New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Explaining Trump

Again, you're trying to solve something that crosses multiple factors of society onto simple data charts.

I'm looking at the available data and trying to understand them with the use of theories. If you have better theories or counterarguments to the ones I offer, I'd be interested. If, instead, you're instantly reduced to gibbering and personal insults, that will, for obvious reasons, make the theories look stronger to me.
 
Try to stay on topic little firefly.

The topic of this post, like most of your others over the past week, is your fear of Trump, coupled with your telegraphing your upcoming support for Hillary "Iraq War" Clinton. Please don't expect me to believe you don't realize how obvious that is...
 
I'm looking at the available data and trying to understand them with the use of theories. If you have better theories or counterarguments to the ones I offer, I'd be interested. If, instead, you're instantly reduced to gibbering and personal insults, that will, for obvious reasons, make the theories look stronger to me.

No you're not. You're trying to bend data to fit what you already believe.
 
Did you miss the post that you were purportedly responding to? Go back and reread it. You didn't even try to address the question of why they went with Trump instead of other anti-establishment alternatives (including Trump and Fiorina, in this cycle, Cain in the last cycle, etc.)


sure i did. did you miss it?
 
I used to argue with fellow progressives regarding the emphasis they put on race. For example, I'd contradict them when they said Republican hatred of Obama was due largely to race. Over time, though, I came to believe they'd been closer to the mark than I'd been -- that race really was an overriding consideration in explaining the modern GOP. The theory has such explanatory power -- helping to clarify things for me that had previously been mysterious. Another example of that is Trump's surprising strength with evangelical voters.

On paper, Trump would seem to be just about the least suitable option for evangelical Christians -- neck and neck with Sanders (who, despite values that would be at home in the Gospels, is a Jew). Even setting aside the parts of the Bible that most evangelical Christians long ago dispensed with (the turn-the-other-cheek stuff, the stuff about the meek inheriting the earth, and the instruction for the rich to give all their wealth to charity), Trump runs afoul of most of the stuff the evangelicals were still pretending to cherish. Trump isn't a regular church goer. I'm not sure anyone believes his recent claim of being pro-life, given his past of supporting even late-term abortion. He has bragged about fornication on Howard Stern's smutty show. He's twice divorced and had very public affairs with married women. He also swears like a sailor, calls people vulgar names, and doesn't even make a pretense of personal modesty. Before becoming known primarily as a reality TV star, his name recognition rested on getting rich on gambling operations -- something that would have made prior generations of evangelicals wince, given the central anti-gambling stances of the Moral Majority. He even owns strip clubs and branded alcohols. And that's not even to get into his famously strained relationship with the truth.

Yet, despite being a completely unrepentant libertine, a narcissist, a vulgarian, a compulsive liar, and vice trafficker, he's taken an evangelical plurality in a number of states and has been embraced by evangelical leaders like Falwell and Robertson. Why? Why did so many "good Christians," who clutched their pearls and reached for the smelling salts when Clinton had an affair (or when he just failed to wear a jacket in the Oval Office) turn to embracing such an avatar of all they claimed to oppose?

If you buy the scholarship around the the origins of the religious right in the fight for racial segregation, there's a pretty simple explanation. In that view, the fixation on sexual matters, including abortion, wasn't really the motivating force behind the rise of politicized Christianity, and instead it was a reaction against the civil rights movement. Since Trump is the angriest and most outspoken in voicing white America's desire to return to an earlier era, he's going to be popular, since that will be heard as a promise to put "those people" back in their place. But, if you reject that scholarship, and think the evangelicals really do care about the things they claim to care about, how do we explain Trump's appeal with them?

When offered two Bible-spouting, church-going, clean-cut family men with policies indistinguishable from GW Bush's -- men without embarrassing sexual histories and past pro-choice positions-- why do so many go for Trump? Even if it were the desire for a non-politician, they have a deeply religious brain surgeon on offer, who is even more "outside the establishment" than Trump, and yet most seem to prefer the Satanic orange clown. Why? Is it just a generic authoritarian impulse, un-driven by racism and xenophobia?

Struggles with questions like that are what convinced me of the importance of race in understanding the modern GOP. It's simply the only way I've been able to make sense of what has been happening.

