New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Michael Sam Drafted

You've just proven my point. You can't be Atticus Finch unless you decide I'm Bob Ewell. Therefore, regardless of anything I say or do, you assign me the viewpoint you need me to have.

This is more about you and your self-image than it is about Sam.
It's not about me. I praised Sam. He's the story here. You're the one who has turned this into a discussion of our personalities, rather than the public issue at hand. As so often happens, you prefer catty inter-personal squabbling to substantive political discussions, and you work to pull the conversation down into that sewer.

You don't like to think of yourself as Bob Ewell. I get that. If I found myself in the embarrassing position you've staked out for yourself, I'd probably be floundering, too.
 
Michael Sam just became the first openly gay man to be drafted by a major sports league in this country. Although the unanimous first-team All American was previously projected as a third-round pick, before he came out, he ended up going in the seventh round, as one of the last people drafted. Some will argue that this was because he was undersized for a defensive end. That would certainly explain why, despite such an illustrious college career, he wasn't a first rounder. It doesn't explain how he slid from the third round.

Michael Sam is 6'2", 261 lbs. That's not the kind of size NFL teams dream about at defensive end, but it's fairly standard "tweener" size (someone who could play either DE or OLB), and every year quite a few defensive ends get drafted higher than Sam at roughly the same size, and with less illustrious college careers.

For example, this year Ik Enemkpali was drafted in the sixth round. He's 6'1", 261 lbs. Not only is Sam taller, he's also faster -- Sam ran a 4.91 40, versus 5.01 for Enemkpali. That means that teams should have been more comfortable with the idea that Sam could convert to linebacker if he ended up not being able to handle NFL linemen at DE. Sam was also SEC Defensive Player of the Year, and started all 14 games (versus just 12 for Enemkpali). Sam also was statistically better, in terms of tackles, etc.

Enemkpali isn't the only undersized end to go ahead of Sam. Chris Smith of Arkansas is 6'1", 266 lbs. He also started only 12 games, but was a fifth-round pick. Dee Ford, the Auburn DE, went in the first round at 6'2", 252 lbs -- the same height as Sam, but nine pounds lighter. He only started 11 games. He also has a medical issue with his back and didn't work out at the combine.

Sam didn't slide below smaller, slower players with much less impressive college careers because he did drugs, or beat up his girlfriend, or ran into injury problems, or had medical questions about his knees, or the other things that typically push a draft pick down the board. So, what was it?

Over the decades, many hundreds of pro sport prospects were almost certainly gay. There's a reason that every single one of them hid their sexuality (and no, this isn't just about "not announcing it" -- it's about keeping relationships hidden in a way that heterosexual athletes don't). Those athletes all knew that public bigotry would make the hard job of making the grade in pro sports even harder. The difference between the four-year value of Sam's first contract and what he would have made as a mid third-rounder is about $2.1 million. Sam knew that coming out could mean a big slide in the draft, and that a big slide would mean millions of dollars lost. He came out anyway. That's why I praised him as a hero, and why I continue to do so.

I applaud the Rams and Sam but will also say the road ahead for Sam will be rough, and he might not even make it in the NFL...

I am glad he came out and applaud his choice but he has to understand that in the locker room he will be shun, and treated in a hostile way...

So as you and I see this as a open window for the gay rights we must also be cautious when celebrating this draft...
 
I applaud the Rams and Sam but will also say the road ahead for Sam will be rough, and he might not even make it in the NFL...

I am glad he came out and applaud his choice but he has to understand that in the locker room he will be shun, and treated in a hostile way...

So as you and I see this as a open window for the gay rights we must also be cautious when celebrating this draft...
I'm sure the NFL locker room of today is far different from the high school locker room of a quarter century ago, when I played. But if that is any guide at all, he's in for some tough times. The homophobia was pretty bad. I guess what's hopeful is that most NFL players are young, and the young have largely outgrown the homophobia of prior generations. He fit in well in college, so maybe the same will happen in the pros. The difficulty could actually end up being greater with coaches and fans, many of whom will come from the older generations where homophobia was rampant. I can definitely see him enduring plenty of taunting from the sidelines. And I feel for the guy the first time he finds himself at the bottom of a pile of bodies after a play. It only takes a very small number of anti-gay bigots to make his life hell.
 
It's not about me. I praised Sam. He's the story here. You're the one who has turned this into a discussion of our personalities, rather than the public issue at hand. As so often happens, you prefer catty inter-personal squabbling to substantive political discussions, and you work to pull the conversation down into that sewer.

You don't like to think of yourself as Bob Ewell. I get that. If I found myself in the embarrassing position you've staked out for yourself, I'd probably be floundering, too.


You praise Sam, whom you know little about, in order to erect a monument to yourself. Now pat yourself on the back, and denigrate anyone else who doesn't applaud you for being noble and good.

I haven't said one bad word about Sam here or wished him any ill will, a fact you see as trivial. That's telling.

And, if you didn't know, you are floundering.
 
