New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Interesting Question

let's use Barack Obama in your query.
why do you cons disbelieve Barack Obama's educational achievement? I trust I don't have to repeat what they've said specifically questioning his attendance, his grades, etc., but isn't that the same as saying that cons don't believe that Obama, a black man, could make it on his own without affirmative action?
my point - when cons stop questioning achievements of black men and women they disagree with, then we can end the discussion of AA.
btw, I do think we need AA for the poor/lower class regardless of color.


Can you cite a specific example of "you cons" questioning Barack Obama's education credentials?
 
What makes you think it was an assignment?

Maybe its not. But his history is very heavy in that direction for the site. If it's not maybe somebody there should tell him this isn't the right wing version of Ebony and to ease up a little.
 
We have a black President.
We have a black Attorney General
We had a black woman Secretary of State
Yes. It is past the time that blacks need a hand up in order to achieve.
They are fully able to achieve anything they wish to achieve.

It's all about work ethic
It's all about the content of someone's character, NOT the color of his/her skin.

We have a black president alright and by the numbers he's done better than any republican since Lincoln. Yet your party's goal is to get him fired from his job and undo his accomplishment rather than work with him.

As for the black AG he was hired by the black president. And the black Secretary of State was the tutor and a family friend of the president that hired her.

If anything it point to just the opposite and the most obvious conclusion. The quaity of your personal association and contacts are more important than the quality of your character.
 
Last edited:
You are being both hypocritical and disingenuous. You lash out with accusations on the motivations and machination of of the left even to the point of blanketing it all with your cryptic monicker "dems/l ibs" . Yet you have no reason to quesiton why a far right website would print so many racially charged articles from a single columnist. Maybe more than all the other columnist combined and not think it might have something to do with his race ? And why does someone have to be deemed a racist when writing about race in a non gushing fashion ? It's done all the time by writers of all different races. But then again they are all writing for the audience this site wants to attract. An audience who would seek to justify the subjective by pointing out the objective.

"Yet you have no reason to quesiton why a far right website would print so many racially charged articles from a single columnist. Maybe more than all the other columnist combined and not think it might have something to do with his race?"

Untrue. I actually said Mr. Williams probably had the most articles that were race related BECAUSE of his race.

And the ONLY reason so many of those articles are, " racially charged", is because YOU, a dem/lib, deem them to be so. Has it ever crossed your mind that Mr. Williams writes about things he sees and things he believes need to be changed to make things better? Why is it that YOU feel that YOU somehow just magically "know" why others write?

"But then again they are all writing for the audience this site wants to attract."

Well no shit. What are the chances of any articles like these, articles that dare do something other than apologize or suck up to blacks getting published anywhere ELSE, say, salon.com or some far left website?

Look we all know that there are lots and lots of articles written by non-blacks and black authors alike that are all about race and those are never deemed to be "racially charged", THOSE are merely pointing out something, right? So why is that exactly?

How is it that ONLY articles about race that present views that dems/l ibs do not agree with are labeled, "racially charged"?
 
Walter Williams posed a legitimate query in one of his recent columns. If anyone would care to discuss this (minus the flame-throwers), I think this is a fair topic for intelligent discussion:


Earlier this month, the 50th anniversary of the Civil Rights Act was celebrated. During the act's legislative debate, then-Sen. Hubert Humphrey, responding to predictions, promised, "I'll eat my hat if this leads to racial quotas." I don't know whether Humphrey got around to keeping his promise, but here's my question: Is it within the capacity of black Americans to make it in this society without the special favors variously called racial preferences, quotas, affirmative action and race-sensitive policies? What might a "yes" answer to that question assume and imply about blacks? Likewise, what would a "no" answer assume and imply?

http://townhall.com/columnists/walterewilliams/2014/07/23/do-blacks-need-favors-n1864237


Thoughts?
I think that --long-term-- the legacies of slavery and Jim Crow will fade away to nothing, whether there's active efforts like affirmative action or not. It's simply a question of how long it will take. Some of these things have impacts that echo from generation to generation. For example, how likely you are to aspire to high academic performance depends in part on the attitude your parents had about academics, which depends on the attitude their parents had, and so on. So, at a natural pace, it can take a long while for the impact of the historical inequities to fade -- many generations after official discrimination ends, its echoes will linger. However, just like there are ways to engineer a room to dampen unwanted echoes, there are also pieces of social engineering that can dampen the unwanted echoes of these past injustices. If used properly, in theory things like affirmative action and quotas can accelerate the process.

