Are you so intensely hung up on his sexuality that you honestly can't get past it long enough to see that he's being praised for being a brave trailblazer,
not for being gay. Nobody is saying his sexuality is a big deal. What's a big deal is that he's not hiding it, in a profession where each of the doubtless dozens or even hundreds of gay men who preceded him went out of their way to make sure to keep their sexuality secret. He refused to bow to that unfair expectation that gay men in major team sports should closet themselves. That's what made him a hero.
It would be as if this were 1955 and I was being so obtuse as to respond to praise of Rosa Parks by saying:
"Rosa is black. So what? When we get to the point where race is not a big deal, we may have accomplished something. I'm there, you're not."
Obviously, the fact Rosa Parks is black was never a big deal. What was a big deal was that she was a trailblazer. What was a big deal is that she refused to sit in the back of the bus. She refused to bow to absurd and unfair expectations of her society, and because of that, the country became a better place. The country will also be a better place thanks to Sam's refusal to bow to the absurd and unfair expectations that gay NFL prospects keep their sexuality a secret. That's why, long after you and I are forgotten, Sam will have his glorious little footnote in the history books.