New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Enemy combatant: the exception that eats the Constitution?

ark - you're conflating/confusing 2 separate news stories.

tsarnarev was not 'mirandaized" under an exception clause for "public safety". they wanted to interrogate him immediately and see if other explosive devices had been set to go off.

mccain - in a separate news thread - had been advocating charging tsarnarev as an "enemy combatant". which would be the correct charge if it can be established that these boys had terrorist training at al qaeda. that's ALSO a reason Miranda wouldn't apply - but it's not the reason be advanced by the FBI and the Massachussetts state police (a wholly owned subsidiary of the state of Massachussets, the bluest of the blue states).

please keep your rumor and innuendo straight, lol

Terrorist training at Al Qaeda? Is there an Al Qaeda Central somewhere, where all the world's terrorists are trained? Sort of an Al Qaeda University for Suicide Bombers?

Tamerlan Tsarnaev appears to have been strongly influenced by CHECHEN terrorism. There is no known link between Al Qaeda terrorists and Chechen terrorists. Until this last incident, virtually all Chechen terrorism has been directed at Russia. For what SHOULD be obvious historical reasons.
 
Terrorist training at Al Qaeda? Is there an Al Qaeda Central somewhere, where all the world's terrorists are trained? Sort of an Al Qaeda University for Suicide Bombers?

Tamerlan Tsarnaev appears to have been strongly influenced by CHECHEN terrorism. There is no known link between Al Qaeda terrorists and Chechen terrorists. Until this last incident, virtually all Chechen terrorism has been directed at Russia. For what SHOULD be obvious historical reasons.

al Qaeda on the brain. Anything Muslim is de facto al Qaeda in the neo world order.

Nevermind this:
http://www.state.gov/j/ct/rls/other/des/123085.htm

or this:
http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/terror/R42536.pdf
http://archive.adl.org/learn/ext_us/militia_m.asp?xpicked=4
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_terrorism_in_the_United_States
 
I'll answer your question when you answer mine.


The ACLU seems to think you might be wrong on this:



The CIA and the military are carrying out an illegal “targeted killing” program in which people far from any battlefield are determined to be enemies of the state and killed without charge or trial.

The executive branch has, in effect, claimed the unchecked authority to put the names of citizens and others on “kill lists” on the basis of a secret determination, based on secret evidence, that a person meets a secret definition of the enemy. The targeted killing program operates with virtually no oversight outside the executive branch, and essential details about the program remain secret, including what criteria are used to put people on CIA and military kill lists or how much evidence is required.

Outside of armed conflict zones, the use of lethal force is strictly limited by international law and, when it comes to U.S. citizens, the Constitution. Specifically, lethal force can be used only as a last resort against an imminent threat to life. Even in the context of an armed conflict against an armed group, the government may use lethal force only against individuals who are directly participating in hostilities against the U. S. Regardless of the context, whenever the government uses lethal force, it must take all possible steps to avoid harming civilian bystanders. These are not the standards that the executive branch is using.

The U.S. continues to carry out illegal targeted killings in Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, and elsewhere. The government must be held to account when it carries out such killings in violation of the Constitution and international law.



http://www.aclu.org/blog/tag/drones



Feel free to explain it to them. Tell them they are wrong, there is no valid view other than yours, and that the matter is settled. I'm sure they'll take it under advisement.

I don't think the ACLU has much expertise in the arena of international law. I can find you no fewer than at least a dozen professors of international law who would testify that our drone program is legal under current international law:

On April 6, The New York Times also reported that President Obama had authorized the killing of al-Awlaki.[32] The CIA and the U.S. military both maintain lists of terrorists linked to al-Qaeda and its affiliates who are approved for capture or killing.[32] Because he is a U.S. citizen, his inclusion on those lists was approved by the National Security Council.[32] U.S. officials said it is extremely rare, if not unprecedented, for an American to be approved for targeted killing.[32] The New York Times reported that international law allows the use of lethal force against people who pose an imminent threat to a country, and U.S. officials said that was the standard used in adding names to the target list.[32] In addition, Congress approved the use of military force against al-Qaeda after 9/11.[32] People on the target list are considered military enemies of the U.S., and therefore not subject to a ban on political assassinations approved by former President Gerald Ford.[201

I USUALLY agree with the ACLU. This is one instance where I do not agree with them.

Having said all that, I DO think there should be more Congressional oversight of the drone program. That has been my position for several years. Then you would not be able to mount the complaint that the executive branch is doing all this on its own.
 
Terrorist training at Al Qaeda? Is there an Al Qaeda Central somewhere, where all the world's terrorists are trained? Sort of an Al Qaeda University for Suicide Bombers?

Tamerlan Tsarnaev appears to have been strongly influenced by CHECHEN terrorism. There is no known link between Al Qaeda terrorists and Chechen terrorists. Until this last incident, virtually all Chechen terrorism has been directed at Russia. For what SHOULD be obvious historical reasons.

leroy - yeah, actually there ARE well established al qaeda training camps. people who read actual newspapers are more likely to be aware of this, i suppose. here are some links for you . . .

