New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Liberal Logic 101

Say I can't stand conservative women who wear cat masks and spout gibberish online. One walks into my bar and I tell her to get lost because it goes against my religious principles to serve her. She gets mad and says nothing. Now say I have a ton of friends who think exactly as I do and want to pass a law saying that the whole state, the whole nation, anyone, anytime, anywhere can tell this woman to jump in the lake because we won't give them gas, food, water, health care, legal protection, police protection, fire protection and so on at our discretion. Want to bet what your little cartoon would be then?

YOu can't compare the two situations.

The vendors who have been sued, harassed and fined for not participating in weddings between same sex partners didn't refuse to do business with any of the people who ended up causing them all the trouble they've had. They simply said that they couldn't participate in making the wedding. But the baker never refused to sell cake or bread to gay folks. The florist never refused to sell flowers to gay folks. The photographer never refused to photograph gay folks. AND NONE of the involved parties complaining about about discrimination were ever thrown out of any of these establishments the way the young lady with the mask is thrown out in your hypothetical situation.

In fact, part of the religion these people follow is to offer hospitality to everyone. When a gay man or woman gets told he or she can't buy a birthday cake someplace, get back to us. Maybe then your analogy will be appropriate.
 
I know some right wing web site fed you those links, but they do not answer the question I asked.

Let me know if you can answer it.

Yes they most certainly do answer the question you asked. You asked "who's they?"
She responded with a sample of stories that DO back up her point. Of course you'd have to read through them if you were really interested in her answer. What did you expect? That she'd go round up the people involved in these incidences and bring them to your house for coffee so you could hear it from them personally? It's pretty well understood that when you ask someone to back something up on the internet, they're going to give you links.
But you don't read the answer she gave you and then you claim she couldn't back up her point.

The reality is that she gave you several stories that prove her point. And if you didn't like the sites they come from, you could have googled the names for yourself. The fact that you insist her sources are incorrect but yet you haven't even tried to show her sources as inaccurate and fabricated speaks to your tactic.
 
1) I said they forced vendors to work. A future tense assertion of the effects of bankrupting size fines (by the way very big fines that bankrupt are unconstitutional).

2) First off, no, they fined them for their religious beliefs in a country fundamentally based on freedom of (and not from) religion. Its first tenet as a matter of fact. In a particular case it was $150K - effectively bankrupting a young couple. Not good for gays or the continued faith in government by a huge part of the population.

1) The top post refers specifically to liberals wishing to businesses "refusing to perform same-sex weddings."
2) No more than if a business owner were fined for refusing to sell cake to an interracial couple because of his religious beliefs. I wonder if you have a citation for that $150K fine, and also for the constitutional provision banning "very big fines that bankrupt."
 
Hotels have taken Bibles out of their rooms because people complained about them being there.
Malls and school districts have banned prayer on their premises because people complained about it.
The complaints are based on the notion that having to view a Bible in a room you are renting, or having to hear prayer in a public place "offend" atheists.

So hotels and malls shouldn't cater to their customers?

I find it highly unlikely that any significant number of atheists complained about Bibles in hotels. I mean, just treat it like an unneeded piece of furniture, right? If anyone is made uncomfortable by Bibles in hotel rooms, I surmise, it's Christians who feel guilty about cheating on their wives with prostitutes there.

And praying at the mall isn't so much an "offense" as a public nuisance that directly interferes with others' enjoyment of it.

As for school districts, I know of none that does not allow prayer, and in fact the Supreme Court has made clear that if students are allowed to organize other groups, they must also be allowed to organize prayer and Bible study groups.
 
Jen, socialism has been tried many times in many different countries in history. It has alway been a dismal failure, often distroying lives as well as governments. On paper it seems like it could work and provide a society that could flourish and provide for everyone. The real problem with socialism was summed up nicely by Margret Thacher when she said, " Socialism is just great until you run out of other peoples money". You see socialism removes individual rights, and gives complete control to big government this is why it is doomed to failure, it is impossible to spend your way into prosperity something Obummer has never ever understood, it is common sense.

You a big believer in neo-Marxist plots?
 
So hotels and malls shouldn't cater to their customers?

I find it highly unlikely that any significant number of atheists complained about Bibles in hotels. I mean, just treat it like an unneeded piece of furniture, right? If anyone is made uncomfortable by Bibles in hotel rooms, I surmise, it's Christians who feel guilty about cheating on their wives with prostitutes there.

And praying at the mall isn't so much an "offense" as a public nuisance that directly interferes with others' enjoyment of it.

