New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Fair share

They need help, at least in the short term, to live in a decent level of comfort, because at the time being they lack the income to afford that decent level of comfort without assistance. So helping them is the moral thing to do.


morality by means of taxation?. but then only of a certain subset of the population..? one would think morality is universal..
 
I just want people to think through the consequences of that kind of reckless move -- the way that it would drastically worsen wealth inequality in this country, destabilizing our social structure while driving the middle class into poverty and the lower class to outright violent desperation.... all so some rich folks can afford longer yachts.
Nonsense. Wages will likely go up for the lower classes to pay their fair share and if you bring back manufacturing jobs nothing will be destabilized.
 
So how is it you have deteremined that
By comparing how much they earn and how much a person would need to earn to live with a decent amount of comfort.

and why is it that they should be helped at the expense of other people the tax payer should wish to help instead?

People are free to help anyone they want. But we'll be most effective when acting in a systematic way through taxes and spending, rather than a piecemeal way based on the whims of individuals.

What makes helping a random unknow person through confiscated tax revenue MORE moral than say -paying that money so your granny can live at home instead of in a nursing facility?

It's not more moral to do it in a systematic way -- merely more effective.

there are afterall - many mnay instances of people found panhandling that actually live in really nice apartments or cars, etc.

Which, of course, is a very strong case against private charity, such as hand-outs on the streets, which are more easily gamed by grifters than a systematic approach with actual means testing.
 
morality by means of taxation?. but then only of a certain subset of the population..? one would think morality is universal..
It is. Anyone would pay the higher tax rates if he ended up getting rich. And anyone would be relieved of the burden if poverty made it a real hardship to pay. That's universal.
 
Nonsense. Wages will likely go up for the lower classes to pay their fair share and if you bring back manufacturing jobs nothing will be destabilized.
Taxes on the lower class were higher in the Reagan/Bush years than the Clinton years. Did you see evidence that this meant wages rising for the lower classes in the Reagan/Bush years and falling in the Clinton years? Wasn't the opposite actually the case?
 
Taxes on the lower class were higher in the Reagan/Bush years than the Clinton years. Did you see evidence that this meant wages rising for the lower classes in the Reagan/Bush years and falling in the Clinton years? Wasn't the opposite actually the case?

Gingrich and Kasich had more to do with the economy of the 90's than Clinton. And the Reagan years weren't so bad after Carter. As a matter of fact the 80's were the launchpad that the 90's enjoyed.

Wages have been stagnant for decades thanks to illegals and H1B visas.
 
Note, I had a typo. I meant "Right now." I mean I'm helping now in the sense that right now I'm championing policies with a proven track record of helping the lower class.

I think we call that a "Freudian slip", not a typo. By your own admission, you don't pay your fair share right now. Why don't you start?
 
I would think "fair share," at its most extreme connotation with respect to taxes, would be that they pay a share of the taxes that is roughly equal to their share of the income:

An article from the TaxFoundation contains federal data for 2010, reporting the following:

  • Top 1% earned 18.9% of $$$$, paid 37.4% of taxes.
  • Top 5% earned 33.8% of $$$$, paid 59.1% of taxes.
  • Bottom 50% earned 11.7% of $$$$, paid 2.4% of taxes.
https://constitutionalconservative.wordpress.com/myth-the-rich-dont-pay-their-fair-share/

So, now who exactly is it that isn't paying their "fair share?" Anyone suggesting such nonsense, in light of the facts (above) is simply displaying their Marxist ideology with respect to tax policy. It has nothing to do with "paying their fair share" and everything to do with "wealth redistribution." The fact that Bernie has to lie about this illustrates the subversive nature of the communist agenda.

Even So, It's So Uneven

Your unrealistic resentment of the unequal burden for those with a higher capacity for carrying it would lead to the bottom 50% paying 5 times the taxes they are paying now. No one would be able to buy a car. Two things that are excluded from the discussion: (1) the unequal sacrifice the same percentage would cause the taxpayer whose life isn't full of showy and unnecessary luxuries, and (2) the unequal amounts that should be owed back to the society that enables the rich to get rich. Therefore, if they get more out of living in America, they should pay a higher percentage of America's taxes.
 
Gingrich and Kasich had more to do with the economy of the 90's than Clinton.

At one point, a reasonable person might have tried to make a straight-faced argument in that direction. After all, even though the Clinton-era improvements had all started before the Republicans took Congress, you could speculate that the improvements would have petered out if not for the Republicans and whatever policy of theirs it is to which you attribute the success (out of curiosity, which policy is that, exactly?) But, the ability to make that argument in a way that won't get you laughed at by informed people really shut down after 2000. It was almost as if the real-world conspired to disprove the right-wing theory. The Republicans stayed in control of Congress and Clinton left the presidency and was replaced by Bush. It was like a controlled experiment to see whether Clinton or the Republican Congress caused the prosperity. If the prosperity continued, then it was the Republicans. If it ended, it was Clinton. It ended. Starting in 2001 we went through a long period of mostly negative socioeconomic trends. That's why you seldom hear anyone other than uninformed right-wing dead-enders trying to attribute the 90s prosperity to the Republican Congress these days.

And the Reagan years weren't so bad after Carter.

Well, that depends on where you look, exactly. For example, job creation rates under Reagan were much worse than under Carter, and the fiscal situation, which had been stable under Carter, went to hell in a hand-basket under Reagan. But, in other ways the Reagan years were a little better. For example, the poverty rate rose a bit under Carter, whereas it was completely unchanged under Reagan.

