's shooting to call people racist? Maybe I'm just missing something.
Can you point to where whites have consistently been targetted by law enforcement for selectively harsh treatment?
 
This is a good post, Arkady, for real. You left out one thing though......Since the shooting, there's been alot of rhetoric about the right and their affection for the right to carry and how that is partly responsible for Trayvon's death. And anytime someone on the right even questions the events or feels they know what events took place and opines that Zimmerman was acting in self defense, right away the talk about racism starts. This all goes on against the ever present backdrop of rhetoric about how conservatives have contempt for poor people and minorities.
That's why this issue has become laden down with divisiveness. It is intentional.

People have boldly, publicly put a price on Zimmerman's head and any discussion about how wrong and illegal that is has also been met with discussion about how blacks have suffered in this country. The mafia style "wanted" calls are almost excused away because of that, with the further assumption that anyone who's unforgiving of this behavior can't or won't understand the plight that drives it. Blacks have a history of being abused and mistreated in America, no doubt. Still doesn't anyone the right to put a bounty on someone's head. The jails are full of people who were convicted for conspiring to order or buy the death of others. Why the people who are attempting to do the same aren't being arrested is a mystery.

Yes, I'm white. A member of my family was shot nearly a dozen times and killed just for being a white cop years ago. Some of the same people speaking out in different ways against Zimmerman for being a racist also came to the assistance of the men who shot and killed my uncle. Only they claimed it was a case of mistaken identity, a lynching of innocents, (nine black jurors and a black judge) despite the fact that witnesses and my uncle's partner, who'd also been shot but thank God lived, identified the murderers, despite the fact that these men bragged about killing a white cop. To this day, some of those people work to gin up support for the one murderer who still survives. There is an entire movement based on the idea that he's the victim. Some members of my family have faced threats from these support systems. The woman who inspired this violent behavior lives in another country because she's wanted for several murders in the U.S. and is empathized with for her status as a political prisoner. So yes, I do know a little bit about losing a family member in an instant just for being the wrong color. Racism is real and it's a horrible and ugly thing. People ought not just throw that accusation around the way they do.

Who was killed in this incident and who seems to suggest Zimmerman was well within his rights, in spite of an apparent lack of further investigation into the incident and in spite of the lead investigator wanting to charge Zimmerman at the time? I think what you may be feeling are those who don't seem to see it simply as Zimmerman defending himself, case closed (which seems to be a popular belief amongst those who seem to identify with the "right" here as well as SYG laws, in spite of the inherent problems with such laws that have already appeared when a question arises about who is feeling threatened, who is standing their ground and who should or should not have weapons or pursue anyone in a Neighborhood Watch capacity.)

I'm not sure why most of the people that represent the right here seem to hint at the idea that Zimmerman was well within his rights and that Trayvon Martin was a stereotype up to no good when what is really at issue is why, when the lead investigator in the case wanted to charge Zimmerman with Manslaughter, the states attorney overruled him and why, in spite of Zimmerman being told NOT to pursue, which is also in line with Neighborhood Watch training and policy as was NOT to carry a firearm, it sure appears as if he went against the rules and there seemed to be no accounting or concern about that with regard to the case, UNTIL it was pointed out and speculation for the reasons for doing so went rampant as anyone aware of the underlying current of racial stereotyping on all sides might expect.

On one side there are those who mistrust all blacks because of the acts of some blacks and on the other side there are those who feel stereotyped and profiled by the former and so they stereotyped and profile back.

The problem and the whole issue was a failure to investigate further and an overriding of the lead investigator's reasons for wanting Zimmerman charged. One might imagine were it it a white 17 year old killed by Zimmerman, whether the same would have occurred with regard to investigating it further or whether the same lack of investigation would have passed if it were Martin who shot Zimmerman and claimed "self defense" under the same law. That seems to be more of a test of where anything racial about the incident might lie, otherwise if both were white, one might still ask why there was no further investigation and an overruling of the lead investigators feeling to charge the survivor with killing their victim based on something other than "self-defense".
 
Oh come on Cit. He was called a White Hispanic by the lefty msm two minutes after this was reported.

Well, not quite. They were calling him straight up white two minutes into it. Only when the picture of him came out a few hours later did they start calling him "white hispanic".
 
gigi,

I do think that you are missing something. I think that your point is really about "playing politics" from a criminal incident that has racial overtones.

The Willie Horton advertisement used by George H.W. Bush during his campaign against Michael Dukakis is an example of "playing" that sort of racial politics. It was unmistakably about "black" crime. The implied victims were "white" IMHO.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Io9KMSSEZ0Y

Righties make plenty of false accusations. I think that you know that. Not absolving lefties. Just pointing out that there is "blood on rightie hands" too. I get a little tired of "righties" playing the victim and claiming to be martyred.

Righties play politics with race as well. It goes both ways. And God looks down equally on both sides and calls on both sides to see their own sins.

I don't think it's so mysterious at all.

Can you bring me up to speed on a story about a crime committed by someone of one race against someone of another that the righties used in the way the left is using Trayvon's shooting to call people racist? Maybe I'm just missing something.
 
Back
Top