New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Jill Stein

No. what they like is "united states" recognizing the individuality of the individual states. you know.. like the founders intended.
Some of the founders intended that...But not all.... that was 250 years ago...Balancing government is daunting job to be sure...Libertarians seem to feel government should be one guy in an office with a rotary phone
 
If you have that part handy - by all means - direct me to it. Otherwise you are admitting that you did not address that point.

You don't seem to know what an admission is. Note: I didn't say "you're admitting you don't know what an admission is," since that would be different. I don't think you've ADMITTED you don't know what an admission is. Rather, I am inferring that you don't know what an admission is by the way you're misusing the term.
 
Some of the founders intended that...But not all.... that was 250 years ago...Balancing government is daunting job to be sure...Libertarians seem to feel government should be one guy in an office with a rotary phone

Yes, it was a perfect plan 250 years ago, and authoritarians and power hungry theives have abused the concept. There is nothing we need from the federal Gov't other than what it was deisgned to do. To see to a common currency, negotiate treaties, and run the military. Within our states where we have more of a voice, we can elect for all the gov;t we want.

connie
 
No. what they like is "united states" recognizing the individuality of the individual states. you know.. like the founders intended.
I'd have no use for the kind of libertarian who is merely wrapping himself in the long-disgraced ideology of states rights, which has been a tool for depriving people of civil liberties (e.g., it was the rallying cry of the pro-slavery movement and the pro-segregation movement). The ones I think might have something useful to offer to the world are those who are interested in maximizing individual freedom, not individual state power.
 
You don't seem to know what an admission is. Note: I didn't say "you're admitting you don't know what an admission is," since that would be different. I don't think you've ADMITTED you don't know what an admission is. Rather, I am inferring that you don't know what an admission is by the way you're misusing the term.

Really well, the your inference is wrong.

You admitted that your post did not address what you told me it did by your inability to point me to the part where it did , and a recitiation of a part which I was not talking about.

Just man up and be honest. You replied to my post like a jack arse. when you infact did not address my point in your top post.

Did you or did you not discuss in your top post - the potential jettisoning of those non-gmo'ers once a successful coalition was formed.

I know its difficult and being an attorney - giving a one word straight answer is near impossible for you.. but i have faith you can do it. Its very simple.. yes or no.

connie
 
I'd have no use for the kind of libertarian who is merely wrapping himself in the long-disgraced ideology of states rights, which has been a tool for depriving people of civil liberties (e.g., it was the rallying cry of the pro-slavery movement and the pro-segregation movement). The ones I think might have something useful to offer to the world are those who are interested in maximizing individual freedom, not individual state power.

Individual freedom is maximized by individual state power because having more power at the lands of local gov'ts gives the citizens of those districts more direct control. That gives a person's vote more power and a more of a voice which is necessary to ensure that people have the freedom to self govern adequately.


connie
 
Yes, it was a perfect plan 250 years ago, and authoritarians and power hungry theives have abused the concept. There is nothing we need from the federal Gov't other than what it was deisgned to do.

To establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty for ourselves and our posterity.

I think that minorities have more of a voice in a federal government than a state one, since they can more meaningfully band together for common cause. For example, if you're one of just a few thousand Jews in your state, your ability to prevent your tax money from being appropriated to promote Christianity is going to be very limited. But if you can team up with millions of Jews nationally for that purpose, you're a lot more able to preserve that wall between church and faith. I think that's why, in our history, you repeatedly find majority groups trying to push authority as much as possible to state or even local levels, where they can dominate, while minorities are more likely to look for help from the federal government. "States rights" has a pretty ugly history as a rallying cry.
 
I'd have no use for the kind of libertarian who is merely wrapping himself in the long-disgraced ideology of states rights, which has been a tool for depriving people of civil liberties

How ironic, your state's Attorney General did just that very recently. But, I have a feeling it was just fine with you, ever the good Tory you are.
 
I'd have no use for the kind of libertarian who is merely wrapping himself in the long-disgraced ideology of states rights, which has been a tool for depriving people of civil liberties (e.g., it was the rallying cry of the pro-slavery movement and the pro-segregation movement). The ones I think might have something useful to offer to the world are those who are interested in maximizing individual freedom, not individual state power.
Agreed...One could only imagine what some States would implement as law and policy...There has to be a balance...
 
To establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty for ourselves and our posterity.

I think that minorities have more of a voice in a federal government than a state one, since they can more meaningfully band together for common cause. For example, if you're one of just a few thousand Jews in your state, your ability to prevent your tax money from being appropriated to promote Christianity is going to be very limited. But if you can team up with millions of Jews nationally for that purpose, you're a lot more able to preserve that wall between church and faith. I think that's why, in our history, you repeatedly find majority groups trying to push authority as much as possible to state or even local levels, where they can dominate, while minorities are more likely to look for help from the federal government. "States rights" has a pretty ugly history as a rallying cry.

They can more meaninfully band together for a common cuase in any state or city where they are not a minority. Which they have.. in pretty much every urban center in this country.. not that that has been a positive.. but whatever.

The idea of course is that like minded people will drft to where other like minded peopel are. We are allowed to move freely here. If you want to live an an area that more represnts your values, there are 49 other states where you can go and form your own majority... just like the homos did in san fran 40 years ago.
 
