Arkady
President
I used to argue with fellow progressives regarding the emphasis they put on race. For example, I'd contradict them when they said Republican hatred of Obama was due largely to race. Over time, though, I came to believe they'd been closer to the mark than I'd been -- that race really was an overriding consideration in explaining the modern GOP. The theory has such explanatory power -- helping to clarify things for me that had previously been mysterious. Another example of that is Trump's surprising strength with evangelical voters.
On paper, Trump would seem to be just about the least suitable option for evangelical Christians -- neck and neck with Sanders (who, despite values that would be at home in the Gospels, is a Jew). Even setting aside the parts of the Bible that most evangelical Christians long ago dispensed with (the turn-the-other-cheek stuff, the stuff about the meek inheriting the earth, and the instruction for the rich to give all their wealth to charity), Trump runs afoul of most of the stuff the evangelicals were still pretending to cherish. Trump isn't a regular church goer. I'm not sure anyone believes his recent claim of being pro-life, given his past of supporting even late-term abortion. He has bragged about fornication on Howard Stern's smutty show. He's twice divorced and had very public affairs with married women. He also swears like a sailor, calls people vulgar names, and doesn't even make a pretense of personal modesty. Before becoming known primarily as a reality TV star, his name recognition rested on getting rich on gambling operations -- something that would have made prior generations of evangelicals wince, given the central anti-gambling stances of the Moral Majority. He even owns strip clubs and branded alcohols. And that's not even to get into his famously strained relationship with the truth.
Yet, despite being a completely unrepentant libertine, a narcissist, a vulgarian, a compulsive liar, and vice trafficker, he's taken an evangelical plurality in a number of states and has been embraced by evangelical leaders like Falwell and Robertson. Why? Why did so many "good Christians," who clutched their pearls and reached for the smelling salts when Clinton had an affair (or when he just failed to wear a jacket in the Oval Office) turn to embracing such an avatar of all they claimed to oppose?
If you buy the scholarship around the the origins of the religious right in the fight for racial segregation, there's a pretty simple explanation. In that view, the fixation on sexual matters, including abortion, wasn't really the motivating force behind the rise of politicized Christianity, and instead it was a reaction against the civil rights movement. Since Trump is the angriest and most outspoken in voicing white America's desire to return to an earlier era, he's going to be popular, since that will be heard as a promise to put "those people" back in their place. But, if you reject that scholarship, and think the evangelicals really do care about the things they claim to care about, how do we explain Trump's appeal with them?
When offered two Bible-spouting, church-going, clean-cut family men with policies indistinguishable from GW Bush's -- men without embarrassing sexual histories and past pro-choice positions-- why do so many go for Trump? Even if it were the desire for a non-politician, they have a deeply religious brain surgeon on offer, who is even more "outside the establishment" than Trump, and yet most seem to prefer the Satanic orange clown. Why? Is it just a generic authoritarian impulse, un-driven by racism and xenophobia?
Struggles with questions like that are what convinced me of the importance of race in understanding the modern GOP. It's simply the only way I've been able to make sense of what has been happening.
On paper, Trump would seem to be just about the least suitable option for evangelical Christians -- neck and neck with Sanders (who, despite values that would be at home in the Gospels, is a Jew). Even setting aside the parts of the Bible that most evangelical Christians long ago dispensed with (the turn-the-other-cheek stuff, the stuff about the meek inheriting the earth, and the instruction for the rich to give all their wealth to charity), Trump runs afoul of most of the stuff the evangelicals were still pretending to cherish. Trump isn't a regular church goer. I'm not sure anyone believes his recent claim of being pro-life, given his past of supporting even late-term abortion. He has bragged about fornication on Howard Stern's smutty show. He's twice divorced and had very public affairs with married women. He also swears like a sailor, calls people vulgar names, and doesn't even make a pretense of personal modesty. Before becoming known primarily as a reality TV star, his name recognition rested on getting rich on gambling operations -- something that would have made prior generations of evangelicals wince, given the central anti-gambling stances of the Moral Majority. He even owns strip clubs and branded alcohols. And that's not even to get into his famously strained relationship with the truth.
Yet, despite being a completely unrepentant libertine, a narcissist, a vulgarian, a compulsive liar, and vice trafficker, he's taken an evangelical plurality in a number of states and has been embraced by evangelical leaders like Falwell and Robertson. Why? Why did so many "good Christians," who clutched their pearls and reached for the smelling salts when Clinton had an affair (or when he just failed to wear a jacket in the Oval Office) turn to embracing such an avatar of all they claimed to oppose?
If you buy the scholarship around the the origins of the religious right in the fight for racial segregation, there's a pretty simple explanation. In that view, the fixation on sexual matters, including abortion, wasn't really the motivating force behind the rise of politicized Christianity, and instead it was a reaction against the civil rights movement. Since Trump is the angriest and most outspoken in voicing white America's desire to return to an earlier era, he's going to be popular, since that will be heard as a promise to put "those people" back in their place. But, if you reject that scholarship, and think the evangelicals really do care about the things they claim to care about, how do we explain Trump's appeal with them?
When offered two Bible-spouting, church-going, clean-cut family men with policies indistinguishable from GW Bush's -- men without embarrassing sexual histories and past pro-choice positions-- why do so many go for Trump? Even if it were the desire for a non-politician, they have a deeply religious brain surgeon on offer, who is even more "outside the establishment" than Trump, and yet most seem to prefer the Satanic orange clown. Why? Is it just a generic authoritarian impulse, un-driven by racism and xenophobia?
Struggles with questions like that are what convinced me of the importance of race in understanding the modern GOP. It's simply the only way I've been able to make sense of what has been happening.