New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Explaining Trump

What percentage of African Americans have been voting for Trump, exactly? In South Carolina, despite a large African American population, it was approximately 0%:

http://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2016-election/primaries/SC

In Virginia, it also rounded down to zero:

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/03/01/us/elections/virginia-republican-poll.html

In what state, SPECIFICALLY, did you see a large African American turnout to support Trump? Or is this just one of those claims you make without any supporting data?

Hello! These are PRIMARIES! Lets see what happens in the general. And again with the "percentages." What were the turnout numbers of African Americans voting for Trump vs. Hillary - I bet there weren't a lot more voters coming out for Hillary, so the percentage looks bigger.
 
RACE RELATIONS is where this diatribe should be.

Nothing current about it, just another Race Baiting post in wrong forum......
Feel free to whine to the moderators to move the thread if it frightens you. But since I'm specifically referring to a current event -- Trump's strength with evangelicals in last night's voting-- this seemed the right place for it.
 
Well, I'm not. I'm looking for better theories. Do you have one? Or are you just content to wallow in your usual mire of personal insults?

Well, I'm not the one making definite claims of racism I can't prove.

I'm not the one thinking I can figure out something that crosses historic, cultural, societal, and political atmospheres by looking at a data chart.

People who do that? Yes, I'd call them intellectually lazy, every day of the week.
 
Feel free to whine to the moderators to move the thread if it frightens you. But since I'm specifically referring to a current event -- Trump's strength with evangelicals in last night's voting-- this seemed the right place for it.

Why don't you just put your race baiting post in RACE RELATIONS. If you think your wisdom of racism is so important, go whine elsewhere, nothing you post frightens me.
 
Did you have an explanation for Trump's dominance that doesn't have to do with racism? That was the point of my post. I was a johnny-come-lately to the idea that race has overwhelming explanatory power in understanding the modern GOP. I only embraced that idea because it did such a good job of explaining things that were otherwise mysterious to me. If you have some better idea of why Republicans would say no to so many more qualified candidates (and at least a couple smarter, less troubling unqualified anti-establishment candidates), to embrace Trump, I'd love to hear it.


sure. a desire to overturn a broken political body.

moreso than some trite...'they hates them some black folk...'

or perhaps a desire for someone other that some preening asswipe with no better offering than 'i've been around', or am a part of the party that has achieved little over these many years.. (which covers much of the rest)..

:)
 
Well, I'm not the one making definite claims of racism I can't prove.

Agreed. You're the one whimpering because someone else has offered a theory that you don't know how to address. If you have a better theory, feel free to offer it. If the best available theory remains the one I offered, then there's no point whimpering about it just because it hurts your feelings.
 
Agreed. You're the one whimpering because someone else has offered a theory that you don't know how to address. If you have a better theory, feel free to offer it. If the best available theory remains the one I offered, then there's no point whimpering about it just because it hurts your feelings.

Ha! Whimper! You're so desperate, it makes me grin.

If you ever want to dig below the "DUH.. IF U VOTE 4 TRUMP UR RACIST" line, get back to me.

;)
 
sure. a desire to overturn a broken political body.

Why Trump, then? As a reminder, Carson is also running and has exactly as much political experience as Trump and is arguably even more of an outsider. And, unlike Trump, Carson is dignified, articulate, self-made, professionally accomplished, and has never gone bankrupt. What drew those looking for an outsider to Trump, while Carson's support looks like a rounding error?

One test of a good theory is its explanatory power. My theory explains the different fates of Trump and Carson pretty well. Another test of a good theory is its predictive power. Based on my theory about the importance of race to the modern GOP, I openly predicted that Carson would vanish, politically, way back during that brief period when the media was talking him up. I just figured that in the whole history of the modern GOP, no black Republican had ever won a single state when facing a contested election against a white person, in all the thousands of presidential, gubernatorial, and senatorial primaries and general elections, and I wasn't expecting it to change this cycle. My theory led me to the correct prediction, the same way it had when Cain was being talked up last time. That doesn't mean it's a correct theory. But presumably you can see my attachment to it when it proves both accurate in predicting the future and useful in explaining events. If you have a better theory, though, I'm open to it.
 
