New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Interesting Case

That is what I'm talking about, when there is a reasonable suspicion. How else is there going to be an intervention if we just sit back and wait for some kid to come forth and say "I've got a problem."? Do people really think that's going to happen, or do they really think kids will grow out of it? It's ridiculous to even think that, just as ridiculous as using the "jack-booted thugs and cages" comment.

Mass testing? No, that is not what I'm talking about. But kids exhibit signs in the way they act and carry themselves. Mood swings, grades falling off; and far too many parents are too busy with their own lives to pay attention.

I have absolutely no problem with testing students based on reasonable suspicion. That's the fourth amendment standard. But that's not what the Republican-packed Supreme Court has come to allow. They've come to allow testing of absolutely all students who do any extracurriculars, without any symptoms suggesting that a particular "suspect" has done anything to be suspect about. Similarly, they've allowed sweeps of all lockers, rather than just those where the student has provided some cause to think there's contraband there.

Ironically, this could actually backfire. I had a friend in high school who was a talented runner -- and also someone who went to parties where pot was smoked, and who smoked an occasional joint himself outside of track season, when he wasn't it training. But, when they began testing the track team for drugs, he quit track, out of fear that he'd test positive. After that, he turned into a much bigger druggie than he'd ever been before, since he had no physical motivation for avoiding the stuff, and also started in with more harmful drugs, like alcohol and nicotine, which he'd previously avoided because they degraded his athleticism.
 
Last edited:
Your opinion, I find it unnecessary, promoting women as sexual objects, offering no value of maturity.

I guess I just hold standards...
I hold standards, too -- like the one that is repelled by the torture-porn iconography you revel in. We can agree to disagree, simply by neither of us using the government to censor the other. I'll let you get your sick jollies contemplating a Jew being nailed to a piece of wood until he's dead. and you can tolerate me having an innocent chuckle at a "boobies" bracelet. Deal?
 
I hold standards, too -- like the one that is repelled by the torture-porn iconography you revel in. We can agree to disagree, simply by neither of us using the government to censor the other. I'll let you get your sick jollies contemplating a Jew being nailed to a piece of wood until he's dead. and you can tolerate me having an innocent chuckle at a "boobies" bracelet. Deal?

LMAO

Sorry, you can't pull yourself out of culture and try to make a back door deal with me.

My icon is well established... as is yours...
 
LMAO

Sorry, you can't pull yourself out of culture and try to make a back door deal with me.

My icon is well established... as is yours...
Well, you're in a culture where the vast majority find "boobies" to be in mildly poor taste, at the very worst. Yet you still want the ability to have the government censor that word, at least with regard to kids in school custody, against the wishes of their parents.

Here's the good news. If we get to the point where secularization leads to the majority seeing your idolatry of the crucifix as, similarly, in poor taste, I'll STILL be on the side fighting to let you decide whether or not your kids get to wear that symbol to school, rather than letting school administrators trump your decision. For me, the sentiment of the majority of the culture is immaterial. I just wish you had the same kind of respect for those whose tastes differ from yours as I do. In other words, I wish you'd do unto others as you'd have done unto you, if the roles were reversed. Since you're a Christian, though, I don't really expect it to happen. My experience has been that it's a rare Christian, indeed, for whom the Golden Rule is a guide.
 
Well, you're in a culture where the vast majority find "boobies" to be in mildly poor taste, at the very worst. Yet you still want the ability to have the government censor that word, at least with regard to kids in school custody, against the wishes of their parents.

Here's the good news. If we get to the point where secularization leads to the majority seeing your idolatry of the crucifix as, similarly, in poor taste, I'll STILL be on the side fighting to let you decide whether or not your kids get to wear that symbol to school, rather than letting school administrators trump your decision. For me, the sentiment of the majority of the culture is immaterial. I just wish you had the same kind of respect for those whose tastes differ from yours as I do. In other words, I wish you'd do unto others as you'd have done unto you, if the roles were reversed. Since you're a Christian, though, I don't really expect it to happen. My experience has been that it's a rare Christian, indeed, for whom the Golden Rule is a guide.

My eyes could not have rolled any more than they did...

What is allowed in society vs. What is allowed in school is entirely different.

Plus, your rant on "golden rule" gives all the same amount of maturity, respect, and credibility, no matter how shocking or hateful the words or imagery are, and that is certainly untrue, I've had you admit as such.

But, to close, the term "boobies" lacks a strong contingent in culture to grasp onto, this requires no doing on my part. It's just seen as an immature term, it's never had any reference in any other context. Give it up man, it's not a big deal to begin with.
 
I have absolutely no problem with testing students based on reasonable suspicion. That's the fourth amendment standard. But that's not what the Republican-packed Supreme Court has come to allow. They've come to allow testing of absolutely all students who do any extracurriculars, without any symptoms suggesting that a particular "suspect" has done anything to be suspect about. Similarly, they've allowed sweeps of all lockers, rather than just those where the student has provided some cause to think there's contraband there.

Ironically, this could actually backfire. I had a friend in high school who was a talented runner -- and also someone who went to parties where pot was smoked, and who smoked an occasional joint himself outside of track season, when he wasn't it training. But, when they began testing the track team for drugs, he quit track, out of fear that he'd test positive. After that, he turned into a much bigger druggie than he'd ever been before, since he had no physical motivation for avoiding the stuff, and also started in with more harmful drugs, like alcohol and nicotine, which he'd previously avoided because they degraded his athleticism.

