New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Interesting Question

its in the power of individual blacks to do so. there is a range of work ethic, intelligence, education, etc in the black community, the same as there is with every other race.

the reason that asians and jews acheive superior careers and success comared to (in descending order) whites, hispanics, and blacks is that their kids don't drop out of school and use drugs.

case closed.
 
A better question is do you think right wing outlets hire Black columnist to write articles like these because they would sound kinda racist coming from a non Black columnist. And isn't that a form of affirmative action in an of itself ?


Mr. Williams is widely read because he's good at what he does. That's the opposite of a quota-based system, that's free enterprise.
 
Yes, of coarse blacks can make it in society without all the special treatment. To do that they need to make changes to their culture and that means, stay in school, quite playing the victim and rejuvenate the families, not the baby daddy society of today. If Blacks would do these simple things I am convinced things would greatly change for them and true equality would evolve. A very smart man once said, " Judge me by the content of my character, not the color of my skin". Truly a great idea, too bad no one listened.

I assume you are paraphrasing affirmative action supporter Martin Luther King, Jr. I also assume that in his time you'd have told him to stop "playing the victim" and make changes to his culture.
 
its in the power of individual blacks to do so. there is a range of work ethic, intelligence, education, etc in the black community, the same as there is with every other race.

the reason that asians and jews acheive superior careers and success comared to (in descending order) whites, hispanics, and blacks is that their kids don't drop out of school and use drugs.

case closed.

Blacks are more likely to have perfect attendance in high school than whites. They are also less likely to use drugs than whites. They are also more likely to get nightly help with homework from their parents.

A Black woman with a college degree is less likely to have a job than a white male high school dropout.
 
http://leftycartoons.com/a-concise-history-of-black-white-relations-in-the-united-states/

concise.png
 
Walter Williams posed a legitimate query in one of his recent columns. If anyone would care to discuss this (minus the flame-throwers), I think this is a fair topic for intelligent discussion:


Earlier this month, the 50th anniversary of the Civil Rights Act was celebrated. During the act's legislative debate, then-Sen. Hubert Humphrey, responding to predictions, promised, "I'll eat my hat if this leads to racial quotas." I don't know whether Humphrey got around to keeping his promise, but here's my question: Is it within the capacity of black Americans to make it in this society without the special favors variously called racial preferences, quotas, affirmative action and race-sensitive policies? What might a "yes" answer to that question assume and imply about blacks? Likewise, what would a "no" answer assume and imply?

http://townhall.com/columnists/walterewilliams/2014/07/23/do-blacks-need-favors-n1864237


Thoughts?
Affirmative Action had its time and place and did great good. I'm glad for it and was warranted. Now its arc of worth is turning downward. We need to pass a law that says Affirmative Action will be sunsetted in 2024/25.

Fair warning for all to get off their ass.
 
Blacks are more likely to have perfect attendance in high school than whites. They are also less likely to use drugs than whites. They are also more likely to get nightly help with homework from their parents.

A Black woman with a college degree is less likely to have a job than a white male high school dropout.

1) You make blacks sound positively Jewish or Asian. Two groups that have had inertia piled on them as well and yet they greatly succeeded.

2) Not all colllege diplomas nor for that matter high school diplomas have intrinsic worth.
 
It's interesting, from my perspective, to see what white posters think about this topic. I've enjoyed reading the comments here.

For what it's worth, here's Mr. Williams take. The last sentence speaks volumes.

There are some areas of black life in which excellence can be found without the slightest hint of racial preferences. Young blacks dominate basketball, football and some track-and-field events despite the fact that there has been a history of gross racial discrimination in those activities. Blacks are also prominent in several areas of the entertainment industry. Those observations mean that racial discrimination alone is not an insurmountable barrier to success. By the way, I can't think of any two fields with more ruthless competition.

You say, "OK, Williams, everyone knows about the success of blacks in sports and entertainment, but what about the intellectual arena?" A few inner-city junior high and high schools have produced black champion chess players, schools such as Philadelphia's Roberts Vaux High School and New York's Edward R. Murrow High School. Last year, two black teens -- from Intermediate School 318 Eugenio Maria de Hostos in Brooklyn, New York -- won the national high-school chess championship. All of this is in addition to quite a few black international masters and grandmasters in chess. Moreover, there's a long list of former and current black inventors and scientists. So there's no question that black people have the capacity to compete intellectually.

Civil rights organizations and their progressive allies, who all but suggest that blacks cannot achieve unless they are given special privileges, grossly insult and demean black people. But worse than that, when civil rights organizations and their progressive allies pursue special privileges for blacks in college admissions and when they attack academic performance standards as racially discriminatory, they are aiding and abetting an education establishment that delivers fraudulent education. They let educators off the hook, thereby enabling them to continue to produce educational fraud.


