New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Interesting Case

Well, that's what I figured as you didn't bother to offer any objective justification for your judgement. So...

Thanks!

Well the alternative to suggesting that anyone who chooses to hold standards is some sort of short-sighted authoritarian is to have none at all.

I'll tell you what, if you have kids (and if you don't, have someone you know do it), send them to school in a T-shirt that says "I F*cked your mom", and make sure he/she flicks off every person they see. You shouldn't have any problem with it, and hey, if any teacher or principal stops them, what an authoritarian bigot! Bring in the SCOTUS!

Extremist? yes, just as your example was of me.

Like stated before, I would tend to agree there are levels to this. Go back and read.
 
Wow, talk about quick to judge.

Sorry, it's not clear to me to whom you're directing that comment. If you're suggesting that I'm quick to judge, well, I don't guess I've ever denied it. Judgement as such is no vice in my book. But then I'm always happy to discuss the basis for my judgements, and I don't believe I've ever relied on "it's obvious" as a trump card. So there's that.

Cheers.
 
Sorry, it's not clear to me to whom you're directing that comment. If you're suggesting that I'm quick to judge, well, I don't guess I've ever denied it. Judgement as such is no vice in my book. But then I'm always happy to discuss the basis for my judgements, and I don't believe I've ever relied on "it's obvious" as a trump card. So there's that.

Cheers.

Sorry, I thought it was directed at me, since no quote showed up, and it was right under your query of me. I was rather surprised that I didn't have time to respond. I am working here, amid reading. Shouldn't be, but tax season is over.
 
Well the alternative to suggesting that anyone who chooses to hold standards is some sort of short-sighted authoritarian is to have none at all.

I'll tell you what, if you have kids (and if you don't, have someone you know do it), send them to school in a T-shirt that says "I F*cked your mom", and make sure he/she flicks off every person they see. You shouldn't have any problem with it, and hey, if any teacher or principal stops them, what an authoritarian bigot! Bring in the SCOTUS!

Extremist? yes, just as your example was of me.

Like stated before, I would tend to agree there are levels to this. Go back and read.

I have read, and if you've read then you've already seen where I've acknowledged that there are levels to this and that Arkady and I come down on slightly different levels.

You and I probably disagree about where "I <heart> boobies" falls with respect to speech that's likely to create a dangerous or extreme disturbance. Seems to me that in part that's exactly what this case is about and that such a question is worthy of being addressed.

Past that, your first sentence is a prime example of a false dichotomy. You can do better.

Cheers.
 
Sorry, it's not clear to me to whom you're directing that comment. If you're suggesting that I'm quick to judge, well, I don't guess I've ever denied it. Judgement as such is no vice in my book. But then I'm always happy to discuss the basis for my judgements, and I don't believe I've ever relied on "it's obvious" as a trump card. So there's that.

Cheers.

Ah, so the quote didn't show up for you? That's weird. I was quoting Mr. Friscus in that reply, and the quote shows up on my page. Oh well, no harm done. I suspect you and I are mostly if not entirely in agreement here.

Cheers!
 
Past that, your first sentence is a prime example of a false dichotomy. You can do better.

Cheers.

I suppose, judging from your "conclusions" about me based on my preference for some sort of standards in education... we are both guilty of the same crime.

Cheers.
 
Which ones would you sweep aside as settled? Personally, I think we should always be open to new evidence, new arguments, and previously-unheard voices. Dred Scott and Plessy v. Ferguson were settled law -- until they weren't. So was Bowers v. Hardwick for that matter... Was revisiting those decisions "lazy" and "weak?"

Cheers.


The suggestion that SOME questions should remain open, doesn't sway me in my belief that in order to come to honest conclusions to those questions, we need a foundation of questions that've been settled.

With all due respect. Dred Scott and a coupla kids sporting boobies bracelets, are in separate intellectual and ideological leagues.
 
I suppose, judging from your "conclusions" about me based on my preference for some sort of standards in education... we are both guilty of the same crime.

Cheers.

What conclusions about you do you think I've drawn, exactly? I've tried to parse the meaning of your statements, but other than that I don't see where I've offered any conclusions about you. In any case, if I've presented a false dichotomy in this thread, please point it out to me.

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
The suggestion that SOME questions should remain open, doesn't sway me in my belief that in order to come to honest conclusions to those questions, we need a foundation of questions that've been settled.

With all due respect. Dred Scott and a coupla kids sporting boobies bracelets, are in separate intellectual and ideological leagues.

