If you mean "small" only in terms of employee count, that's fine. But employee count isn't a very sensible way to count business size. The Baupost Group has 42 employees. But it's not some local car dealership or landscaping service. It's a $30 billion hedge fund. It's "bigger," in terms of value, than Time Warner, Halliburton, International Paper, or McDonalds. By any "actual business person's standards," it's a big business, employee count notwithstanding.Arkady,
Do you realize a business could do a million dollars in volume - EASY and employ three or four people - max? I have clients that do 10 million and only employ 12 or 15 people at any one time and half of them family. That is STILL a small business by any actual business persons standards. In fact, below a million or so is a micro-business. Those businesses -don't even practically register or count as a business in my opinion. They are the kind of clients that if they didn't have some serious potential, I would politely tell them to go to some bookkeeping or tax service to get their work done. They aren't even a real player.
My point about the downsizing is the overall impact of what one company wants to do. The idea that big companies controlling the economy as being a bad thing - goes back all the way to Teddy Roosevelt and trust busting. Like anything else - to minimize risk - diversify. The more businesses we have, the less the overall impact will be when one fails. Thus we should be encouraging small private business growth.
connie
Yep. I'm aware of that. In my professional life I need to be conversant in their silly definitions.As additional consideration - here is what the SBA considers "small" by industry.
http://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/files/Size_Standards_Table.pdf
If you want to insist on your particular definition, that's fine. However, in that case what percentage of Americans do you think would be in the "middle," using your definition? I think we end up with a functionally useless definition, akin to saying that anywhere in the middle 98% of a football field is "midfield." Heck, it's worse than that. If you're only counting controlling shareholders and CEOs of big companies, the "upper class" might be a tenth of a percent of the nation, which is a truly useless definition for everyday conversations.I disagree completely. The relevant factor IS how they make their money, not the money they make. That is exactly how you determine "class". Middle class is middle management, owners of small businesses, scholars, professionals. Simply choosing to or not making the most of your economic opportuntiies - and thus earning less than your contemporaries, does not change your class. Controlling shareholders in publically traded companies, the CEO's, etc - and those who do not work at all for a living but are high income people - are the upper class - becasue they predominantly make their money off of other people's work -without being part of the actual work itself. The working class are your standard laborer's office workers, etc -anyone whose position lacks much authority or autonomy.
The side playing the word game are those who are seeking to raise income taxes on the middle class. You see - when you start saying to the people who are actually in the middle class - hey - YOU people have to start giving more money to the working class - it changes perspective. You keep talking about all these taxes on the "rich" and the professionals and small business owners don't know you are talking about them. So, that is where the dishonesty is. The term "middle class" has always been the class of people - between the gentry - and the serfs. It has never had anything to do with income.
connie
Yep. I'm aware of that. In my professional life I need to be conversant in their silly definitions.
Nope. My views would be the same even if I stood to inherit millions. I set my views based on morality and efficiency, not based on what's in my personal best interest.In other words, your parents don't have millions to leave you, so why should anybody else inherit anything from their parents?
Connie, would you HONESTLY suggest that a reasonable way to define terms, for purposes of everyday political conversation, is to use statutory or regulatory definitions? If so, then I could rightly claim that George Zimmerman intentionally shot and killed an infant. Trayvon Martin, legally, was an infant:Well, then why are you arguing with me about "small"? The SMALL BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION - has already identified what "small" is. And thus - yes, many "small" businesses - easily have people with over 5Mil in net worth upon death who are owners and thus this affects "small businesses". And, it affects the people who work for them, and the families of those people, and the customers they serve and the surrounding communities, etc.
As far as your Carnegie quote - I am sure you would rather Gov't control everything. Of course we disagree here. But, what that would amount to more than anything else - is a ruling class of elitists and rich which is exactly what we had at the time of Carnegie. At least with a small business backed economy - more people have a chance of getting to the top most income levels - even if it is a long chance. I would never in a million years toil away at a big company. I would rather be a big fish in a small pond every day and maximize my own earning potential, than compete with some sort of established hierarchy and bureaucracy.
connie
Read the article. It said "...a boom in inheritance would start about 2031." I believe that 's gonna be close to the time when whites will only be 50% of the population of this country. I believe by 2050 the percentage of whites in the US population is forecast to be down to 46%. If the estate tax laws remain the same or the exemption level is increased,the inheritance boom will be skewed towards whites at the same time their electoral power is in decline.This article makes the argument that there will be a major shift in inheritance patterns in a few years, as Baby Boomers die off an leave their fortunes:
http://www.salon.com/2014/04/02/gen...mericas_coming_inheritance_explosion_partner/
I suppose it makes sense that would be the case. The Baby Boomer generation was unusually large and, at least during the period when "Generation X" was born, produced relatively few heirs. That's a recipe for a much greater share of individual wealth being attributable to inheritance than in prior generations, when big fortunes would have been divided up among more heirs.