I'll be very happy when the bigots stop pushing the politics of division over gay issues. The day will come. You don't, for example, hear many bigots going after the Irish and the Catholics, any more, even though they were once prime targets for reactionary hatred. Some day the same will happen for gays. And it'll be the courage of men like Michael Sam that speeds us towards that day.
But, you're one of those bigots pushing the politics of division over gay issues.
 
Much like race, Zam. But, when its no longer a big deal and no one actually cares anymore... what will they have to peddle and how will they foster their philosophies of divide? So they are going to keep at it.


Some have a desire to have it both ways: Sexuality is not a big deal, but Sam's sexuality is a big deal. Well, either it is, or it isn't, but it can't be both. For me, it's his own business, and I don't care.
 
You praise Sam, whom you know little about, in order to erect a monument to yourself. Now pat yourself on the back, and denigrate anyone else who doesn't applaud you for being noble and good.

I haven't said one bad word about Sam here or wished him any ill will, a fact you see as trivial. That's telling.

And, if you didn't know, you are floundering.
Again, this wasn't about me, until you decided to go with the ad hominem attack. That's your way. You see every topic of national importance as nothing but a launching point for petty sniping against other individuals here. Whatever floats your boat, I guess. I'm more interested in the bigger issue, not your insecurities.

The bigger issue is that, for decades, every single gay man in major pro sports felt the need to hide his sexuality for the sake of his career, his safety, or his peace of mind. I can't even imagine what a struggle that must have been for many. When all their teammates could embrace their wives to celebrate the big win, or attend team events with their families, or talk openly with their colleagues about what was going on in their private lives, these men had to avoid all of that. They had to make up lies to cover up suspicious relationships. Some felt the need to cover up by entering loveless marriage, creating miserable families. No doubt many of them had to cause real emotional pain to the people they loved most dearly in the world, by seeming like they were ashamed of those people and the lives they had built together. That was a terrible personal tragedy for hundreds or thousands of people, over the years. And, meanwhile, young gay men who were into athletics were growing up without public role models, and they were dogged by negative cultural stereotypes of effeminacy that could have been partly dispelled by having some strong openly gay men winning glory for the home team on the field.

Now, those things will start to change a lot more rapidly. Thanks to Michael Sam taking the most difficult initial steps, more gay men will dare to live openly in sports, and more broadly within fields of traditional masculinity where gays have been most driven to closet themselves. Before too long, there won't be many men putting themselves through hell to draw a line of secrecy between their personal lives and their careers. And when some player experiences the simple joy of thanking his spouse for all his support, when he wins an award or hits a milestone, as so many thousands of heterosexual athletes have done over the years, he can say an unspoken thank you to Michael Sam, as well, for paving the way for that shared joy. And as more and more gay men live openly in pro sports and other traditionally masculine fields of endeavor, gay boys and young men can grow up in a society that doesn't automatically perceive them through the lens of a feminizing stereotype.

What's important here is what Michael Sam's courage seems likely to set in motion... not your fear that you've fallen into the role of the Bob Ewell of the story.
 
But, you're one of those bigots pushing the politics of division over gay issues.
In what way? I posted something praising a man for the courage not to hide his sexuality, even though he knew it would probably cost him, and even though it seems quite clear that it did. Is that what you perceive as "pushing the politics of division over gay issues"? Praising the courage of a pioneering minority isn't pushing division. The fact it would be taken that way by so many is very telling.
 
In what way? I posted something praising a man for the courage not to hide his sexuality, even though he knew it would probably cost him, and even though it seems quite clear that it did. Is that what you perceive as "pushing the politics of division over gay issues"? Praising the courage of a pioneering minority isn't pushing division. The fact it would be taken that way by so many is very telling.
The fact that you're praising Sam for being gay is also telling. Most people don't "come out" about their sexuality. Most consider it nobody's business. That you encourage gays to make themselves a spectacle speaks volumes.
 
I wouldn't have hired him, just for the simple fact that if he doesn't make the grade he could sue on the grounds of discrimination. Aand not every college all American or even Heisman winner makes the grade at the pro level.
 
Some have a desire to have it both ways: Sexuality is not a big deal, but Sam's sexuality is a big deal. Well, either it is, or it isn't, but it can't be both. For me, it's his own business, and I don't care.
No. Do you HONESTLY not understand this issue? It's not about Sam's sexuality being a big deal. How many times does this need to be explained for you to get it? Being gay is worthy of neither praise nor condemnation, any more than being black or left handed is. What's the big deal here isn't Sam's sexuality, but rather his willingness not to hide that sexuality in a context where every single gay man before him felt the need to do so. It's his pioneering spirit -- his willingness to make sacrifices to blaze a new trail in a way that will result in positive developments for his fellow man-- that's a big deal. One doesn't praise Rosa Parks for being black, Susan B. Anthony for being a woman, or Hank Greenberg for being a Jew. One praises their pioneering roles. Take a step back. Take a deep breath. Think. Now try again.
 