Believe it... Trump is ahead because many Americans are sick and tired of the Washington insiders, the political elites, our self-proclaimed lords and masters. We're sick and tired of their corruption, greed, and downright disdain for ordinary people, the people they're supposed to SERVE, NOT to rule, living like kings and queens on the backs of those who struggle to feed their families.

We're simply disgusted with the status quo, and while Trump probably isn't any better, we're ready for the change Obama promised in 2008 - that in many ways turned out to be a change for the worse - and ready for the hope Obama dashed in the past 7 years.

You apparently can't see it from your ivory tower, and in your total devotion to all things democrat and liberal you don't even WANT to see it... but for far too many Americans life hasn't gotten any better under Obama... except, that is, if you happen to be an illegal alien or a radical Islamic terrorist-in-waiting.

THAT'S why Trump is ahead. It really IS that simple. Race has absolutely nothing to do with it.
 
Believe it... Trump is ahead because many Americans are sick and tired of the Washington insiders, the political elites, our self-proclaimed lords and masters. We're sick and tired of their corruption, greed, and downright disdain for ordinary people, the people they're supposed to SERVE, NOT to rule, living like kings and queens on the backs of those who struggle to feed their families.

We're simply disgusted with the status quo, and while Trump probably isn't any better, we're ready for the change Obama promised in 2008 - that in many ways turned out to be a change for the worse - and ready for the hope Obama dashed in the past 7 years.

You apparently can't see it from your ivory tower, and in your total devotion to all things democrat and liberal you don't even WANT to see it... but for far too many Americans life hasn't gotten any better under Obama... except, that is, if you happen to be an illegal alien or a radical Islamic terrorist-in-waiting.

THAT'S why Trump is ahead. It really IS that simple. Race has absolutely nothing to do with it.

I wish I could have liked this twice. But I'm not from Chicago.
 
Who do you think their base is, exactly? It can't be the tax-cutting, small-government crowd, since any of the other major candidates have taken stronger stances on that than Trump. Do you think it's mostly about nativism? What is it, exactly, that you think people are thinking about when they look at Cruz, Rubio, Carson, and Kasisch and decide that Trump's got something better on offer?

There is no "base" that is the problem. The RNC is simply the "other" the alternative to progressive democrat, big Gov't agenda. And, while Donald Trump is beating the other candidates, he is mostly getting about 1/3 of the vote, which means he appeals to only about 1/3 of the "base" whatever that base is. And, really, I don't think he is even getting that of the "base" as far as long time registered republicans because he is actually getting democrats and independents who are crossing party lines - or declaring for the first time.

What I think it shows is how the RNC how greatly flawed the RNC strategy has been. They haven't bothered to find out what the great swath of independents have wanted. Instead, they have been playing their own losing game of identity politics. They gave up blacks and minorities, and have pandered to the religious right. They have lumped fiscal conservatism with religious conservatism alienating a lot of fiscal conservatives who aren't social conservatives. What Trump has brought has been the antithesis of "identity politics".

In fact, he has no identity - and that is what is working. The Nativists can go for him because he talks tough on illegal immigration. But, other fiscal conservatives who don't want an expanded welfare state will also go for that because we know that importing uneducated, unskilled workers means - more low income children in our schools, more SNAP, more calls for expanded medicaid and social service spending.. which we don't want, as well as the resulting increase in democratic votes, which we don't want. Some may be willing to overlook his rudeness and crassness because they like the message for a wholly other reason. Independents may go for him because he isn't spouting about shutting down abortion - although he panders slightly with pro-life. Except that guess what, many independents personally identify as "pro-life" but not wanting to regulate abortion - so he is eliminating the whole faux 'war on women" meme which held back independents and his stance there appeals to them. For many independents, the thing that kept them from voting Republican was abortion and gay marriage. He has eliminated those issues as impediments - so he appealing in that way, too. People who are anti- big gov't may be willing to put that issue on the back-burner as long as "big gov't" isn't being used to expand social welfare. People who are hard core neo-cons can listen to him talk about waterboarding if it may get us info, but at the same time may be willing to overlook that he isn't going to face off with Russia.