. My theory led me to the correct prediction, the same way it had when Cain was being talked up last time. That doesn't mean it's a correct theory.

Funny, because you sure say it's correct in most posts you make.

You pretty much just corrected yourself, which I think is a good thing.
 
Why Trump, then? As a reminder, Carson is also running and has exactly as much political experience as Trump and is arguably even more of an outsider. And, unlike Trump, Carson is dignified, articulate, self-made, professionally accomplished, and has never gone bankrupt. What drew those looking for an outsider to Trump, while Carson's support looks like a rounding error?

One test of a good theory is its explanatory power. My theory explains the different fates of Trump and Carson pretty well. Another test of a good theory is its predictive power. Based on my theory about the importance of race to the modern GOP, I openly predicted that Carson would vanish, politically, way back during that brief period when the media was talking him up. I just figured that in the whole history of the modern GOP, no black Republican had ever won a single state when facing a contested election against a white person, in all the thousands of presidential, gubernatorial, and senatorial primaries and general elections, and I wasn't expecting it to change this cycle. My theory led me to the correct prediction, the same way it had when Cain was being talked up last time. That doesn't mean it's a correct theory. But presumably you can see my attachment to it when it proves both accurate in predicting the future and useful in explaining events. If you have a better theory, though, I'm open to it.


sure, are there no examples of dissatisfied voters seeking to oust entrenched politicos? off the cuff, i think we've seen it fairly regularly in varied elections..

i think this a case of a plurality of voters seeking to shake out the system... their choice is perhaps a might unsettling. but, where faced with a rubio or cruz, there is perhaps a sense of more of the same...
 
Funny, because you sure say it's correct in most posts you make.

You pretty much just corrected yourself, which I think is a good thing.
You aren't following. Try harder. I'm admitting I haven't proven the theory. Like any theory, it might be wrong. Maybe some later evidence will come along and show us it's incorrect. Maybe someone will offer up a competing theory that better explains the available evidence. But, for now, it does a decent job matching up with the observable evidence, and I've seen nothing better. Have you?
 
I didn't claim that anyone who votes for Trump is racist. Read again. Try harder.

Not in a direct quote, but by every other measure? Absolutely.

You're saying Trumps success is due largely to "racism" (whatever that means today). So, if someone DOES endorse Trump, they'd be connected with said "racism" without you having to say it directly.

It's overall a rookie move. However, at least own up to it.
 
sure, are there no examples of dissatisfied voters seeking to oust entrenched politicos? off the cuff, i think we've seen it fairly regularly in varied elections..

i think this a case of a plurality of voters seeking to shake out the system... their choice is perhaps a might unsettling. but, where faced with a rubio or cruz, there is perhaps a sense of more of the same...
Did you miss the post that you were purportedly responding to? Go back and reread it. You didn't even try to address the question of why they went with Trump instead of other anti-establishment alternatives (including Trump and Fiorina, in this cycle, Cain in the last cycle, etc.)
 
You aren't following. Try harder. I'm admitting I haven't proven the theory. Like any theory, it might be wrong. Maybe some later evidence will come along and show us it's incorrect. Maybe someone will offer up a competing theory that better explains the available evidence. But, for now, it does a decent job matching up with the observable evidence, and I've seen nothing better. Have you?

Again, you're trying to solve something that crosses multiple factors of society onto simple data charts. That doesn't work, and is often attacked by those like you when talking race, when it suits your needs.

Try harder. Get your face out of data sheets and view the world. Data sheets can be useful, but you're all in on them defining reality. I could draw up a really interesting reality based on just data sheets.
 
Not in a direct quote, but by every other measure? Absolutely.

Incorrect. My recommendation for you would be to try some adult education classes. A decent teacher could quickly get your reading the material that's actually in front of you, rather than tangentially related material that only exists in your imagination. Obviously, a large portion of support for a candidate can be driven by racism without that meaning all those who support him are racists.
 
Back
Top