To head off the problems associated with excessive wealth inequality (and particularly with having much of the society's wealth in the hands of people who've shown no particular talent), we'd do well to reform inheritance laws now, while there's still time before the Boomers start kicking the bucket in large numbers.
My preferred reform is to exempt a relatively small portion of an estate (e.g., set at 120% of the value of a median home, so that a typical person could leave the family home and personal effects tax free), with everything beyond that taxed as regular income for the heirs. So, for example, if someone died with an estate valued at $1 million, leaving it to three children, something around $275,000 would be exempted, with each heir then having around $242,000 in extra "income" to account for. To avoid having it be too harsh a hit, I'd allow the income to be pro-rated over the next decade, so that, in the described scenario, it would only increase taxable income by $24,200 per heir per year.
However, even short of that kind of comprehensive reform, just rolling the rules back to something more like we had in earlier eras would help. For example, starting in 1942, and throughout our economic golden age (the 50s and 60s), we had a fairly low estate tax exemption and graduated rates that rose as high as 77%. The exemption in that time was $60,000. If we adjusted that for inflation, from the late 60s to today, that would be like a $400,000 exemption today (instead of the sky-high exemption of $5 million we currently have). A $400,000 exemption would allow a fairly nice home and personal effects, or even a genuinely small business, to be handed down without worrying about tax.
Over the years, a number of changes to the estate tax were implemented to benefit the very rich, aside from just a vastly higher exemption and lower rates. In 1980, for example they retroactively repealed the "carry-over basis" rules. In effect, the rule directly before the repeal was that if you inherited property, your "basis" was what the prior owner had paid for it. For example, if someone bought stocks for $100 and then left them to you when they were worth $1000, and then you sold them for $1600, your capital gain would be on $1500 -- the actual capital gain those stocks had experienced. After 1980, you got "stepped up basis," so that you got to pretend you'd acquired the property for whatever it was worth when you inherited it, even though you had not, in fact, paid a dime, so that, in the prior example, you'd only pay capital gains taxes on the $600 of the capital gain that happened to occur after you were handed the stocks, thereby sheltering the majority of the gain from ever being taxed. By simply repealing this rule and going back to carried-over basis, we could reduce the accumulation of wealth by the very rich, while also enhancing revenues in order to cut the deficit. We would also reduce a distortion in the market, since currently the wealthy have an incentive to hold onto assets until they die, even if it would be more economically efficient to sell them, simply because if those assets have unrealized capital gains, those need never be taxed if they're inherited before being liquidated.
So, for example, say you own some land out west that you no longer have any use for, and which others have great use for, and you could really use the cash from selling it to help grow a business you have back east. But say the estern property has millions of dollars of unrealized capital gains, so you'll take a tax hit on it if you sell. The current code encourages you to sit on it until you die, and then your heir can immediately liquidate it tax-free. Meanwhile, the land is being under-utilized and your business is unnecessarily cash-starved. Without stepped-up basis, this isn't an issue, since the taxes will have to be paid sooner or later, by you or your heir, so you may as well make the move whenever it makes sense from a purely business perspective, rather than gaming the tax system.
Another change was letting spouses inherit tax free. It used to be that 50% of jointly owned property was subject to taxation upon the death of a spouse -- the idea being you were being taxed on the half of the property you'd received from your spouse, just as you'd be taxed for property you inherited from anyone else. That was changed so that spouses could inherit unlimited amounts tax free. This allows for multi-generational passage of wealth without tax. For example, a wealth old man can marry a young woman and leaves her all his money tax-free. Decades later, when she's a rich society matron, she can marry a boy-toy and leave him that money tax-free, and so on.
All these changes together resulted in estate taxes bringing in a much smaller share of total federal revenue. Estate and gift taxes brought in 2.3% of total revenues in the mid-1960s, and as of 2009 (in 2010, there was no estate tax), that was down to 1.1%, a decrease of over half. And because of that, the rule changes have played some role in sky-rocketing wealth inequality in this country. Simply by rolling back some or all of these rules to something closer to what we had in the 1960s, we could minimize the social damage tax-free and low-tax inheritance of large estates has been causing.
Connie, would you HONESTLY suggest that a reasonable way to define terms, for purposes of everyday political conversation, is to use statutory or regulatory definitions? If so, then I could rightly claim that George Zimmerman intentionally shot and killed an infant. Trayvon Martin, legally, was an infant:
http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/infancy
But that's a very specialized definition for purposes of statutory and regulatory interpretation, not for purposes of social policy analysis. Whatever Zimmerman's sins, he didn't intentionally shoot and kill an "infant" in the sense that we typically understand that word. And, in the same way, a big company that just happens to fit the definition of "small business" in one poorly-considered regulatory framework is still no more a small business than Trayvon Martin was an infant.
