New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Interesting Case

ompla


The main point of the first amendment was to protect politically-oriented speech that's unpopular. What the Founders had in mind was stuff like burning the king in effigy, or depicting the shootings at the Old State House as a Boston Massacre. Those things were absolutely meant to shock and instigate. Compared to that, a little infantile semi-sexualized breast cancer awareness messaging is about as un-shocking a form of instigation as I can imagine. If we're even going to be censoring that kind of political expression by our young citizens, we shouldn't be surprised when they grow up to be spineless sheep.

Again, a big difference between free speech IN public schools and free speech outside of it.

It's the same as on the job and off the job décor.. when you're on the job, there's just certain things you can't say or do that won't get you fired.
 
Again, a big difference between free speech IN public schools and free speech outside of it.

It's the same as on the job and off the job décor.. when you're on the job, there's just certain things you can't say or do that won't get you fired.
It's different from a job setting because people are required to be there. You chose your employer. Up to a certain age, public school students are required by law to be there -- it's a custodial situation, and so when their rights are denied in that context, it's less like them voluntarily laying them down for an opportunity, when they could easily choose many other opportunities with different expectations. If you don't like the speech and dress code when working as a bank teller, you could be a software coder or coffee barrista or bounty hunter. But if you don't like the speech or dress code at school, you probably don't have a lot of alternative places to get that education without those restrictions. As a legal or at least practical reality, they're forced to lay down those rights when such rules are created.

A public school is also different in that we're supposed to be raising citizens there. That's not the role of an employer, it's the role of a school (along with parents -- and these parents didn't mind the bracelets). If we deny students basic rights for most of their formative years, we're going to be raising really lousy citizens -- people who either grow so accustomed to submitting to authority that it's all they're capable of, or, nearly as bad, people who have never been trusted with any discretion in things like choosing their modes of expression, so when they finally are given that discretion, they lack any experience and wisdom in using it. If we can't even trust our students to experiment with free speech when the contents are as utterly innocuous as a playful "boobies" healthcare promotion, then that really says something about how fully the authoritarian impulse has overtaken this country.
 
It's different from a job setting because people are required to be there. You chose your employer. Up to a certain age, public school students are required by law to be there -- it's a custodial situation, and so when their rights are denied in that context, it's less like them voluntarily laying them down for an opportunity, when they could easily choose many other opportunities with different expectations. If you don't like the speech and dress code when working as a bank teller, you could be a software coder or coffee barrista or bounty hunter. But if you don't like the speech or dress code at school, you probably don't have a lot of alternative places to get that education without those restrictions. As a legal or at least practical reality, they're forced to lay down those rights when such rules are created.

A public school is also different in that we're supposed to be raising citizens there. That's not the role of an employer, it's the role of a school (along with parents -- and these parents didn't mind the bracelets). If we deny students basic rights for most of their formative years, we're going to be raising really lousy citizens -- people who either grow so accustomed to submitting to authority that it's all they're capable of, or, nearly as bad, people who have never been trusted with any discretion in things like choosing their modes of expression, so when they finally are given that discretion, they lack any experience and wisdom in using it. If we can't even trust our students to experiment with free speech when the contents are as utterly innocuous as a playful "boobies" healthcare promotion, then that really says something about how fully the authoritarian impulse has overtaken this country.

I get it, but, if you allow "boobies", then you have to allow "[Unwelcome language removed]", "N*****s", shirts that say "I'm going to rape your sister"... weird crazed shocking stuff like that.

I don't think it's the job of education to fight for the "right" for that sort of nonsense.

"boobies" isn't as shocking, but it's nothing but an immature sexual innuendo.. There's just no need for it. You can make a message about breast cancer and such without it.
 
I get it, but, if you allow "boobies", then you have to allow "****", "N*****s", shirts that say "I'm going to rape your sister"... weird crazed shocking stuff like that.

I don't think it's the job of education to fight for the "right" for that sort of nonsense.

"boobies" isn't as shocking, but it's nothing but an immature sexual innuendo.. There's just no need for it. You can make a message about breast cancer and such without it.


Yep... Before you know it, we'll have students marrying dogs in public school hallways.

I'm tellin' ya! Those boobies are a gateway!
 
I get it, but, if you allow "boobies", then you have to allow "****", "N*****s", shirts that say "I'm going to rape your sister"... weird crazed shocking stuff like that.

I don't think it's the job of education to fight for the "right" for that sort of nonsense.