As for school districts, I know of none that does not allow prayer, and in fact the Supreme Court has made clear that if students are allowed to organize other groups, they must also be allowed to organize prayer and Bible study groups.

First of all, Christians like Jen don't cheat, and if there is a mall that doesn't allow praying, I've never heard of it. In any case, Jen would change her mind right quick about praying in a mall if Muslims were praying there five times a day, and she'd change her mind about religious tracts in hotels if they were the Koran. About conservatives complaining at facebook, complaining is what conservatives do at the direction of their masters. Facebook should give conservative complaints the tin ear.
 
Last edited:
And it would be your right to refuse service for whatever reason. But you lose business when 30% of the people in your state are cat women who don't show up to your ladies night and all your male customers dry up because they show up at the new pussy cat club down the road.

Yet the top post complains about malls making a business decision to cater to those who prefer not to be prayed at while shopping.
 
YOu can't compare the two situations.

The vendors who have been sued, harassed and fined for not participating in weddings between same sex partners didn't refuse to do business with any of the people who ended up causing them all the trouble they've had. They simply said that they couldn't participate in making the wedding. But the baker never refused to sell cake or bread to gay folks. The florist never refused to sell flowers to gay folks. The photographer never refused to photograph gay folks. AND NONE of the involved parties complaining about about discrimination were ever thrown out of any of these establishments the way the young lady with the mask is thrown out in your hypothetical situation.

In fact, part of the religion these people follow is to offer hospitality to everyone. When a gay man or woman gets told he or she can't buy a birthday cake someplace, get back to us. Maybe then your analogy will be appropriate.

What if someone's religion prohibits participating in gay birthdays? After all, that's no more arbitrary than gay weddings.
 
What if someone's religion prohibits participating in gay birthdays? After all, that's no more arbitrary than gay weddings.
So?

You can't force people to like you as irrational as their dislike may be.

There is a leg to stand on when it comes to discrimination when ownership of a business/property/what have you is public or widely owned - like say a market listed company or a public park. Individuals and small closed groups have a right to their prejudices wrong as they may be. It is childish to believe otherwise.
 
Last edited:
So?

You can't force people to like you as irrational as their dislike may be.

Their is a leg to stand on when it comes to discrimination when ownership of a business/property/what have you is public or widely owned - like say a market listed company or a public park. Individuals and small closed groups have a right to their prejudices wrong as they may be. It is childish to believe otherwise.

You may wish to go back to the days of segregated lunch counters. I, on the other hand, am relieved that the government is stepping in to outlaw them.
 
Yes they most certainly do answer the question you asked. You asked "who's they?"
She responded with a sample of stories that DO back up her point. Of course you'd have to read through them if you were really interested in her answer. What did you expect? That she'd go round up the people involved in these incidences and bring them to your house for coffee so you could hear it from them personally? It's pretty well understood that when you ask someone to back something up on the internet, they're going to give you links.
But you don't read the answer she gave you and then you claim she couldn't back up her point.

The reality is that she gave you several stories that prove her point. And if you didn't like the sites they come from, you could have googled the names for yourself. The fact that you insist her sources are incorrect but yet you haven't even tried to show her sources as inaccurate and fabricated speaks to your tactic.

I didn't ask for a long winded speech. My question was very simple.

Someone above said that "they" forced caterers and photographers to work at a gay marriage ceremony.

Who is the "they" that supposedly did that? I suspected hooey so I asked who supposedly did that. All I got in response is dissembling, so it looks like my suspicion was correct.
 
You may wish to go back to the days of segregated lunch counters. I, on the other hand, am relieved that the government is stepping in to outlaw them.

Actively suppressing a sub-group in a given community is an expensive proposition (especially under separate but equal idiocies) and has an opportunity cost that is staggering. So, I too am glad we don't have segregated lunch counters. MLK's greatest accomplishment was economic. But by the same token a lot of black owned businesses disappeared after desegregation. A lot of key metrics slid in the wrong directions for the black community after desegregation as it was implemented.

This is a good book on the subject by Jason Riley:

Please Stop Helping Us: How Liberals Make It Harder for Blacks to Succeed
http://www.amazon.com/Please-Stop-Helping-Us-Liberals/dp/1594037256

So it is not all good and it seems that maybe a more controlled desegregation may have had better results, or not. Regardless, we've had positive results and Affirmative Action was useful but may now need to have an official sunset time - say 2020 or 2022 - because it is unconstitutional and arguably the the remedy has been made.

I think the results would have been better and more concrete if equal rights for minorities had been implementable in a different manner. Where the lunch counter owner was not forced to desegregate but went out of business because a better more inclusive business drove him out with his individual rights intact.
 
Back
Top