New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Historical Question.

Or put it another way. The amount of debt that exceeds the GDP is LESS THAN what Obama inheritted coming into office (9 trillion).

The debt currently is 109% of GDP.

The Debt, as a percentage of GDP when Obama took office was 75% of GDP.

Facts DO matter, and yours are wrong.
 
The debt currently is 109% of GDP.

The Debt, as a percentage of GDP when Obama took office was 75% of GDP.

Facts DO matter, and yours are wrong.

You are correct on that. But remember that 85% of that debt is due to GOP poliices Obama either directly or indirectly inherited. Remember 1/3 of the debt Obama inheritted was created by the Patron Saint of Conservativism - the holy Ronald Reagan (and it actually was higher than that, but GHWB got the blame for the TARP costs even though it was Reagan's policies that caused the crash).
 
Lastly the roads were built BEFORE road taxes were enough to ay for them. IN fact the whole Interstate Highway system was built using Defense Department funds and authority.


So what? They made possible the transportation of goods for commerce. Totally constitutional and EVERYBODY benefited through the more efficient transportation of food and other goods. And the efficient transportation of war materials and troops is essential for national defense.

That means that the WORKERS who built the trucks and cars that used the roads benefited as did the WORKERS who built the parts for those trucks and cars benefited, and the people that drove those trucks and cars benefited, and the people that made those goods benefited and the people who SOLD those goods that were transported in those trucks and cars benefited and the persons who purchased those goods that were now readily available benefited.


Road construction was not forcibly taking wealth from one man and giving it to another. And if gas and transportation taxes were used for solely what they are intended for, they would be totally sufficient to pay for that maintenance.

Why is it that liberals have such a difficult time understanding the difference between necessary taxation for constitutional authorized functions and taxation simply used to unconstitutionally violate private property rights and redistribute wealth.

Maybe because they're incapable of logical thought?

Since ALL societies throughout history have engaged in redistribution of wealth, this is a nonsense claim

Hardly nonsense, because if you look at historical fact, you quickly realize that most societies ended up as tyrannical police states.

And that's how we'll end up if we follow the same pattern.
 
So I assume Sarge supports the radical libertarian view of scrapping everything done on domestic policy back to the 1890s?
 
"Road construction was not forcibly taking wealth from one man and giving it to another. "

So you the taxpayer don't pay the construction worker? Who does?
 
You are correct on that. But remember that 85% of that debt is due to GOP poliices Obama either directly or indirectly inherited.

Wrong again the debt Obama inherited was incurred by many presidents, especially Democrats and Republicans such as Wilson Hoover and FDR.

And Obama's part of the debt, per year in office is greater than any other president in our history.

Interest rates are most surely going to go up eventually. In 10 years even at a relatively low interest rate 5%, just the interest on the debt will be over a trillion dollars, double our national defense budget.

Obama's budget doesn't cut ANYTHING. his budget actually is larger than this year's budget. He cuts some money in one program but adds it to another program and the tax increases in the budget go for increased spending not deficit reduction.

It's the same Democrat smoke an mirrors which depends on the ignorance of the populace.

And even though budgets are not subject to filibuster and only need a simple majority to pass, Harry Reid and the Democrats won't bring it up for a vote so they, once again , depending on ignorance of the voters, with help from their media propagandists, will accuse Republicans of blocking it.
 
You might start at the time roads were built using taxpayer money to accommodate the needs of the automobile industry. That may have been the first instance of government giving hand outs to the wealthy. It's never stopped....................

Since that never happened, it's as good a place as any to start -- and stop.
 
Wrong again the debt Obama inherited was incurred by many presidents, especially Democrats and Republicans such as Wilson Hoover and FDR.
No - the debt going into Reagan was Less than $1 Trillion.
Reagan added $3.5 TRillion
GHWB added $1.5 or so trilion
Clinton added $1 Trillion
GWB added $5 trillion.