"boobies" isn't as shocking, but it's nothing but an immature sexual innuendo.. There's just no need for it. You can make a message about breast cancer and such without it.
I don't believe that it's an all or nothing thing. I think there are at least five positions one could take here:

(1) The true absolutist: you can say anything at all you want.
(2) The near absolutist: you can say almost anything you want, with various very narrow exceptions to cover things like threats of violence, slander, copyright violations, and other matters where the direct harm goes beyond merely upsetting someone's sensibilities.
(3) The pragmatist who leans towards free speech: in addition to the exceptions recognized by the near absolutist, there are also exceptions for things where the offense or disruption inflicted by the speech are overwhelming enough (e.g., "Fighting Words") that they amount to something that could incite bad behavior from otherwise reasonable people, and so they can be censored.
(4) The offense avoider: unpopular speech can be banned, based on the offense it will cause the majority, however mild. Essentially: the majority has a right not to be exposed to speech that makes it uncomfortable.
(5) The authoritarian: the state can ban even popular speech, if it is in the interest of the powerful or the state as an abstract entity.

I fall in category two, so I would allow a shirt with a racial epithet, but not one with a threat of violence. Someone who falls in category three might ban the racial epithet, too, on the basis of it inciting hatred and a serious risk of violence, but would not ban a "boobies" bracelet, which only incites some tittering, a little distraction, and maybe some mild discomfort among prudes.

As for the argument that you can make a breast cancer message without the "hook" of mild innuendo used for that particular message, of course you can. But something similar could be said about any political speech. For example, if I go on a rant about Bush and his fellow warmongers tricking the American people into the Iraq War, an authoritarian could say that I could argue against the war without using hot-button terms like "warmonger" and "tricked," and he'd be right. But that should be my choice, not his. The mere fact such words make him uncomfortable isn't an adequate justification for censorship, any more than your prudish discomfort with "boobies" is.
 
I don't believe that it's an all or nothing thing. I think there are at least five positions one could take here:

(1) The true absolutist: you can say anything at all you want.
(2) The near absolutist: you can say almost anything you want, with various very narrow exceptions to cover things like threats of violence, slander, copyright violations, and other matters where the direct harm goes beyond merely upsetting someone's sensibilities.
(3) The pragmatist who leans towards free speech: in addition to the exceptions recognized by the near absolutist, there are also exceptions for things where the offense or disruption inflicted by the speech are overwhelming enough (e.g., "Fighting Words") that they amount to something that could incite bad behavior from otherwise reasonable people, and so they can be censored.
(4) The offense avoider: unpopular speech can be banned, based on the offense it will cause the majority, however mild. Essentially: the majority has a right not to be exposed to speech that makes it uncomfortable.
(5) The authoritarian: the state can ban even popular speech, if it is in the interest of the powerful or the state as an abstract entity.

I fall in category two, so I would allow a shirt with a racial epithet, but not one with a threat of violence. Someone who falls in category three might ban the racial epithet, too, on the basis of it inciting hatred and a serious risk of violence, but would not ban a "boobies" bracelet, which only incites some tittering, a little distraction, and maybe some mild discomfort among prudes.

As for the argument that you can make a breast cancer message without the "hook" of mild innuendo used for that particular message, of course you can. But something similar could be said about any political speech. For example, if I go on a rant about Bush and his fellow warmongers tricking the American people into the Iraq War, an authoritarian could say that I could argue against the war without using hot-button terms like "warmonger" and "tricked," and he'd be right. But that should be my choice, not his. The mere fact such words make him uncomfortable isn't an adequate justification for censorship, any more than your prudish discomfort with "boobies" is.

The thing is, kids and adults are treated differently. Thus, anything sexual is as well. Boobies isn't anything to care about among adults. However, middle school kids? That's the line I draw, and to me it's a pretty clear one.
 
I don't believe that it's an all or nothing thing. I think there are at least five positions one could take here:

(1) The true absolutist: you can say anything at all you want.
(2) The near absolutist: you can say almost anything you want, with various very narrow exceptions to cover things like threats of violence, slander, copyright violations, and other matters where the direct harm goes beyond merely upsetting someone's sensibilities.
(3) The pragmatist who leans towards free speech: in addition to the exceptions recognized by the near absolutist, there are also exceptions for things where the offense or disruption inflicted by the speech are overwhelming enough (e.g., "Fighting Words") that they amount to something that could incite bad behavior from otherwise reasonable people, and so they can be censored.
(4) The offense avoider: unpopular speech can be banned, based on the offense it will cause the majority, however mild. Essentially: the majority has a right not to be exposed to speech that makes it uncomfortable.
(5) The authoritarian: the state can ban even popular speech, if it is in the interest of the powerful or the state as an abstract entity.

I fall in category two, so I would allow a shirt with a racial epithet, but not one with a threat of violence. Someone who falls in category three might ban the racial epithet, too, on the basis of it inciting hatred and a serious risk of violence, but would not ban a "boobies" bracelet, which only incites some tittering, a little distraction, and maybe some mild discomfort among prudes.