You say, "What do you mean by educational fraud, Williams?" There are many inputs to education that are beyond the control of educators, such as poor home environment, derelict parental oversight and students with minds alien and hostile to the education process. But there's one thing entirely within the control of the education establishment. That is the conferral of a high-school diploma. When a school confers a diploma upon a student, it attests that the student has mastered the 12th-grade levels of reading, writing and arithmetic. If, in fact, the student cannot perform at the seventh- or eighth-grade levels, the school has committed gross fraud. Even worse is the fact that black people, including those holding fraudulent diplomas, are completely unaware. It has absolutely nothing to do with racial discrimination. In fact, black education is the worst in cities where blacks have been the mayor, chief of police and superintendent of schools and where most of the teachers and principals are black.

Racial preferences in college admissions give elementary schools, middle schools and high schools a free hand to continue their destructive educational policy. If colleges did not have special admissions practices for black students, there would be far fewer blacks in colleges, and the fraud would be more apparent to parents. They might begin to ask why so many blacks with high-school diplomas could not get into college.

If the civil rights establishment and the progressives have their way, blacks will have to rely on special privileges in perpetuity.


I think the educational fraud is the most damaging. We don't do anyone a favor by making them think they are better or smarter than they are - or that they have mastered material they haven't etc. And, the problem is - even if people discover it later - its almost too late.... its much harder to learn as you get older. We are wasting the golden years of learning by passing kids on that should not be passed on.
 
Affirmative Action had its time and place and did great good. I'm glad for it and was warranted. Now its arc of worth is turning downward. We need to pass a law that says Affirmative Action will be sunsetted in 2024/25.

Fair warning for all to get off their ass.

The Black-white income gap, segregation in public elementary and high schools, and Black unemployment are all higher today than 40 years ago. Sounds to me like affirmative action is still quite necessary.

And of course, the main beneficiaries of affirmative action are women.
http://www.nwlc.org/resource/affirmative-action-and-what-it-means-women
 
Walter Williams posed a legitimate query in one of his recent columns. If anyone would care to discuss this (minus the flame-throwers), I think this is a fair topic for intelligent discussion:


Earlier this month, the 50th anniversary of the Civil Rights Act was celebrated. During the act's legislative debate, then-Sen. Hubert Humphrey, responding to predictions, promised, "I'll eat my hat if this leads to racial quotas." I don't know whether Humphrey got around to keeping his promise, but here's my question: Is it within the capacity of black Americans to make it in this society without the special favors variously called racial preferences, quotas, affirmative action and race-sensitive policies? What might a "yes" answer to that question assume and imply about blacks? Likewise, what would a "no" answer assume and imply?

http://townhall.com/columnists/walterewilliams/2014/07/23/do-blacks-need-favors-n1864237


Thoughts?

let's use Barack Obama in your query.
why do you cons disbelieve Barack Obama's educational achievement? I trust I don't have to repeat what they've said specifically questioning his attendance, his grades, etc., but isn't that the same as saying that cons don't believe that Obama, a black man, could make it on his own without affirmative action?
my point - when cons stop questioning achievements of black men and women they disagree with, then we can end the discussion of AA.
btw, I do think we need AA for the poor/lower class regardless of color.
 
I assume you are paraphrasing affirmative action supporter Martin Luther King, Jr. I also assume that in his time you'd have told him to stop "playing the victim" and make changes to his culture.

Yes, of coarse I was quoting King and no during his time I would not have said that as there were wrongs that needed righting, but since that time the Black community has taken a step back and actually regressed as a people. Yes, society has done much to accept and accommodate them, but I believe the Blacks have not held up their end in moving forward. Much of the problems today can be laid squarely at the feet of the black community.
 
Conservative whites have blamed Black pathology, and not white racism, for the problems facing the Black community since the days of slavery, and they have consistently been wrong. They did it in King's time, and they were wrong then. What makes you think the conservative whites, who haven't changed their tune, are suddenly right this time?
 
Conservative whites have blamed Black pathology, and not white racism, for the problems facing the Black community since the days of slavery, and they have consistently been wrong. They did it in King's time, and they were wrong then. What makes you think the conservative whites, who haven't changed their tune, are suddenly right this time?

I have seen great strides in society in accepting black. I also see blacks using racism as an excuse for them not succeeding. It is so nice to have an out as to why you don't do well, just look at how the race card has been over used, it is used to the point of irrelevance. Look to the Black family falling apart, thank you social system. The pendulum has swung and now they use everything and are becoming an entitled group.
Look at the knock out games, the black mobs swarming stores, if they were afraid of racism this would not be happening, they know they will get by with it, society gives them a pass.
 
No, that is not a "better question".

The BEST question would be;
Why do you think right wing outlets have to hire black columnist to write articles like these least they be deemed to be "racist", by dems/l ibs coming from a non black columnist.

