New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Left Behind

I haven't read the mildly popular "Left Behind" books, or seen the box office flops by that name (either the version with former child star Kirk Cameron or the reboot starring Nicolas "Whatever Gets Me a Paycheck" Cage). But, I think I know the basic plot (amusingly spoofed in a couple recent movies "Rapturepalooza" and "This is the End"): the end-times have arrived and -- consistent with a textually specious reading of the Book of Revelation -- the good Christians have been taken up to Heaven, leaving the rest of us to suffer through a period of chaos and the ascendency of the antichrist. It occurs to me that the world would probably be better if the most devout believers were, in fact, "raptured" to some other existence.

Picture a world in which all the most devout people suddenly vanished -- not just the Christians, mind you, but anyone who has enough faith in a supernatural dogma for it to govern his life in a major way. Picture waking up tomorrow morning and ISIS and al Qaeda have ceased to exist. The vast majority of votes against gay marriage and reproductive choice: gone. No more female genital mutilation. No more stoning people to death for having the wrong kind of consensual sex. A quarter of the GOP's leadership gone, and the other three-quarters revealed to be poseurs. No more attempts to have creation taught as science. No more Catholic hierarchy interfering with efforts to encourage family planning in poor countries. No more Israelis convinced "Greater Israel" was given to the Jews by divine mandate, and no more Palestinians willing to kill and die in the name of Allah.

It wouldn't be utopia, to be sure. There are plenty of jackass non-believers out there. And losing some true believers would have negative consequences as well -- missionaries, for example, often do some real good in poor parts of the world in the process of trying to spread their faith. But I suspect that if if the 10% of mankind that most fervently believes in the supernatural were to vanish, once the shock wore off, the rest of us would find we were a lot happier, more peaceful, and more productive.

No more female genital mutilation.
 
I have no quarrel with the words of the bible - there are many and beautiful truths in it - I am Gnostic and no I don't believe in deities in the literal sense - other than as philosophical tools -

I do btw believe in the supernatural but not that it can or does affect us as 'it' will - only if we harness its forces -

Oh and what position? I haven't stated one - not yet anyway :)

So in other words, no one can really pin you down?

You believe in the supernatural but do not dare define what it means, or if it is like a personal God or if it is merely some force.

You say we can harness this “force,” but you probably could not point to how or when that may be accomplished.

Then you call yourself a Gnostic which is such an ambivalent theology or philosophy, it can mean all kinds of things to whomever. It is based upon knowledge and revelation, but it sure appears to me to be based upon personal interpretation as well.

So to sum: you are free to think as you please and do as you please, and you do not feel there will be any retribution for your decisions unless you egregiously violate your conscience. Yes or no?

I think it’s dangerous because you do not appear able to deny certain supernatural revelations of the Christian or Jewish faiths, and yet, you go forward thinking or acting as though you have nothing to acknowledge or be held accountable to a “higher power.” Not even sure you acknowledge immortality?
 
I have no quarrel with the words of the bible - there are many and beautiful truths in it - I am Gnostic and no I don't believe in deities in the literal sense - other than as philosophical tools -

I do btw believe in the supernatural but not that it can or does affect us as 'it' will - only if we harness its forces -

Oh and what position? I haven't stated one - not yet anyway :)

The gnostics were found out for forging "gospels" back in the second and third century.

What I don't understand is if you have no quarrel with the words in the Bible and, in fact, believe some of them, how do you know the rest of them are not the truth? Or is it because you're familiar with the history of the gnostics and the forgeries that all the Gospels are suspect to you?
 
So in other words, no one can really pin you down?

You believe in the supernatural but do not dare define what it means, or if it is like a personal God or if it is merely some force.

You say we can harness this “force,” but you probably could not point to how or when that may be accomplished.

Then you call yourself a Gnostic which is such an ambivalent theology or philosophy, it can mean all kinds of things to whomever. It is based upon knowledge and revelation, but it sure appears to me to be based upon personal interpretation as well.

So to sum: you are free to think as you please and do as you please, and you do not feel there will be any retribution for your decisions unless you egregiously violate your conscience. Yes or no?

I think it’s dangerous because you do not appear able to deny certain supernatural revelations of the Christian or Jewish faiths, and yet, you go forward thinking or acting as though you have nothing to acknowledge or be held accountable to a “higher power.” Not even sure you acknowledge immortality?


