New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Looking for Moderators

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ah yes...but you see the FACTS are.....that was only AFTER you attacked Cicero and compared him to Andrew Breitbart....intended by you as an insult and a personal attack, of course.

Truth matters.

Lapcat compared me to Bill Maher and Michael Moore.
 
I find it significant that Pace, Lapcat, and MaryAnne all agreed about this. I think that degsme and Cicero and many others have essentially agreed. (I know that I agree.) Given this, following degsme's example, I would like to suggest an alternative solution.

I think that if Dave and Chris need some help with the volume of moderating work that needs to be done, they should follow Pace's suggestion and hire people from outside who do not have a direct stake in the arguments.

However, I have a feeling that Dave and Chris might also like to have more consistent input into setting the rules and structure of PJ so that both lefties and righties felt that the "game" was fair. I think that part of the problem is that different people not only interpret rules differently but feel that different sorts of rules are appropriate. This seems clear for Jen and degsme. I think that it holds true for Cicero and me as well. If the problem is "the rules of the game" themselves, I think that it would make more sense to set up a rules/infractions board made up of, for example, three regular posters elected by righties and three regular posters elected by lefties. Though Dave and Chris would make the ultimate decisions on the rules, the board could provide healthy discussion between left and right and provide useful perspectives to Dave and Chris. In addition, lefties could complain to one or more of their three reps if they felt that they were being abused and righties could complain to one of their three reps if they felt that they were being abused. And the reps could raise the issues with Dave and with the board. One advantage of this scheme is that I think that it would be significantly less work for the individuals. Also, you could hold elections once a year or something similar so that no one permanently filled a board position. (In other words, you put in term limits.)

My instincts tell me that something along these lines might be more workable. (I know that if I was elected to a board like this, I could probably find the time to do it where I wouldn't be able to do something that required a more open-ended and time-consuming commitment. I suspect that there are others who would feel the same.)

I am with you on this,Pace.We can all see the thread just became more of the same.There is noo one on this board,unbiased,with hurt feelings,digs,etc.

Dave and Chris,you need to bring in someone not connected, because no matter who you choose,there will be those who are not happy,myself included. Find complete strangers.
 
So your "mauling and clawing" and unrestrained name-calling are not "personal attacks"? :rofl:

As the saying goes, kittys in glass houses should not be throwing stones.

So that justifies the personal attacks you have made on me (and other cons here) then?

Got it.

I rest my case.

(and thanks for proving my point)
 
I did not attack Cicero. I compared him to Andrew Breitbart and you and Cicero interpreted it as an attack. Cicero does remind me of Andrew Breitbart. How does the comparison fail? You compared me to Bill Maher. I took it as a complement.

Ah yes...but you see the FACTS are.....that was only AFTER you attacked Cicero and compared him to Andrew Breitbart....intended by you as an insult and a personal attack, of course.

Truth matters.
 
You forgot the "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest" (wild west style?) analogy...lol!!!

Think of the Wild West complete with town drunks, quick shooting gun fighters, bank robbers, saloons, and boot hill. You got that? Okay, now think of something worse.
 
Oh right....cause lefties ALL consider Andrew Breitbart to be a fine, upstanding citizen, and as such, comparing a con to him would be a compliment.

Give me a break!

Not even your fellow lefties are dumb enough to believe that one.

But nice try.


I did not attack Cicero. I compared him to Andrew Breitbart and you and Cicero interpreted it as an attack. Cicero does remind me of Andrew Breitbart. How does the comparison fail? You compared me to Bill Maher. I took it as a complement.
 
Hahahahaha!

Ah Cicero you can be fun. I can't take credit for it as Dave is actually the one who said it:

"We will look at suggestions and make decisions based on 1) if the people nominated actually want to moderate 2) their history with infractions and the posts they report and 3) their overall fairness and kindness towards other posters opposite sides or not." which I think is a logical idea.

As for my own view; I think many can do the job well and be neutral but perhaps the best way to start it off on the right track for the kiddies would be to exclude everyone on this thread. ;-)

Don't underestimate the value of the quiet, reasonable posters and their ability to be fair.
 
Yes and that's no laughing matter. Those of us who were not on Fray or BB are even in a worse situation since we have no clue what went on before.


Lily,if that is the case,you would be great as a moderator!:eek:) Where did you migrate from? Most of us were on different boards on Slate. I came from a small board that Mickey Kaus started for his regulars who were knocked off the board when he had an article.
 
Um....got a link to my so-called (coming from a leftie) ""unrestrained name-calling""?

Any time I slipped up (as YOU have done) I got punished. How about you? No? Probably not. What happens when lefties are allowed to continue unabated is....they get worse.

So your "mauling and clawing" and unrestrained name-calling are not "personal attacks"? :rofl:

As the saying goes, kittys in glass houses should not be throwing stones.
 
I agree and I'm a liberal, I can't see how this can work except IRP seems open minded yet he's too busy.

The others I think deserve the job, I'd hate to lose posting. :confused:

Edit: Edit: I should have said, I agree with most of this post but I have no idea what went on on Fray and other sites some have been members.

