New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Here is another question

Judy1

Mayor
If I am not jewish but work for a jewish employer, and I travel on business and get a meal allowance, if the practice is to reimburse for meal allowances, do I have to eat only kosher food in order to get that meal allowance?
 
If they are paying for your meal, they most certainly should be able to tell you what to eat. Is there no end to your inflated sense of entitlement?
 
If they are paying for your meal, they most certainly should be able to tell you what to eat. Is there no end to your inflated sense of entitlement?

Lol.. that was a satirical answer right Lukey?

It's an allowance and as such can be used for any kind of food Judy wishes to eat.
 
I know this is hypothetical, so when I say "you"/ "your" in my answer it doesn't specifically mean "you" - it's general.

Your meal allowance us meant to pay for meals, so you can eat whatever you usually eat. However, if it were me, I would know my employer well enough to discuss it with him/ her.

It goes back to the same premise though.......... whoever pays gets to call the shots. You might get money from someone no strings attached, but many times strings are attached and the giver of the money can do that.
 
If this is a health care related question the premise is not a good one though... most strict sects probably wouldn't hire non Jews... conversely most that would hire you wouldn't force you to follow their religious beliefs. The Jewish religion runs from liberal to very fundamentalist sects- like most of our religions here. From what I have seen most would fall under very forgiving and respectful if you were a non Jew.

But we might have to wait till after sunset tonight to get an answer? My near Zionist friend from Cali won't respond to facebook until then...
So when I want to piss him off I wait til Friday night to answer a post... His rebuttal is at least 24 hours away... ;0)

The nice things is about Kosher laws is with a few exceptions "all rules are made to be broken" so to speak... if it saves a life?




If I am not jewish but work for a jewish employer, and I travel on business and get a meal allowance, if the practice is to reimburse for meal allowances, do I have to eat only kosher food in order to get that meal allowance?
 
This question raises an interesting conundrum, that I think has gotten short shrift in the context of this whole discussion around some of the Catholic Bishop's feelings. We assume that eating kosher is a matter of "principle" worthy of especial protection. But, we seem to forget that NOT eating kosher must be considered equally principled and worthy of protection. And, anyone who's mind quick-diverts to the personal feeling that "non-kosher" isn't the equivalent of kosher, is missing the point. For as soon as we get to feeling that we get to arbitrate what's valid and what's not, we're obviating the essential idea of "freedom of belief".

The SAME is true, in the context of contraception. Some people are convinced that as a matter of "principle", contraception is bad. Many others...are convinced that as a matter of principle, contraception is good.
 
This question raises an interesting conundrum, that I think has gotten short shrift in the context of this whole discussion around some of the Catholic Bishop's feelings. We assume that eating kosher is a matter of "principle" worthy of especial protection. But, we seem to forget that NOT eating kosher must be considered equally principled and worthy of protection. And, anyone who's mind quick-diverts to the personal feeling that "non-kosher" isn't the equivalent of kosher, is missing the point. For as soon as we get to feeling that we get to arbitrate what's valid and what's not, we're obviating the essential idea of "freedom of belief".

The SAME is true, in the context of contraception. Some people are convinced that as a matter of "principle", contraception is bad. Many others...are convinced that as a matter of principle, contraception is good.

The further we get from the guy paying the bill getting to call the shots, the closer we are to communism...
 
This question raises an interesting conundrum, that I think has gotten short shrift in the context of this whole discussion around some of the Catholic Bishop's feelings. We assume that eating kosher is a matter of "principle" worthy of especial protection. But, we seem to forget that NOT eating kosher must be considered equally principled and worthy of protection. And, anyone who's mind quick-diverts to the personal feeling that "non-kosher" isn't the equivalent of kosher, is missing the point. For as soon as we get to feeling that we get to arbitrate what's valid and what's not, we're obviating the essential idea of "freedom of belief".

The SAME is true, in the context of contraception. Some people are convinced that as a matter of "principle", contraception is bad. Many others...are convinced that as a matter of principle, contraception is good.

You are getting closer to my point, FS. I think the point I'm getting at is that while religious employers have a right to practice their religion, and I wouldn't argue that a catholic hospital has a right not to perform abortions, freedom of religion also encompasses freedom from religion, in that if they are buying a health plan for their employees, the choice for their catholic employees is whether to engage in accepting that birth control coverage or not, but it should not be up to them to dictate birth control coverage for their non catholic employees. And, if you look at Georgetown's health insurance policy for their 2000+ employees, they do not restrict birth control coverage from their 2012 policy.
 
If the owner of a company is a vegan...Said owner I guess should demand the employees on meal allowance only eat vegan...I know most of these Republican types would have no problem with that....If they went out for a steak...That could lead America down the road to Communism
 
You are getting closer to my point, FS. I think the point I'm getting at is that while religious employers have a right to practice their religion, and I wouldn't argue that a catholic hospital has a right not to perform abortions, freedom of religion also encompasses freedom from religion, in that if they are buying a health plan for their employees, the choice for their catholic employees is whether to engage in accepting that birth control coverage or not, but it should not be up to them to dictate birth control coverage for their non catholic employees. And, if you look at Georgetown's health insurance policy for their 2000+ employees, they do not restrict birth control coverage from their 2012 policy.