You asked me a short question, out of curiosity you said, I gave you an answer accordingly.

Pin me down to what? No I do not believe that God is The Creator - but Creation.

That all is a part of Creation/God and that finding God is finding a connection with the All - That spirit is the life force and that our souls are our connection to that spirit and each other - That these words are our understandings not out side forces - That since we are all a tiny piece of God we find him/her within as well as without.

Of the supernatural, I mentioned it because of my own experiences none of which are other wise explainable.

Gnostic/Heathen/Pagan - take your pick - There is nothing ambivalent about any of them of which I am a mixture and I will add 'The Mystery religions' too boot which have had a huge effect on my thinking and way of being - of course I take truths from everywhere and of course they are personal.

Pardon? Let me read this bit again -

So to sum: you are free to think as you please and do as you please, and you do not feel there will be any retribution for your decisions unless you egregiously violate your conscience. Yes or no?

Free thought - Yes, it is essential. Ummmm I think you will have to be more specific in that last bit because I do not understand what I stand accused of here.

Accountable? I am accountable of course I am - but I take whole responsibility for myself - We and we alone are responsible for this Planet and it is time we realised this, no one is coming to help us no one else is to blame or should be praised for what we have and do and will do - just us - we are alone.

As for Karma, it is a more complex philosophy than we first realize :)
 
Last edited:
The gnostics were found out for forging "gospels" back in the second and third century.

What I don't understand is if you have no quarrel with the words in the Bible and, in fact, believe some of them, how do you know the rest of them are not the truth? Or is it because you're familiar with the history of the gnostics and the forgeries that all the Gospels are suspect to you?

No they were not - but it is only now that we realize they were genuine, they crafted the bible and as was the way would have kept on crafting it for ever, with deeper understandings, so was it before Dogma which froze us - as too the Hermetica was not a Greek forgery but genuine -

I believe the bible was a Gnostic creation - that Jesus was a pagan man/god -
 
Last edited:
No more female genital mutilation.
I think male circumcision, which you count as "genital mutilation," would continue even without devoutly religious people. Even fairly unreligious Jews would likely continue it just as a cultural marker, and lots of secular people would continue it based on the way it reduces susceptibility to HIV and possibly other infections.
 
I think male circumcision, which you count as "genital mutilation," would continue even without devoutly religious people. Even fairly unreligious Jews would likely continue it just as a cultural marker, and lots of secular people would continue it based on the way it reduces susceptibility to HIV and possibly other infections.

I am not trying to take this tread off course so am not getting on a soap box but -

You are being religiously bias actually - you are saying one form of religious mutilation should be wiped out and didn't mention the other - and then you say the one is secular but the other isn't - when there is no actual difference between the two so why mention either?

Nah you are picking and choosing -

It does what? - Oh blimy is that what they tell you? The opposite is true :( They lie -
 
Last edited:
Try rereading what I wrote. If you're still having trouble spotting your error, let me know and I can explain it to you.

Mr. Arkady,

I did, you said you would rather succumb to pestilance, war, famine, and death than have to associate with a christian.

You are in luck. That is what happened in every athiestic society that has ever existed.
 
I am not trying to take this tread off course so am not getting on a soap box but -

You are being religiously bias actually - you are saying one form of religious mutilation should be wiped out and didn't mention the other - and then you say the one is secular but the other isn't - when there is no actual difference between the two so why mention either?

Nah you are picking and choosing -

It does what? - Oh blimy is that what they tell you? The opposite is true :( They lie -
No religious bias here. I'm not religious, and have no "dog in that fight." I simply distinguish between a very small operation that has legitimate non-religious goals (fighting infection), and a much more major operation that, as far as I know, is only there to deprive women of sexual pleasure.

There have been a number of studies about male circumcision reducing HIV infection by a substantial amount. The evidence is compelling.

http://www.who.int/hiv/topics/malecircumcision/en/
http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/prevention/research/malecircumcision/
http://healthland.time.com/2013/04/17/why-circumcision-lowers-risk-of-hiv/

There's also evidence it reduces susceptibility for other diseases, like syphilis:
http://www.aidsmeds.com/articles/syphilis_circumcision_1667_25925.shtml
And urinary tract infections:
http://healthland.time.com/2012/07/09/study-uncircumcised-boys-have-a-higher-risk-of-uti/
and chlamydia:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2422990/
and HPV and penile cancer:
http://www.cancer.org/cancer/penilecancer/detailedguide/penile-cancer-risk-factors

It also simplifies the task of keeping clean.