Take out GWB, Reagan and GHWB. and you have a National debt that is $1.9 Trillion vs. $11+ Trillion.

FACTS MATTER

And Obama's part of the debt, per year in office is greater than any other president in our history.
Um nope. not adjusted for inflation. Adjust for inflation and coming out of The Great Depression our Defict spending was greater. And since this crash was the 2nd biggest as a funciton of GDP and the biggest in absolute terms, that's not surprising.

Interest rates are most surely going to go up eventually. In 10 years even at a relatively low interest rate 5%,
And the current interest rate is ... -0.1%. So your 5% estimate is a bit self serving. Historically the US Debt has cost around 3%-4%.


Obama's budget doesn't cut ANYTHING. his budget actually is larger than this year's budget
and the population is bigger
and we have 2% inflation
and GDP is growing.

yes and?


And even though budgets are not subject to filibuster and only need a simple majority to pass, Harry Reid and the Democrats won't bring it up for a vote
Budget bills have to originiate in the House. So when is Boehner going to bring this bill to the floor?
 
No - the debt going into Reagan was Less than $1 Trillion.
Reagan added $3.5 TRillion
GHWB added $1.5 or so trilion
Clinton added $1 Trillion
GWB added $5 trillion.

Among the facts that matter is that while a president presents congress with a budget, Congress controls the final purse strings. An additional fact (which would apparently matter) is that seven out of eight of Reagan's budgets were balanced when they went to Congress. As Reagan never faced a Republican controlled Congress, the excess spending of that era is as much or more a Democrat creation as it is a Republican one. While you cite that Clinton added an additional trillion, you gloss over it. GWB increased spending -- the nation was at war and expenditures go up during a war.

Take out GWB, Reagan and GHWB. and you have a National debt that is $1.9 Trillion vs. $11+ Trillion.

No proof of that at all especially as Congress was controlled exclusively by the Democratic Party during the terms of both Reagan and GHWB.

Um nope. not adjusted for inflation. Adjust for inflation and coming out of The Great Depression our Defict spending was greater. And since this crash was the 2nd biggest as a funciton of GDP and the biggest in absolute terms, that's not surprising.

And the deficit spending at the time of the Depression didn't work, hence the "Roosevelt Recession" in 1938 (you'll claim this happened because Roosevelt reduced spending about that time, but most economic historians disagree).
 
when it became life, liberty and the guarantee - rather than pursuit - of happiness.

the other disgusting trend is the statist's desire to penalize success. that the few - who persevere, work hard, fail and pick themselves back up again - and succeed, somehow owe those who didn't.

the top 20% of income earners is extremely fluid. i've read a figure as high as 57% of those in one year are out the next. just like the bottom quintile is fluid. people don't stay poor in America. Same with corporations who's profitability varies from year to year.

so I guess the lib's ideology is to penalize us when successful and subsidize us when we fail.

I always wanted a big brother
 
When did the idea of getting something for free being called a right begin?

Since nothing is free, someone has to pay for it So when a person gets something for free from the government some other person is paying for it.

We've now advance even that radical idea. We are now saying that not having something provided for free is the same as saying we are DENYING ACCESS to it. This is an expansion of getting something for free being a right.

I believe, that if we could find the exact point in our history where getting something for free started being considered a right, we could find the exact point in our history that we began our national decline, by getting away from the basic TRUE RIGHTS that were given in the Constitution that made this country the leading economic power in the world, basically the RIGHT TO PRIVATE PROPERTY an the right to INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY that prevents your private property from being confiscated forcibly by government.

We're increasingly having our individual liberty and private property confiscated to an ever greater degree. If this continues we are headed for economic and totalitarian misery that will affect each and every American. There will be no escaping it.




The problem you don't understand Sarge is this country does not belong to anyone. It belongs to all of us. And the country has one thing that must be held up high and that is, what is the general welfare of the nation.