I've babbled around this before, but we all know that every "right" must be balanced against another. It's virtually impossible for us to extend, codify, or formalize a right for one or some, without it coming at the cost of some one or some other's right. Society EXISTS, so's to consider those trade-offs and achieve amenable balance. None of us would insist that free speech "right" to holler "fire" in a crowded theater, must be upheld as a function of some sort of mythical Constitutional "absoluteness".

Yet...that doesn't seem to prevent people from making this absoluteness argument at their whim, and seeming to "feel" that it's the be all, and end all. As a Catholic, I know godamned well that the various GOP states before the latest Obama ruling on contraception, and Obama himself, have gone out of their way to offering "The Bishops" a rights-balance pathway, that can suit everyone's righteous sensibilities just fine.

There's no reason whatsoever - no matter what some narrow minded partisans might tell you - for "The Bishops" to be drawing this line in the sand. They don't have to do it, in order to fulfill their mandate. And, I'll go so far as to suggest that by picking this particular political fight, they're actually VIOLATING their obligation to God. Their obligation is to resolve conflict, not engender it.
 
If I am not jewish but work for a jewish employer, and I travel on business and get a meal allowance, if the practice is to reimburse for meal allowances, do I have to eat only kosher food in order to get that meal allowance?


I think I need more information from you, Judy.

As far as the Jewish employer, does he tell his employees to only eat Kosher with the money he gives them? Does he somehow interrogate them or put them through some test to verify what they ate with the money he gave them? Of course not.

But let's say your Jewish employer who you say keeps kosher offers to go buy lunch for everyone in the office on Mondays. It's a new employee perk he's offering. And you order a ham and cheese sandwich. I don't know if his commitment to keeping kosher prohibits him from buying that for you. We'd have to ask him if he's allowed to provide that. But if he's asking people not to buy nonkosher food with the money he gives them for expenses, I bet he's not going to want to be the guy ordering it and bringing to you.

So let's say his commitment to keeping Kosher prevents him from supplying the lunch you asked for, and he says he can't buy it for you but he'll buy you something else. Maybe the place he's going to doesn't even prepare ham.....or cheese together with any meat. Is he infringing on your rights because he's providinig something in good faith to you, but not everything everyone has a right to eat? Does the new perk he's giving now become a violation of your individual rights? Are you going to make a giant stink to the point where the poor guy is going to feel forced to abandon this thing he's offering his employees?

Or do you think you'll be able to muster up some empathy for the idea that he believes with all his heart and soul that he can't be involved in providing something his God rules is defiling to the human bodies He created and to the law He expects the faithful to follow?
 
I've babbled around this before, but we all know that every "right" must be balanced against another. It's virtually impossible for us to extend, codify, or formalize a right for one or some, without it coming at the cost of some one or some other's right. Society EXISTS, so's to consider those trade-offs and achieve amenable balance. None of us would insist that free speech "right" to holler "fire" in a crowded theater, must be upheld as a function of some sort of mythical Constitutional "absoluteness".

Yet...that doesn't seem to prevent people from making this absoluteness argument at their whim, and seeming to "feel" that it's the be all, and end all. As a Catholic, I know godamned well that the various GOP states before the latest Obama ruling on contraception, and Obama himself, have gone out of their way to offering "The Bishops" a rights-balance pathway, that can suit everyone's righteous sensibilities just fine.

There's no reason whatsoever - no matter what some narrow minded partisans might tell you - for "The Bishops" to be drawing this line in the sand. They don't have to do it, in order to fulfill their mandate. And, I'll go so far as to suggest that by picking this particular political fight, they're actually VIOLATING their obligation to God. Their obligation is to resolve conflict, not engender it.


fairsheet, Absolutely the GOP is going to build the bandwagon and jump on it and power it, too! But I think the point to continue to consider is.....where'd the inspiration come from? It came from the mandate.

The bishops job is not to resolve conflict by going along with anything they're asked to do when they believe it violates what God commands them to do. Jesus didn't resolve conflict. He caused some conflict. He said....houses would be divided over Him. HE watched people walk away in droves one day because of something He said, "Whoever doesn't eat My Flesh and drink My Blood........"
That scandalized people and they left Him. He didn't say, "wait a minute, come back, maybe we can work something out..."
He loved those people. He wanted them to follow Him. But He wasnt' compromising the truth for them.

Not everyone believes what the Catholic bishops do about contraception. But the bishops do. And they can't compromise WHAT THEY BELIEVE is the truth. If Christ didn't do it to the point where He was tortured and murdered, then they have even less power to do it.
 
What about the simple answer that if your employer is buying your lunch he indeed has a right to tell you what he will buy. And if you don't want to eat that, you can pay for your own? When the leftie is invited to a dinner party, does he get to set the menu?
 
if they cant do what is required of employers, then they shud get out of the business of employing people.
 
Back
Top