The fact that you're praising Sam for being gay is also telling. Most people don't "come out" about their sexuality. Most consider it nobody's business. That you encourage gays to make themselves a spectacle speaks volumes.
Dealing with really stupid people is difficult for me. I try dumbing myself down to communicate at your level, but there's a point at which I've reached a floor beneath which I can't sink any farther in the effort to meet you at your level, without lapsing into utter incoherence. I've explained that nobody is praising Sam for being gay in terms so simple that a mild developmentally-disabled child should be able to follow the argument by now, but you're still falling back into that same asinine talking point. What more can I do? I can't make you any smarter and I can't act any dumber. I just have to ask you to try to step up your game a little.
 
I wouldn't have hired him, just for the simple fact that if he doesn't make the grade he could sue on the grounds of discrimination. Aand not every college all American or even Heisman winner makes the grade at the pro level.
It's legal to discriminate against gays in the backwards parts of America (which is to say, most of the country): https://www.aclu.org/maps/non-discrimination-laws-state-state-information-map

Out of curiosity, do you have the same hiring practices elsewhere? Do you avoid hiring women, black people, Jews, veterans, older people, the handicapped, and anyone else who is a member of a "protected class" that could sue if they "don't make the grade"?
 
Dealing with really stupid people is difficult for me. I try dumbing myself down to communicate at your level, but there's a point at which I've reached a floor beneath which I can't sink any farther in the effort to meet you at your level, without lapsing into utter incoherence. I've explained that nobody is praising Sam for being gay in terms so simple that a mild developmentally-disabled child should be able to follow the argument by now, but you're still falling back into that same asinine talking point. What more can I do? I can't make you any smarter and I can't act any dumber. I just have to ask you to try to step up your game a little.
You keep making the claim, but you have already established that is a lie. We both know that Sam's "heroism" is predicated on his being gay. You yourself established that when you backed away from praising his supposed heroism in coming clean on other controversial matters.

So you can "talk down" as far as you want, but you're fooling no one, except maybe yourself.
 
It's legal to discriminate against gays in the backwards parts of America (which is to say, most of the country): https://www.aclu.org/maps/non-discrimination-laws-state-state-information-map

Out of curiosity, do you have the same hiring practices elsewhere? Do you avoid hiring women, black people, Jews, veterans, older people, the handicapped, and anyone else who is a member of a "protected class" that could sue if they "don't make the grade"?
I don't hire trouble makers any one that will cry discrimination.
 

What's important here is what Michael Sam's courage seems likely to set in motion... not your fear that you've fallen into the role of the Bob Ewell of the story.


Ad hominem attack, indeed.


You win. You're noble and good, everyone else is a knuckledragger compared to you, because you so decree it. Enjoy the view from the pedestal.
 
No. Do you HONESTLY not understand this issue? It's not about Sam's sexuality being a big deal. How many times does this need to be explained for you to get it? Being gay is worthy of neither praise nor condemnation, any more than being black or left handed is. What's the big deal here isn't Sam's sexuality, but rather his willingness not to hide that sexuality in a context where every single gay man before him felt the need to do so. It's his pioneering spirit -- his willingness to make sacrifices to blaze a new trail in a way that will result in positive developments for his fellow man-- that's a big deal. One doesn't praise Rosa Parks for being black, Susan B. Anthony for being a woman, or Hank Greenberg for being a Jew. One praises their pioneering roles. Take a step back. Take a deep breath. Think. Now try again.



David Marquette Kopay (born June 28, 1942) is a former American football running back in the National Football League who in 1975 became one of the first professional athletes to come out as gay.



Kopay wasn't even the first, he was "one of the first".
 
You keep making the claim, but you have already established that is a lie.
Are you just screwing with me, or do you honestly not get it?

We both know that Sam's "heroism" is predicated on his being gay.

His heroism is predicated on his being gay in the same sense as the heroism of Rosa Parks or Jackie Robinson was predicated on being black. In all three cases, the people were doing something that countless others were able to do without it being any kind of issue because they lacked that particular trait. If Rosa Parks had been white and sat in the front of the bus, if Jackie Robinson had been white and played in major league baseball, and if Michael Sam had been straight and made his sexual orientation known before the draft, none of those things would have been stories, and none of the three would have been praised for courage and pioneering work. But that doesn't mean we're praising Parks and Robinson for being black, or Sam for being gay. There were countless black and gay people that weren't being praised. What was praise-worthy was the pioneering work.

You yourself established that when you backed away from praising his supposed heroism in coming clean on other controversial matters.

I don't know what you're referring to.
So you can "talk down" as far as you want, but you're fooling no one, except maybe yourself.

I'm not seeking to fool anyone, I'm seeking to educate you.
 
What's important here is what Michael Sam's courage seems likely to set in motion... not your fear that you've fallen into the role of the Bob Ewell of the story.

Ad hominem attack, indeed.


You win. You're noble and good, everyone else is a knuckledragger compared to you, because you so decree it. Enjoy the view from the pedestal.
Again, it's not about me. It's about an issue of national importance. Do try to focus.
 
Back
Top