As for your accusation, I very clearly don't want government controlling everything. I like to have a framework that is primarily one of private enterprise, but with enough government involvement to counter-balance the problems of private enterprise. Among wealthy nations, the "sweet spot" for how much of the GDP is flowing through the government is between around 24% and 50%. If the US were near the top of that range, I'd be concerned we were too socialized, and I'd favor shrinking government. Instead, we're at the absolute bottom of that range, and so I'm concerned we're too privatized, and would be comfortable growing the government.
That could be a recipe for serious social unrest, and maybe even some sort of mass violence. If you wind up with a nation with an even richer elite, relative to the masses, and the masses are mostly a different color than that elite, and the elite has enough political strength to close off attempts to resolve the inequities through peaceful political changes, things could get very ugly.Read the article. It said "...a boom in inheritance would start about 2031." I believe that 's gonna be close to the time when whites will only be 50% of the population of this country. I believe by 2050 the percentage of whites in the US population is forecast to be down to 46%. If the estate tax laws remain the same or the exemption level is increased,the inheritance boom will be skewed towards whites at the same time their electoral power is in decline.
I agree with you on the social security caps and higher taxation for the ultra rich. Boise had a multi billionaire who ran everything in this state for years. His ex-son-in-law is now governor. However, when Mr. Simplot had a hip replaced, it was paid for by Medicare. Yes, he paid into it, but on the other hand.....Nope. My views would be the same even if I stood to inherit millions. I set my views based on morality and efficiency, not based on what's in my personal best interest.
Many years ago, when I first started discussing policy matters online, conservatives who were out of their intellectual depth used to use a similar line of attack with me on the topic of income taxes. They couldn't argue the substance of my policy arguments, so instead they flopped pathetically into an ad hominem attack on me, personally, by suggesting that it was only because I was poor that I thought higher income taxes for high earners were a good thing. After all, those tax hikes I was calling for weren't going to hit me. But today I advocate strongly for income tax increases that will, absolutely, hit me. For example, I want the Social Security tax cap to be eliminated, even though, under the current rule, I get to stop paying into Social Security sometime around June every year. I'm not driven by narrow self interest. I'm driven by patriotism. But for those who lack the capacity to make an intelligent substantive argument, it's more comforting to imagine I simply argue from a perspective of selfishness.
AS with "middle class" it's again ultimately a word game. You can call almost any company "small," since all save one are smaller than some other company. But the labels don't really matter to the analysis. The policy issue, yet again, is not whether we should tax some estate to which you feel like attaching a particular label, whether that's "small" business or "middle" class. The policy issue is whether it makes sense to tax these estates left by a very small economic elite (5%, 2%, 0.2%, or what have you, of all estates, depending on which exemption level we're talking about). I favor doing so. I believe that those who are handed a lot of unearned value should pay at least as much in taxes on that as they would if they'd earned the exact same value.In this case - YES - the regulatory definition is a good working definition. The sizes of the businesses you are talking about and calling "small" are little more than sole proprietorship. That is being self employed - not having a business.
The thing is - when you talk about those terms with someone like me who works in the industry - that is exactly what I am thinking about as a "small" business. Cripe I don't even think about sole proprietor ships as "businesses".. they aren't even on my radar, nor are they on the radar of any professionals who are not "tax" or bookkeeping services. Most companies - don't even look to hire a regular CPA firm that isn't a mom and pop bookkeeping service until they are around the 5 to 10 mil range in my experience. Lower volume than that you can't even afford the fees nor do you need the services like reviewed statements, etc.
If someone asked me what was a small business I would say a company doing about 5 - 15 million a year in volume depending on the industry. I would have said that prior to looking at the SBA list - but upon review of the SBA list, I say that would pretty much is what a small business is - by their definition too. I have one client that has 1 tiny little retail store - selling party supplies - they do about 2 mil a year in volume. You can't get much smaller than having one little retail store in a strip center. That probably fits anyone's definition of "small" family owned business. But, they just had a valuation done and the valuation came back at over 5 mil. I just think that you and others who think a "small" business couldn't possibly have these values, etc. are out of touch with the real dollars we are talking about here.
I'm in favor of a fairly level playing field. I get that the children of the rich will always get a huge, unearned head start, simply because they get education, training, and connections that poorer kids never have access to. But we don't need to add insult to injury by the boosting their head start even farther when their parents die.I agree with you on the social security caps and higher taxation for the ultra rich. Boise had a multi billionaire who ran everything in this state for years. His ex-son-in-law is now governor. However, when Mr. Simplot had a hip replaced, it was paid for by Medicare. Yes, he paid into it, but on the other hand.....