For example, think of someone in a black community where there are almost no examples of anyone who ever "made it" through a professional career path. It's going to be fairly unlikely that's a direction in which he'll strive. But if you seed the community with a sprinkling a successful professionals, by way of special efforts to make professional success more achievable for members of that community, you can catalyze a transformation, by providing the necessary role-models, mentors, and professional connections needed to let others rise.

So, I think it's tendentious and misleading to speak of it as if there were a dilemma where blacks either have the capacity to make it in this society without help or not. Instead, it should be thought of as a question of what should society be doing to help the negative legacies of past injustice to fade more quickly.
 
Last edited:
"Yet you have no reason to quesiton why a far right website would print so many racially charged articles from a single columnist. Maybe more than all the other columnist combined and not think it might have something to do with his race?"

Untrue. I actually said Mr. Williams probably had the most articles that were race related BECAUSE of his race.

And the ONLY reason so many of those articles are, " racially charged", is because YOU, a dem/lib, deem them to be so. Has it ever crossed your mind that Mr. Williams writes about things he sees and things he believes need to be changed to make things better? Why is it that YOU feel that YOU somehow just magically "know" why others write?

"But then again they are all writing for the audience this site wants to attract."

Well no shit. What are the chances of any articles like these, articles that dare do something other than apologize or suck up to blacks getting published anywhere ELSE, say, salon.com or some far left website?

Look we all know that there are lots and lots of articles written by non-blacks and black authors alike that are all about race and those are never deemed to be "racially charged", THOSE are merely pointing out something, right? So why is that exactly?

How is it that ONLY articles about race that present views that dems/l ibs do not agree with are labeled, "racially charged"?

So back to the original question. Isn't that just another form of affirmative action. And I never said I knew why he wrote his articles. That's you not me.

I am sure they could get published somewhere else. But the wouldn't be followed with the same zeal as a TH audience has for them.

Who says the only the articles "dm,md/./od" disagree with with are racically charged except for you ?
 
So back to the original question. Isn't that just another form of affirmative action. And I never said I knew why he wrote his articles. That's you not me.

I am sure they could get published somewhere else. But the wouldn't be followed with the same zeal as a TH audience has for them.

Who says the only the articles "dm,md/./od" disagree with with are racically charged except for you ?

As far as your original question, "Isn't that just another form of affirmative action", no, not unless there is some way to show that the articles of Mr. Williams were selected to be published BECAUSE they were submitted by a black man and some other, article equal to or better than his was not.

Being there is no way for me to know that my answer is still, no, it is not, " just another form of affirmative action", sorry. Perhaps YOU have some way of knowing differently that makes you believe it is, if so then please share.

"I am sure they could get published somewhere else."

And I am not. So there we are.......

"But the wouldn't be followed with the same zeal as a TH audience has for them."

I would certainly suspect not. Having ones work followed with as much zeal is pretty much the goal of all people in every field. As an author one would not want their work to be seen by few, appreciated by even fewer anymore than a professional athlete would prefer to perform in NYC as opposed to Wazoo City Mississippi, right?

"Who says the only the articles "dm,md/./od" disagree with with are racically charged except for you ?"

Only me.

Seems noone else is honest enough to show where they labeled other articles involving race as "racially charged" if the article was gushing over how grand non-whites are or was being apologetic for every wrong any black anywhere on earth at any time in history.....

But I could be wrong, I could be presented with evidence of this having been done and me just not noticing so feel free to correct me if I an mistaken. It has happened before and will happen again.............
 
Last edited:
The Black-white income gap, segregation in public elementary and high schools, and Black unemployment are all higher today than 40 years ago. Sounds to me like affirmative action is still quite necessary.

And of course, the main beneficiaries of affirmative action are women.
http://www.nwlc.org/resource/affirmative-action-and-what-it-means-women
The excuses are over. Time to achieve on a level playing field. Blacks and Hispanics have already responded to opportunity. More will follow in an egalitarian system.

What failure has happened is because of lieberale values that have stunted the growth of many. Starting with forcing single parent family values with economic incentives and abortion values. Lieberales need to fade now.
 
As far as your original question, "Isn't that just another form of affirmative action", no, not unless there is some way to show that the articles of Mr. Williams were selected to be published BECAUSE they were submitted by a black man and some other, article equal to or better than his was not.