What is best for the people of this nation as whole, not just for a small group who have been able to use what is provided to them to capture what this country has and want to call their own. This is why we have always had an inheritance tax and a gift tax to stop generational ownership from being passed on that would allow a small group of people to gather much larger portions of control of our country that was deemed logical or acceptable to the founding fathers. They wanted a land that was of the people.

The old adage was it's yours till death do you part, when you became dead your wealth that the country allowed you to have and use also left your ownership.

But greed has taken over this country and the desire to have more and more of the ownership of this country has blinded us to the a beautiful idea of a free nation that is devoted to the care and needs of our people as a whole. Now is the call for allowing a few to control all things and the rest of America to be at their beckon call.
 
You guys have the word "free" on the brain. I don't recall Obama even using it more than once or twice in three years.

Btw, you can spend $70 or so once a year servicing your air conditioner and furnace, or you can spend 6 grand or so replacing them. Which do you prefer?

Totalitarian misery? Lol.. you guys will clearly be miserable until 2016. But don't worry, Obama won't take your guns or march you to the guillotine. :D


ah shucks, I was beginning to believe those on the right that this will happen, now you have spoiled it Bo-4
 
The problem you don't understand Sarge is this country does not belong to anyone. It belongs to all of us. And the country has one thing that must be held up high and that is, what is the general welfare of the nation.

That is true -- but only if you ignore the historical use of the words "general welfare" as they applied to the U.S. Constitution prior to the 1930s. Before that time, tax dollars could be spent on only things that benefited the "general welfare" (the military, the post office) and not on things that benefitted specific portions of the population (farmers, the elderly, the indigent).

What is best for the people of this nation as whole, not just for a small group who have been able to use what is provided to them to capture what this country has and want to call their own. This is why we have always had an inheritance tax and a gift tax to stop generational ownership from being passed on that would allow a small group of people to gather much larger portions of control of our country that was deemed logical or acceptable to the founding fathers.

Actually this isn't true -- there hasn't always been an inheritance tax. The estate tax was first imposed in 1916, alongside the newly imposed income tax.

The old adage was it's yours till death do you part, when you became dead your wealth that the country allowed you to have and use also left your ownership.

"Until death do us part" is a part of traditional Christian marriage vows. The country doesn't "allow" an individual to build wealth, at least not in a free country. Individuals work to build wealth, or they may inherit some wealth, and it isn't up to the government to permit, deny, or otherwise interfere with the individual in that pursuit. And before your die you are, or should be, allowed to make plans for the disposition of your wealth (which is YOURS and not "the country's") as you see fit.
 
That is true -- but only if you ignore the historical use of the words "general welfare" as they applied to the U.S. Constitution prior to the 1930s.
You mean these??? http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/a1_8_1s21.html

The terms "general Welfare" were doubtless intended to signify more than was expressed or imported in those which Preceded; otherwise numerous exigencies incident to the affairs of a Nation would have been left without a provision. The phrase is as comprehensive as any that could have been used; because it was not fit that the constitutional authority of the Union, to appropriate its revenues shou'd have been restricted within narrower limits than the "General Welfare" and because this necessarily embraces a vast variety of particulars, which are susceptible neither of specification nor of definition.

It is therefore of necessity left to the discretion of the National Legislature, to pronounce, upon the objects, which concern the general Welfare, and for which under that description, an appropriation of money is requisite and proper.​
​
Written in 1789 AFTER ratification of the 10th Amendment.. Written by one of the Founding Fathers who was actually ON the committee that drafted the General Welfare clause?

The estate tax was first imposed in 1916, alongside the newly imposed income tax.
Not quite. Inheritance WOULD HAVE BEEN INcome covered by the income tax. Instead an TAX EXEMPTION was carved out for part of the inherited income... It is a TAX EXEMPTION not a tax.

