New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Facts

Lukey, American Patriot couldn't even get to his second paragraph without telling a BLATANT LIE, the claim that we have lost five million manufacturing jobs under Obama. We most certainly have not, AND YOU KNOW IT!!

So: Why are you here, defending such lies?

And it was also a lie to claim that the dollar has become weaker under Obama, when in FACT it has strengthened against EVERY MAJOR WORLD CURRENCY.

And you know that, too.


Actually it is a bit over 5 million jobs lost in manufacturing. The dollar has been very unstable under Obama and continues to be. You like Bugs have no idea what you are talking about.
 
Actually it is a bit over 5 million jobs lost in manufacturing. The dollar has been very unstable under Obama and continues to be. You like Bugs have no idea what you are talking about.

I have been teaching college-level economics for more than 25 years now, AP, and it is YOU who have NO idea what you are talking about. I invite you to look, CAREFULLY, at the graph from the Department of Labor that Middleview provided on page one of this thread. It shows the MASSIVE number of manufacturing jobs that America lost during the George W. Bush tenure. It also shows the modest RECOVERY in manufacturing jobs that we have seen over the past six years. There have been many articles about the manufacturing renaissance in America, in such publications as The Wall Street Journal, The Economist, The Atlantic, and Fortune.

You should try reading some of them, sometime. Get yourself an education.
 
So are you suggesting the Obama "recovery" has generated more good, "breadwinner" type jobs than when he was elected?

View attachment 28565

Nope, still 2.5 million below the 2001 peak. Let us know when he gets us back to Clinton era levels of good breadwinner jobs, and then we'll talk about what a great job he has done with the economy. But don't forget, there's about 25 or 30 million more working age folks so he'll still have a ways to go on a percentage basis. How long has he got left in office? Man I hope he's got a great economic plan for his final months in office...

Did you read the top post and my reply? Context matters.
 
By the way, I love your signature quote from Jack Dallas. STILL one of the funniest things I have ever read.......


Well Professor here is your proof of the 5 million lost manufacturing jobs. Read the entire article please. So what ever it is you are teaching is far from correct or even vaguely accurate.



Obama's claim of 500,000 manufacturing jobs, month after ...
https://www.washingtonpost.com/.../obamas...manufac...
The Washington Post
Loading...
Jun 10, 2013 - Moreover, the growth in manufacturing jobs has basically stalled over the past year. The president's continued use of this 500,000-job statist
 
Lukey, I have watched Bugs in here for some time. Rarely is he honest and mostly he promotes socialist propaganda and Obama's political agenda. I think he is actually paid to be here causing havoc and telling endless fabrications aimed at making the far left look pristine. He knows little about real economics and even less about foreign affairs. At best he is a political toad. When Bugs is presented with real facts he does one of two things he either changes the subject or he claims the source is unreliable. Then he will accuse you of being racist or worse.

The truth is that your relationship with facts is distant at best. The only way you can substantiate your loss of 5 million jobs is by including the Bush recession.
 
Lukey, American Patriot couldn't even get to his second paragraph without telling a BLATANT LIE, the claim that we have lost five million manufacturing jobs under Obama. We most certainly have not, AND YOU KNOW IT!!

So: Why are you here, defending such lies?

And it was also a lie to claim that the dollar has become weaker under Obama, when in FACT it has strengthened against EVERY MAJOR WORLD CURRENCY.

And you know that, too.

Well the fact is that the dollar has spent most of the Obama years on a weakening trend. It has recently skyrocketed due to the Fed's (likely false) claim that they are seeking to tighten monetary policy. That has nothing to do with Obama's economic policies, as they have been the reason it has spent most of his time in office in the dumps:

Screen Shot 2015-11-11 at 10.13.04 AM.png

My guess is that as the economy continues to head for recession, all talk of Fed tightening will evaporate and the dollar will start to fall again by early 2016. So I find it really hard to place any credit on Obama's policy set, since that is what has kept the economy weak.

As for the jobs claim, perhaps it was overstated, but it is (when including the bad Bush Keynesian policy set along with Obama's):

The United States lost 5 million manufacturing jobs between January 2000 and December 2014.

http://www.epi.org/publication/manufacturing-job-loss-trade-not-productivity-is-the-culprit/

But there's also a good case to be made that Obama has not created the number of jobs he has claimed:

http://davidstockmanscontracorner.c...-whopper-he-did-not-create-12-8-million-jobs/

So it's a "no harm no foul" situation in my view (unless AP is going to deny that Bush's policies played a role in the loss of 5 million manufacturing jobs).
 
Well Professor here is your proof of the 5 million lost manufacturing jobs. Read the entire article please. So what ever it is you are teaching is far from correct or even vaguely accurate.



Obama's claim of 500,000 manufacturing jobs, month after ...
https://www.washingtonpost.com/.../obamas...manufac...
The Washington Post
Loading...
Jun 10, 2013 - Moreover, the growth in manufacturing jobs has basically stalled over the past year. The president's continued use of this 500,000-job statist

Quite hilarious, seeing as how the article offers ZERO support for your claim that we have lost five million manufacturing jobs under Obama:

According to Bureau of Labor Statistics data, the low point in U.S. manufacturing was reached on February 2010, when there were just 11.46 million manufacturing jobs in the country. That was about 1.1 million fewer than when Obama took office — and nearly 2.3 million fewer than when the Great Recession officially began in December 2007.

Then manufacturing jobs began to rebound, thanks in part to the rescue of the auto industry. By July 2012, the number of manufacturing jobs had risen to 11.957 million, or just shy of a 500,000 job gain. That’s when it became part of the president’s campaign rhetoric.