Okay. But you didn't answer my fundamental question. How shall we determine which questions are settled and which are not? How do we establish these "separate intellectual and ideological leagues?"

Mind you, I'm not denying that such categories exist, at least as a practical matter; I'm only asking how you think we ought to go about assigning a particular complaint to one category or another.

Cheers.
 
Ah, so the quote didn't show up for you? That's weird. I was quoting Mr. Friscus in that reply, and the quote shows up on my page. Oh well, no harm done. I suspect you and I are mostly if not entirely in agreement here.

Cheers!

That is wierd, because the quote still doesn't show up on my screen. No harm done.
 
Okay. But you didn't answer my fundamental question. How shall we determine which questions are settled and which are not? How do we establish these "separate intellectual and ideological leagues?"

Mind you, I'm not denying that such categories exist, at least as a practical matter; I'm only asking how you think we ought to go about assigning a particular complaint to one category or another.

Cheers.


I'll suggest that we make each of these determinations for ourselves. So...when the question of boobies bracelets comes up, we consider the question from our OWN foundation. My foundation is different from other peoples'. That's the way it is. But....the last thing I'm ever going to do, is chase every 21st-century question, back to my feelings around "original intent". IMHO, that's no way to run a 200+-year old democracy.
 
I'll suggest that we make each of these determinations for ourselves. So...when the question of boobies bracelets comes up, we consider the question from our OWN foundation. My foundation is different from other peoples'. That's the way it is. But....the last thing I'm ever going to do, is chase every 21st-century question, back to my feelings around "original intent". IMHO, that's no way to run a 200+-year old democracy.

Good Lord, who suggested that we need to apply some narrow interpretation of "original intent" to settle this or any other issue of constitutional law? Not I.

Anyway... Yes, we must perforce make each of these determinations for ourselves and we all necessarily consider this and any question of rights and liberties from our own foundation of experience and beliefs. No offense, but so what? I'm repeating myself, but that's the start of a discussion and debate, not the end.

If we fail in our duty to establish some common foundation for making these decisions, then we default to the simple "majority rules" standard, do we not? In that case, for example, Scalia is right and same-sex couples ought to be able to marry in Washington state while those who engage in "the abominable crime against nature either with mankind or with beast" can be sentenced to ten years in the state penitentiary in Oklahoma. (Yes, that law is still on the books.) Community standards rule!

So, ummm... Refresh my memory, why did we fight the Civil War?

Cheers.
 
Agreed, when a Havelock comes in and wants to act as if nobody has ever discussed any part of anything, and there is no historical and modern context... it gets to be a pointless debate.

So, you'd rather ask questions than answer them. Oh well, nothing unusual about that... I've also noticed that you like to characterize others but don't like being characterized yourself. Nothing unusual about that either...

Cheers.
 
I always thought boobies was a dumb word to use, but I suspect they wouldn't want my word.

As for the drug testing, especially in intramural sports, I don't see anything wrong with drug testing. There's way too much pressure to use PED's, even by coaches. This may actually protect kids.

4 letter word?:)
 
What in the world is the USSC doing taking a bracelet issue?

I agree that Children should not rule the world,as El Gringo commented,but when we have a bunch of adults who act like children on the USSC and Congress they are the ones who need to be reigned in!
 
That is what I'm talking about, when there is a reasonable suspicion. How else is there going to be an intervention if we just sit back and wait for some kid to come forth and say "I've got a problem."? Do people really think that's going to happen, or do they really think kids will grow out of it? It's ridiculous to even think that, just as ridiculous as using the "jack-booted thugs and cages" comment.

Mass testing? No, that is not what I'm talking about. But kids exhibit signs in the way they act and carry themselves. Mood swings, grades falling off; and far too many parents are too busy with their own lives to pay attention.

If a kid in a public school has a serious problem with drug abuse, then it should be obvious to their fellow students, teachers and counselors. I've never said that there should be no attempt to intervene in such a case.

You, on the other hand, read the latest "OMG!!! Johnny's On Drugs!!!" article in the news and immediately jump to prescribing random urinalysis, locker searches and police dogs. There is a middle ground here.

It is this sort of emotional overreaction to deviant behavior among kids that has excused the constant drip, drip erosion of our civil liberties over the past few decades. That's how we got zero tolerance policies that caused a valedictorian to be expelled from school for having a Midol in her purse, or first grade boys suspended for having a toy gun in their jacket pocket.

We need not treat our school kids like prisoners of war in order to assist those who have behavioral problems. You're calling for a sledgehammer approach to a thumbtack problem.
 
Back
Top