"Until death do us part" is a part of traditional Christian marriage vows. The country doesn't "allow" an individual to build wealth, at least not in a free country.
Sure it does. Particularly if your "free country" - like the USA at the time of Constitutonal Ratification - did not convey property rights to women - and hence the Marriage Dowry became the way to build wealth by merging the assets of two families into one

Historic facts matter Trap... but you have to include ALL OF THEM. even the inconvenient bits about what Founding Father's wrote about General Welfare and how Jefferson used General Welfare in the Louisiana Purchase and how women did not have personhood rights in a "free country" and have never Constitutionally had them granted. So using your logic of "founding fathers" they should not have them now.
 
People that use the roads pay for them through transportation and fuel taxes, and the roads were built, not to accomodate the automobile industry, they were built to accommodate the people that use automobiles.so the people that use automobiles are paying for something they use and not receiving them for free. If you don't use an automobile, you don't pay the gas and transportation taxes. That is what we call taxation with representation.

Governments can't give anything to the wealthy as it is the wealthy that pay for the bulk of government. All governments can do is let the people that 'earn ' the money, keep more for it, or take more if it.

Where liberals always make their mistake with regards to government spending, is the difference between taxation which is used to fund the essential functions of government (National Defense, Foreign policy and the State Department, Regulating ACTUAL commerce, and other specifics outlined in article one section eight of the Constitution, and taxation that is used for re-distribution to pay for SOMEONE ELSE'S food, housing, education, medical care, school lunches, etc.

Get it now? It is the redistributive actions of government that end up bankrupting nations and destroying civil societies.

And it can and will happen here, if we don't get away from the idea of getting something for nothing.


Oh my , you left out "Bail-Outs to Banks , Insurance Companys etc... to cover the losses of poor investments.

Must have ben an over-sight on your part I'm sure.
 
Among the facts that matter is that while a president presents congress with a budget, Congress controls the final purse strings
and different Parties deal differently. Dems basically gave Reagan 90% of what he wanted. Same with GHWB and with GWB. Unlike the GOP minority in 2009, the Dem minority in 2001 did NOT engage in unprecedented levels of filibustering.

Clinton increased the national debt by $1 trillion about 20% of his predecessors.

And GWB's deficits took place because unlike previous "wars" he took this one "off the books" precisely because of ideology.

Take out GWB, Reagan and GHWB. and you have a National debt that is $1.9 Trillion vs. $11+ Trillion.
No proof of that at all especially as Congress was controlled exclusively by the Democratic Party during the terms of both Reagan and GHWB.
Of course there is Trap. Look at the Reagan tax cuts... They reduced tax collections as a percent of GDP, and as a percent of expenditures. No Reagan? No massive deficits.

Ibid GWB.

And the deficit spending at the time of the Depression didn't work,
Sorry it did.

you'll claim this happened because Roosevelt reduced spending about that time, but most economic historians disagree).
Actually no. the ONLY economic historians that "disagree" are those that are hard core ideologues. the vast majority recognize that the spending cuts in 1937 lead directly to the drop in GDP

Look at the DJIA curve and the GDP curve
astockcharts.com_freecharts_historical_images_djia1900s.png

File:Gdp20-40.jpg

GDP.jpg
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gdp20-40.jpg
Notice the steady increase in GDP at TWICE the growth rate prior to the crash from '33-'37? then the crash in '37, then the resumption of the steep GDP growth curve from '39 onwards when defiict spending for the "war effort" began again?

Gosh that has no correlation to spending does it
awww_usgovernmentspending_com_usgs_line_php_c8842f94db6d6598fe59e1bafe6324ea._.pnghttp://www.usgovernmentspending.com...p_13s1li011lcn_F0t_Spending_As_Percent_Of_GDP
Boy am I embarassed about how wrong I just proved myself..


Sorry Deficit spending during the Depression worked. The Roosevelt Recession was a direct result of the drop in spending in '37 and was "fixed" 18 mos later by massive defiit spending for the war effort.