He is in fact, the ultimate compromise, between the socially conservative right, and the pro-social welfare left. That pro-social welfare left, that has alienated many an independent and other fiscal conservatives, as they watch themselves pay more in taxes - for poorer performing schools, pay more in HI premiums, so someone else can get a subsidy, are facing paying higher taxes, so someone who didn't scrimp and save and sacrifice the way they did, can get help sending their kid to college, so that kids who come here illegally with their parents can get tuition breaks and subsidies. People are tired of having their heart strings tugged, and voting for someone who appears compassionate - only to be stuck with the bill.
 
Believe it... Trump is ahead because many Americans are sick and tired of the Washington insiders, the political elites, our self-proclaimed lords and masters.

That's a good talking point, but why Trump, instead of Carson, or Fiorina (or, back in the last cycle, Cain)? I have no doubt that anti-establishment sentiment is a big factor in the last few cycles (it helped get Obama elected in 2008). But it does nothing to explain why Trump took fire instead of the other anti-establishment options.
 
I look forward to it. But, in the meantime, I'm wondering which specific state's results you based your claim on. Or did you just pull it out of your ass?

Just speculating is all. You really can't take all that much from primaries, even in the open states where they could vote for him, the only people who turn out are the political activists, and they are still going to vote for the Democrat. Based off the reports of Democrat apathy, I'm thinking the turnout for Democrats in November will be low - especially if the economy continues to drift into recession. And that makes the cross over African American vote likely to be less skewed to the Democratic candidate than normal.
 
Just speculating is all. You really can't take all that much from primaries, even in the open states where they could vote for him, the only people who turn out are the political activists, and they are still going to vote for the Democrat.

I'll concede that point. Given all the primary rules and the super-low turnout, it's tough to say much of anything at this point. But my own guess is that Trump will get MUCH lower vote totals from blacks (as well as Hispanics and other major minority groups) than Clinton does in the general election (assuming those are the nominees).

Based off the reports of Democrat apathy, I'm thinking the turnout for Democrats in November will be low

Could be. That's one factor that makes Trump a preferable opponent, I'm sure, from a Democratic perspective. He's entertaining and offensive, which may keep Democratic turnout from being too low. Someone like Rubio could have lulled Democrats into midterm-like apathy. Trump will wake them up to a greater degree.
 
That's a good talking point, but why Trump, instead of Carson, or Fiorina (or, back in the last cycle, Cain)? I have no doubt that anti-establishment sentiment is a big factor in the last few cycles (it helped get Obama elected in 2008). But it does nothing to explain why Trump took fire instead of the other anti-establishment options.

I've talked to a lot of people about this, mostly because I'm not sure I understand it myself... Seems like many people are of the opinion that, while they like Carson, they don't feel he's tough enough to withstand the pressure the elites will apply should he win the election. Fiorina just doesn't have enough exposure, and Rubio and Cruz are part of "the establishment", which is exactly what people hate.
 
That's a good talking point, but why Trump, instead of Carson, or Fiorina (or, back in the last cycle, Cain)? I have no doubt that anti-establishment sentiment is a big factor in the last few cycles (it helped get Obama elected in 2008). But it does nothing to explain why Trump took fire instead of the other anti-establishment options.

Carson imploded as soon as the San Bernadino thing happened because he was perceived as soft on foreign policy. And, he was. He also quite honestly, is perceived as far too nice. He is a very good man. I like him a lot, he is a hometown hero kind of person to me. I know people whose lives he has directly touched... but being a surgeon and being all nice and compassionate, are not the qualities I look for in a President. Sorry but I want a president to be a D!ck.

Fiorina, I liked her a lot, I still like her. I would love to see her revived as someone's VP. But, she just never got enough traction. She wasn't well known enough and didn't have all the right connections. And, she has the one thing... HP... which to be honest, did not go all that well.... so its hard for her to pimp that in the way that Trump running a world wide organization can, even if he has had failures along the way.

Donald Trump quite simply was already a household name, that helped him "take fire". No one had to get to know him. His very personality - sucks all the rest of the oxygen out of the room. His style of hitting back twice as hard, silenced much of his opposition. Which helped him get ahead. And, I think the RNC doubted his staying power, and feared a third party run, so they catered to him and allowed him to suck the oxygen from the other candidates.

