Hi Dave:
I would like to add to this, I don't think that a republican/democratic moderator would cause a republican/democratic poster who went off the reservation, see the folly of their ways.
That makes the reaction to the action a partisan issue, now conduits are required to communicate to people, but there are regulations and rules in almost every facet of one's life.
Over eat and you'll gain weight and have health problems, your choice
Pass a stop sign and get a ticket, your choice
Come here and inflame, drive away advertisers and reduce readership, and the site suffers. get banned or suspended, your choice.
So in my view, it has to be impartial and arbitrary; it has to be individuals who are well versed in moderation, which is the root of the noun you use.
So inpartiality, lack of familiarity, a knowledge base of organizing and moderating a discussion are probably the key elements required. I really don't see how anyone here could moderate, given the passion and partiality of the posts. myself included in this.
I think you are referring to soft skills, where the message, while sancrosant in nature is delivered thru a conduit that is recognized.
I would argue that most here don't know the policemen who pulls them over and gives them a ticket, the result of the infraction is the same, regardless of the political leaning.
There should never be a day where a policeman gives someone a pass based on political leanings.
As I see it, this site is called Political Jack, and in order to moderate, you need individuals unfamiliar with previous histories, who do not have personal friendship (fratenization) and a clear ability to compartmentalize their own political proclivities.
I would say, while there are some in this thread who are clearly respected for their views and what is perceived as impartiality, it's probably better to find individuals not so closely connected with the site.
Regards
Pace