What I am talking about is personal inheritances. I am not so patriotic that I think the government should tax someone to the hilt and then re-tax his/her property at death. Whatever I end up having, I want my children to have so maybe they can have better lives. When one's "richness" is in property, I wouldn't want my children to have to carry a mortgage on it to pay to the government--no matter how large the estate. I'm not a fan of government forever meddling in private lives, taking our money and then spending it on what "they" want to spend it on. Sorry, we disagree.
AS with "middle class" it's again ultimately a word game. You can call almost any company "small," since all save one are smaller than some other company. But the labels don't really matter to the analysis. The policy issue, yet again, is not whether we should tax some estate to which you feel like attaching a particular label, whether that's "small" business or "middle" class. The policy issue is whether it makes sense to tax these estates left by a very small economic elite (5%, 2%, 0.2%, or what have you, of all estates, depending on which exemption level we're talking about). I favor doing so. I believe that those who are handed a lot of unearned value should pay at least as much in taxes on that as they would if they'd earned the exact same value.
Let's say you own one of these "small" $5million businesses. And say we make a deal. I will act as your personal lawyer, putting in 50 hour per week, 50 weeks per year, for the next twenty years. And each such year, you agree to pay me, in exchange for that work, 5% of the shares in your business, so that at the end of the 20 years, I own it outright. In that case, I'd pay taxes, each year, equivalent to my having earned $250,000 (the value of the compensation). My effective tax rate might be around 30%, total. But what if, instead of me having done something to EARN that value, you simply handed it to me when you died, for no reason? In that case, because I didn't "pollute" the transaction by actually producing any value for the economy or otherwise getting my hands dirty with a hard day's work, I get it completely tax free. How does that even begin to make sense?
I don't think that is anybody's business but their own.I'm in favor of a fairly level playing field. I get that the children of the rich will always get a huge, unearned head start, simply because they get education, training, and connections that poorer kids never have access to. But we don't need to add insult to injury by the boosting their head start even farther when their parents die.
If someone in the top 2% perceives his situation as "very average," then that's exactly the kind of woeful ignorance we have to work on -- ignorance that festers in the Orwellian condition you're trying to perpetuate, where the very language is tortured to block understanding. If we stubbornly insist that 98%+ of Americans are in the "middle" class, it encourages a failure of people in the top few percent to grasp just how far removed their circumstances are from the struggles of normal Americans.It is not a word game, Arkady. These are the working definitions used by business professionals. These things mean something very specific to the people who help businesses plan for successions and individuals do estate planning. When you throw out terms like only the rich or the top 2% or whatever - and people who consider themselves very "average" people don't know you are talking about taxing what they intend to pass onto their kids they may think that sounds like not a bad idea... but when you say - we are going to tax the assests of businesses in 5mil in assets for estate purposes and your kids may have to sell that business or get a loan to keep all your hard work - it opens people eyes. I think if anything it is the left that uses the word game to more or less "hide" or be disingenious about who exactly they are talking about.
As far as estate taxes, I am not fan.Period. BUT - I think that when you inherit - you get the other person's basis. So, if your dad bought land for 20K 50 years ago and now it worth 10 million - I think that should pass to you tax free. BUT - your basis is now 20K. So, if YOU sell it - you pay taxes based on the difference between the 20K and the current market value. If the family is made up of wastrels like is your contention - sooner or later they will sell those things to finance their lifestyle and that is when they get taxed. And, if in the interim, it lets families over time build their wealth to the point they become part of the elite, good for them. I believe in policies which allow people to make and keep wealth, rather than those who punish those who have managed to amass it.
connie
I think it's everybody's business.I don't think that is anybody's business but their own.
If someone in the top 2% perceives his situation as "very average," then that's exactly the kind of woeful ignorance we have to work on -- ignorance that festers in the Orwellian condition you're trying to perpetuate, where the very language is tortured to block understanding. If we stubbornly insist that 98%+ of Americans are in the "middle" class, it encourages a failure of people in the top few percent to grasp just how far removed their circumstances are from the struggles of normal Americans.
And no, as you know full well, this isn't about taxing businesses with 5 million in assets. You can have 5 million in assets and if they're subject to a $5 million indenture, that's a net value of zero.
I agree with you about maintaining the original tax basis (which seems like a fair compromise between stepped-up basis and the more honest basis of $0, which reflects what the heir actually paid for it). However, one issue with that, in a situation without estate taxes, is it does tend to discourage the alienation of inefficient property uses from old money. If the land was bought by your great grandfather for $1000 and is now worth $10 million, and you just have that original basis, you have a very strong incentive not to sell it, even if selling it would otherwise be best for you, the buyer, and the society. Taxing it upon the transfer, whether by sale or inheritance, and having basis reset at that moment, helps to prevent the spread between basis and sale price from becoming so huge very often.
Ahhhh, yes. I see where you're coming from....glad you acknowledged it.I think it's everybody's business.