New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Fair share

That hasn't been what I've observed. What I've seen is that the most economically successful people are generally awful. For example, my richest relative made his fortune first by stealing a customer list from his old employer, then selling those customers reconditioned machines as new, and gaming government contracting rules by putting his company in his wife's name to get access to "woman-owned business" advantages. Ethics would have been a huge hindrance for him.

I see the same within large organizations where I've worked. People who get ahead are those who have no qualms about taking credit for other people's work, and who will happily do the wrong thing, legally or morally, if they perceive it will be liked by whoever controls their next promotion, and they think they can get away with it. And those are just the rank-and-file contestants in the rat race. When you get to the real elite, you find the world-class scumbags, like the crooks who gave us the 2008 meltdown, or Enron, or Tyco, or the Russian oil oligarchs, or African kleptocrats, etc. Even when their houses of cards eventually crumble, they walk away with millions.

That's not even to get into people like Waltons, Kochs, Trump, and the Bushes, who just get rich with money from their wealthy families and political and business connections from their aristocratic upbringings. I think that if it were possible to graph "virtue" against wealth, you'd see a strong inverse correlation as you moved up from the middle ranks of wealth towards the elite.

But, even if they were mostly decent folks, I don't think that would change the fact that the system is currently set up to exploit the poor and middle class for the benefit of the elite. It's a bit like if you were a slave on the plantation of a kindly master, or a serf working the land of a generous Lord. The system itself is exploitative, whether the particular member of the elite is decent or not.



OK. Check the real numbers on that, then. Median weekly earnings for someone with less than a high school diploma are $493, and unemployment rates for that group are 8.0%. By the time you get up to a professional degree, it's $1,730 and 1.5%. Assuming 50 weeks per year and factoring in unemployment, it works out to $85,203 for a professional degree versus $22,678 for not having a high school diploma. Even factoring in the cost of the education, you're going to come out way ahead with the professional degree, on average. And that isn't changed by higher tax rates for higher earners. Progressive taxation isn't anywhere close to progressive enough to counter the impact of the higher earnings.

Go to a really up-scale neighborhood sometime and check out the education levels. For example, close to my own home:

http://www.movoto.com/sudbury-ma/01776/demographics/

90% of the population has at least a Bachelors degree. That's the path to success, and there's no sign people are responding to slightly higher taxes on the top bracket under Obama (or a similar hike under Clinton) by drifting away from that path. They know that there's no serious sense in which they're being punished for their effort. They know that even after the higher taxes, they'll still be getting a big return on investment.

That said, I would point out that our tax policy is a bit weird with regard to education in one way. You "earn out" of interest deductions on your college education loans, even though you don't "earn out" of interest deductions on things like second homes or yachts. So, you end up with a situation where some rich dude with a mortgage on his vacation mansion gets to write off the interest, but someone who invested in his education by borrowing doesn't get to write it off. That makes no sense. So, a modest proposal: eliminate the deductibility of mortgage interest other than for the primary residence and only to the extent that the house's value is median or less. So, for example, if the median house costs $200k and yours is worth $1 million, you can write off 20% of your mortgage interest. Then, make a person's entire educational expense deductible (not just the interest), on the theory that it's an investment that makes the income possible, and so should be taken out when counting what the income's true profit is to the person.



I seek that, too. And based on both common sense and empirical data, I see that they're more likely to stay dependent if you keep them just north of starvation level than if you give them the tools and relative shelter from the hardships of poverty needed to get their lives together and become self sufficient. A little extra investment in people in the short term saves a lot in the long term.


so, do I take it that you and I are the exception? that is, we're not awful, and have qualms...

:)
 

No. You've overlooked every other kind of taxation other than federal income taxes -- SS taxes, Medicare taxes, indirect taxation through tariffs, use fees for things like public parks, state and local taxes, etc.

damn topic is fed income taxes
 
Lower income- is not in and of itself prove they can not demonstrably do for themselves.

I guess it comes down to definitions. What they're not doing for themselves is earning enough money to live with a minimal level of comfort. The moral thing is to help them to get there.

Again, you are back to assuming that they are somehow more deserving by saying is moral to help them.