Being there is no way for me to know that my answer is still, no, it is not, " just another form of affirmative action", sorry. Perhaps YOU have some way of knowing differently that makes you believe it is, if so then please share.


"But the wouldn't be followed with the same zeal as a TH audience has for them."

I would certainly suspect not. Having ones work followed with as much zeal is pretty much the goal of all people in every field. As an author one would not want their work to be seen by few, appreciated by even fewer anymore than a professional athlete would prefer to perform in NYC as opposed to Wazoo City Mississippi, right?

"Who says the only the articles "dm,md/./od" disagree with with are racically charged except for you ?"

Only me.

Seems noone else is honest enough to show where they labeled other articles involving race as "racially charged" if the article was gushing over how grand non-whites are or was being apologetic for every wrong any black anywhere on earth at any time in history.....

But I could be wrong, I could be presented with evidence of this having been done and me just not noticing so feel free to correct me if I an mistaken. It has happened before and will happen again.............

"I am sure they could get published somewhere else."

And I am not. So there we are.......

At the point where you are saying his articles need special help to be published.

How is that not affirmative action as you see it ?
 
I find it interesting that people always point out athletics as a field where Blacks do good. Its is obvious to anyone that Blacks are built different, watch a basketball game, blacks can really jump well, its a physical difference. In the same token blacks show constantly that they do not perform well in studies. It might just be a real difference. I'm sure people might go nuts over this as its not politically correct. Why point out one area that they excel and refuse to touch an area where they don't. I'm convinced there are mental differences in the races, I believe the Asians are way better than whites, just look to the test scores.

I had a friend who moved manufacturing to china, he was astounded by the difference. He said they had a hard time teaching people to do the jobs properly, when he moved the operation to Korea the people being hired from the farms could do the jobs better than the American counterpart. There are differences people.
 

Obama is president, he should disclose everything, like past presidents. Obama has sequestered all his college grades and forms. One has to ask, what is he hiding. Yes, I question his academics based on the hiding of records, not because he is Black.
 
Obama is president, he should disclose everything, like past presidents. Obama has sequestered all his college grades and forms. One has to ask, what is he hiding. Yes, I question his academics based on the hiding of records, not because he is Black.

You should be tired of being wrong all the time by now.

How about you show me Bush Sr. college transcripts or LBJ's or Kennedy's
 
I find it interesting that people always point out athletics as a field where Blacks do good. Its is obvious to anyone that Blacks are built different, watch a basketball game, blacks can really jump well, its a physical difference. In the same token blacks show constantly that they do not perform well in studies. It might just be a real difference. I'm sure people might go nuts over this as its not politically correct. Why point out one area that they excel and refuse to touch an area where they don't. I'm convinced there are mental differences in the races, I believe the Asians are way better than whites, just look to the test scores.

I had a friend who moved manufacturing to china, he was astounded by the difference. He said they had a hard time teaching people to do the jobs properly, when he moved the operation to Korea the people being hired from the farms could do the jobs better than the American counterpart. There are differences people.
I'm not one to dismiss the idea of racial mental differences out of hand. But, there are a few important points to consider, if you want to poke that hornet's nest with a stick:

(1) Even if there are racial trends, they're nearly always vastly smaller than differences between individuals. So, it's important not to take an overly determinative view of race. For example, if you can choose a black person or a white person for your basketball team, and all you know is race, then maybe there's some sense in picking the black one, if you believe there's some genetic factor there. But if you know ANYTHING more about the people -- age, gender, height, weight, build, background, etc.-- you can probably choose a crap-load better than just by knowing race. I'd much rather have the option to pick between a 25-year-old and a 70-year-old, site unseen, for example, than between a black and a white person.

(2) The very concept of race is problematic, and never more so than with black people, since people of African heritage have more genetic diversity amongst themselves than the rest of humankind has combined. Speaking of one "black" race, that encompasses the lanky Dinka people (average height of 6') and the Mbutsi people (pygmies with an average male height of 4'6"), is just a matter of focusing on superficial traits like skin color and hair coarseness. Within Africa, for example, you also have West Africans, known for fast-twitch muscles (the vast majority of the world's best sprinters come from West African origins), and East Africans, known for slow-twitch muscles (Kenyans and Ethiopians are powerhouses in distance running). So, if we were looking to figure out mental tendencies by "race," we'd have to think a lot more tribally and genetically, not just in terms of large socially-constructed population blocks based on trivia like skin color.