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afghan_training_camp

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derunta_training_camp

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Qaeda

www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/para/al-qaida-camps.htm


online.wsj.com/.../SB10001424052748704355304576215762431072584.html
 
I don't think the ACLU has much expertise in the arena of international law. I can find you no fewer than at least a dozen professors of international law who would testify that our drone program is legal under current international law:

On April 6, The New York Times also reported that President Obama had authorized the killing of al-Awlaki.[32] The CIA and the U.S. military both maintain lists of terrorists linked to al-Qaeda and its affiliates who are approved for capture or killing.[32] Because he is a U.S. citizen, his inclusion on those lists was approved by the National Security Council.[32] U.S. officials said it is extremely rare, if not unprecedented, for an American to be approved for targeted killing.[32] The New York Times reported that international law allows the use of lethal force against people who pose an imminent threat to a country, and U.S. officials said that was the standard used in adding names to the target list.[32] In addition, Congress approved the use of military force against al-Qaeda after 9/11.[32] People on the target list are considered military enemies of the U.S., and therefore not subject to a ban on political assassinations approved by former President Gerald Ford.[201

I USUALLY agree with the ACLU. This is one instance where I do not agree with them.

Having said all that, I DO think there should be more Congressional oversight of the drone program. That has been my position for several years. Then you would not be able to mount the complaint that the executive branch is doing all this on its own.




I believe this is an issue where there are no easy answers, despite your insistence that there are. I don't think we should be unduly comfortable with the suspension of due process whenever the government deems it expedient and therefor desirable. Dictatorships of course do this with ease, we should be a bit more wary. There seems to be little in the way of checks and balances to prevent this from being arbitrary. To whit, who decides? Who is consulted? Is it subject to review?

If you're going to continue with there is but one valid point of view and it's yours, then I guess you've drawn your line in the sand and further discussion would be pointless.
 
leroy - yeah, actually there ARE well established al qaeda training camps. people who read actual newspapers are more likely to be aware of this, i suppose. here are some links for you . . .

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afghan_training_camp

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derunta_training_camp

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Qaeda

www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/para/al-qaida-camps.htm


online.wsj.com/.../SB10001424052748704355304576215762431072584.html

I am WELL AWARE that there are Al Qaeda terrorist training camps, you very foolish person. But you said trained AT Al Qaeda, as if there was ONE centrally-located place where ALL the terrorist training was done. If that were the case, of course, we would have LONG AGO droned the place into non-existence.

Learn to write more carefully if you don't want to be made fun of.
 
8th Amendment violation. Just like questioning him without reading him his rights is a 5th Amendment violation. Either the Constitution means something, or it doesn't.



Creating a cabinet-level Department of Homeland Security is an idea introduced by Sen. Joseph Lieberman, who was at the time a Democrat. Bush opposed it at first, and changed his mind because of Congressional pressure. Not that this excuses Bush's signing of it by any means.

The Department of Homeland Security was created by a bill introduced in the House by Dick Armey. It was H.R. 5005 and was passed in mid-2002 and then went to the senate....
 
I am WELL AWARE that there are Al Qaeda terrorist training camps, you very foolish person. But you said trained AT Al Qaeda, as if there was ONE centrally-located place where ALL the terrorist training was done. If that were the case, of course, we would have LONG AGO droned the place into non-existence.

Learn to write more carefully if you don't want to be made fun of.

Well, Al Quaeda means "the base" in Arabic and it originally was a specific location in Afghanistan. I think your linguistic quibble is wrong -- if a computer programmer goes to the right conglomerate he can say he was "trained at IBM" even though IBM has offices in cities all over the world.
 
Well, Al Quaeda means "the base" in Arabic and it originally was a specific location in Afghanistan. I think your linguistic quibble is wrong -- if a computer programmer goes to the right conglomerate he can say he was "trained at IBM" even though IBM has offices in cities all over the world.

I am not sure there was EVER a time when Al Qaeda had only ONE terrorist training camp. I think your computer programmer would be more likely to say he was trained BY IBM.
 
I am not sure there was EVER a time when Al Qaeda had only ONE terrorist training camp. I think your computer programmer would be more likely to say he was trained BY IBM.

Yes, but he would'nt be wrong to say he was trained at IBM. Or to reference his training period, "You know, when I was at IBM..."

"You know, when I was at Al Qaeda..."

Same difference, your referring to a larger organization, not a specific location. It's not really a substantive discussion.
 
been in IT since 1975 and never heard anyone describe their training in the context you suggest....
 
There is an exception to the Miranda rule and it has been in place since 1980. You are permitted to ask question related to imminent dangers to either public safety or the safety of arresting officers. Asking the bomber if there are any more bombs planted or if he has an accomplice who may be a threat is permitted.....if the suspect answers "Yeah, there's another bomb at 5th and Main in the trash can" then that can be used against them as an incriminating utterance.
 
The Department of Homeland Security was created by a bill introduced in the House by Dick Armey. It was H.R. 5005 and was passed in mid-2002 and then went to the senate....

And his bill was introduced to replace S. 2452 introduced by Lieberman with a Republican version.
 
Back
Top