New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

DOMA down

Ok. I guess I am blinded by the sheer brilliance of inaction.

Inaction where appropriate, is action. (you can quote me on that one!) But....my post did go directly to the point that all too often, GOPs AND Dems are driven to "action" in order to feather their own political nests, when "inaction" may be the more statesmanlike approach.

A good and perhaps HUGE example of that, might be GHWB's and Clinton's relative INaction as to Iraq, as opposed to Li'l George's "action".
 
This multplies the economic advantage the "marriage equality" states already had over the homophobic states. Now there's even MORE reason for those gay people of especial "value", to locate in these states. EVERY Fortune 500 company here in WA, is 100% onboard with full equality, and has been for some time now. These are companies that cater to a national market, not a local one. So clearly, they see this issue as not just one of attracting the best talent, but one of pleasing their overall markets.

Those states that rammed through their homophobic laws and constitutional amendents, are 6 feet deeper in the latrine, than they were yesterday!

All good points related to those states who acted fairly without homophobic fear. You have some of the biggest Fortune 500 companies so they were wise to match the quality of the state on this issue.

I am wondering what the lawsuits are going to look like now that they can't use DOMA as a crutch or flag post to their fears. Kind of sucks the air out of all past lawsuits against states that voted to recognize gay marriage. Well done all the way around. Jeez if this country keeps this it may actually end up with equal rights.
 
Big defeat for Bill Clinton.

Bill Clinton has always been regretful of signing that Congressional law and well he should be. The bottom line is even he acknowledges he should not have and he should have fought Congress on it.

My personal view is at that time, Clinton believed the description. He is not alone. Many believed it. Today the population has a different understanding of marriage.
 
Bill Clinton has always been regretful of signing that Congressional law and well he should be. The bottom line is even he acknowledges he should not have and he should have fought Congress on it.

My personal view is at that time, Clinton believed the description. He is not alone. Many believed it. Today the population has a different understanding of marriage.

Reference to Clinton in the context of either DOMA or DADT, are sort of akin to the redkooks herein, who're now trying to shout that the Democrats are the real racists. Political time flies - even faster now, than ever. Clinton confronted an entirely different sociopolitic than the one we do today. There's little use in trying to judge HIM against our 2013 politic.
 
Inaction where appropriate, is action. (you can quote me on that one!) But....my post did go directly to the point that all too often, GOPs AND Dems are driven to "action" in order to feather their own political nests, when "inaction" may be the more statesmanlike approach.

A good and perhaps HUGE example of that, might be GHWB's and Clinton's relative INaction as to Iraq, as opposed to Li'l George's "action".

That's fine. I'm not necessarily arguing for "action". I simply question ascribing "accomplishment" to doing nothing. From my perspective, we'd all be better off if our politicians did less. :)
 
That's fine. I'm not necessarily arguing for "action". I simply question ascribing "accomplishment" to doing nothing. From my perspective, we'd all be better off if our politicians did less. :)

In this particular instance, I imagine "accomplishment" turns on whether or not you think the shitcanning of DOMA is a good thing. If you believe as I do, that it's a good thing and that Obama furthered that good thing, then you might see it as an obvious "accomplishment". But, if you're neutral-to-negative on the demise of DOMA, you might be more inclined to seeing it as a "thing", but not necessarily an "accomplishment".

The word "accomplishment" implies positivity. We "accomplish" success. We don't "accomplish" failure.
 
Reference to Clinton in the context of either DOMA or DADT, are sort of akin to the redkooks herein, who're now trying to shout that the Democrats are the real racists. Political time flies - even faster now, than ever. Clinton confronted an entirely different sociopolitic than the one we do today. There's little use in trying to judge HIM against our 2013 politic.

To bear that out here is some Gallup history. Look at 1996:

Gallup poll finds 68 percent opposition to recognizing same-sex marriage (March 15-17)…. U.S. Supreme Court strikes down anti-gay ballot measure in Colorado (May 20)…. Federal Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) signed into law (Sept. 21); more than 30 states pass similar laws by end of decade.

http://photo.pds.org:5012/cqresearcher/document.php?id=cqresrre2013031504#.UcsoRr7D_IU

It was very different.
 
To bear that out here is some Gallup history. Look at 1996:

Gallup poll finds 68 percent opposition to recognizing same-sex marriage (March 15-17)…. U.S. Supreme Court strikes down anti-gay ballot measure in Colorado (May 20)…. Federal Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) signed into law (Sept. 21); more than 30 states pass similar laws by end of decade.

http://photo.pds.org:5012/cqresearcher/document.php?id=cqresrre2013031504#.UcsoRr7D_IU

It was very different.

Progress was slower at first but man-o-man, once that ball started rolling down hill, there was no stopping it.
 
In this particular instance, I imagine "accomplishment" turns on whether or not you think the shitcanning of DOMA is a good thing. If you believe as I do, that it's a good thing and that Obama furthered that good thing, then you might see it as an obvious "accomplishment". But, if you're neutral-to-negative on the demise of DOMA, you might be more inclined to seeing it as a "thing", but not necessarily an "accomplishment".