No. My observation that it's the moral thing to do is not dependent on the idea that they're "more deserving."
 
Yes, and as I pointed out, framing the topic that way overlooks all the other kinds of taxes.


which..persons with means would be likely to be paying more of... too. no?

(i.e. SS taxes, Medicare taxes, indirect taxation through tariffs, use fees for things like public parks, state and local taxes, etc)
 
so, do I take it that you and I are the exception? that is, we're not awful, and have qualms...

:)
I'm more awful than I used to be when I was lower on the totem pole. Back then, for example, I took my role as a lawyer to be to help my clients not to hurt themselves with dumb mistakes. So, I'd really push, to convince those who were eager to do something dumb that it was a bad idea. But I came to realize that this was a thankless task. Even though I'd often succeed, they'd only remember how unpleasant it was to have all their mental errors pointed out by me, and since they could never really be certain I'd helped them avoid being run over by a bus, that negative experience outweighed the positive. Now, though, I content myself with gently guiding my client away from dumb moves, and if they push back, I let them, knowing that I'm on the record warning them about the oncoming bus. This works well for me. They find the interactions pleasant, review me well, and come back repeatedly.... and when they get run over by a bus, they remember me having mentioned that it was coming, so they don't hold it against me. There's no question in my mind that my clients were better off back when I was willing to hurt my relationship with them to keep them out of harm's way, but there's also no question that these days I'm better off from a career perspective. So, I'd say I've gotten more awful than I used to be, and that this has contributed directly to my success. Others have gotten ahead even more than me by being even more awful -- for example, jockeying to take on only the marquee projects that get attention, and forcing the more thankless tasks to others.
 
which..persons with means would be likely to be paying more of... too. no?

(i.e. SS taxes, Medicare taxes, indirect taxation through tariffs, use fees for things like public parks, state and local taxes, etc)
Yes, they'd be paying those things, too.... just much too little overall. We can fix that, though, by removing the preferential treatment for the kinds of income rich people disproportionately have (capital gain, inheritance, and dividends), and by removing the SS tax cap and making all income subject to payroll taxes.
 
If one were truly interested in "fairness", all citizens would pay the same amount. Forget sliding scales, forget percentages. It is inherently UNFAIR that citizen cost for infrastructure is higher for one than another. That is clearly UNEQUAL PROTECTION under the law.

However, we know that the purpose of taxation is not merely funding for government operations. It is intended to be redistributive...and to be demonstrative to certain classes that the hoi polloi are being hammered (a sort of protection racket to keep the mob at bay).

Fairness has nothing to do with taxation. And funding operational cost is but a small part of its purpose.
As Mitt Romney showed in the last election, it's not just a matter of adjusting our "progressive" tax system, but clarifying the tax code and, most importantly, tax loopholes.


http://www.salary.com/why-mitt-romney-other-wealthy-investors-pay-less-taxes/
In 2010, Romney and his wife totaled $21.6 million in income and paid slightly more than $3 million in federal income taxes. That's good for an effective tax rate of 13.9 percent, according to the documents he released. Last year, according to estimates Romney released, the pair took in $20.9 million, on which they will pay $3.2 million -- 15.4 percent of their income.

(The Obamas, by way of comparison, had $1.7 million in income in 2010 and paid an effective tax rate of 26.3 percent.)

So how does a man worth hundreds of millions end up with a tax rate similar to that paid by a household earning $50,000 per year?

The answer lies not in any shady accounting or financial trickery, but in the federal income tax code, explained Joseph Newpol, a professor of law, taxation and financial planning at Bentley University in Waltham, Mass.

“Essentially, the policy is this: if you have income from capital, we’re going to tax it at a preferential rate,” Newpol said.

Most workers are familiar with the progressive income tax: Money earned in wages or salary is taxed at a higher rate the more you earn. For 2011, a married couple earning a total of $50,000 – after deductions – is subject to a maximum tax rate of 15 percent; those earning more than $379,150 will pay 35 percent on some of their income.

But capital gains – the profit made from selling an asset, such as real estate or stocks – are taxed differently. Though there are some exceptions, this money is generally assessed at a rate of 15 percent.