As for the argument that you can make a breast cancer message without the "hook" of mild innuendo used for that particular message, of course you can. But something similar could be said about any political speech. For example, if I go on a rant about Bush and his fellow warmongers tricking the American people into the Iraq War, an authoritarian could say that I could argue against the war without using hot-button terms like "warmonger" and "tricked," and he'd be right. But that should be my choice, not his. The mere fact such words make him uncomfortable isn't an adequate justification for censorship, any more than your prudish discomfort with "boobies" is.

In a school environment...? I'd probably fall in category 3, as a rule. For most situations, I'd be a 2. In any case, I believe the lawsuit in question is worth hearing and certainly doesn't constitute "whining." Fighting for one's basic rights doesn't generally amount to "whining" in my book -- even if we happen to disagree about where to draw this or that line.

For what it's worth...

Cheers!
 
The thing is, kids and adults are treated differently. Thus, anything sexual is as well. Boobies isn't anything to care about among adults. However, middle school kids? That's the line I draw, and to me it's a pretty clear one.

Jeepers. The above sounds awfully like the old, "I'm obviously right and lot's of people agree with me!" argument. Man, I hate that argument. That can be the beginning of a debate; it should never be the end.

Cheers.
 
Jeepers. The above sounds awfully like the old, "I'm obviously right and lot's of people agree with me!" argument. Man, I hate that argument. That can be the beginning of a debate; it should never be the end.

Cheers.

I'll argue that the argument that no lines are "obvious", is lazy and....shall we say.....weak. Our Constitution presents us with no end of conundrums. If we can't sweep a few aside as settled, our Constitution is one helluva lot more of a burden than a benefit.
 
The thing is, kids and adults are treated differently. Thus, anything sexual is as well. Boobies isn't anything to care about among adults. However, middle school kids? That's the line I draw, and to me it's a pretty clear one.
There is a difference, I'll grant. An adult who calls breasts boobies sounds embarrassingly infantile. Among middle school kids, on the other hand, it's adorable.
 
In a school environment...? I'd probably fall in category 3, as a rule. For most situations, I'd be a 2. In any case, I believe the lawsuit in question is worth hearing and certainly doesn't constitute "whining." Fighting for one's basic rights doesn't generally amount to "whining" in my book -- even if we happen to disagree about where to draw this or that line.

For what it's worth...

Cheers!
Yeah, I assume a lot of people would shift one category down the list, from their customary position, when dealing with kids in a public school setting. I don't shift, but I can see why someone might.
 
I'll argue that the argument that no lines are "obvious", is lazy and....shall we say.....weak. Our Constitution presents us with no end of conundrums. If we can't sweep a few aside as settled, our Constitution is one helluva lot more of a burden than a benefit.

Which ones would you sweep aside as settled? Personally, I think we should always be open to new evidence, new arguments, and previously-unheard voices. Dred Scott and Plessy v. Ferguson were settled law -- until they weren't. So was Bowers v. Hardwick for that matter... Was revisiting those decisions "lazy" and "weak?"

Cheers.
 
People have been freaking out about the supposed rising risk of drugs for sixty years, at least. But it's no reason to conduct unreasonable searches and seizures -- in schools or elsewhere. If there's a reasonable, individualized suspicion of illegal conduct, that justifies a search. But invading the privacy and assaulting the dignity of hundreds of innocents in the hopes of catching a few guilty people betrays our national ideals.

That is what I'm talking about, when there is a reasonable suspicion. How else is there going to be an intervention if we just sit back and wait for some kid to come forth and say "I've got a problem."? Do people really think that's going to happen, or do they really think kids will grow out of it? It's ridiculous to even think that, just as ridiculous as using the "jack-booted thugs and cages" comment.

Mass testing? No, that is not what I'm talking about. But kids exhibit signs in the way they act and carry themselves. Mood swings, grades falling off; and far too many parents are too busy with their own lives to pay attention.
 
There is a difference, I'll grant. An adult who calls breasts boobies sounds embarrassingly infantile. Among middle school kids, on the other hand, it's adorable.

Your opinion, I find it unnecessary, promoting women as sexual objects, offering no value of maturity.

I guess I just hold standards...
 
That is what I'm talking about, when there is a reasonable suspicion. How else is there going to be an intervention if we just sit back and wait for some kid to come forth and say "I've got a problem."? Do people really think that's going to happen, or do they really think kids will grow out of it? It's ridiculous to even think that, just as ridiculous as using the "jack-booted thugs and cages" comment.

Mass testing? No, that is not what I'm talking about. But kids exhibit signs in the way they act and carry themselves. Mood swings, grades falling off; and far too many parents are too busy with their own lives to pay attention.

Who here has objected to using probable cause as a grounds for authorizing a search? No one that I've noticed...

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
Your opinion, I find it unnecessary, promoting women as sexual objects, offering no value of maturity.

I guess I just hold standards...

So, your opinions and judgements are basically standards to which everyone should properly adhere without further justification? Right, got it...

Cheers.
 
Back
Top