You admitted that your post did not address what you told me it did by your inability to point me to the part where it did , and a recitiation of a part which I was not talking about.

No. You INFERRED that I was unable to point you to that part and you took that as equivalent to an admission. That is, obviously, not an admission. You're trying to redefint the word, but if we play that game I could just as easily say that you just admitted I was right, by failing to make an argument that I was wrong.

Did you or did you not discuss in your top post - the potential jettisoning of those non-gmo'ers once a successful coalition was formed.

You complete lost track of this thread. Try thinking next time. This time, I'll help you out:

You said "Oh, I am sorry, I must have missed your disdain for the practice of aligning with those left wing nut jobs to form a coalition." I pointed out that in the top post I did, in fact, express my disdain for that practice. The whole post was taking Stein to task for aligning with left wing nut jobs to form a coalition (the anti-GMOers and the anti-Vaxxers). If you failed to spot the disdain in the phrase "lunatic fringe" I'm afraid I can't help you further.
 
Agreed...One could only imagine what some States would implement as law and policy...There has to be a balance...

Yes, its called the constitution. And, those laws get challenged in court and overturned. You know.. the way the process is supposed to work.
 
They can more meaninfully band together for a common cuase in any state or city where they are not a minority. Which they have.. in pretty much every urban center in this country.. not that that has been a positive.. but whatever.

The idea of course is that like minded people will drft to where other like minded peopel are. We are allowed to move freely here. If you want to live an an area that more represnts your values, there are 49 other states where you can go and form your own majority... just like the homos did in san fran 40 years ago.
I fully admit that "states rights" is a recipe for returning to segregation -- both by way of minorities having an incentive to flee to minority enclaves for mutual protection, and by way of a return of de jure segregation once that ethnic cleansing has been accomplished.
 
No. You INFERRED that I was unable to point you to that part and you took that as equivalent to an admission. That is, obviously, not an admission. You're trying to redefint the word, but if we play that game I could just as easily say that you just admitted I was right, by failing to make an argument that I was wrong.



You complete lost track of this thread. Try thinking next time. This time, I'll help you out:

You said "Oh, I am sorry, I must have missed your disdain for the practice of aligning with those left wing nut jobs to form a coalition." I pointed out that in the top post I did, in fact, express my disdain for that practice. The whole post was taking Stein to task for aligning with left wing nut jobs to form a coalition (the anti-GMOers and the anti-Vaxxers). If you failed to spot the disdain in the phrase "lunatic fringe" I'm afraid I can't help you further.


Ah.. so we are talking past each other then.

I specifically was addressing - inquiring if you expressed disdain in pandering to those voters for the purpose of forming a coalition - to get policies done... but then dropping them later once that coalition had served its usefulness.

Do you or do you not endorse such polices?


connie
 
I fully admit that "states rights" is a recipe for returning to segregation -- both by way of minorities having an incentive to flee to minority enclaves for mutual protection, and by way of a return of de jure segregation once that ethnic cleansing has been accomplished.

Right, so the authoritarian in you can't stand that people would want to live and work and share resources with people who share their same values...
 
Ah.. so we are talking past each other then.

Fair enough. That appears to be the theme of this whole forum.

I specifically was addressing - inquiring if you expressed disdain in pandering to those voters for the purpose of forming a coalition - to get policies done... but then dropping them later once that coalition had served its usefulness.

Do you or do you not endorse such polices?

I consider it unethical to implicitly promise something you have no intent of trying to deliver. So, generally I'd be against that, though it would depend on exactly how it was done. I mean, if what you were implicitly promising wasn't that you'd do something you didn't intend to do (like working to block GMO crops), but rather that you just wouldn't actively work against the anti-GMOers, then as long as there was no deception involved, that could be an ethical trade-off. I could see myself doing that. For example, I think GMO labeling is pointless clutter, but that doesn't strike me as terribly important, so I wouldn't go out of my way to fight against labeling laws of that sort, and I'd be willing to trade that for support I could use for more important things.
 
Right, so the authoritarian in you can't stand that people would want to live and work and share resources with people who share their same values...
People are free to live and work with others who share their values. But, I've seen the petty tyrannies of small-town and small-state politics up close, and it has left me with little faith in the ability of smaller, more-local government to preserve individual liberties.
 
People are free to live and work with others who share their values. But, I've seen the petty tyrannies of small-town and small-state politics up close, and it has left me with little faith in the ability of smaller, more-local government to preserve individual liberties.

If the people in the areas are electing those people to create standards by which they want to live, then they are preserving the most important individual liberty - the one of self governing. Simply because they would like to pass a law that says in the public square women should have their hair covered - then that should be their right. If enough of the voters -believe that women should have their hair covered. If they don't then they can riseup and vote those people out of office.While that may seem tyrannical, it only is -if it is as a result of a minority strong arming their will on the majority.
 
Yes, it was a perfect plan 250 years ago, and authoritarians and power hungry theives have abused the concept. There is nothing we need from the federal Gov't other than what it was deisgned to do. To see to a common currency, negotiate treaties, and run the military. Within our states where we have more of a voice, we can elect for all the gov;t we want.

connie

Sorry, no. It was not "perfect". Indeed, it was so imperfect, it required 10 Amendments in short order.
 
Back
Top