You are right,Lily. Most do choose those who lean to their side. I had not seen enough of your posts to know until you just told us.

There are some good posters on both sides,but when they get in the pack they stick together. I try hard to see both sides,but right now I see little out of the Republican side to agree with. Hoping Obama and the Country fails does not float my boat.
 
In fact, it was a legitimate comparison. It does not matter what "lefties" think about Breitbart's behavior. I compared Breitbart's posting behavior to Cicero's posting behavior. You compared my posting behavior to Bill Maher's posting behavior. I thought that that was a legitimate comparison (and was complemented). A comparison is within the rules. It is not a personal attack.

However, your habit of throwing out generic insults (and I would say that Cicero shares in this) directed at a class of "lefties" and then claiming that those are not personal attacks is IMHO very questionable. In fact, you just demonstrated that in your answer because you suggested that all "lefties" understood that my comparison was a personal attack.

So, you and Cicero are both VERY aware that you both engage in the moral equivalent of personal attacks.

Oh right....cause lefties ALL consider Andrew Breitbart to be a fine, upstanding citizen, and as such, comparing a con to him would be a compliment.

Give me a break!

Not even your fellow lefties are dumb enough to believe that one.

But nice try.
 
MA...time has fogged my memory. Did you also start out at Damned Spot before moving to Kausfiles Special?

Lily,if that is the case,you would be great as a moderator!:eek:) Where did you migrate from? Most of us were on different boards on Slate. I came from a small board that Mickey Kaus started for his regulars who were knocked off the board when he had an article.
 
What is amusing is that you provided an example of your behavior in this very post.

"What happens when lefties are allowed to continue unabated is ... they get worse" is an example of name-calling directed at a liberal strawman and strawwoman. You do this so persistently that it seems that you are not even aware that you do it.

You should just admit that your purpose is to insult people on the left. You justify this by claiming that all people on the left are ALWAYS insulting you.


Um....got a link to my so-called (coming from a leftie) ""unrestrained name-calling""?

Any time I slipped up (as YOU have done) I got punished. How about you? No? Probably not. What happens when lefties are allowed to continue unabated is....they get worse.
 
Oh really? Posting behavior? And where, pray tell, did you manage to observe Breit Bart's ""posting behavior""? Got a link to that forum?

From my perspective, you are just trying to justify your personal attack here...in your usual manner. It ain't working.

And as for my generalization and use of "lefties"....are you really going to TRY to claim you or your side has never used such generalizations when referring to conservatives? Really???

We've been called everything from racists to homophobes to "tea baggers" in leftie attempts to insult us. I repeat....

give me a break!


In fact, it was a legitimate comparison. It does not matter what "lefties" think about Breitbart's behavior. I compared Breitbart's posting behavior to Cicero's posting behavior. You compared my posting behavior to Bill Maher's posting behavior. I thought that that was a legitimate comparison (and was complemented). A comparison is within the rules. It is not a personal attack.

However, your habit of throwing out generic insults (and I would say that Cicero shares in this) directed at a class of "lefties" and then claiming that those are not personal attacks is IMHO very questionable. In fact, you just demonstrated that in your answer because you suggested that all "lefties" understood that my comparison was a personal attack.

So, you and Cicero are both VERY aware that you both engage in the moral equivalent of personal attacks.
 
I find it significant that Pace, Lapcat, and MaryAnne all agreed about this. I think that degsme and Cicero and many others have essentially agreed. (I know that I agree.) Given this, following degsme's example, I would like to suggest an alternative solution.

I think that if Dave and Chris need some help with the volume of moderating work that needs to be done, they should follow Pace's suggestion and hire people from outside who do not have a direct stake in the arguments.

However, I have a feeling that Dave and Chris might also like to have more consistent input into setting the rules and structure of PJ so that both lefties and righties felt that the "game" was fair. I think that part of the problem is that different people not only interpret rules differently but feel that different sorts of rules are appropriate. This seems clear for Jen and degsme. I think that it holds true for Cicero and me as well. If the problem is "the rules of the game" themselves, I think that it would make more sense to set up a rules/infractions board made up of, for example, three regular posters elected by righties and three regular posters elected by lefties. Though Dave and Chris would make the ultimate decisions on the rules, the board could provide healthy discussion between left and right and provide useful perspectives to Dave and Chris. In addition, lefties could complain to one or more of their three reps if they felt that they were being abused and righties could complain to one of their three reps if they felt that they were being abused. And the reps could raise the issues with Dave and with the board. One advantage of this scheme is that I think that it would be significantly less work for the individuals. Also, you could hold elections once a year or something similar so that no one permanently filled a board position. (In other words, you put in term limits.)

My instincts tell me that something along these lines might be more workable. (I know that if I was elected to a board like this, I could probably find the time to do it where I wouldn't be able to do something that required a more open-ended and time-consuming commitment. I suspect that there are others who would feel the same.)

Uhoh,That last post did it! Half the board has named you, think you are highly qualified and fair. For me, your sense of humor and ability to turn away wrath does it!

And now you say,"You could find the time." I doubt it is a full time job. Surely Dave,Chris and Johnny have full time jobs.:eek:)

There you have one,Dave and Chris!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top