(3) Social factors can have huge impacts that massively outweigh genetic ones. For example, the Dutch were once known as the shortest people of Europe. Now they're the tallest nation on Earth. Their genes didn't change that much in that little time. Nutrition did. But that kind of thing can take a while to show up. If your mother was stunted through poor nutrition, then even if you get good nutrition, you may never reach your full potential height, because your first nine months were spent in a stunted womb. And if you're a little stunted, too, even your kid may be a bit stunted. So, it can take a couple generations for improved nutrition to show up fully in average heights. It makes sense it would be true for mental situations, too. If you spend your first nine months in a stunted person, maybe your mind won't be fully able to reach its genetic potential. And then there's the whole field of epigentics, where there's the possibility that which genes get expressed can be influenced by environmental factors, and that these expressions can get passed along -- for example, if your grandfather experienced famine, you may be less likely to get heart disease, because certain genes got activated in him by that environmental stress, and those genes got passed down in their "switched on" form, to you.

With all those things to consider, and the severe difficulty of measuring minds even in the best of circumstances, it would be very, very hard to reach any meaningful conclusions about any genetic differences in mental abilities from one group of humans to another. As such, for policy-setting purposes, it's probably better to focus our efforts on individuals and on society, rather than spending too much time worrying about some relatively minor population-group genetic differences that may or may not actually exist.
 
Last edited:
You should be tired of being wrong all the time by now.

How about you show me Bush Sr. college transcripts or LBJ's or Kennedy's

Damn, the only thing you loons can answer with is Bush. I think your all just crazy stupid. Try commenting about something without saying Bush, it can be done.
 
I have seen great strides in society in accepting black.

Translation: society, that is, white people, have magnanimously agreed to tolerate the presence of Black people among them. You deem the progress made by (white) society in this regard more than adequate.

I also see blacks using racism as an excuse for them not succeeding. It is so nice to have an out as to why you don't do well, just look at how the race card has been over used, it is used to the point of irrelevance.

Translation: you've stopped listening to Black people on the rare occasions when they point out the most blatant forms of the racial discrimination that they face on a daily basis.

Look to the Black family falling apart, thank you social system. The pendulum has swung and now they use everything and are becoming an entitled group.

Translation: ignore the fact that the white family is falling apart as well. Ignore the social science research demonstrating that racial discrimination is still commonplace and that, as a result, whites have distinct advantages in nearly all areas including law enforcement, education, housing, health care, and employment. Instead, complain because uppity Blacks are drinking from society's water fountains.

Look at the knock out games, the black mobs swarming stores, if they were afraid of racism this would not be happening, they know they will get by with it, society gives them a pass.

Translation: some racist myths with almost no basis in fact prove that racism no longer exists.
 
We have a black President.
We have a black Attorney General
We had a black woman Secretary of State
Yes. It is past the time that blacks need a hand up in order to achieve.
They are fully able to achieve anything they wish to achieve.

It's all about work ethic
It's all about the content of someone's character, NOT the color of his/her skin.

As Kwame Ture put it, "Black visibility does not equal Black power." The presence of a few token Blacks in positions of power--positions that they probably would not have been able to attain if not for affirmative action--does not change the fact that the Black working class as a whole faces severe obstacles to achieving things that many whites are able to take for granted.
 
It's also about culture. Many blacks are still brought up to believe that assimilating into American society is "acting too white". That has hurrt the chances of many blacks to achieve. In essence, many have chosen to segregate themselves.

This is more a self created problem than anything else


Despite claims by many on the right that blacks (especially youth) lack a connection to “mainstream values,” evidence contradicts this notion. One mid-1990s questionnaire of black high school seniors found that black seniors were just as likely as white seniors to say that a good marriage and family life were “extremely important” life goals; 32 percent more likely than whites to say that professional success and accomplishment were “extremely important” life goals; 26 percent more likely than whites to say “making a contribution to society” was extremely important; and 75 percent more likely than whites to say “being a leader in their community” was an extremely important life goal.

http://www.timwise.org/2002/11/not-...n-and-the-myth-of-black-anti-intellectualism/
 
The excuses are over. Time to achieve on a level playing field. Blacks and Hispanics have already responded to opportunity. More will follow in an egalitarian system.

What failure has happened is because of lieberale values that have stunted the growth of many. Starting with forcing single parent family values with economic incentives and abortion values. Lieberales need to fade now.

There isn't a level playing field. Name a facet of a typical American's life, and there is ample evidence of unequal distribution of opportunity based on race.
 
Back
Top