New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Fair share

accurately stated..the poor cannot afford to pay their fair share. those who can, fill the gap. but they do not pay more than.
I believe they currently pay more than their fair share. What we're ultimately talking about here is the maintenance cost on a particular socio-economic system. That socio-economic system is wildly beneficial to some, and oppressive to others. Calling for those oppressed by it to pay anything to help support it is calling on them to pay more than their fair share. The poor currently pay more than their fair share, once you look beyond just income taxation. Their effective tax rates should be lowered, while the effective tax rates of those best advantaged by the system should go up.
 
A fair share is a flat tax. EVERYBODY pays say 15% of their income.
The average effective rate for the last year I have on record was 17.6%. So, if we moved to a 15% rate, you'd cut revenues by about 15%. You'd add something in the ballpark of half a trillion dollars to the deficit. Meanwhile, you'd increase the effective poverty rate massively, since the after-tax income of the lower-middle class would fall to the level where the after-tax income of today's poor is. Your 15% flat rate would be a tax hike on something like 70% of all Americans, even as it was a titanic windfall for the very rich. None of that strikes me as fair.
 
I believe they currently pay more than their fair share. What we're ultimately talking about here is the maintenance cost on a particular socio-economic system. That socio-economic system is wildly beneficial to some, and oppressive to others. Calling for those oppressed by it to pay anything to help support it is calling on them to pay more than their fair share. The poor currently pay more than their fair share, once you look beyond just income taxation. Their effective tax rates should be lowered, while the effective tax rates of those best advantaged by the system should go up.


we should question why they are oppressed by it, and take measures to correct that...rather than absolve them of their responsibility to pay in to it...or penalize another.
 
I would agree with that with a caveat of, say, the first $35k not taxed then 15% beyond that. And remove FICA and all other add-on taxes.
The top 1% currently pays at an effective rate around 29%. The top quintile averages about 23.4%. Your plan would constitute a gigantic reduction in their taxes. For example, for someone earning $5 million per year, your plan would save them about $700,000 per year. But you don't get something for nothing. All that extra money that goes to buying third homes and fourth BMWs for the wealthy is money not available for the budget. It'll either mean a massive increase in the tax burden of the poor and middle class, or massive deficit increases, or big cuts in spending. If any of those spending cuts come from social spending, you'll be making our unusually austere social spending even more austere.
 
If you feel that way, you claim to make $250,000, why don't you do what you want the government to do.........go share your wealth.

(of course you're all talk and no walk)

You just want other people money away, not yours, its why republicans give more to charity than liberals.
I'm advocating a systematic change. Obviously, I don't want to pay extra merely to decrease the pressure that would otherwise help lead to systematic change. That would be pretty counter-productive, wouldn't it?
 
we should question why they are oppressed by it, and take measures to correct that...rather than absolve them of their responsibility to pay in to it...or penalize another.
Why not do them both: take measures to eliminate the oppressive aspects of the system, but in the meantime excuse the oppressed of the obligation of paying for their own oppression?
 
Why not do them both: take measures to eliminate the oppressive aspects of the system, but in the meantime excuse the oppressed of the obligation of paying for their own oppression?

I simply do not agree. I dont view it so much as oppression, as a failure to learn how to work , and advance, within the system..
 
The average effective rate for the last year I have on record was 17.6%. So, if we moved to a 15% rate, you'd cut revenues by about 15%. You'd add something in the ballpark of half a trillion dollars to the deficit. Meanwhile, you'd increase the effective poverty rate massively, since the after-tax income of the lower-middle class would fall to the level where the after-tax income of today's poor is. Your 15% flat rate would be a tax hike on something like 70% of all Americans, even as it was a titanic windfall for the very rich. None of that strikes me as fair.
Already explained it t you. Try and [Unwelcome language removed] remember this time. Let the states tax to make up the difference as they see fit.
 
Already explained it t you. Try and [Unwelcome language removed] remember this time. Let the states tax to make up the difference as they see fit.
If the states hike taxes to make up for the gigantic revenue shortfall you're creating, that just worsens the effective tax hike on the vast majority of Americans -- who wouldn't just be hit by a much bigger federal tax bill, but also possibly a bigger state tax bill.
 
If the states hike taxes to make up for the gigantic revenue shortfall you're creating, that just worsens the effective tax hike on the vast majority of Americans -- who wouldn't just be hit by a much bigger federal tax bill, but also possibly a bigger state tax bill.

So what?

I'm not telling states how to tax, if at all.
 
He Only Has One Rolls-Royce Because He's in a High Tax-Bracket

It's not about percentage, it's about what people have to sacrifice. The rich should sacrifice expensive luxuries before others have to sacrifice essentials.

Why? The poor are of no benefit or necessity to the rich. Why should the rich sacrifice anything for them?
 
Not to mention who gets to define what is a "luxury" and what is a "necessity"? I'll bet I know who the progs think it should be...

Yeah.. exactly. Personally, I know quite a few "poor" who have luxuries we don't have like for instance my husband does not have a smart phone or a data plan.
 
Yeah.. exactly. Personally, I know quite a few "poor" who have luxuries we don't have like for instance my husband does not have a smart phone or a data plan.

We don't have cable/satellite TV (by choice). I've seen this referred to as a "necessity". I call BS!
 
I'm all for an eisenhoweresque solution...where you and I and everyone else paid the proverbial 91%

the marginal tax rate applies to everyone.....when you make over a certain amount, you start paying the marginal rate.
I get it that you're bothered that we have a progressive tax system and the wealthy pay more in taxes.
 
We don't have cable/satellite TV (by choice). I've seen this referred to as a "necessity". I call BS!

Exactly. Just like SNAP benefits. What a person"needs"and what they want - are too separate things.

But, if many of these people were able to adequately distinguish between the two and put of the instant gratification that comes with "treating" oneself, most of them wouldn't be poor.

My friend a recently quit smoker tallied up the money here and her BF have likely spent on cigarettes in the 25 yers, and 30 years they have smoked.. and it was over 50,000. Seriously - they have pissed away over 50K. I laughed and said.. hmmm well, imagine how much you have wasted in alcohol and when he was younger.. pot. They consitently hover at the poverty line.. and she said it made her ill to think of how much better off they could be if they had made better choices.
 
I'm advocating a systematic change. Obviously, I don't want to pay extra merely to decrease the pressure that would otherwise help lead to systematic change. That would be pretty counter-productive, wouldn't it?

Just as I figured and posted, YOU all talk and no walk. You as well have the in-side on deductions and probably as Bernie pay 13% or less in income taxes.......
 
the marginal tax rate applies to everyone.....when you make over a certain amount, you start paying the marginal rate.
I get it that you're bothered that we have a progressive tax system and the wealthy pay more in taxes.

Oh I'm not bothered in the slightest. You can make up for yourself that I am, but I am not.

I get it that you want to oppress the poor and keep them dependent.

See how that sucks...making shit up...?
 
Why not do them both: take measures to eliminate the oppressive aspects of the system, but in the meantime excuse the oppressed of the obligation of paying for their own oppression?


Come to think of it.. you know what is oppressive? Keeping people dependent rather than facilitating the means to their betterment... all the while casting those whom we would tax more as some evil.

Sure, let's do tax the wealthy, and corporations more, lots more, but how about the rest of us not so much as to make effort and investment punitive...
 
Back
Top