Why do a parallel increase across other brackets? The poor and the middle class have already been losing ground over the last fifteen years or so, so why make that loss even greater by increasing their tax burden? The rich have been pulling ahead in that time, so greater taxes on them merely decrease the speed with which they're pulling away from the rest of society.then perhaps it should be increased, given a parallel increase across other brackets.
I like to play that game with the ignorant young right-wingers, so many of whom are wholly oblivious to the fact that the top bracket paid between 70% and 92% throughout the entire period when America's GDP was growing most rapidly and incomes were rising most quickly for the middle class. That's the kind of history their right-wing media outlets are careful not to teach them. I've had them accuse me of lying outright, then slink away when I bring up the historical tax tables to prove it.Most of the young, PC modernists have no idea how much the rich pay in taxes when you ask them, and are usually shocked to hear it's so high.
It doesn't add up to the propaganda they've been programmed with for the past years of their lives.
I've seen it many, many times. Always fun to watch youngens learning a valuable life lesson right in front of your eyes.
I like to play that game with the ignorant young right-wingers, so many of whom are wholly oblivious to the fact that the top bracket paid between 70% and 92% throughout the entire period when America's GDP was growing most rapidly and incomes were rising most quickly for the middle class. That's the kind of history their right-wing media outlets are careful not to teach them. I've had them accuse me of lying outright, then slink away when I bring up the historical tax tables to prove it.
How about this:So, a question...
What is a 'fair share', as a percentage of income?
If you have a point to make, please feel free to make it. I don't know what factors you're thinking of.You should also bring up the other factors that were contributing to that rise, but I know your DNC contract prohibits it.
Why do a parallel increase across other brackets? The poor and the middle class have already been losing ground over the last fifteen years or so, so why make that loss even greater by increasing their tax burden? The rich have been pulling ahead in that time, so greater taxes on them merely decrease the speed with which they're pulling away from the rest of society.
How about this:
The fair share at any given income level is the tax level at which the average wealth accumulation rate of people at that level is neither greater nor less than the average wealth accumulation rate of the population as a whole. So, for example, if the population as a whole is getting richer at a rate of 1% per year, and those at the 99th income percentile are getting richer at a rate of 5% per year, then it means they aren't paying their fair share of taxes and should pay more. Meanwhile, if those at the 5th income percentile are actually getting poorer, the nit means they are paying more than their fair share of taxes and should pay less.
Of course, that pre-supposes that the current wealth distribution is optimal. If not, then you'd want to revise that a bit so that you establish desired glide-paths from the current distribution to the desired distribution over some time period, and the increase or decrease in taxes would be based on whether a given income level was above or below that glide path.
why cant such a 'glide path' of distribution be applied to the taxation side. if the top 20% of earners already contribute some 87% of all tax revenue, and the remaining 80 pay only 13% thereof .. is that 'fair'?
According to @Arkady, it isn't fair. The top 20% aren't paying enough.
some 45% of all americans pay no income tax (after all the adjustments, credits, etc)..
is that fair?
seems an odd contrast to me. some would fault those that already contribute a huge proportion of tax revenue as inadequate...unfair even. but somehow, persons paying nil..escape such scrutiny and negative casting.I don't think it is, but apparently there's a large segment of our population that believes success needs to be punished severely. "Trickle-up poverty" is as good a term as any for it.
seems an odd contrast to me. some would fault those that already contribute a huge proportion of tax revenue as inadequate...unfair even. but somehow, persons paying nil..escape such scrutiny and negative casting.
why not.
How about this:
The fair share at any given income level is the tax level at which the average wealth accumulation rate of people at that level is neither greater nor less than the average wealth accumulation rate of the population as a whole. So, for example, if the population as a whole is getting richer at a rate of 1% per year, and those at the 99th income percentile are getting richer at a rate of 5% per year, then it means they aren't paying their fair share of taxes and should pay more. Meanwhile, if those at the 5th income percentile are actually getting poorer, the nit means they are paying more than their fair share of taxes and should pay less.
Of course, that pre-supposes that the current wealth distribution is optimal. If not, then you'd want to revise that a bit so that you establish desired glide-paths from the current distribution to the desired distribution over some time period, and the increase or decrease in taxes would be based on whether a given income level was above or below that glide path.
I don't know what you're asking. What I'm talking about is trying to use tax policy to coax the wealth structure in the direction of an optimal structure.why cant such a 'glide path' of distribution be applied to the taxation side. if the top 20% of earners already contribute some 87% of all tax revenue, and the remaining 80 pay only 13% thereof .. is that 'fair'?
Because wealth inequality encourages social dysfunction and if, unchecked, can make a society top-heavy and prone to collapse. So, since our wealth inequality is already high by developed nation standards and getting worse, why go with across-the-board tax hikes that will do nothing to combat it, rather than progressive hikes that will help to combat that dangerous trend?
I don't know what you're asking. What I'm talking about is trying to use tax policy to coax the wealth structure in the direction of an optimal structure.
In some cases it's unfair, because once you count payroll taxes they're still paying too much. We can fix that unfairness, though, with refundable tax credits that will do more to offset those payroll taxes.some 45% of all americans pay no income tax (after all the adjustments, credits, etc)..
is that fair?