I understand that. I had a client who pretty much did the same thing.
 
If a kid in a public school has a serious problem with drug abuse, then it should be obvious to their fellow students, teachers and counselors. I've never said that there should be no attempt to intervene in such a case.

You, on the other hand, read the latest "OMG!!! Johnny's On Drugs!!!" article in the news and immediately jump to prescribing random urinalysis, locker searches and police dogs. There is a middle ground here.

It is this sort of emotional overreaction to deviant behavior among kids that has excused the constant drip, drip erosion of our civil liberties over the past few decades. That's how we got zero tolerance policies that caused a valedictorian to be expelled from school for having a Midol in her purse, or first grade boys suspended for having a toy gun in their jacket pocket.

We need not treat our school kids like prisoners of war in order to assist those who have behavioral problems. You're calling for a sledgehammer approach to a thumbtack problem.

Wrong, wrong, wrong. I don't have to read the latest news article on anything, I've seen it in action. And I did not call for open random checks.
 
Wrong, wrong, wrong. I don't have to read the latest news article on anything, I've seen it in action. And I did not call for open random checks.


Everything that I wrote about is already happening in some of our public schools -- right down to the police dogs inspecting lockers.

How much is enough?
 
Are the bracelets detracting from education in any way? If they are then they've got to go. I find it difficult to believe that the students who have worn these bracelets to school did not expect to elicit some sort of reaction from their fellow students based solely on the word 'boobies'.

As Butthead would say: huh huh huh he....said....boobies.
 
That's a different issue. I'm asking why police state tactics are presumed to be the appropriate response.

I'm sorry, you're not giving any particulars about the school, or what is happening in that school. Nor are you giving any particulars about what the parents of those students want. I know of metal detectors, and random searches, but those are things the parents wanted implemented, and I don't have a problem with that. They are their kids.
 
I'm sorry, you're not giving any particulars about the school, or what is happening in that school. Nor are you giving any particulars about what the parents of those students want. I know of metal detectors, and random searches, but those are things the parents wanted implemented, and I don't have a problem with that. They are their kids.

No, I didn't. We were really discussing the broader concepts of authoritarian rule vs. individual freedom as it applies to a public school environment in general, but we don't have to.

It's getting late for me anyway.


Later,
NS
 
No, I didn't. We were really discussing the broader concepts of authoritarian rule vs. individual freedom as it applies to a public school environment in general, but we don't have to.

It's getting late for me anyway.


Later,
NS

And you are muddling together authoritarian rule and individual freedom. Kids are the responsibility of their parents, which gives parents certain rights. Unless you can show me that some 'dictator' someplace is forcing what you posted, I'll not consider it to be the general rule.
 
And you are muddling together authoritarian rule and individual freedom. Kids are the responsibility of their parents, which gives parents certain rights. Unless you can show me that some 'dictator' someplace is forcing what you posted, I'll not consider it to be the general rule.

Must be getting late for you too. That didn't make any sense at all.
 
It may be late, but the fact remains I have seen no evidence of some authoritarian ruler making the decisions you were posting.

Well no. There is no warlord riding his stallion into the public schools and caning disobedient children, but the particular incidents of abuse of students' rights to privacy and free speech that I brought up in this discussion have all occurred in US public schools. Google them, if you don't believe me.

This discussion has now veered hopelessly away from the original topic and into the ditch, and I suspect that it's because you can't really defend your position. Your position was never quite clear to begin with, truth be told. Just a vague sentiment that Constitutional rights aren't really all that important when compared to the need to protect our school children from themselves.

You've never even come close to defining where you think the legal line should be drawn. Instead, you've merely made repeated appeals to emotion.
 
What is allowed in society vs. What is allowed in school is entirely different.

Some things are necessarily different. There's no necessity for making "boobies" bracelets be one of those things that are different. Just as we wouldn't outlaw wearing those bracelets for people outside of school, we shouldn't outlaw wearing them for people inside school. And I'd say the exact same for crucifixes.... it isn't just that I'd grant an adult citizen on the street the right to wear such an image, however distasteful, I'd also grant that right to a person, adult or not, in a public school setting. If you, as a parent, are OK with your kid wearing an idol of a tortured man to school, that should be our call. And if I'm OK with my kid wearing a breast-cancer awareness message to school, that should be my call.

That's what I mean by the golden rule. I'm a moral person, and so I do unto others as I'd have done unto me. I wouldn't want you using the government to censor something I find acceptable for my child, like a whimsical public awareness bracelet, and so I am morally compelled not to use the government to censor something you find acceptable for your child, like that Christan icon. In order for me to morally try to censor something for you, it must be in accordance with rules I'd want to apply equally if our roles were reversed. For example, I'm fine censoring your kid when it comes to making death threats, because I'd be fine with your censoring my kid when it comes to making death threats.

But I don't think you follow that same golden-rule reasoning. If the majority found something like a crucifix to be "dispruptive" or "in poor taste," the way you find those bracelets, I don't think you'd want the majority to ban the wearing of crucifixes in school, the way you'd allow the banning of the bracelets. I think you expect the society to respect your judgment on such matters, but you aren't willing to respect the judgment of other parents.
 
Back
Top