There rest of the "outsiders" you mentioned simply do not have the same kind of personality and style. It is really that simple. Another time and place, in a race without donald trump.. it could have been different for them. I wouldn't be surprised if Trump makes Carson his running mate. Christy is angling for Attorney General.
 
I'll concede that point. Given all the primary rules and the super-low turnout, it's tough to say much of anything at this point. But my own guess is that Trump will get MUCH lower vote totals from blacks (as well as Hispanics and other major minority groups) than Clinton does in the general election (assuming those are the nominees).



Could be. That's one factor that makes Trump a preferable opponent, I'm sure, from a Democratic perspective. He's entertaining and offensive, which may keep Democratic turnout from being too low. Someone like Rubio could have lulled Democrats into midterm-like apathy. Trump will wake them up to a greater degree.

But he also appeals the best to cross over voters. So good luck with Clinton:

Screen Shot 2016-03-02 at 12.37.00 PM.png
 
Carson imploded as soon as the San Bernadino thing happened because he was perceived as soft on foreign policy. And, he was. He also quite honestly, is perceived as far too nice. He is a very good man. I like him a lot, he is a hometown hero kind of person to me. I know people whose lives he has directly touched... but being a surgeon and being all nice and compassionate, are not the qualities I look for in a President. Sorry but I want a president to be a D!ck.

Fiorina, I liked her a lot, I still like her. I would love to see her revived as someone's VP. But, she just never got enough traction. She wasn't well known enough and didn't have all the right connections. And, she has the one thing... HP... which to be honest, did not go all that well.... so its hard for her to pimp that in the way that Trump running a world wide organization can, even if he has had failures along the way.

Donald Trump quite simply was already a household name, that helped him "take fire". No one had to get to know him. His very personality - sucks all the rest of the oxygen out of the room. His style of hitting back twice as hard, silenced much of his opposition. Which helped him get ahead. And, I think the RNC doubted his staying power, and feared a third party run, so they catered to him and allowed him to suck the oxygen from the other candidates.

There rest of the "outsiders" you mentioned simply do not have the same kind of personality and style. It is really that simple. Another time and place, in a race without donald trump.. it could have been different for them. I wouldn't be surprised if Trump makes Carson his running mate. Christy is angling for Attorney General.
I appreciate the substantive reply. Essentially, it comes down to the fact that in a field that had plenty of d!cks, outsiders, and people with lots of name recognition, Trump was the only one who was a d!ck, AND an outsider, AND a person with lots of name recognition. Could be, I guess. But that ends up being a very specific theory that only has value in explaining this particular election, whereas the theory I offered is more broadly applicable (it would, for example, help to explain the fact there has been very nearly zero success by black Republicans for decades -- possibly not even a single black Republican winning a state-wide election contested by a white opponent).
 
I've talked to a lot of people about this, mostly because I'm not sure I understand it myself... Seems like many people are of the opinion that, while they like Carson, they don't feel he's tough enough to withstand the pressure the elites will apply should he win the election. Fiorina just doesn't have enough exposure, and Rubio and Cruz are part of "the establishment", which is exactly what people hate.
I appreciate the substantive reply, which is along the same lines as connieb's. See above for my response.
 
Carson imploded as soon as the San Bernadino thing happened because he was perceived as soft on foreign policy. And, he was. He also quite honestly, is perceived as far too nice. He is a very good man. I like him a lot, he is a hometown hero kind of person to me. I know people whose lives he has directly touched... but being a surgeon and being all nice and compassionate, are not the qualities I look for in a President. Sorry but I want a president to be a D!ck.

Fiorina, I liked her a lot, I still like her. I would love to see her revived as someone's VP. But, she just never got enough traction. She wasn't well known enough and didn't have all the right connections. And, she has the one thing... HP... which to be honest, did not go all that well.... so its hard for her to pimp that in the way that Trump running a world wide organization can, even if he has had failures along the way.

Donald Trump quite simply was already a household name, that helped him "take fire". No one had to get to know him. His very personality - sucks all the rest of the oxygen out of the room. His style of hitting back twice as hard, silenced much of his opposition. Which helped him get ahead. And, I think the RNC doubted his staying power, and feared a third party run, so they catered to him and allowed him to suck the oxygen from the other candidates.

