The average effective rate for the last year I have on record was 17.6%. So, if we moved to a 15% rate, you'd cut revenues by about 15%. You'd add something in the ballpark of half a trillion dollars to the deficit. Meanwhile, you'd increase the effective poverty rate massively, since the after-tax income of the lower-middle class would fall to the level where the after-tax income of today's poor is. Your 15% flat rate would be a tax hike on something like 70% of all Americans, even as it was a titanic windfall for the very rich. None of that strikes me as fair.