So, quite apart to the silly religious reasons for circumcision, there are a number of health benefits. One might, of course, decide that the benefits of being uncircumcised (whatever those are) outweigh those of being circumcised. But there are certainly plenty of secular reasons a person might get a male child circumcised. I don't know of any secular reasons for doing so to a female child.
 
Mr. Arkady,

I did, you said you would rather succumb to pestilance, war, famine, and death than have to associate with a christian.

You are in luck. That is what happened in every athiestic society that has ever existed.
Where, exactly, did you see me saying I'd rather succumb to pestilance [sic], war, famine, and death than to have to associate with a christian?
 
Where, exactly, did you see me saying I'd rather succumb to pestilance [sic], war, famine, and death than to have to associate with a christian?

Mr. Arkady,

Dude, is your short term memory so bad you forgot what you said in your top post?
 
No they were not - but it is only now that we realize they were genuine, they crafted the bible and as was the way would have kept on crafting it for ever, with deeper understandings, so was it before Dogma which froze us - as too the Hermetica was not a Greek forgery but genuine -

I believe the bible was a Gnostic creation - that Jesus was a pagan man/god -

Crafting it forever with deeper understandings? The books were written and deeper understanding was being spread, and continues to be spread to this day.
But yes, I agree with you that the gnostics would do what they always did....borrow bits from different religions and try to lay some ownership to the master level of it, which is what they also attempted to do with Christianity.
What the gnostics did was attempt to rewrite Christianity so that salvation came from being "in the know" and achieving knowledge and power, rather than from the life, death, and resurrection of Christ. The forgeries the gnostics attempted to pass off were merely rewrites of pantheistic beliefs they'd held for centuries. What you claim is that these would still be being written if "dogma" hadn't frozen you. Dogma didn't freeze gnostics. Gnosticism was a widely held belief and the gnostic pseudochristianity was widely popular and gaining popularity at the time it was successfully challenged and usurped. The big bad church didn't blow your house down. The Truth did.
 
My memory is superb. I remember my top-post quite clearly. You, on the other hand, have either forgotten it, or you never actually understood it in the first place.

Here's the relevant portion:

"... It occurs to me that the world would probably be better if the most devout believers were, in fact, "raptured" to some other existence... Picture a world in which all the most devout people suddenly vanished -- not just the Christians, mind you, but anyone who has enough faith in a supernatural dogma for it to govern his life in a major way.... I suspect that if if the 10% of mankind that most fervently believes in the supernatural were to vanish, once the shock wore off, the rest of us would find we were a lot happier, more peaceful, and more productive."

Note, my thought experiment in no way envisions succumbing to pestilence, war, famine, and death. If you reread, you'll see that I'm not picturing what life would be like if a "four horsemen of the apocalypse" scenario played out. That's just something you injected into it. In fact, I'm not even picturing what an atheist world would look like. Those believers who weren't among the "most devout" would still be around. I didn't even mean to imply that all the Christians would be gone. My guess, quite to the contrary, is that the "most devout" are disproportionately Muslim, so that you'd probably lose more than 10% of Muslims and less than 10% of Christians.

My thought experiment was specific: what would happen if the 10% of mankind that believes most fervently in the supernatural were to vanish. Not a word about pestilence, war, famine, and death. No implication of universal atheism. Probably the vast majority of Christians still around.

I used to teach the SAT verbal section for the Princeton Review. Teaching the vocabulary part wasn't frustrating. Some people just hadn't been exposed to that many words, or had a poor memory for them, and that was easy enough to fix with a little drilling. The frustrating part was the reading comprehension section. Again and again these students would take a simple paragraph, in which they understood every single word, and they'd come away from it with a completely false idea of what it said, even after reading it carefully. The skill of pulling a clear understanding out of a simple, standard English text is just something some people's brains can't handle very well, and it's very hard to "fix" these lousy readers.

Well Arkady if you ever do get around to envisioning an atheist world, you might want to think about including war, famine, and death. In the last century, over 370 million people were killed for the sake of instilling atheist regimes.

