New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Flame wars - Moderator actions

Dave

Council Member
It's been a busy day of reading dozens of pm's and reported posts. I am a little sick to be honest. Since October we've had to make constant rule additions and modifications to try to keep some old battles that happened on a site we had nothing to do with from happening here.

We have tried many things, including infractions on the dumbest of things, to giving slack, and adding moderators. The moderator panel is here to stay and is end of line for us in terms of dealing with these old battles, that once again Jon, Chris, and myself simply do not want here.

The moderators have been asked to help us end these by deleting threads that start in on the BS and warning those that partake in these mini-battles. They have been doing a fine job, even while taking an IMMENSE amount of heat from members of this forum that are on the opposite side of the isle as them. Thank you mods, we really appreciate your efforts.

For those of you bashing the mods in the public forums I'll kindly ask you one time to refrain from doing so. From now on if you have a complaint about a moderator I'm all ears, and ask that you send the complaint to me in PM's. The moderators are all volunteers, are not getting paid, and are doing this for the reason of improving the forum. If you think a specific mod is out to get you, you are sorely mistaken. The moderators all post their actions in our moderator section and hold each other accountable. In other words, if you are on the right politically, the left mods don't have the ability to pick on you. If you think they are, talk to a right aligned moderator about it or myself.

Take my word for it, they are not picking on you. If anything, it's my fault. We have been working on a set of guidelines (and will continue to do so) and they are all doing their best to follow them. Their actions are a direct result of the protocols that I have put in place.

Back to my original point. We don't want the old wars to continue here and after about 4 or 5 months of us asking you all nicely, we are at the end of our ropes. The moderators will be deleting posts that don't discuss politics and instead are meant solely to attack another forum member. They are not out to censor you, we don't want you to feel like you are walking on egg shells, but we don't want the name calling and crap from the past on Political Jack anymore. Don't know how to ask anymore so the bans are going to start if you keep it up. It is YOUR CHOICE, not mine. If you keep doing it, I will be forced to ban you. I've had dozens of conversations with some of you in pm's/emails, and I just can't let it slide anymore. I think a few of you have the goal to get banned for some reason, and it's unfortunate because I think everyone has the mental capacity to have an intelligent conversation here.

I'll leave this thread open until the flaming starts, we'll see how far it gets.
 
I am really in the dark about this. What kind of old (Ballot Box I suppose) battles are still raging on this forum ? Because this place, as far as I can tell, it looks NOTHING like what you used to see on that front page of that forum.
 
Good luck. Some of those old battles from days gone by are never going to end and are eventually going to get people banned. I wouldn't worry about it a bit if I were you - they'll just go some place else and drag the discourse at that site down into the mire they enjoy wallowing in.

I say Goodbye and good riddance.
 
ANY posters having received warnings or infractions within this past month need to reassess posting habits. This is NOT a Left of Center versus a Right of Center problem.
 
Good luck mate!!!

The fact is the BB crowd from the slate can be very rude, mean, and let face it stubborn when it come to letting the past go... I for one was one of those posters over there and could lie by sayin' I never did anything wrong, but the fact is I broke every rule at the Slate just for the fun of it...

Now I am not proud of that, and just stating the fact, and trying to tell you that those you write about are most likely laughing at you, and saying to themselves give it your best shot...

The only way you will end the flame wars from the BB days is booting all of the old Slate members from your site...

So again Good Luck Mate and hope you can get a little peace in here, but in the end as long as the BB crew is here there will never be peace...

P.S.

I promise you will know when I flame because your inbox will be filled with complaints from both right, left, and the nutters of this site, but I prefer not to do that anymore.
 
We have tried many things, including infractions on the dumbest of things, to giving slack, and adding moderators. The moderator panel is here to stay and is end of line for us in terms of dealing with these old battles, that once again Jon, Chris, and myself simply do not want here.

The moderators are all volunteers, are not getting paid, and are doing this for the reason of improving the forum. If you think a specific mod is out to get you, you are sorely mistaken. The moderators all post their actions in our moderator section and hold each other accountable. In other words, if you are on the right politically, the left mods don't have the ability to pick on you. If you think they are, talk to a right aligned moderator about it or myself.

Take my word for it, they are not picking on you. If anything, it's my fault. We have been working on a set of guidelines (and will continue to do so) and they are all doing their best to follow them. Their actions are a direct result of the protocols that I have put in place.

The moderator panel may be here to stay, but it isn't going to work. You are taking people with long standing grudges towards one another, and then giving a few of them the authority to punish the others. A recipe for disaster if I ever saw one.

