New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Liberal Logic 101

I didn't ask for a long winded speech. My question was very simple.

Someone above said that "they" forced caterers and photographers to work at a gay marriage ceremony.

Who is the "they" that supposedly did that? I suspected hooey so I asked who supposedly did that. All I got in response is dissembling, so it looks like my suspicion was correct.

"They" are those that made demands and the courts that enforced that the demands be met. What's so hard to understand?
 
I didn't ask for a long winded speech. My question was very simple.

Someone above said that "they" forced caterers and photographers to work at a gay marriage ceremony.

Who is the "they" that supposedly did that? I suspected hooey so I asked who supposedly did that. All I got in response is dissembling, so it looks like my suspicion was correct.


And from the response Barb gave you to your question about who forces people to work weddings between same sex spouses, you couldn't draw the obvious conclusion; that the message is clear, either provide your service for that wedding of face severe, livelihood-ending punishment? That sure sounds like force to me.
You didn't put that together? Really? I doubt that.
You're just looking to create a loophole. That loophole is that the people in the stories she gave you refused rather than succumbed. The fact that they are paying heavy prices for that is a fact you'd like to ignore. But it is at the core of this argument.
 
And from the response Barb gave you to your question about who forces people to work weddings between same sex spouses, you couldn't draw the obvious conclusion; that the message is clear, either provide your service for that wedding of face severe, livelihood-ending punishment? That sure sounds like force to me.
You didn't put that together? Really? I doubt that.
You're just looking to create a loophole. That loophole is that the people in the stories she gave you refused rather than succumbed. The fact that they are paying heavy prices for that is a fact you'd like to ignore. But it is at the core of this argument.

Nope. Lotsa bobbing, weaving and dodging, but no one can say who the "they" are who supposedly forced caterers and photographers to work a gay wedding.

The reason? It's hooey.
 
What if someone's religion prohibits participating in gay birthdays? After all, that's no more arbitrary than gay weddings.

You may as well ask what if someone's religion says they have to dance around their unicorn at sundown everyday? There's no such thing as a gay birthday.
The problem people who can't participate in any way in a wedding between same sex spouses is not about gay people eating cake or smelling flowers or being photographed.
 
You may as well ask what if someone's religion says they have to dance around their unicorn at sundown everyday? There's no such thing as a gay birthday.
The problem people who can't participate in any way in a wedding between same sex spouses is not about gay people eating cake or smelling flowers or being photographed.

A baker refusing to sell cake to a same-sex couple has everything to do with gay people eating cake, and absolutely nothing to do with anything else.
 
Actively suppressing a sub-group in a given community is an expensive proposition (especially under separate but equal idiocies) and has an opportunity cost that is staggering. So, I too am glad we don't have segregated lunch counters. MLK's greatest accomplishment was economic. But by the same token a lot of black owned businesses disappeared after desegregation. A lot of key metrics slid in the wrong directions for the black community after desegregation as it was implemented.

This is a good book on the subject by Jason Riley:

Please Stop Helping Us: How Liberals Make It Harder for Blacks to Succeed
http://www.amazon.com/Please-Stop-Helping-Us-Liberals/dp/1594037256

So it is not all good and it seems that maybe a more controlled desegregation may have had better results, or not. Regardless, we've had positive results and Affirmative Action was useful but may now need to have an official sunset time - say 2020 or 2022 - because it is unconstitutional and arguably the the remedy has been made.

I think the results would have been better and more concrete if equal rights for minorities had been implementable in a different manner. Where the lunch counter owner was not forced to desegregate but went out of business because a better more inclusive business drove him out with his individual rights intact.

Jim Crow was in the interests of the capitalist class as a whole, because pitting workers against each other on racial lines was what allowed them to keep the South from becoming unionized. So it wasn't a case of this or that business owner acting on his individual beliefs, it was a rigidly (and legally) enforced code that those who broke would face severe sanctions that might well go beyond driving them out of business. Legally mandated desegregation was the only way to put a stop to this system that was the organizational basis for all economic activity in the region. And as affirmative action has been chipped away at, Jim Crow has started to reassert itself ... not just in the South now, but nationwide. Your post hoc reasoning aside, do you really want to argue that Blacks are better off as a result?
 
Jim Crow was in the interests of the capitalist class as a whole, because pitting workers against each other on racial lines was what allowed them to keep the South from becoming unionized. So it wasn't a case of this or that business owner acting on his individual beliefs, it was a rigidly (and legally) enforced code that those who broke would face severe sanctions that might well go beyond driving them out of business. Legally mandated desegregation was the only way to put a stop to this system that was the organizational basis for all economic activity in the region. And as affirmative action has been chipped away at, Jim Crow has started to reassert itself ... not just in the South now, but nationwide. Your post hoc reasoning aside, do you really want to argue that Blacks are better off as a result?

Today we have illegal immigrants who make a mean grilled chicken salad delivered from farm to the table side very, very cheap. Except that the happy eating taxpayer does not realize all the other costs that come with that grilled chicken salad. The cost of uninsured health care; the cost of educating the children of illegal immigrants; the stagnation of wages and therefore government revenue; the cost of a higher crime rate; the cost of corruption; the environmental costs; addition to the welfare rolls; technology developments that were not realized to do farm labor;... It goes on and on.

That grilled chicken salad ends up being much more expensive than anticipated in the end. Segregation had those same kind of costs. Worse was having citizens not able to fully participate in the economy (an opportunity cost) and therefore the nation not being able to fully realize its economic potential. What MLK achieved arguably was an economic boon for America. Has that been fully realized? Probably not. The metrics could improve drastically for that community with that legacy (including Hispanic citizens of that time who were also segregated).

Here is an interesting interview from CSPAN
http://www.c-span.org/video/?320049-1/words-jason-riley
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
Today we have illegal immigrants who make a mean grilled chicken salad delivered from farm to the table side very, very cheap. Except that the happy eating taxpayer does not realize all the other costs that come with that grilled chicken salad. The cost of uninsured health care; the cost of educating the children of illegal immigrants; the stagnation of wages and therefore government revenue; the cost of a higher crime rate; the cost of corruption; the environmental costs; addition to the welfare rolls; technology developments that were not realized to do farm labor;... It goes on and on.

That grilled chicken salad ends up being much more expensive than anticipated in the end. Segregation had those same kind of costs. Worse was having citizens not able to fully participate in the economy (an opportunity cost) and therefore the nation not being able to fully realize its economic potential. What MLK achieved arguably was an economic boon for America. Has that been fully realized? Probably not. The metrics could improve drastically for that community with that legacy (including Hispanic citizens of that time who were also segregated).

Here is an interesting interview from CSPAN
http://www.c-span.org/video/?320049-1/words-jason-riley

Yup, Jim Crow is one example of capitalism's political and profit imperatives holding back economic growth, and neocolonialism and exploitation of immigrant labor is another.
 
This belongs in the Failed Humor subforum, but since we don't have one, trash heap will have to do.

Whatever.
donmartin.jpg
 
Back
Top