As a matter of fact the 80's were the launchpad that the 90's enjoyed.

As you may recall, the 90s started under Bush with a recession and then a jobless recovery, while the nation hit some all-time sociological problems, like an all-time high for violent crime rates. Thing only really started improving in a meaningful way once Clinton was president.
 
I think we call that a "Freudian slip", not a typo. By your own admission, you don't pay your fair share right now. Why don't you start?
I'll be happy to start, once the law is changed. I just don't want to diminish the pressure for a change in the law through piecemeal individual efforts.
 
By comparing how much they earn and how much a person would need to earn to live with a decent amount of comfort.



People are free to help anyone they want. But we'll be most effective when acting in a systematic way through taxes and spending, rather than a piecemeal way based on the whims of individuals.



It's not more moral to do it in a systematic way -- merely more effective.



Which, of course, is a very strong case against private charity, such as hand-outs on the streets, which are more easily gamed by grifters than a systematic approach with actual means testing.


How do you know how much they earned? You only know how much they claim to have earned. You only know they lack the appearance of wealth. You only know the wealth they have earned from reportable sources.

What is "most effective". You think it is "most effective" given your priorities. But, that doesn't mean it is "most effective" there is no completely objective way of determining that.

connie
 
So, I'm laying about watching the flyers tonight with my son...commercial comes on.. Bernie sanders.. theme is 'make the wealthy pay their fair share'

Given that the ..... saaay..... top ten percent pay some 79% of all income tax revenue. (Guesstimating here...)

What is unfair about that share?

They earn 25% more than the combined bottom 90%. Also income taxes are not the only taxes. You figure does not take into consideration payroll taxes which overwhelmingly paid by the bottom 90% and make up 40% of all revenue.
 
I'll be happy to start, once the law is changed. I just don't want to diminish the pressure for a change in the law through piecemeal individual efforts.

As I suspected, you need the government (your God) to validate your so-called "morality". I knew this to be true, but I have to admit I'm still surprised you're so willing to make this embarrassing admission in public.

We don't know they're more moral or more deserving. But it's helping out those of our fellow men who most need it. That's the moral thing to do.

They're demonstrably struggling in "doing for themselves." The moral thing is to give them a hand. We can, of course, try to excuse ourselves from that moral obligation through any manner of sophistry that comforts us. But I'm not interested in self delusion.

It appears you are in fact interested in self delusion.
 
How do you know how much they earned? You only know how much they claim to have earned

True. As with absolutely anything the government or the private sector does, there's always the risk of fraud.

What is "most effective".

Producing the biggest gain in overall human happiness and fulfillment for a given cost.

But, that doesn't mean it is "most effective" there is no completely objective way of determining that.

True. When it comes to issues like morality, we eventually come down to irreducible qualitative judgments. Fortunately, the democratic process gives us a way to resolve such issues. When you think it would be more effective, say, to leave the poor to suffer so that the rich aren't interfered with in the enjoyment of their luxuries, and I think that taking a bit more from the rich to give the poor more assistance would ultimately be in all our interests, we can each take our case to the People and see who is more convincing.
 
As I suspected, you need the government (your God) to validate your so-called "morality". I knew this to be true, but I have to admit I'm still surprised you're so willing to make this embarrassing admission in public.

You misunderstood. I made no such admission. It's not a question of needing government validation of my morality. It's a question of believing that systematic problems call for systematic solutions. It might be easier for you to understand if you look at the same issue in some policy context where your views are the reverse. For example, if you believe that to be secure we should spend more on our military than we currently do, does this mean that you should unilaterally cut the Pentagon a check? I'd say no -- that ultimately the defense of the nation is a collective effort and even if you think we, collectively, are underspending, that doesn't make it your responsibility to enable the free-riding of others by trying to make up the difference. Instead, you should work on convincing the rest of us to make a systematic change. Similarly, if you think we need to destroy ISIS, and Obama isn't doing as much as you think he should, does this mean you need to arm yourself and fly to Syria or Iraq to fight them yourself? Again, I'd say no. If defeating ISIS benefits us, it benefits us as a group, and it's not your job to unilaterally sacrifice for that. Instead, you should work to alter policy, and then you'd sacrifice in line with whatever distribution of sacrifices the policy called for.
 
True. When it comes down to issues like morality, we eventually come down to irreducible qualitative judgments. Fortunately, the democratic process gives us a way to resolve such issues. When you think it would be more effective, say, to leave the poor to suffer so that the rich aren't interfered with in the enjoyment of their luxuries, and I think that taking a bit more from the rich to give the poor more assistance would ultimately be in all our interests, we can each take our case to the People and see who is more convincing.

I bid you good luck in convincing "the People" to do something you yourself have confirmed you're unwilling to do. That type of hypocrisy is roundly rejected by patriots and other members of the productive segment of society.
 
I bid you good luck in convincing "the People" to do something you yourself have confirmed you're unwilling to do. That type of hypocrisy is roundly rejected by patriots and other members of the productive segment of society.
As I explained, I'm entirely willing to pay higher taxes once we alter the tax system to require that. That's all I'm asking others to do. If I was instead calling on people to unilaterally volunteer to pay more even in the face of the tax system being unchanged, and I was unwilling to do so myself, that would be hypocrisy. But that's not what I'm doing.
 
Back
Top