For tax purposes, other income also falls under the capital gains rate, including carried interest, which is when an individual is paid a portion of the profits generated by a fund or partnership.

In Romney’s case, $12.6 million of his 2010 income was classified as capital gains, according to his tax filings. Had that money been paid as salary or wages, most of it would have been taxed at 35 percent; instead, it was assessed at less than half that rate.
 
I'm more awful than I used to be when I was lower on the totem pole. Back then, for example, I took my role as a lawyer to be to help my clients not to hurt themselves with dumb mistakes. So, I'd really push, to convince those who were eager to do something dumb that it was a bad idea. But I came to realize that this was a thankless task. Even though I'd often succeed, they'd only remember how unpleasant it was to have all their mental errors pointed out by me, and since they could never really be certain I'd helped them avoid being run over by a bus, that negative experience outweighed the positive. Now, though, I content myself with gently guiding my client away from dumb moves, and if they push back, I let them, knowing that I'm on the record warning them about the oncoming bus. This works well for me. They find the interactions pleasant, review me well, and come back repeatedly.... and when they get run over by a bus, they remember me having mentioned that it was coming, so they don't hold it against me. There's no question in my mind that my clients were better off back when I was willing to hurt my relationship with them to keep them out of harm's way, but there's also no question that these days I'm better off from a career perspective. So, I'd say I've gotten more awful than I used to be, and that this has contributed directly to my success. Others have gotten ahead even more than me by being even more awful -- for example, jockeying to take on only the marquee projects that get attention, and forcing the more thankless tasks to others.


may I ask what law you practice.. just curious.. my wife practices labor and empl.. me, I'm not a lawyer, but i play one on tv... :)

i seem to recall patent law... maybe..

understand if no..
 
In terms of their lower incomes.



If so, then that's a moot point, since they'll eschew the government assistance and there will be no cost associated with it. For those who don't eschew material wealth, though, but who are having trouble providing anything more than the barest necessities for their family, providing them this assistance to brighten their futures is the moral thing to do.

Then I can assume you're doing this independent of having the government enforce it at gunpoint, yes?
 
may I ask what law you practice.. just curious.. my wife practices labor and empl.. me, I'm not a lawyer, but i play one on tv... :)

i seem to recall patent law... maybe..

understand if no..
These days I do general commercial law, but I've had narrower specialties in the past (first M&A, then IP, then IT contracts).
 
No. I favor systematic changes. Unilateral ones would detract from the pressure that might otherwise bring about systematic changes.

I see. Unsurprisingly, you're not willing to part with your own money until the government is forcing everyone else to do it at gunpoint. Exactly as I expected...
 
I guess it comes down to definitions. What they're not doing for themselves is earning enough money to live with a minimal level of comfort. The moral thing is to help them to get there.



No. My observation that it's the moral thing to do is not dependent on the idea that they're "more deserving."

You can't justify the moral thing to do - without somehow justifying they are deserving of help, or that they need the help. You haven't done either.
 
You can't justify the moral thing to do - without somehow justifying they are deserving of help, or that they need the help.
They need help, at least in the short term, to live in a decent level of comfort, because at the time being they lack the income to afford that decent level of comfort without assistance. So helping them is the moral thing to do.
 
They need help, at least in the short term, to live in a decent level of comfort, because at the time being they lack the income to afford that decent level of comfort without assistance. So helping them is the moral thing to do.

So how is it you have deteremined that - and why is it that they should be helped at the expense of other people the tax payer should wish to help instead? What makes helping a random unknow person through confiscated tax revenue MORE moral than say -paying that money so your granny can live at home instead of in a nursing facility? Furthermore by appearances htey may appear to lack that comfort, but how do you know that infact that is the case, there are afterall - many mnay instances of people found panhandling that actually live in really nice apartments or cars, etc.

Again - you are ASSuming they need aid based on some markers that you have made up.. and proclaiming yourself moral for forcing others to "help" them......
 
They need help, at least in the short term, to live in a decent level of comfort, because at the time being they lack the income to afford that decent level of comfort without assistance. So helping them is the moral thing to do.

So, why aren't you helping?
 
Back
Top