Perhaps you're mad at some member of your large Catholic family that you claim to love, or one of your many religious minded friends that you claim to respect and love. Maybe you lost a case, or you're just roiling again over the fact that the Christians didn't get our asses kicked in the SC awhile back. Who knows what has ticked you off this time or why you prefer to come here and tell us how much better the world would be without us in it instead of facing off directly with the source of your irritation. We can only conclude two things based on what you've written in this thread. One, someone rang your bell today but good and you're mad. And two, you don't have the courage to tell them you regret and resent their existence. So you dump in a safe, anonymous place.
Whatever the cause, of course you know you're free to continue telling us how awful the world is with us in it. Meanwhile, we await news of your great contribution to humankind, and that of the inspired works of atheism in general.
The missions, the soup kitchens, the hospitals, the schools, the homeless shelters, the refugee centers, the feeding and care of the lepers....tell us!
 
Mr. Arkady,

Dude, is your short term memory so bad you forgot what you said in your top post?
My memory is superb. I remember my top-post quite clearly. You, on the other hand, have either forgotten it, or you never actually understood it in the first place.

Here's the relevant portion:

"... It occurs to me that the world would probably be better if the most devout believers were, in fact, "raptured" to some other existence... Picture a world in which all the most devout people suddenly vanished -- not just the Christians, mind you, but anyone who has enough faith in a supernatural dogma for it to govern his life in a major way.... I suspect that if if the 10% of mankind that most fervently believes in the supernatural were to vanish, once the shock wore off, the rest of us would find we were a lot happier, more peaceful, and more productive."

Note, my thought experiment in no way envisions succumbing to pestilence, war, famine, and death. If you reread, you'll see that I'm not picturing what life would be like if a "four horsemen of the apocalypse" scenario played out. That's just something you injected into it. In fact, I'm not even picturing what an atheist world would look like. Those believers who weren't among the "most devout" would still be around. I didn't even mean to imply that all the Christians would be gone. My guess, quite to the contrary, is that the "most devout" are disproportionately Muslim, so that you'd probably lose more than 10% of Muslims and less than 10% of Christians.

My thought experiment was specific: what would happen if the 10% of mankind that believes most fervently in the supernatural were to vanish. Not a word about pestilence, war, famine, and death. No implication of universal atheism. Probably the vast majority of Christians still around.

I used to teach the SAT verbal section for the Princeton Review. Teaching the vocabulary part wasn't frustrating. Some people just hadn't been exposed to that many words, or had a poor memory for them, and that was easy enough to fix with a little drilling. The frustrating part was the reading comprehension section. Again and again these students would take a simple paragraph, in which they understood every single word, and they'd come away from it with a completely false idea of what it said, even after reading it carefully. The skill of pulling a clear understanding out of a simple, standard English text is just something some people's brains can't handle very well, and it's very hard to "fix" these lousy readers.
Well Arkady if you ever do get around to envisioning an atheist world, you might want to think about including war, famine, and death. In the last century, over 370 million people were killed for the sake of instilling atheist regimes.

I have no interest in creating a communist cult, like those of China and the Soviet Union. I believe those are essentially religious systems. As with religions, they have strict dogmas, holy texts, cult figures to which they ascribe supernatural powers, empty ceremonies, indoctrination of the very young, etc. Juche, in North Korea, is similar:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_religion

I prefer secularism chosen by free will, with a hefty dose of skepticism and strict protection of freedom of speech and of the press. My ideal is for the darkness of religion to fade gradually as people become smarter, more knowledgeable, and more emotionally mature. That, not an enforced substitution of a supernatural religion with a political religion, is the path forward.
 
I picked up what I think was the first in the "Left Behind" series, before boarding a flight one time. I didn't know it was some sort of religious tome until I was about 25 pages in.

Anyway, it left me thinking about how surprised many of the self-righteous would be upon finding their asses left behind!
 
I picked up what I think was the first in the "Left Behind" series, before boarding a flight one time. I didn't know it was some sort of religious tome until I was about 25 pages in.

Anyway, it left me thinking about how surprised many of the self-righteous would be upon finding their asses left behind!

You're right...there will be MANY left behind that thought they would be taken. Because they weren't truly believers. That doesn't mean they won't still be saved. Even if your not taken, it doesn't mean there's no chance of salvation.
 
Back
Top