As far as the rest of what I included in my quote is concerned, it's all very nice sentiment, but quite frankly without having your own involvement in the Slate forums you can't know how wrong you are. Unless you make everybody a moderator with the power to punish every other poster, all you are doing is handing a gun to one party in a fist fight and telling them to go easy on the one you left unarmed. And in at least one case the people you have chosen as moderators are among the biggest game players and flame baiters on the board. You've put some of the bloodiest, nuttiest turds in charge of the toilet bowl, and are expecting the other turds to respect their authority.

I appreciate what you are trying to do, but your efforts are doomed to failure.

So what next? Ban most of the posters that have come here from the other site? Might work, but if you leave even one former Slate poster here, many of the others will just keep coming back under new names and stirring the turd bowl up again. One alternative might be a flame room, where everything goes. It seems the problems don't come so much from the insults themselves but from the perceived double standard in enforcement of the rules. Make a room where no rules apply, or just the bare minimum of rules so nobody can try to sue you(no "n" word, for example), and make it clear that you will entertain no complaints about posts from that room, and will have zero tolerance for battles that leave the confines of the room.

Slate posters and in particular Ballot Box posters have been flinging turds at each other for years, and have been able to handle it for years. Now that they have the ability to tattle on one another and in some cases actually punish one another, they are predictably using these new abilities as nothing more than extra playing pieces in their little games. Games that in at least one case and with at least one of your chosen moderators, you have endorsed.

It will be interesting to see how this evolves, in the same way that it is interesting to gawk at car accidents on the highway.

Edit: what you are seeing on political boards such as this one is also what we are seeing in our national political discourse in general. Alinski's rules for radicals and the politics of personal destruction are no longer just the methods for the extreme fringes, it has gone mainstream. It may just be par for the course when it comes to these types of forums nowadays, and nothing you can do will stop it, without killing what you are trying to save.
 
Good luck. Wish people could just debate sans the immature behavior.

Maybe you need me to talk to these naughty posters. Part of my job in law enforcement was talking to bad people and making them see things my way. :D
 
Good luck. Wish people could just debate sans the immature behavior.

Maybe you need me to talk to these naughty posters. Part of my job in law enforcement was talking to bad people and making them see things my way. :D

Mr. Whispers,

How would you beat an handcuffed poster with a bag of oranges so it leaves no mark over the internet....;<)
 
While I disagree with setting up a forum for foul behavior, and I have higher hopes for PJ moderators, I do recognize the voice of experience. Pogue has been around the fray from its beginning and his observations are tried and true. Which is to say, he knows these posters as well as anybody.... so it behooves PJ to heed his advice.
 
Actually, I know of two other forums that are having the exact same problems, arguments, enforcement issues, etc. that PJ has been having. So yeah...it's going mainstream and is not unique to just here.

Edit: what you are seeing on political boards such as this one is also what we are seeing in our national political discourse in general. Alinski's rules for radicals and the politics of personal destruction are no longer just the methods for the extreme fringes, it has gone mainstream. It may just be par for the course when it comes to these types of forums nowadays, and nothing you can do will stop it, without killing what you are trying to save.
 
Well I for one am getting tired of being reported for responding to stupid things that are posted by people that are just plain lies or meant hurt or start arguments. Yes it's hard to stay on the straight and narrow and not be infuriated at some of the meanness, but I guess I will have to really pay attention to how i respond, as I don't know who it is that can't take any criticism, whether it's the person or someone else turning us in.

I tried that crap a couple of times but saw it was just hurting me so I have refused to do it any more. Maybe some of you guys should do the same, because when your pushing your views your going to piss someone off.

I would like to know who it is, that is constantly turning people in, is it the same person over and over or is it the one who was responded too. I will have to be better I guess, and there are few people who maybe I will just refuse to reply to.
 
Thanks, Jack. We're working hard to make it good.

Good luck mate!!!

The fact is the BB crowd from the slate can be very rude, mean, and let face it stubborn when it come to letting the past go... I for one was one of those posters over there and could lie by sayin' I never did anything wrong, but the fact is I broke every rule at the Slate just for the fun of it...

Now I am not proud of that, and just stating the fact, and trying to tell you that those you write about are most likely laughing at you, and saying to themselves give it your best shot...

The only way you will end the flame wars from the BB days is booting all of the old Slate members from your site...

So again Good Luck Mate and hope you can get a little peace in here, but in the end as long as the BB crew is here there will never be peace...

P.S.

I promise you will know when I flame because your inbox will be filled with complaints from both right, left, and the nutters of this site, but I prefer not to do that anymore.
 
your definition of intelligent conversation may differ from someone elses and it seems its a "my ball and my definition or im taking my ball and going home!"
 
Back
Top