In some cases it's unfair, because once you count payroll taxes they're still paying too much. We can fix that unfairness, though, with refundable tax credits that will do more to offset those payroll taxes.
but it is not unfair to the top earner?
In some cases it's unfair, because once you count payroll taxes they're still paying too much. We can fix that unfairness, though, with refundable tax credits that will do more to offset those payroll taxes.
I've never met anyone who believes that. But, there is a question of whether our society rewards the right things (e.g., "succeeding" by being born into a wealthy family, and thereby getting tax-free inheritance, where you'd have to pay taxes if you actually earned the money). And there's a question of whether the rewards need to be so large to incentivize the desired behaviors. For example, even with a 70% tax on the top bracket, that didn't stop Steve Jobs and Bill Gates from setting up their companies, nor did it prevent their teams from being very hard working and innovative. Those taxes didn't punish them for their success. They just somewhat diminished the magnitude of the reward for their success. So, the argument needs to be around whether larger rewards are desirable or not, not around the the idea that people are going to be punished for succeeding, which nobody has proposed.I don't think it is, but apparently there's a large segment of our population that believes success needs to be punished severely. "Trickle-up poverty" is as good a term as any for it.
I disagree. I think wealth distribution is a serious and proper concern for the government, and tax policy should take it into consideration."Wealth distribution" shouldn't even enter into the equation
I'm not proposing it as a sole remedy. I"m all for improving education, facilitating opportunity, etc. The nice thing is we can do both -- use those higher upper-class taxes to finance better education and to facilitate opportunity. That's essentially the formula we followed in our best economic years, when we paired high upper-class taxes with the GI Bill, various loan programs, etc., to expand opportunity.so increased taxation (of the top tiers of earners) is the remedy to wealth inequality?
odd, I would think education, facilitating opportunity, etc.. is the remedy
I think not everyone pays their fair share.
No. Top earners pay less than their fair share. Raising their taxes would make the system fairer.but it is not unfair to the top earner?
Higher. Why?
I disagree. I think wealth distribution is a serious and proper concern for the government, and tax policy should take it into consideration.
Agreed. The wealthy pay less than their fair share and the poor pay more than their fair share.
No. Top earners pay less than their fair share. Raising their taxes would make the system fairer.
so why should your rate be higher than someone in the top 1%?
during the Eisenhower years, the top marginal income tax rate was 91%. those were the good old days.....economically.
That's the great thing about democracy. You can have your view of what government's proper role is, and I can have mine, and we can fight it out at the ballot box and see who can convince more citizens.Making sure that the wealth creation was not done through fraud or intimidation - is a serious concern of Government. Making sure that Gov't provides stability through even handed law enforcement, reliable and trustworthy court systems, and understandable regulation, is a function of Gov't.
Making sure that "wealth" created in many cases from factors outside of the borders of the Government of the country they happen to reside in, is "fairly" distributed not a concern.
connie
sez you. ;-)
the system would be fair-est.. where we all paid a fair share.
Indeed.
Agreed. But the whole point is that we disagree abut what a "fair share" is. I think the poor currently pay more than their fair share and the rich currently pay a lot less than their fair share.
During the Eisenhower years, the tax system was much more progressive than today -- there were a lot more brackets, and more spread in rates between the top and bottom brackets. For 1955, there were 24 tax brackets, capping out at 91% By comparison, now there are only seven tax brackets, capping out at 39.6%. Back in 1955, the rates kept progressing higher until you got to household income of $3.6 million per year, in today's dollars. Today, the top bracket starts at just $450,000, which treats some everyday doctors, lawyers, and other professionals pay the same as CEOs and other multi-million-earning plutocrats. Moving back to a more progressive system, like we used to have, would make sense. Triple the number of brackets and keep escalating the rates for higher-end earners.I'm all for an eisenhoweresque solution...where you and I and everyone else paid the proverbial 91%
For some of the 45%, that may be fair. For others, it may still leave them with an unfairly heavy tax burden, once you consider other kinds of taxes. We can make it fairer, as I said, by using larger refundable tax credits to do more to lighten the overall tax burden on the poorer among them.roughly 45% of Americans pay no federal income tax because they have no taxable income, and or get enough tax breaks to erase their tax liability,
fair?
First define "fair share".
So somebody is deserving of a fair share of someone else's income?
Why?
Does someone working hard have a "fair share" to give to the government? To non workers?
Okay. The government does certain things for us and we all need to pay a "fair share" to that government so we can have highways to drive on, schools for our kids, safe borders. We get some of that....... highways seem pretty crappy, schools don't really turn out a good product sometimes. And our borders......... basically don't exist. So based on that product......... 79% seems excessive unless those three things come up to speed. And we know they won't.
And then non workers. They deserve a "fair share" of our money? Their jobs have been given to people taking advantage of our open borders. Some of them don't want jobs. So we have to pay for them to have a lifestyle similar to ours?
Is that "fair"?
I don't think so.
Why don't the non workers and people coming across the borders ante up with their "fair share".......... oh yeah. That's free.
Lucky them.
I would agree with that with a caveat of, say, the first $35k not taxed then 15% beyond that. And remove FICA and all other add-on taxes.A fair share is a flat tax. EVERYBODY pays say 15% of their income.
I disagree. I think wealth distribution is a serious and proper concern for the government, and tax policy should take it into consideration.
No, 15% for everybody. FICA included if we keep SS and the rest. You make $10K you put in $1500. You want it back? Get it back as a stipend to attend college (if that is what Democrats want to do with the money).I would agree with that with a caveat of, say, the first $35k not taxed then 15% beyond that. And remove FICA and all other add-on taxes.