The word "accomplishment" implies positivity. We "accomplish" success. We don't "accomplish" failure.

I think George W Bush accomplished some failure. :)

Accomplishing would infer both agency and activism, rather than inaction and deference to a different, distinct branch of government. In any case, I'm not a proponent of DOMA, so it's relative worth to me is a non-factor. I prefer that the state be neutral toward adult private consensual relationships and should neither sanction nor forbid them.

With which other Judicial actions do you credit the Executive Branch? ;)
 
Ok. I guess I am blinded by the sheer brilliance of inaction.

That is Obie's Modus Operandi.....do nothing, say nothing, don't get involved.....this way you get the minimum amount of blame when something goes wrong. So far it has worked for him.
 
That is Obie's Modus Operandi.....do nothing, say nothing, don't get involved.....this way you get the minimum amount of blame when something goes wrong. So far it has worked for him.

Apparently doing nothing is a "gutsy call". :)
 
Bill Clinton has always been regretful of signing that Congressional law and well he should be. The bottom line is even he acknowledges he should not have and he should have fought Congress on it.

My personal view is at that time, Clinton believed the description. He is not alone. Many believed it. Today the population has a different understanding of marriage.

I'm about as big a fan of Clinton as you'll find in this forum, but I'm not that forgiving of him on this issue. I think Clinton saw it as a chance to triangulate his way to some centrist approval (at a time when gay marriage was still extremely unpopular among the centrists), and so he sided with the bigots. The only defense I can offer is that it probably didn't matter -- the votes were probably there for a veto override even if he's spent political capital to try to stop it. Besides, DOMA was functionally meaningless in the Clinton years -- there wasn't any state-sanctioned gay marriage until Massachusetts, after Clinton left, and so nobody lost any rights due to DOMA, in the Clinton years, given the way DOMA works. So, he could see it as a way to win some easy political points for a functionally-meaningless gesture.
 
I think George W Bush accomplished some failure. :)

Accomplishing would infer both agency and activism, rather than inaction and deference to a different, distinct branch of government. In any case, I'm not a proponent of DOMA, so it's relative worth to me is a non-factor. I prefer that the state be neutral toward adult private consensual relationships and should neither sanction nor forbid them.

With which other Judicial actions do you credit the Executive Branch? ;)

I disagree and just to make sure, I double-checked the definition of "accomplish". "Accomplish" goes straight to achieving a goal - finishing what one set out to do. That implies positivity, since presumably, no one sets out to fail. If you believe that Li'l George's goal was bad, even as he met it, it's still his accomplishment since it was his goal.

Again, we don't "accomplish" failure. We either accomplish success or we fail to accomplish success.
 
I disagree and just to make sure, I double-checked the definition of "accomplish". "Accomplish" goes straight to achieving a goal - finishing what one set out to do. That implies positivity, since presumably, no one sets out to fail. If you believe that Li'l George's goal was bad, even as he met it, it's still his accomplishment since it was his goal.

Again, we don't "accomplish" failure. We either accomplish success or we fail to accomplish success.

So if someone else achieves something that I prefer, I accomplished it - right?
 
So if someone else achieves something that I prefer, I accomplished it - right?

Good question! Let's say that a candidate you prefer, accomplishes her goal of being elected. Should you claim this as your own personal accomplishment? Maybe yes. Maybe no. What if you never lifted a finger to help her in her campaign, didn't contribute a dime to her campaign, and didn't even make it to the polls on election day, is her accomplishment your personal accomplishment? Probably not, right?

On the other hand, what if in spite of your non-participation, you're convinced that her election is good for our nation? In that case, it might be reasonable for you speak of her accomplishment as a "collective American" accomplishment. In that case presumably, it was the goal of the majority of Americans to see her elected and the majority's goal was accomplished.
 
Yes, Clinton signed the defense of marriage act.. and some 340+ congressmen and 80+ Senators supported it.

Were they all bigots and homophobes?

Was Obama a mere year and some ago?
 
Yes, Clinton signed the defense of marriage act.. and some 340+ congressmen and 80+ Senators supported it.

Were they all bigots and homophobes?

Was Obama a mere year and some ago?

I suspect the majority weren't bigots and homophobes. They were just cynical politicians willing to pretend to be bigots and homophobes for political advantage, back when that form of bigotry and homophobia was still popular with the majority of voters.
 
Good question! Let's say that a candidate you prefer, accomplishes her goal of being elected. Should you claim this as your own personal accomplishment? Maybe yes. Maybe no. What if you never lifted a finger to help her in her campaign, didn't contribute a dime to her campaign, and didn't even make it to the polls on election day, is her accomplishment your personal accomplishment? Probably not, right?

On the other hand, what if in spite of your non-participation, you're convinced that her election is good for our nation? In that case, it might be reasonable for you speak of her accomplishment as a "collective American" accomplishment. In that case presumably, it was the goal of the majority of Americans to see her elected and the majority's goal was accomplished.

Ok. So Obama gets one three hundred and sixty millionths of the credit.
1/360,000,000? :)
 
Back
Top