But I do suppose that having a black columnist labeled an "Uncle Tom" for daring to question the way the left demands we all treat people differently based upon nothing more than their race today in order to make amends for................well, hell, the way we treated people differently based upon nothing more than their race in the past COULD be less of a shot to absorb from liberals than having a non-black columnist labeled a "racist" for doing exactly the same thing a black columnist can do......

It all makes perfect sense when looked at in that "certain" way, huh?

Your supposition aside. Williams points to areas of Black success that rely on pure talent above that of the average individual. Sports either you got it or you ain't. Entertainment either the public response to your performances or it doesn't. Even chess while intellectual is same as sports and the champions are rare individuals. But in the REAL working world that's not the case.

Let's take my question and expand on it with a little evidence.

Here is Williams' history with Town Hall. Can you find me a single or even combined columnists who have written more of these racially charged stories for that site.

http://townhall.com/columnists/walterewilliams/


Ball's in your court champ.
 
Last edited:
Your supposition aside. Williams points to areas of Black success that rely on pure talent above that of the average individual. Sports either you got it or you ain't. Entertainment either the public response to your performances or it doesn't. Even while chess intellectual is same as sports and the champions are rare individuals. But in the REAL working world that's not the case.

Let's take my question and expand on it with a little evidence.

Here is Williams' history with Town Hall. Can you find me a single or even to combined columnist who have written more of these racially charged stories for that site.

http://townhall.com/columnists/walterewilliams/


Ball's in your court champ.

I find no reason to question WHY Mr. Williams writes whatever he writes any more than I would question any other writer.

Without doing a study on the matter i would be inclined to believe that every writer out there opts to write about whatever moves him and he believes he understands. Just as most sports writers write about certain sports more than others.

As for why it is Mr. Williams has so many of the race based articles on that site I suspect that would be because of the fact that, as a black man, he feels far less intimidated by the left than most non-black writers who, as YOU know, WILL get labeled as "racist" by dems/l ibs if they dare so much as mention race in an article that might not be gushing toward said race.

So I would expect him to have far and away more articles about race. No one else wants to be deemed to be a "racist"........by racist.
 
Walter Williams posed a legitimate query in one of his recent columns. If anyone would care to discuss this (minus the flame-throwers), I think this is a fair topic for intelligent discussion:


Earlier this month, the 50th anniversary of the Civil Rights Act was celebrated. During the act's legislative debate, then-Sen. Hubert Humphrey, responding to predictions, promised, "I'll eat my hat if this leads to racial quotas." I don't know whether Humphrey got around to keeping his promise, but here's my question: Is it within the capacity of black Americans to make it in this society without the special favors variously called racial preferences, quotas, affirmative action and race-sensitive policies? What might a "yes" answer to that question assume and imply about blacks? Likewise, what would a "no" answer assume and imply?

http://townhall.com/columnists/walterewilliams/2014/07/23/do-blacks-need-favors-n1864237


Thoughts?

We have a black President.
We have a black Attorney General
We had a black woman Secretary of State
Yes. It is past the time that blacks need a hand up in order to achieve.
They are fully able to achieve anything they wish to achieve.

It's all about work ethic
It's all about the content of someone's character, NOT the color of his/her skin.
 
I find no reason to question WHY Mr. Williams writes whatever he writes any more than I would question any other writer.

Without doing a study on the matter i would be inclined to believe that every writer out there opts to write about whatever moves him and he believes he understands. Just as most sports writers write about certain sports more than others.

As for why it is Mr. Williams has so many of the race based articles on that site I suspect that would be because of the fact that, as a black man, he feels far less intimidated by the left than most non-black writers who, as YOU know, WILL get labeled as "racist" by dems/l ibs if they dare so much as mention race in an article that might not be gushing toward said race.

So I would expect him to have far and away more articles about race. No one else wants to be deemed to be a "racist"........by racist.

You are being both hypocritical and disingenuous. You lash out with accusations on the motivations and machination of of the left even to the point of blanketing it all with your cryptic monicker "dems/l ibs" . Yet you have no reason to quesiton why a far right website would print so many racially charged articles from a single columnist. Maybe more than all the other columnist combined and not think it might have something to do with his race ? And why does someone have to be deemed a racist when writing about race in a non gushing fashion ? It's done all the time by writers of all different races. But then again they are all writing for the audience this site wants to attract. An audience who would seek to justify the subjective by pointing out the objective.
 
We have a black President.
We have a black Attorney General
We had a black woman Secretary of State
Yes. It is past the time that blacks need a hand up in order to achieve.
They are fully able to achieve anything they wish to achieve.

It's all about work ethic
It's all about the content of someone's character, NOT the color of his/her skin.

It's also about culture. Many blacks are still brought up to believe that assimilating into American society is "acting too white". That has hurrt the chances of many blacks to achieve. In essence, many have chosen to segregate themselves.

This is more a self created problem than anything else
 
Back
Top