But at that point, the number also stopping climbing and instead began bouncing around.

In August 2012, 14,000 manufacturing jobs were lost. In the next month, an additional 18,000 were lost. Then came several months of gains — followed by three months of losses. The preliminary numbers in the employment report released Friday show a loss of 9,000 manufacturing jobs in April and 8,000 in May.

So, here we are, nearly one year later, and the United States is still stuck at a gain of 500,000 jobs.

LeRoy: Do you see that last sentence? Stuck at a GAIN of 500,000 jobs.

Yes, the manufacturing resurgence in America HAS slowed down. But do you know WHY? Overwhelmingly, the consensus is that it is because of the MUCH stronger U.S. dollar, which makes our products more expensive to foreign buyers. Which, of course, is contrary to the other major lie you told in your OP, that the dollar has been getting weaker.
 
Quite hilarious, seeing as how the article offers ZERO support for your claim that we have lost five million manufacturing jobs under Obama:

According to Bureau of Labor Statistics data, the low point in U.S. manufacturing was reached on February 2010, when there were just 11.46 million manufacturing jobs in the country. That was about 1.1 million fewer than when Obama took office — and nearly 2.3 million fewer than when the Great Recession officially began in December 2007.

Then manufacturing jobs began to rebound, thanks in part to the rescue of the auto industry. By July 2012, the number of manufacturing jobs had risen to 11.957 million, or just shy of a 500,000 job gain. That’s when it became part of the president’s campaign rhetoric.

But at that point, the number also stopping climbing and instead began bouncing around.

In August 2012, 14,000 manufacturing jobs were lost. In the next month, an additional 18,000 were lost. Then came several months of gains — followed by three months of losses. The preliminary numbers in the employment report released Friday show a loss of 9,000 manufacturing jobs in April and 8,000 in May.

So, here we are, nearly one year later, and the United States is still stuck at a gain of 500,000 jobs.

LeRoy: Do you see that last sentence? Stuck at a GAIN of 500,000 jobs.

Yes, the manufacturing resurgence in America HAS slowed down. But do you know WHY? Overwhelmingly, the consensus is that it is because of the MUCH stronger U.S. dollar, which makes our products more expensive to foreign buyers. Which, of course, is contrary to the other major lie you told in your OP, that the dollar has been getting weaker.

Both Bush and Obama are directly responsible for these 5 million manufacturing job looses. I never said it was completely Obama's fault but clearly his overall economic policies have failed.
 
Did you read the top post and my reply? Context matters.

I read your post and I replied. Are you suggesting that Obama's economy has generated sufficient good "bread winner" type jobs to recover those lost since Bush took office and provide same for the 30 million new people in the US workforce or not? That's all I want to know.
 
I read your post and I replied. Are you suggesting that Obama's economy has generated sufficient good "bread winner" type jobs to recover those lost since Bush took office and provide same for the 30 million new people in the US workforce or not? That's all I want to know.

The discussion was manufacturing....
 
Both Bush and Obama are directly responsible for these 5 million manufacturing job looses. I never said it was completely Obama's fault but clearly his overall economic policies have failed.

Really? You never said it was "completely" Obama's fault?

During the past year 81,000 pages of new regulations were enacted by the Obama administration. These regulations resulted in the loss of 5 million manufacturing jobs and the loss of 135 thousand manufacturing businesses. What does this actually tell us. It should say that over regulation and government control based on socialist principals are killing our manufacturing base as well as our economy.
 
My guess is that as the economy continues to head for recession, all talk of Fed tightening will evaporate and the dollar will start to fall again by early 2016. So I find it really hard to place any credit on Obama's policy set, since that is what has kept the economy weak.

As for the jobs claim, perhaps it was overstated, but it is (when including the bad Bush Keynesian policy set along with Obama's):

The United States lost 5 million manufacturing jobs between January 2000 and December 2014.

Given the recent very strong jobs report, I think we will see the first rate hike in December....less than a month from now. The markets are putting a 70% probability on that. And the vast majority of those lost manufacturing jobs, in fact ALL of them, were between January 2000 and early 2010. We have GAINED manufacturing jobs since then. Given that Mr. Obama had been in office barely a year by early 2010, it is nothing less than MADNESS to blame him for those job losses, when the great bulk of them took place under his predecessor.
 
He was pretty clearly talking about MANUFACTURING jobs. Context matters, you know.

Do they think they score debating points with childish displays of dementia? It is usually tough to feel like PJ is a good way to spend time...I could be rearranging my sock drawer or flossing my teeth....but then when we get into spending time on unrelated nonsense like the crap Boca or AP throw out it seems even less useful or productive.
 
Given the recent very strong jobs report, I think we will see the first rate hike in December....less than a month from now. The markets are putting a 70% probability on that. And the vast majority of those lost manufacturing jobs, in fact ALL of them, were between January 2000 and early 2010. We have GAINED manufacturing jobs since then. Given that Mr. Obama had been in office barely a year by early 2010, it is nothing less than MADNESS to blame him for those job losses, when the great bulk of them took place under his predecessor.

If we do, it will only make the coming recession worse. This isn't rocket science...

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-...e-store-sales-tumble-guidance-slashed-lack-sp

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-11-11/forget-oil-base-metals-collapse-50-2011-highs

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-...e-continues-burst-china-suffers-more-defaults

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-...raight-day-commodities-freight-index-collapse

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-11-10/most-important-earnings-report-you-should-know-about

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-11-10/its-not-record-high-debt-biggest-risk-its

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-...andle-after-api-confirms-huge-inventory-build

I could go on but what's the point? They're just a little "tin foil hat" blog...
 
Back
Top