There rest of the "outsiders" you mentioned simply do not have the same kind of personality and style. It is really that simple. Another time and place, in a race without donald trump.. it could have been different for them. I wouldn't be surprised if Trump makes Carson his running mate. Christy is angling for Attorney General.

Excellent analysis Connie. It puts to shame the bottom-of-the-barrel "Trump is Hitler" type of DNC-funded hackery we're seeing here as of late...
 
I'll concede that point. Given all the primary rules and the super-low turnout, it's tough to say much of anything at this point. But my own guess is that Trump will get MUCH lower vote totals from blacks (as well as Hispanics and other major minority groups) than Clinton does in the general election (assuming those are the nominees).

You don't even realize what you just said, Mr. triple 9.
 
I appreciate the substantive reply. Essentially, it comes down to the fact that in a field that had plenty of d!cks, outsiders, and people with lots of name recognition, Trump was the only one who was a d!ck, AND an outsider, AND a person with lots of name recognition. Could be, I guess. But that ends up being a very specific theory that only has value in explaining this particular election, whereas the theory I offered is more broadly applicable (it would, for example, help to explain the fact there has been very nearly zero success by black Republicans for decades -- possibly not even a single black Republican winning a state-wide election contested by a white opponent).

This is an election season like no other, so no I don't think the more "broadly applicable" trends, apply.

I think for instance that Dr. Carson should have run for Mikulski's senate seat instead of for Pres. and I think he would have had a great chance of winning that. He is extremely well known in maryland, well liked, and the field was softened by our pretty popular republican Governor who came in on a landslide. That could have risen him to a level of a statewide elected position.

However, you have pointed out that some miniscule percentage of black people - vote republican. So, of that miniscule portion - how many are actually running for office? Of that then what is the relative qualification and experience level to their republican opposition? What are their connections like? What is the base of support for funding? You would need to have a detailed analysis of this before you proclaim the lack of elected republicans is indicative of the racism of the republican voter. Its somene' bias, but not necessarily the Republicans.

The MSM and the democrats have pimped the meme for 50 years that the Republicans are racists - despite little to no actual evidence of real racism. What they point to are instead positions of the Republican party - such as reduced social service spending or being against affirmative action - which have nothing to do with racism, and everything to do with conservative, small Government - Gov't out of "social justice" and social welfare activities. They have been so good at misrepresenting those positions that white and black people have bought it. But, like any other meme, its getting tiresome. And, I think each year, each election cycle, more and more people are coming around and are actually willing to listen to the reasons for opposition to those things. But, as long as "social justice" and Gov't intervention to "level the playing field" are of paramount concern to the black voter - there won't be much place for them in the republican party - because on principle that is simply not a "conservative" position. For the black voters who have realized that these programs have run their course or are being abused, or that they were actually counterproductive to their wellbeing, I am sure the Republicans are there to welcome them with open arms.

Same with women voters. I don't vote for "womens issues". My women's issues are a strong economy, strong military, and opportunity for my children and reducting in debt. I don't give a [Unwelcome language removed] about planned parenthood. I don't give a [Unwelcome language removed] about the anti-woman meme's that the democrats push. But, I admit, when I was younger I fell for all that - they are trying to control your body crapola and propaganda. Now my priorities are different. Now my understanding is different. Now, my faith in myself is different, my independence is different. I oppose for instance "fair pay" laws because I think that what you get paid is what you agree you are worth, and if you think you are worth more, then prove it. If not, then you weren't. When I realized that my gender, should have nothing to do with the policies I support, I realized the error of my ways in supporting Dems for many years. I think that will happen with other minorities and women as well as time goes by and the shrill cry of "racisms" and "sexism" lose their value.



connie
 
Incorrect. My recommendation for you would be to try some adult education classes. A decent teacher could quickly get your reading the material that's actually in front of you, rather than tangentially related material that only exists in your imagination. Obviously, a large portion of support for a candidate can be driven by racism without that meaning all those who support him are racists.

I'll sign up for some classes if you do. We can take them together ;)
 
Back
Top