I'm not "making a claim" - I'm showing you data. And I can also point you to economists that debunk your minorty "economic historian" view
http://debunkingeconomics.com/samples/misunderstanding-the-crisis/
 
You mean these??? http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/a1_8_1s21.html

@Degs: I'm not going to play duelling quotes with you again. None of the people you cite were the primary author of the Constitution. That was Madison, who had a view of general welfare 180 degress from your quotations (and whose views prevailed from the adoption of the Constitution through the 1930s with only a few variations).


Not quite. Inheritance WOULD HAVE BEEN INcome covered by the income tax. Instead an TAX EXEMPTION was carved out for part of the inherited income... It is a TAX EXEMPTION not a tax.

Odd -- no such exemption appears in the actual law. What appears in the law is a rated tax on estates above a given value (that's also what was in the law circa 1916 when it was first imposed). There is no "exemption" from income tax -- the estate tax was created at the same time as the income tax. Inheritance was never taxed under income tax.

Sure it does. Particularly if your "free country" - like the USA at the time of Constitutonal Ratification - did not convey property rights to women - and hence the Marriage Dowry became the way to build wealth by merging the assets of two families into one

Private property is not a matter of public power. You are not "permitted" to build wealth in a free country -- you either do so or you don't and whether you do so or not is not the government's business (where, in the Constitution which lays out those areas where the government has authority, is this authority to permit people to build wealth? I think there's a general statement that except in a few areas where the government has control, the people are on their own to build wealth any legal way they can -- via business, trade, marriage dowery or casino gambling.

"Historic facts" do indeed matter -- and Jefferson said himself that he was violating the Constitution when he made the Liousiana Purchase (he may not have been -- the government has the authority to acquire new territory, and the methodolgy to do so isn't a prescribed one). Nonetheless, you cannot find a widespread expansive use of the "general welfare" authority before the court's flip flop on the matter in Helvering v. Davis. That's why we didn't have the alphabet soup of federal agencies that exist today prior to that time.
 
and different Parties deal differently. Dems basically gave Reagan 90% of what he wanted. Same with GHWB and with GWB. Unlike the GOP minority in 2009, the Dem minority in 2001 did NOT engage in unprecedented levels of filibustering.

No, Degs, the Democratic Party didn't give Reagan "90 percent of what he wanted," because among that 90 percent were specifically named social program cuts that balanced his budgets. The Democrats refused those cuts, taking the budgets out of balance and causing the deficit spending of the Reagan administration. Reagan presented budgets that had 100 percent of what he wanted -- and seven of eight of those budgets were balanced.


And GWB's deficits took place because unlike previous "wars" he took this one "off the books" precisely because of ideology.

How he spent the money is irrelevant to the fact that it was spent, on or off the books, and was spent in the name of warfare, which costs money.

Of
course there is Trap. Look at the Reagan tax cuts... They reduced tax collections as a percent of GDP, and as a percent of expenditures. No Reagan? No massive deficits.

No Congressional refusal of Reagan's program cuts, no massive deficits. Who has final control of the budget under the Constitution? Oh, yeah.



The graphs you display are too fine for me to read (I can see the lines, but not the corresponding dates, which are too small). I do think, however, that you will find any historical interpretation that disagrees with you to have come from a "hard core ideologue" no matter how well researched.

And FDR's expenditures were not where we originated. We originated with the three financial crises that took place in the 30-year period prior to 1913. None of these were resolved with government deficit spending, even if I agreed with you that FDR's expenditures "solved" the Depression. I can actuallly read the numbers in your final graph -- where's the big hike in government spending 1907 or 1913? That's right, there isn't one because not every financial crisis in the last 125 years (your original claim) was resolved by such spending. (And what your numbers appear show is a sluggish recovery until the onset of WWII.)

Housekeeping -- in the future, would you merely link to the graphs? I think they'd display better, and they wouldn't mess up my screen format when I'm responding.
 
Back
Top