New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

DOMA down

My what a difference 20 years makes! I seriously doubt that any sentient saw this was one as going any other way. And, I'm not hearing anyone of the least note, complaining about it.

As an aside...this is just another of Pres. Obama's historic accomplishments for which he'll receive little credit. That's the price a statesman pays.
 
Takes a handful of them to get down to terms wingers understand.
 
My what a difference 20 years makes! I seriously doubt that any sentient saw this was one as going any other way. And, I'm not hearing anyone of the least note, complaining about it.

As an aside...this is just another of Pres. Obama's historic accomplishments for which he'll receive little credit. That's the price a statesman pays.

yes, Barack Obama ran for president in 2008 endorsing the repeal of DOMA and in 2/2011 restated his belief that DOMA was unconstitutional and the DOJ would no longer defend it.

House republicans then scrambled to waste taxpayer $$ defending it.
 


I am glad that they did this on a tax case. Because it will leave very little wiggle room for the IRS to not recognize joint returns which has become a MAJOR problem recently. It will be interesting to see if they actually address this issue and officially say it is ok for same sex couples to file married joint. I actually had to advise some clients last year to keep a close eye on this. They got a big refund they would not have gotten if they had filed jointly for federal purposes.
 
yes, Barack Obama ran for president in 2008 endorsing the repeal of DOMA and in 2/2011 restated his belief that DOMA was unconstitutional and the DOJ would no longer defend it.

House republicans then scrambled to waste taxpayer $$ defending it.

I'm particularly impressed with the WAY he made it go down, as opposed to the fact of it's going down. And, I'm not sure if any other Democrat could have pulled it off the way he did. He COULD have manned the political ramparts around this one, brought the question to an obvious political head, and claimed credit for a wonderous victory over the Fox/GOP, for the Democrats and especially him.
Instead...he remained patient to the extent that the issue essentially took care of itself. Some were wont to call him "spineless" for not taking an overt, axe-handle-on-the-schoolhouse-steps, position against DOMA. Instead...he simply declined defending it and just let it go away, which was to the benefit of all - our nation AND those who were previously impacted by DOMA.

Obama did what was right, at the "cost" of his not being hailed for it.
 
The BIGGEST obstacle imo to gay marriage equality was DOMA in terms of each state passing these gay marriage laws but the Federal Government stuck with the same tax system forced by DOMA. It did not allow gay marriage partners to claim rightful Federal tax credits aka equality etc. I have always felt that until the Federal government either changed the tax laws to equalize this unfair practice or tossed out DOMA to achieve fairness it was far from fair. Logic dictated they would not toss out tax codes but this tossing of DOMA over the 5th Amendment is even better for gay couples.

This was a much more important decision than many know.
 
I'm particularly impressed with the WAY he made it go down, as opposed to the fact of it's going down. And, I'm not sure if any other Democrat could have pulled it off the way he did. He COULD have manned the political ramparts around this one, brought the question to an obvious political head, and claimed credit for a wonderous victory over the Fox/GOP, for the Democrats and especially him.
Instead...he remained patient to the extent that the issue essentially took care of itself. Some were wont to call him "spineless" for not taking an overt, axe-handle-on-the-schoolhouse-steps, position against DOMA. Instead...he simply declined defending it and just let it go away, which was to the benefit of all - our nation AND those who were previously impacted by DOMA.

Obama did what was right, at the "cost" of his not being hailed for it.

One note - you and Julie are hailing the crap out of him...for doing "nothing", BTW. Whatever stirs the KoolAid, I guess. :)
 
One note - you and Julie are hailing the crap out of him...for doing "nothing", BTW. Whatever stirs the KoolAid, I guess. :)

Don't blame Julie on this one. I'M hailing him for "doing nothing", which resulted in the finest outcome for all concerned. If "doing nothing" was the right thing to do, he SHOULD be hailed for it, as compared with all those who might've been driven to do "something", even as it might not have been the best thing to do.
 
The BIGGEST obstacle imo to gay marriage equality was DOMA in terms of each state passing these gay marriage laws but the Federal Government stuck with the same tax system forced by DOMA. It did not allow gay marriage partners to claim rightful Federal tax credits aka equality etc. I have always felt that until the Federal government either changed the tax laws to equalize this unfair practice or tossed out DOMA to achieve fairness it was far from fair. Logic dictated they would not toss out tax codes but this tossing of DOMA over the 5th Amendment is even better for gay couples.

This was a much more important decision than many know.

This multplies the economic advantage the "marriage equality" states already had over the homophobic states. Now there's even MORE reason for those gay people of especial "value", to locate in these states. EVERY Fortune 500 company here in WA, is 100% onboard with full equality, and has been for some time now. These are companies that cater to a national market, not a local one. So clearly, they see this issue as not just one of attracting the best talent, but one of pleasing their overall markets.

Those states that rammed through their homophobic laws and constitutional amendents, are 6 feet deeper in the latrine, than they were yesterday!
 
Don't blame Julie on this one. I'M hailing him for "doing nothing", which resulted in the finest outcome for all concerned. If "doing nothing" was the right thing to do, he SHOULD be hailed for it, as compared with all those who might've been driven to do "something", even as it might not have been the best thing to do.

Ok. I guess I am blinded by the sheer brilliance of inaction.
 
Back
Top